Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Confusion of Languages

On the Confusion of Languages (191-195)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg013.1st1K-eng1:191-195
Refs {'start': {'reference': '191', 'human_reference': 'Section 191'}, 'end': {'reference': '195', 'human_reference': 'Section 195'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Accordingly, this lawgiver usually gives a handle for this doctrine to those who are not utterly blind in their intellect; as in fact he does in his account of this very event, which we are now discussing: for he has called what took place, confusion; and yet, if he had only intended to speak of the origin of languages, he would have given a more felicitous name, and one of better omen, calling it division instead of confusion; for things that are divided, are not confused, but, on the contrary, are distinguished from one another, and not only is the one name contrary to the other, but the one fact is contrary to the other fact.

For confusion, as I have already said, is the destruction of simple powers for the production of one concrete power; but division is the dissection of one thing into many parts, as is the case when one distinguishes a genus into its subordinate species so that, if the wise God had ordered his ministers to divide language, which was previously only one, into the divisions of several dialects, he would have used more appropriate expressions, which should have given a more accurate idea of the case: calling what he did, dissection, or distribution, or division, or something of that kind, but not confusion, a name which is at variance with all of them.

v.2.p.42

But his especial object here is to dissolve the company of wickedness, to put an end to their confederacy, to destroy their community of action, to put out of sight and extirpate all their powers, to overthrow the might of their dominion, which they had strengthened by fearful lawlessness.

Do you not see that he also who made the parts of the soul did not unite any one part to another in such a way as to enable one to discharge the duties of the other? But the eyes would never be able to hear, nor the ears to see, nor the lips of the mouth to smell, nor the nostrils to taste; nor, again, could reason ever be exposed to those influences which operate upon the outward senses, nor again, would the outward senses be able to develop reason.

For the Creator knew that it was desirable that each of these parts should not hear the voice of its neighbour, but that the parts of the soul should each exert its own peculiar faculties without confusion, for the advantage of living animals, and should, with the same object, be deprived of any power of exerting themselves in common, and that all the powers of vice should be brought to confusion and utter destruction, so that they might neither in confederacy, nor separately, be injurious to the better parts.

Tokens

Accordingly 1 w 11
this 1 w 16
lawgiver 1 w 24
usually 1 w 31
gives 1 w 36
a 3 w 37
handle 1 w 43
for 1 w 46
this 2 w 50
doctrine 1 w 58
to 1 w 60
those 1 w 65
who 1 w 68
are 1 w 71
not 1 w 74
utterly 1 w 81
blind 1 w 86
in 4 w 88
their 1 w 93
intellect 1 w 102
as 1 w 105
in 6 w 107
fact 1 w 111
he 2 w 113
does 1 w 117
in 7 w 119
his 3 w 122
account 1 w 129
of 1 w 131
this 3 w 135
very 1 w 139
event 1 w 144
which 1 w 150
we 1 w 152
are 2 w 155
now 1 w 158
discussing 1 w 168
for 2 w 172
he 3 w 174
has 1 w 177
called 1 w 183
what 1 w 187
took 1 w 191
place 1 w 196
confusion 1 w 206
and 2 w 210
yet 1 w 213
if 1 w 216
he 4 w 218
had 1 w 221
only 1 w 225
intended 1 w 233
to 3 w 235
speak 1 w 240
of 2 w 242
the 2 w 245
origin 1 w 251
of 3 w 253
languages 1 w 262
he 6 w 265
would 1 w 270
have 1 w 274
given 1 w 279
a 20 w 280
more 1 w 284
felicitous 1 w 294
name 1 w 298
and 3 w 302
one 1 w 305
of 4 w 307
better 1 w 313
omen 1 w 317
calling 1 w 325
it 2 w 327
division 1 w 335
instead 1 w 342
of 5 w 344
confusion 2 w 353
for 3 w 357
things 1 w 363
that 1 w 367
are 3 w 370
divided 1 w 377
are 4 w 381
not 2 w 384
confused 1 w 392
but 1 w 396
on 9 w 399
the 3 w 402
contrary 1 w 410
are 5 w 414
distinguished 1 w 427
from 1 w 431
one 2 w 434
another 1 w 441
and 4 w 445
not 4 w 448
only 2 w 452
is 9 w 454
the 5 w 457
one 3 w 460
name 2 w 464
contrary 2 w 472
to 5 w 474
the 6 w 477
other 2 w 482
but 2 w 486
the 8 w 489
one 4 w 492
fact 2 w 496
is 10 w 498
contrary 3 w 506
to 6 w 508
the 9 w 511
other 3 w 516
fact 3 w 520
For 1 w 524
confusion 3 w 533
as 3 w 536
I 1 w 537
have 2 w 541
already 1 w 548
said 1 w 552
is 11 w 555
the 11 w 558
destruction 1 w 569
of 6 w 571
simple 1 w 577
powers 1 w 583
for 4 w 586
the 12 w 589
production 1 w 599
of 7 w 601
one 5 w 604
concrete 1 w 612
power 2 w 617
but 3 w 621
division 2 w 629
is 13 w 631
the 13 w 634
dissection 1 w 644
of 8 w 646
one 6 w 649
thing 2 w 654
into 1 w 658
many 1 w 662
parts 1 w 667
as 4 w 670
is 15 w 672
the 14 w 675
case 1 w 679
when 1 w 683
one 7 w 686
distinguishes 1 w 699
a 46 w 700
genus 1 w 705
into 2 w 709
its 1 w 712
subordinate 1 w 723
species 1 w 730
so 1 w 732
that 2 w 736
if 2 w 739
the 15 w 742
wise 1 w 746
God 1 w 749
had 2 w 752
ordered 1 w 759
his 5 w 762
ministers 1 w 771
to 9 w 773
divide 2 w 779
language 2 w 787
which 2 w 793
was 1 w 796
previously 1 w 806
only 3 w 810
one 8 w 813
into 3 w 818
the 16 w 821
divisions 1 w 830
of 9 w 832
several 1 w 839
dialects 1 w 847
he 24 w 850
would 2 w 855
have 3 w 859
used 2 w 863
more 2 w 867
appropriate 1 w 878
expressions 1 w 889
which 3 w 895
should 1 w 901
have 4 w 905
given 2 w 910
a 59 w 911
more 3 w 915
accurate 1 w 923
idea 1 w 927
of 10 w 929
the 17 w 932
case 2 w 936
calling 2 w 944
what 2 w 948
he 26 w 950
did 1 w 953
dissection 2 w 964
or 13 w 967
distribution 1 w 979
or 14 w 982
division 4 w 990
or 15 w 993
something 1 w 1002
of 11 w 1004
that 3 w 1008
kind 1 w 1012
but 5 w 1016
not 5 w 1019
confusion 4 w 1028
a 67 w 1030
name 3 w 1034
which 4 w 1039
is 25 w 1041
at 9 w 1043
variance 1 w 1051
with 1 w 1055
all 5 w 1058
of 12 w 1060
them 1 w 1064
But 1 w 1068
his 6 w 1071
especial 1 w 1079
object 1 w 1085
here 1 w 1089
is 27 w 1091
to 11 w 1093
dissolve 1 w 1101
the 19 w 1104
company 1 w 1111
of 13 w 1113
wickedness 1 w 1123
to 12 w 1126
put 1 w 1129
an 11 w 1131
end 2 w 1134
to 13 w 1136
their 2 w 1141
confederacy 1 w 1152
to 14 w 1155
destroy 1 w 1162
their 3 w 1167
community 1 w 1176
of 14 w 1178
action 1 w 1184
to 15 w 1187
put 2 w 1190
out 1 w 1193
of 15 w 1195
sight 1 w 1200
and 5 w 1203
extirpate 1 w 1212
all 6 w 1215
their 4 w 1220
powers 2 w 1226
to 16 w 1229
overthrow 1 w 1238
the 23 w 1241
might 1 w 1246
of 16 w 1248
their 5 w 1253
dominion 1 w 1261
which 5 w 1267
they 1 w 1271
had 3 w 1274
strengthened 1 w 1286
by 1 w 1288
fearful 1 w 1295
lawlessness 1 w 1306
Do 1 w 1309
you 1 w 1312
not 6 w 1315
see 1 w 1318
that 4 w 1322
he 37 w 1324
also 1 w 1328
who 2 w 1331
made 1 w 1335
the 27 w 1338
parts 2 w 1343
of 17 w 1345
the 28 w 1348
soul 1 w 1352
did 2 w 1355
not 7 w 1358
unite 1 w 1363
any 3 w 1366
one 9 w 1369
part 3 w 1373
to 17 w 1375
another 2 w 1382
in 26 w 1384
such 1 w 1388
a 91 w 1389
way 1 w 1392
as 8 w 1394
to 18 w 1396
enable 1 w 1402
one 10 w 1405
to 19 w 1407
discharge 1 w 1416
the 30 w 1419
duties 1 w 1425
of 18 w 1427
the 31 w 1430
other 5 w 1435
But 2 w 1439
the 33 w 1442
eyes 1 w 1446
would 3 w 1451
never 1 w 1456
be 2 w 1458
able 2 w 1462
to 20 w 1464
hear 1 w 1468
nor 1 w 1472
the 34 w 1475
ears 1 w 1479
to 21 w 1481
see 2 w 1484
nor 2 w 1488
the 35 w 1491
lips 1 w 1495
of 19 w 1497
the 36 w 1500
mouth 1 w 1505
to 22 w 1507
smell 1 w 1512
nor 3 w 1516
the 37 w 1519
nostrils 1 w 1527
to 23 w 1529
taste 1 w 1534
nor 4 w 1538
again 1 w 1544
could 1 w 1550
reason 1 w 1556
ever 3 w 1560
be 3 w 1562
exposed 1 w 1569
to 24 w 1571
those 2 w 1576
influences 1 w 1586
which 6 w 1591
operate 1 w 1598
upon 1 w 1602
the 38 w 1605
outward 1 w 1612
senses 1 w 1618
nor 5 w 1622
again 2 w 1627
would 4 w 1633
the 39 w 1636
outward 2 w 1643
senses 2 w 1649
be 4 w 1651
able 3 w 1655
to 25 w 1657
develop 1 w 1664
reason 2 w 1670
For 2 w 1674
the 40 w 1677
Creator 1 w 1684
knew 1 w 1688
that 5 w 1692
it 7 w 1694
was 2 w 1697
desirable 1 w 1706
that 6 w 1710
each 1 w 1714
of 20 w 1716
these 1 w 1721
parts 3 w 1726
should 2 w 1732
not 9 w 1735
hear 2 w 1739
the 42 w 1742
voice 1 w 1747
of 21 w 1749
its 2 w 1752
neighbour 1 w 1761
but 6 w 1765
that 7 w 1769
the 43 w 1772
parts 4 w 1777
of 22 w 1779
the 44 w 1782
soul 2 w 1786
should 3 w 1792
each 2 w 1796
exert 1 w 1801
its 3 w 1804
own 1 w 1807
peculiar 1 w 1815
faculties 1 w 1824
without 1 w 1831
confusion 5 w 1840
for 5 w 1844
the 45 w 1847
advantage 1 w 1856
of 23 w 1858
living 1 w 1864
animals 1 w 1871
and 6 w 1875
should 4 w 1881
with 3 w 1886
the 46 w 1889
same 1 w 1893
object 2 w 1899
be 5 w 1902
deprived 1 w 1910
of 24 w 1912
any 4 w 1915
power 4 w 1920
of 25 w 1922
exerting 1 w 1930
themselves 1 w 1940
in 32 w 1942
common 1 w 1948
and 7 w 1952
that 8 w 1956
all 7 w 1959
the 48 w 1962
powers 3 w 1968
of 26 w 1970
vice 1 w 1974
should 5 w 1980
be 6 w 1982
brought 1 w 1989
to 27 w 1991
confusion 6 w 2000
and 8 w 2003
utter 2 w 2008
destruction 2 w 2019
so 9 w 2022
that 9 w 2026
they 2 w 2030
might 2 w 2035
neither 1 w 2042
in 33 w 2044
confederacy 2 w 2055
nor 6 w 2059
separately 1 w 2069
be 7 w 2072
injurious 1 w 2081
to 28 w 2083
the 51 w 2086
better 2 w 2092
parts 5 w 2097