Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Apollodorus Against Stephanus, Charged with False Testimony I

Apollodorus Against Stephanus, Charged with False Testimony I (50-52)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0014.tlg045.perseus-eng2:50-52
Refs {'start': {'reference': '50', 'human_reference': 'Section 50'}, 'end': {'reference': '52', 'human_reference': 'Section 52'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

For you have sworn to give a verdict, not in regard to matters upon which the defendant asks your decision, but in regard to those only which are raised by the prosecution. The cause of action must be made clear by the complaint of the prosecutor, and this in my case is a suit against this man for false testimony. Let him not, then, leave this and talk about matters regarding which I am not suing him; and do you, if he is so shameless, refuse to permit it.

I imagine that, having no just argument to advance on any point, he will have recourse to this defence alsothat it is absurd for me, after having been worsted in the case of the special plea, to sue those who gave evidence of a will; and he will maintain that the jurymen in that trial were led to vote in favor of Phormio, by the evidence of those who testified to the release rather than by that of those who testified to the will. But, men of Athens, I think you all know that it is your habit to examine the facts no less closely than the pleas which men make regarding them; and these men, by giving false testimony against me regarding the facts themselves, weakened my arguments on the special plea.

However, besides this, it is absurd, when all have given false evidence, to demonstrate who did the greatest amount of harm, instead of making each one prove that he has himself testified to the truth. It is not by proving that another has done more outrageous things than himself that a witness is to be let off, but by showing that he has himself given testimony that is true.

Tokens

For 1 w 3
you 1 w 6
have 1 w 10
sworn 1 w 15
to 1 w 17
give 1 w 21
a 2 w 22
verdict 1 w 29
not 1 w 33
in 1 w 35
regard 1 w 41
to 2 w 43
matters 1 w 50
upon 1 w 54
which 1 w 59
the 1 w 62
defendant 1 w 71
asks 1 w 75
your 1 w 79
decision 1 w 87
but 1 w 91
in 2 w 93
regard 2 w 99
to 3 w 101
those 1 w 106
only 1 w 110
which 2 w 115
are 1 w 118
raised 1 w 124
by 1 w 126
the 2 w 129
prosecution 1 w 140
The 1 w 144
cause 1 w 149
of 1 w 151
action 1 w 157
must 1 w 161
be 1 w 163
made 1 w 167
clear 1 w 172
by 2 w 174
the 3 w 177
complaint 1 w 186
of 2 w 188
the 4 w 191
prosecutor 1 w 201
and 1 w 205
this 1 w 209
in 4 w 211
my 1 w 213
case 1 w 217
is 4 w 219
a 17 w 220
suit 1 w 224
against 1 w 231
this 2 w 235
man 1 w 238
for 1 w 241
false 1 w 246
testimony 1 w 255
Let 1 w 259
him 1 w 262
not 2 w 265
then 1 w 270
leave 1 w 276
this 3 w 280
and 2 w 283
talk 1 w 287
about 1 w 292
matters 2 w 299
regarding 1 w 308
which 3 w 313
I 1 w 314
am 1 w 316
not 3 w 319
suing 1 w 324
him 2 w 327
and 3 w 331
do 1 w 333
you 3 w 336
if 1 w 339
he 7 w 341
is 7 w 343
so 1 w 345
shameless 1 w 354
refuse 1 w 361
to 5 w 363
permit 1 w 369
it 3 w 371
I 2 w 373
imagine 1 w 380
that 1 w 384
having 1 w 391
no 4 w 393
just 1 w 397
argument 1 w 405
to 6 w 407
advance 1 w 414
on 7 w 416
any 1 w 419
point 1 w 424
he 8 w 427
will 1 w 431
have 2 w 435
recourse 1 w 443
to 7 w 445
this 4 w 449
defence 1 w 456
also 1 w 460
that 2 w 465
it 4 w 467
is 9 w 469
absurd 1 w 475
for 2 w 478
me 3 w 480
after 1 w 486
having 2 w 492
been 1 w 496
worsted 1 w 503
in 12 w 505
the 6 w 508
case 2 w 512
of 3 w 514
the 7 w 517
special 1 w 524
plea 1 w 528
to 8 w 531
sue 1 w 534
those 2 w 539
who 1 w 542
gave 1 w 546
evidence 1 w 554
of 4 w 556
a 48 w 557
will 2 w 561
and 4 w 565
he 11 w 567
will 3 w 571
maintain 1 w 579
that 3 w 583
the 8 w 586
jurymen 1 w 593
in 15 w 595
that 4 w 599
trial 1 w 604
were 1 w 608
led 1 w 611
to 9 w 613
vote 1 w 617
in 16 w 619
favor 1 w 624
of 5 w 626
Phormio 1 w 633
by 3 w 636
the 9 w 639
evidence 2 w 647
of 6 w 649
those 3 w 654
who 2 w 657
testified 1 w 666
to 10 w 668
the 10 w 671
release 1 w 678
rather 1 w 684
than 1 w 688
by 4 w 690
that 5 w 694
of 7 w 696
those 4 w 701
who 3 w 704
testified 2 w 713
to 11 w 715
the 12 w 718
will 4 w 722
But 1 w 726
men 3 w 730
of 8 w 732
Athens 1 w 738
I 3 w 740
think 1 w 745
you 4 w 748
all 1 w 751
know 1 w 755
that 6 w 759
it 5 w 761
is 10 w 763
your 2 w 767
habit 1 w 772
to 12 w 774
examine 1 w 781
the 14 w 784
facts 1 w 789
no 6 w 791
less 2 w 795
closely 1 w 802
than 2 w 806
the 15 w 809
pleas 1 w 814
which 4 w 819
men 4 w 822
make 1 w 826
regarding 2 w 835
them 1 w 839
and 5 w 843
these 1 w 848
men 5 w 851
by 5 w 854
giving 1 w 860
false 2 w 865
testimony 2 w 874
against 2 w 881
me 8 w 883
regarding 3 w 892
the 18 w 895
facts 2 w 900
themselves 1 w 910
weakened 1 w 919
my 2 w 921
arguments 1 w 930
on 9 w 932
the 20 w 935
special 2 w 942
plea 3 w 946
However 1 w 954
besides 1 w 962
this 5 w 966
it 7 w 969
is 12 w 971
absurd 2 w 977
when 1 w 982
all 2 w 985
have 3 w 989
given 1 w 994
false 3 w 999
evidence 3 w 1007
to 13 w 1010
demonstrate 1 w 1021
who 4 w 1024
did 1 w 1027
the 21 w 1030
greatest 1 w 1038
amount 1 w 1044
of 9 w 1046
harm 1 w 1050
instead 1 w 1058
of 10 w 1060
making 1 w 1066
each 1 w 1070
one 1 w 1073
prove 1 w 1078
that 7 w 1082
he 27 w 1084
has 1 w 1087
himself 1 w 1094
testified 3 w 1103
to 14 w 1105
the 22 w 1108
truth 1 w 1113
It 1 w 1116
is 13 w 1118
not 4 w 1121
by 6 w 1123
proving 1 w 1130
that 8 w 1134
another 1 w 1141
has 2 w 1144
done 1 w 1148
more 1 w 1152
outrageous 1 w 1162
things 1 w 1168
than 3 w 1172
himself 2 w 1179
that 9 w 1183
a 98 w 1184
witness 1 w 1191
is 14 w 1193
to 15 w 1195
be 4 w 1197
let 1 w 1200
off 1 w 1203
but 2 w 1207
by 7 w 1209
showing 1 w 1216
that 10 w 1220
he 30 w 1222
has 3 w 1225
himself 3 w 1232
given 2 w 1237
testimony 3 w 1246
that 11 w 1250
is 15 w 1252
true 1 w 1256