Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Confusion of Languages

On the Confusion of Languages (141-145)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg013.1st1K-eng1:141-145
Refs {'start': {'reference': '141', 'human_reference': 'Section 141'}, 'end': {'reference': '145', 'human_reference': 'Section 145'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

On which account a law has been enacted among those nations which have the most excellent constitution, that one must not give evidence on hearsay, because by its own nature the tribunal of the sense of hearing is liable to be corrupted. And Moses indeed says in the prohibitory part of his law, "Thou shalt not receive vain hearing." [*] Meaning not only this, that one ought not to receive false or silly reports by hearsay, but that, as far as the clear comprehension of the truth is concerned, the hearing is a long way behind the sight, being full of vanity.

28

We say that this is the reason why it is said that God went down to see the city and the tower; and the addition, "Which the sons of men had built," is not a mere superfluity. For perhaps some profanely disposed person may mock and say, "The lawgiver is here teaching us a very novel kind of lesson, when he says that no one else but the sons of men build cities and towers; for who, even of the most crazy people is ignorant of what is so evident and notorious as that?"

But we must not suppose that such a plain and unquestionable fact as that, is what is intended to be conveyed by the mention of it in the holy scriptures, but rather there is some hidden meaning concealed under these apparently plain words which we must trace out.

What then is this hidden meaning? Those who, as it were, attribute many fathers to existing things, and who represent the company of the gods as numerous, displaying great ignorance of the nature of things and causing great confusion, and making pleasure the proper object of the soul, are those who are, if we must tell the plain truth, spoken of as the builders of the aforesaid city, and of the citadel in it; having increased the efficient causes of the desired end, building them up like houses, being, as I imagine, in no respect different from the children of the harlot whom the law expels from the assembly of God, where it says, "The offspring of a harlot shall not come into the assembly of the Lord." [*] Because, like archers shooting at random at many objects, and not aiming skilfully or successfully at any one mark, so these men, putting forward ten thousand principles and causes for the creation of the universe, every one of which is false, display a perfect ignorance of the one Creator and Father of [*] [*]

v.2.p.31
all things;

but they who have real knowledge, are properly addressed as the sons of the one God, as Moses also entitles them, where he says, "Ye are the sons of the Lord God." [*] And again, "God who begot thee;" [*] and in another place, "Is not he thy father?" Accordingly, it is natural for those who have this disposition of soul to look upon nothing as beautiful except what is good, which is the citadel erected by those who are experienced in this kind of warfare as a defence against the end of pleasure, and as a means of defeating and destroying it.

Tokens

On 1 w 2
which 1 w 7
account 1 w 14
a 2 w 15
law 1 w 18
has 1 w 21
been 1 w 25
enacted 1 w 32
among 1 w 37
those 1 w 42
nations 1 w 49
which 2 w 54
have 1 w 58
the 1 w 61
most 1 w 65
excellent 1 w 74
constitution 1 w 86
that 1 w 91
one 1 w 94
must 1 w 98
not 1 w 101
give 1 w 105
evidence 1 w 113
on 6 w 115
hearsay 1 w 122
because 1 w 130
by 1 w 132
its 1 w 135
own 1 w 138
nature 1 w 144
the 2 w 147
tribunal 1 w 155
of 1 w 157
the 3 w 160
sense 1 w 165
of 2 w 167
hearing 1 w 174
is 1 w 176
liable 1 w 182
to 1 w 184
be 3 w 186
corrupted 1 w 195
And 1 w 199
Moses 1 w 204
indeed 1 w 210
says 1 w 214
in 3 w 216
the 4 w 219
prohibitory 1 w 230
part 1 w 234
of 3 w 236
his 1 w 239
law 2 w 242
Thou 1 w 248
shalt 1 w 253
not 2 w 256
receive 1 w 263
vain 1 w 267
hearing 2 w 274
Exodus 1 w 282
xxiii 1 w 287
1 1 w 289
Meaning 1 w 297
not 3 w 300
only 1 w 304
this 1 w 308
that 2 w 313
one 2 w 316
ought 1 w 321
not 4 w 324
to 3 w 326
receive 2 w 333
false 1 w 338
or 3 w 340
silly 1 w 345
reports 1 w 352
by 2 w 354
hearsay 2 w 361
but 1 w 365
that 3 w 369
as 2 w 372
far 1 w 375
as 3 w 377
the 5 w 380
clear 1 w 385
comprehension 1 w 398
of 4 w 400
the 6 w 403
truth 1 w 408
is 4 w 410
concerned 1 w 419
the 7 w 423
hearing 3 w 430
is 5 w 432
a 34 w 433
long 1 w 437
way 1 w 440
behind 1 w 446
the 8 w 449
sight 1 w 454
being 1 w 460
full 1 w 464
of 5 w 466
vanity 1 w 472
We 1 w 475
say 4 w 478
that 4 w 482
this 2 w 486
is 7 w 488
the 9 w 491
reason 1 w 497
why 1 w 500
it 5 w 502
is 8 w 504
said 1 w 508
that 5 w 512
God 1 w 515
went 1 w 519
down 1 w 523
to 4 w 525
see 1 w 528
the 10 w 531
city 1 w 535
and 1 w 538
the 11 w 541
tower 1 w 546
and 2 w 550
the 12 w 553
addition 1 w 561
Which 1 w 568
the 13 w 571
sons 1 w 575
of 6 w 577
men 1 w 580
had 1 w 583
built 1 w 588
is 9 w 592
not 5 w 595
a 46 w 596
mere 1 w 600
superfluity 1 w 611
For 1 w 615
perhaps 1 w 622
some 1 w 626
profanely 1 w 635
disposed 1 w 643
person 1 w 649
may 1 w 652
mock 1 w 656
and 3 w 659
say 5 w 662
The 1 w 667
lawgiver 1 w 675
is 11 w 677
here 1 w 681
teaching 1 w 689
us 4 w 691
a 54 w 692
very 1 w 696
novel 1 w 701
kind 1 w 705
of 8 w 707
lesson 1 w 713
when 1 w 718
he 23 w 720
says 2 w 724
that 6 w 728
no 7 w 730
one 3 w 733
else 1 w 737
but 2 w 740
the 14 w 743
sons 2 w 747
of 9 w 749
men 2 w 752
build 1 w 757
cities 1 w 763
and 4 w 766
towers 1 w 772
for 1 w 776
who 1 w 779
even 1 w 784
of 10 w 786
the 15 w 789
most 2 w 793
crazy 1 w 798
people 1 w 804
is 12 w 806
ignorant 1 w 814
of 11 w 816
what 1 w 820
is 13 w 822
so 7 w 824
evident 1 w 831
and 5 w 834
notorious 1 w 843
as 5 w 845
that 7 w 849
But 1 w 854
we 4 w 856
must 2 w 860
not 7 w 863
suppose 1 w 870
that 8 w 874
such 1 w 878
a 65 w 879
plain 1 w 884
and 6 w 887
unquestionable 1 w 901
fact 1 w 905
as 6 w 907
that 9 w 911
is 14 w 914
what 2 w 918
is 15 w 920
intended 1 w 928
to 8 w 930
be 6 w 932
conveyed 1 w 940
by 3 w 942
the 16 w 945
mention 1 w 952
of 12 w 954
it 10 w 956
in 14 w 958
the 17 w 961
holy 1 w 965
scriptures 1 w 975
but 3 w 979
rather 1 w 985
there 1 w 990
is 16 w 992
some 2 w 996
hidden 1 w 1002
meaning 1 w 1009
concealed 1 w 1018
under 1 w 1023
these 1 w 1028
apparently 1 w 1038
plain 2 w 1043
words 1 w 1048
which 3 w 1053
we 5 w 1055
must 3 w 1059
trace 1 w 1064
out 1 w 1067
What 1 w 1072
then 1 w 1076
is 17 w 1078
this 3 w 1082
hidden 2 w 1088
meaning 2 w 1095
Those 1 w 1101
who 2 w 1104
as 7 w 1107
it 11 w 1109
were 1 w 1113
attribute 1 w 1123
many 1 w 1127
fathers 1 w 1134
to 9 w 1136
existing 1 w 1144
things 1 w 1150
and 7 w 1154
who 3 w 1157
represent 1 w 1166
the 23 w 1169
company 1 w 1176
of 13 w 1178
the 24 w 1181
gods 1 w 1185
as 8 w 1187
numerous 1 w 1195
displaying 1 w 1206
great 1 w 1211
ignorance 1 w 1220
of 14 w 1222
the 25 w 1225
nature 2 w 1231
of 15 w 1233
things 2 w 1239
and 8 w 1242
causing 1 w 1249
great 2 w 1254
confusion 1 w 1263
and 9 w 1267
making 1 w 1273
pleasure 1 w 1281
the 26 w 1284
proper 1 w 1290
object 1 w 1296
of 16 w 1298
the 27 w 1301
soul 1 w 1305
are 2 w 1309
those 2 w 1314
who 4 w 1317
are 3 w 1320
if 1 w 1323
we 7 w 1325
must 4 w 1329
tell 1 w 1333
the 28 w 1336
plain 3 w 1341
truth 2 w 1346
spoken 1 w 1353
of 17 w 1355
as 10 w 1357
the 29 w 1360
builders 1 w 1368
of 18 w 1370
the 30 w 1373
aforesaid 1 w 1382
city 2 w 1386
and 10 w 1390
of 19 w 1392
the 31 w 1395
citadel 1 w 1402
in 25 w 1404
it 14 w 1406
having 1 w 1413
increased 1 w 1422
the 32 w 1425
efficient 1 w 1434
causes 1 w 1440
of 20 w 1442
the 33 w 1445
desired 1 w 1452
end 2 w 1455
building 1 w 1464
them 1 w 1468
up 4 w 1470
like 1 w 1474
houses 1 w 1480
being 2 w 1486
as 12 w 1489
I 1 w 1490
imagine 1 w 1497
in 31 w 1500
no 12 w 1502
respect 1 w 1509
different 1 w 1518
from 1 w 1522
the 35 w 1525
children 1 w 1533
of 21 w 1535
the 36 w 1538
harlot 1 w 1544
whom 1 w 1548
the 37 w 1551
law 4 w 1554
expels 1 w 1560
from 2 w 1564
the 38 w 1567
assembly 1 w 1575
of 22 w 1577
God 2 w 1580
where 1 w 1586
it 15 w 1588
says 3 w 1592
The 2 w 1597
offspring 1 w 1606
of 24 w 1608
a 116 w 1609
harlot 2 w 1615
shall 1 w 1620
not 8 w 1623
come 1 w 1627
into 1 w 1631
the 39 w 1634
assembly 2 w 1642
of 25 w 1644
the 40 w 1647
Lord 1 w 1651
Deuteronomy 1 w 1664
xxiii 2 w 1669
2 1 w 1671
Because 1 w 1679
like 2 w 1684
archers 1 w 1691
shooting 1 w 1699
at 21 w 1701
random 1 w 1707
at 22 w 1709
many 2 w 1713
objects 1 w 1720
and 12 w 1724
not 9 w 1727
aiming 1 w 1733
skilfully 1 w 1742
or 13 w 1744
successfully 1 w 1756
at 23 w 1758
any 4 w 1761
one 4 w 1764
mark 1 w 1768
so 10 w 1771
these 2 w 1776
men 4 w 1779
putting 1 w 1787
forward 1 w 1794
ten 2 w 1797
thousand 1 w 1805
principles 1 w 1815
and 14 w 1818
causes 2 w 1824
for 4 w 1827
the 42 w 1830
creation 1 w 1838
of 26 w 1840
the 43 w 1843
universe 1 w 1851
every 1 w 1857
one 5 w 1860
of 27 w 1862
which 4 w 1867
is 21 w 1869
false 2 w 1874
display 2 w 1882
a 138 w 1883
perfect 1 w 1890
ignorance 2 w 1899
of 28 w 1901
the 44 w 1904
one 6 w 1907
Creator 1 w 1914
and 15 w 1917
Father 1 w 1923
of 29 w 1925
Exodus 2 w 1931
xxiii 3 w 1936
1 2 w 1938
Deuteronomy 2 w 1950
xxiii 4 w 1955
2 2 w 1957
all 2 w 1961
things 3 w 1967
but 5 w 1971
they 1 w 1975
who 6 w 1978
have 2 w 1982
real 1 w 1986
knowledge 1 w 1995
are 4 w 1999
properly 1 w 2007
addressed 1 w 2016
as 15 w 2018
the 47 w 2021
sons 3 w 2025
of 30 w 2027
the 48 w 2030
one 7 w 2033
God 3 w 2036
as 16 w 2039
Moses 2 w 2044
also 1 w 2048
entitles 1 w 2056
them 2 w 2060
where 2 w 2066
he 64 w 2068
says 4 w 2072
Ye 1 w 2076
are 5 w 2079
the 50 w 2082
sons 4 w 2086
of 31 w 2088
the 51 w 2091
Lord 2 w 2095
God 4 w 2098
Deuteronomy 3 w 2111
xiv 1 w 2114
1 3 w 2116
And 2 w 2120
again 1 w 2125
God 5 w 2130
who 7 w 2133
begot 1 w 2138
thee 1 w 2142
Deuteronomy 4 w 2155
xxxii 1 w 2160
18 1 w 2163
and 16 w 2167
in 40 w 2169
another 1 w 2176
place 1 w 2181
Is 1 w 2185
not 11 w 2188
he 69 w 2190
thy 1 w 2193
father 2 w 2199
Accordingly 1 w 2212
it 17 w 2215
is 23 w 2217
natural 1 w 2224
for 5 w 2227
those 3 w 2232
who 8 w 2235
have 3 w 2239
this 4 w 2243
disposition 1 w 2254
of 32 w 2256
soul 2 w 2260
to 12 w 2262
look 1 w 2266
upon 1 w 2270
nothing 1 w 2277
as 17 w 2279
beautiful 1 w 2288
except 1 w 2294
what 3 w 2298
is 26 w 2300
good 1 w 2304
which 5 w 2310
is 27 w 2312
the 55 w 2315
citadel 2 w 2322
erected 1 w 2329
by 4 w 2331
those 4 w 2336
who 9 w 2339
are 6 w 2342
experienced 1 w 2353
in 43 w 2355
this 5 w 2359
kind 2 w 2363
of 33 w 2365
warfare 1 w 2372
as 18 w 2374
a 170 w 2375
defence 1 w 2382
against 1 w 2389
the 56 w 2392
end 3 w 2395
of 34 w 2397
pleasure 2 w 2405
and 17 w 2409
as 20 w 2411
a 176 w 2412
means 1 w 2417
of 35 w 2419
defeating 1 w 2428
and 18 w 2431
destroying 1 w 2441
it 20 w 2443