Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On Sobriety

On Sobriety (46-50)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg012.1st1K-eng1:46-50
Refs {'start': {'reference': '46', 'human_reference': 'Section 46'}, 'end': {'reference': '50', 'human_reference': 'Section 50'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But no lawgiver ever affixes a punishment to wicked men while in a state of inaction, but only when they are in a state of motion and practise actions in accordance with injustice, just as a moderate man would not care about killing a snake if it were not about to bite him. For we must leave out of the question, that natural cruelty of soul which in the case of some persons delights to deal destruction upon everything.

Very appropriately, therefore, the just man will appear to have launched his curses against his grandson, Canaan. But I have used the expression "will appear," because in effect he is cursing his son Ham through the medium of

v.1.p.511
Canaan; for Ham being moved to commit sin does himself become Canaan. For there is one subject, namely wickedness, of which one kind is contemplated in a stationary condition, and the other in motion. But a stationary condition is antecedent to motion, so that that which is moved appears to have the relation of offspring to that which is stationary.

In reference to which fact Canaan is, according to the order of nature, described as the son of Ham; commotion as the offspring of tranquillity, in order that the statement made in another passage may be true, namely, "visiting the iniquities of the fathers upon the sons to the third and fourth generations." [*] For against these accomplishments of, and as it were, children of thoughts, punishments advance which await them, but which will hardly seize upon these thoughts which are not carried out by any action, and which consequently escape accusation.

On this account, therefore, in the law concerning leprosy the great and wise Moses speaks of motion and its further progress and diffusion as unclean, but of tranquillity as pure. For he says, "If it be diffused over the skin the priest shall pronounce him polluted. But if the bright colour remain in its place and be not diffused, he shall pronounce him clean." [*] So that, as tranquillity is an abiding of evils and of the passions within the soul (for that is what is intimated by leprosy), it is not liable to reproach; but its motion and progress are of necessity open to accusation.

There is also something like this in the sacred scriptures, where the account of the creation of the universe is given and it is expressed more distinctly. For it is said to the wicked man, "O thou man, thou hast sinned. Cease to sin:" [*] because sin is condemned with reference to its being in motion and energising according to wickedness: but tranquillity is free from blame, and is even preservative because of its remaining stationary and inactive.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
no 1 w 5
lawgiver 1 w 13
ever 1 w 17
affixes 1 w 24
a 3 w 25
punishment 1 w 35
to 1 w 37
wicked 1 w 43
men 2 w 46
while 1 w 51
in 1 w 53
a 4 w 54
state 1 w 59
of 1 w 61
inaction 1 w 69
but 1 w 73
only 1 w 77
when 1 w 81
they 1 w 85
are 1 w 88
in 3 w 90
a 8 w 91
state 2 w 96
of 2 w 98
motion 1 w 104
and 1 w 107
practise 1 w 115
actions 1 w 122
in 4 w 124
accordance 1 w 134
with 1 w 138
injustice 1 w 147
just 2 w 152
as 1 w 154
a 16 w 155
moderate 1 w 163
man 1 w 166
would 1 w 171
not 1 w 174
care 1 w 178
about 1 w 183
killing 1 w 190
a 21 w 191
snake 1 w 196
if 1 w 198
it 2 w 200
were 1 w 204
not 2 w 207
about 2 w 212
to 2 w 214
bite 1 w 218
him 1 w 221
For 1 w 225
we 2 w 227
must 1 w 231
leave 1 w 236
out 3 w 239
of 3 w 241
the 2 w 244
question 1 w 252
that 1 w 257
natural 1 w 264
cruelty 1 w 271
of 4 w 273
soul 1 w 277
which 1 w 282
in 7 w 284
the 3 w 287
case 1 w 291
of 5 w 293
some 1 w 297
persons 1 w 304
delights 1 w 312
to 3 w 314
deal 1 w 318
destruction 1 w 329
upon 1 w 333
everything 1 w 343
Very 1 w 348
appropriately 1 w 361
therefore 1 w 371
the 5 w 375
just 3 w 379
man 2 w 382
will 1 w 386
appear 1 w 392
to 4 w 394
have 1 w 398
launched 1 w 406
his 1 w 409
curses 1 w 415
against 1 w 422
his 2 w 425
grandson 1 w 433
Canaan 1 w 440
But 2 w 444
I 1 w 445
have 2 w 449
used 1 w 453
the 6 w 456
expression 1 w 466
will 2 w 471
appear 2 w 477
because 1 w 486
in 10 w 488
effect 1 w 494
he 9 w 496
is 5 w 498
cursing 1 w 505
his 3 w 508
son 3 w 511
Ham 1 w 514
through 1 w 521
the 7 w 524
medium 1 w 530
of 6 w 532
Canaan 2 w 538
for 2 w 542
Ham 2 w 545
being 1 w 550
moved 1 w 555
to 5 w 557
commit 1 w 563
sin 2 w 566
does 1 w 570
himself 1 w 577
become 1 w 583
Canaan 3 w 589
For 2 w 593
there 2 w 598
is 7 w 600
one 1 w 603
subject 1 w 610
namely 1 w 617
wickedness 1 w 627
of 7 w 630
which 2 w 635
one 2 w 638
kind 1 w 642
is 8 w 644
contemplated 1 w 656
in 15 w 658
a 57 w 659
stationary 1 w 669
condition 1 w 678
and 3 w 682
the 9 w 685
other 1 w 690
in 16 w 692
motion 2 w 698
But 3 w 702
a 61 w 703
stationary 2 w 713
condition 2 w 722
is 9 w 724
antecedent 1 w 734
to 6 w 736
motion 3 w 742
so 6 w 745
that 2 w 749
that 3 w 753
which 3 w 758
is 10 w 760
moved 2 w 765
appears 1 w 772
to 7 w 774
have 3 w 778
the 11 w 781
relation 1 w 789
of 8 w 791
offspring 1 w 800
to 8 w 802
that 4 w 806
which 4 w 811
is 11 w 813
stationary 3 w 823
In 1 w 826
reference 1 w 835
to 9 w 837
which 5 w 842
fact 1 w 846
Canaan 4 w 852
is 12 w 854
according 1 w 864
to 10 w 866
the 12 w 869
order 1 w 874
of 10 w 876
nature 1 w 882
described 1 w 892
as 3 w 894
the 13 w 897
son 4 w 900
of 11 w 902
Ham 3 w 905
commotion 1 w 915
as 4 w 917
the 14 w 920
offspring 2 w 929
of 13 w 931
tranquillity 1 w 943
in 20 w 946
order 2 w 951
that 5 w 955
the 15 w 958
statement 1 w 967
made 1 w 971
in 21 w 973
another 1 w 980
passage 1 w 987
may 1 w 990
be 5 w 992
true 1 w 996
namely 2 w 1003
visiting 1 w 1013
the 17 w 1016
iniquities 1 w 1026
of 14 w 1028
the 18 w 1031
fathers 1 w 1038
upon 2 w 1042
the 20 w 1045
sons 2 w 1049
to 11 w 1051
the 21 w 1054
third 1 w 1059
and 4 w 1062
fourth 1 w 1068
generations 1 w 1079
Exodus 1 w 1087
xx 1 w 1089
5 1 w 1091
For 3 w 1095
against 2 w 1102
these 1 w 1107
accomplishments 1 w 1122
of 15 w 1124
and 5 w 1128
as 6 w 1130
it 10 w 1132
were 2 w 1136
children 1 w 1145
of 16 w 1147
thoughts 1 w 1155
punishments 1 w 1167
advance 1 w 1174
which 6 w 1179
await 1 w 1184
them 1 w 1188
but 2 w 1192
which 7 w 1197
will 3 w 1201
hardly 1 w 1207
seize 1 w 1212
upon 3 w 1216
these 2 w 1221
thoughts 2 w 1229
which 8 w 1234
are 3 w 1237
not 4 w 1240
carried 1 w 1247
out 4 w 1250
by 1 w 1252
any 1 w 1255
action 3 w 1261
and 6 w 1265
which 9 w 1270
consequently 1 w 1282
escape 1 w 1288
accusation 1 w 1298
On 1 w 1301
this 1 w 1305
account 1 w 1312
therefore 2 w 1322
in 25 w 1325
the 26 w 1328
law 2 w 1331
concerning 1 w 1341
leprosy 1 w 1348
the 27 w 1351
great 1 w 1356
and 7 w 1359
wise 1 w 1363
Moses 1 w 1368
speaks 1 w 1374
of 17 w 1376
motion 5 w 1382
and 8 w 1385
its 1 w 1388
further 1 w 1395
progress 1 w 1403
and 9 w 1406
diffusion 1 w 1415
as 7 w 1417
unclean 1 w 1424
but 3 w 1428
of 18 w 1430
tranquillity 2 w 1442
as 8 w 1444
pure 1 w 1448
For 4 w 1452
he 32 w 1454
says 1 w 1458
If 1 w 1462
it 14 w 1464
be 6 w 1466
diffused 1 w 1474
over 1 w 1478
the 29 w 1481
skin 1 w 1485
the 30 w 1488
priest 1 w 1494
shall 1 w 1499
pronounce 1 w 1508
him 3 w 1511
polluted 1 w 1519
But 4 w 1523
if 4 w 1525
the 31 w 1528
bright 1 w 1534
colour 1 w 1540
remain 1 w 1546
in 29 w 1548
its 2 w 1551
place 1 w 1556
and 10 w 1559
be 7 w 1561
not 5 w 1564
diffused 2 w 1572
he 36 w 1575
shall 2 w 1580
pronounce 2 w 1589
him 4 w 1592
clean 2 w 1597
Leviticus 1 w 1608
xiii 1 w 1612
12 1 w 1615
So 1 w 1618
that 6 w 1622
as 9 w 1625
tranquillity 3 w 1637
is 18 w 1639
an 31 w 1641
abiding 1 w 1648
of 19 w 1650
evils 1 w 1655
and 11 w 1658
of 20 w 1660
the 32 w 1663
passions 1 w 1671
within 1 w 1677
the 33 w 1680
soul 2 w 1684
for 4 w 1688
that 7 w 1692
is 19 w 1694
what 1 w 1698
is 20 w 1700
intimated 1 w 1709
by 2 w 1711
leprosy 2 w 1718
it 19 w 1722
is 21 w 1724
not 6 w 1727
liable 1 w 1733
to 12 w 1735
reproach 1 w 1743
but 4 w 1747
its 3 w 1750
motion 6 w 1756
and 12 w 1759
progress 2 w 1767
are 4 w 1770
of 21 w 1772
necessity 1 w 1781
open 1 w 1785
to 13 w 1787
accusation 2 w 1797
There 1 w 1803
is 22 w 1805
also 1 w 1809
something 1 w 1818
like 1 w 1822
this 2 w 1826
in 34 w 1828
the 34 w 1831
sacred 1 w 1837
scriptures 1 w 1847
where 1 w 1853
the 35 w 1856
account 2 w 1863
of 22 w 1865
the 36 w 1868
creation 1 w 1876
of 23 w 1878
the 37 w 1881
universe 1 w 1889
is 24 w 1891
given 1 w 1896
and 13 w 1899
it 22 w 1901
is 25 w 1903
expressed 1 w 1912
more 1 w 1916
distinctly 1 w 1926
For 5 w 1930
it 23 w 1932
is 27 w 1934
said 1 w 1938
to 14 w 1940
the 38 w 1943
wicked 3 w 1949
man 3 w 1952
O 2 w 1955
thou 3 w 1959
man 4 w 1962
thou 4 w 1967
hast 1 w 1971
sinned 1 w 1977
Cease 1 w 1983
to 15 w 1985
sin 4 w 1988
Genesis 1 w 1997
iv 4 w 1999
7 1 w 2001
because 2 w 2009
sin 5 w 2012
is 29 w 2014
condemned 1 w 2023
with 3 w 2027
reference 2 w 2036
to 16 w 2038
its 4 w 2041
being 2 w 2046
in 40 w 2048
motion 7 w 2054
and 14 w 2057
energising 1 w 2067
according 2 w 2076
to 17 w 2078
wickedness 2 w 2088
but 5 w 2092
tranquillity 4 w 2104
is 31 w 2106
free 1 w 2110
from 1 w 2114
blame 1 w 2119
and 15 w 2123
is 32 w 2125
even 1 w 2129
preservative 1 w 2141
because 3 w 2148
of 24 w 2150
its 5 w 2153
remaining 1 w 2162
stationary 4 w 2172
and 16 w 2175
inactive 1 w 2183