Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / One of the Sons of Aristaechmus Against Nausimachus and Xenopeithes

One of the Sons of Aristaechmus Against Nausimachus and Xenopeithes (20-22)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0014.tlg038.perseus-eng2:20-22
Refs {'start': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}, 'end': {'reference': '22', 'human_reference': 'Section 22'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

For my own part, I think that the large sum asked as damages in the suits then brought is a stronger proof for us, that our father was the victim of a malicious action, than for them, that they were being defrauded of a large estate. For if he could prove his claims for eighty talents, no man in the world would have accepted three talents in settlement; whereas anyone, being defendant in a guardianship suit involving such large sums, would have paid three talents to buy off the risk and the advantages with which at that time nature supplied these men. They were orphans and young, and you were ignorant of their real characters; and everyone says that in your courts these things have more weight than strong arguments.

Moreover, I think I can also prove that you might with good reason refuse to hear a word from them in regard to the guardianship.[*] For suppose one should grant that they have suffered the greatest possible wrongs, and that everything which they will now allege about these matters is true, this, at least, I presume you would all admit: that it has happened to others ere now to have suffered many wrongs more serious than pecuniary wrongs. For involuntary homicides, outrages on what is sacred, and many other such crimes are committed; yet in all these cases the fact they have yielded to persuasion and given a release is appointed for the parties wronged as a limit and settlement of the dispute.

And this just principle is so binding among all men, that, if one, having convicted another of involuntary homicide, and clearly shown him to be polluted, subsequently takes pity upon him, and releases him, he has no longer the right to have the same person driven into exile. If, then, when life and all that is most precious are at stake, a release has this power and validity, shall it be without effect, when money is at stake, or claims of lesser importance? Surely not. For the thing most to be feared is, not that I should fail to obtain justice in your court, but that a just practice, established from the beginning of time, should now be done away with.

Tokens

For 1 w 3
my 1 w 5
own 1 w 8
part 1 w 12
I 1 w 14
think 1 w 19
that 1 w 23
the 1 w 26
large 1 w 31
sum 1 w 34
asked 1 w 39
as 2 w 41
damages 1 w 48
in 2 w 50
the 2 w 53
suits 1 w 58
then 1 w 62
brought 1 w 69
is 1 w 71
a 8 w 72
stronger 1 w 80
proof 1 w 85
for 1 w 88
us 1 w 90
that 2 w 95
our 1 w 98
father 1 w 104
was 1 w 107
the 5 w 110
victim 1 w 116
of 2 w 118
a 12 w 119
malicious 1 w 128
action 1 w 134
than 1 w 139
for 2 w 142
them 1 w 146
that 3 w 151
they 1 w 155
were 1 w 159
being 1 w 164
defrauded 1 w 173
of 3 w 175
a 18 w 176
large 2 w 181
estate 1 w 187
For 2 w 191
if 1 w 193
he 8 w 195
could 1 w 200
prove 1 w 205
his 1 w 208
claims 1 w 214
for 3 w 217
eighty 1 w 223
talents 1 w 230
no 1 w 233
man 1 w 236
in 4 w 238
the 8 w 241
world 1 w 246
would 1 w 251
have 1 w 255
accepted 1 w 263
three 1 w 268
talents 2 w 275
in 5 w 277
settlement 1 w 287
whereas 1 w 295
anyone 1 w 301
being 2 w 307
defendant 1 w 316
in 7 w 318
a 30 w 319
guardianship 1 w 331
suit 2 w 335
involving 1 w 344
such 1 w 348
large 3 w 353
sums 1 w 357
would 2 w 363
have 2 w 367
paid 1 w 371
three 2 w 376
talents 3 w 383
to 1 w 385
buy 1 w 388
off 1 w 391
the 9 w 394
risk 1 w 398
and 1 w 401
the 10 w 404
advantages 1 w 414
with 1 w 418
which 1 w 423
at 6 w 425
that 4 w 429
time 1 w 433
nature 1 w 439
supplied 1 w 447
these 1 w 452
men 2 w 455
They 1 w 460
were 2 w 464
orphans 1 w 471
and 2 w 474
young 1 w 479
and 3 w 483
you 2 w 486
were 3 w 490
ignorant 1 w 498
of 5 w 500
their 1 w 505
real 1 w 509
characters 1 w 519
and 4 w 523
everyone 1 w 531
says 1 w 535
that 5 w 539
in 10 w 541
your 1 w 545
courts 1 w 551
these 2 w 556
things 1 w 562
have 3 w 566
more 1 w 570
weight 1 w 576
than 2 w 580
strong 2 w 586
arguments 1 w 595
Moreover 1 w 604
I 2 w 606
think 2 w 611
I 3 w 612
can 1 w 615
also 1 w 619
prove 2 w 624
that 6 w 628
you 4 w 631
might 1 w 636
with 2 w 640
good 1 w 644
reason 1 w 650
refuse 1 w 656
to 2 w 658
hear 1 w 662
a 62 w 663
word 1 w 667
from 1 w 671
them 2 w 675
in 13 w 677
regard 1 w 683
to 3 w 685
the 15 w 688
guardianship 2 w 700
The 2 w 704
following 1 w 713
passage 1 w 720
is 4 w 722
repeated 1 w 730
almost 1 w 736
verbatim 1 w 744
from 2 w 748
the 16 w 751
preceding 1 w 760
oration 1 w 767
Dem 1 w 771
37 1 w 774
58 1 w 777
ff 2 w 779
For 3 w 783
suppose 1 w 790
one 3 w 793
should 1 w 799
grant 1 w 804
that 7 w 808
they 2 w 812
have 4 w 816
suffered 1 w 824
the 18 w 827
greatest 1 w 835
possible 1 w 843
wrongs 1 w 849
and 5 w 853
that 8 w 857
everything 1 w 867
which 2 w 872
they 3 w 876
will 1 w 880
now 1 w 883
allege 1 w 889
about 1 w 894
these 3 w 899
matters 1 w 906
is 5 w 908
true 1 w 912
this 1 w 917
at 18 w 920
least 1 w 925
I 4 w 927
presume 1 w 934
you 5 w 937
would 3 w 942
all 2 w 945
admit 1 w 950
that 9 w 955
it 6 w 957
has 1 w 960
happened 1 w 968
to 4 w 970
others 1 w 976
ere 6 w 979
now 2 w 982
to 5 w 984
have 5 w 988
suffered 2 w 996
many 1 w 1000
wrongs 2 w 1006
more 2 w 1010
serious 1 w 1017
than 3 w 1021
pecuniary 1 w 1030
wrongs 3 w 1036
For 4 w 1040
involuntary 1 w 1051
homicides 1 w 1060
outrages 1 w 1069
on 12 w 1071
what 1 w 1075
is 7 w 1077
sacred 1 w 1083
and 6 w 1087
many 2 w 1091
other 2 w 1096
such 2 w 1100
crimes 1 w 1106
are 1 w 1109
committed 1 w 1118
yet 1 w 1122
in 18 w 1124
all 3 w 1127
these 4 w 1132
cases 1 w 1137
the 24 w 1140
fact 1 w 1144
they 4 w 1148
have 6 w 1152
yielded 1 w 1159
to 6 w 1161
persuasion 1 w 1171
and 7 w 1174
given 1 w 1179
a 105 w 1180
release 1 w 1187
is 8 w 1189
appointed 1 w 1198
for 4 w 1201
the 26 w 1204
parties 1 w 1211
wronged 1 w 1218
as 12 w 1220
a 110 w 1221
limit 1 w 1226
and 8 w 1229
settlement 2 w 1239
of 6 w 1241
the 27 w 1244
dispute 1 w 1251
And 1 w 1255
this 2 w 1259
just 1 w 1263
principle 1 w 1272
is 11 w 1274
so 3 w 1276
binding 1 w 1283
among 1 w 1288
all 4 w 1291
men 5 w 1294
that 10 w 1299
if 2 w 1302
one 4 w 1305
having 1 w 1312
convicted 1 w 1321
another 1 w 1328
of 7 w 1330
involuntary 2 w 1341
homicide 2 w 1349
and 9 w 1353
clearly 1 w 1360
shown 1 w 1365
him 1 w 1368
to 7 w 1370
be 3 w 1372
polluted 1 w 1380
subsequently 1 w 1393
takes 1 w 1398
pity 1 w 1402
upon 1 w 1406
him 2 w 1409
and 10 w 1413
releases 1 w 1421
him 3 w 1424
he 34 w 1427
has 2 w 1430
no 6 w 1432
longer 1 w 1438
the 29 w 1441
right 1 w 1446
to 8 w 1448
have 7 w 1452
the 30 w 1455
same 1 w 1459
person 1 w 1465
driven 1 w 1471
into 1 w 1475
exile 1 w 1480
If 1 w 1483
then 2 w 1488
when 1 w 1493
life 1 w 1497
and 11 w 1500
all 5 w 1503
that 11 w 1507
is 12 w 1509
most 2 w 1513
precious 1 w 1521
are 2 w 1524
at 23 w 1526
stake 1 w 1531
a 132 w 1533
release 3 w 1540
has 3 w 1543
this 3 w 1547
power 1 w 1552
and 12 w 1555
validity 1 w 1563
shall 1 w 1569
it 11 w 1571
be 4 w 1573
without 1 w 1580
effect 1 w 1586
when 2 w 1591
money 1 w 1596
is 14 w 1598
at 24 w 1600
stake 2 w 1605
or 17 w 1608
claims 2 w 1614
of 8 w 1616
lesser 1 w 1622
importance 1 w 1632
Surely 1 w 1639
not 2 w 1642
For 5 w 1646
the 32 w 1649
thing 3 w 1654
most 3 w 1658
to 10 w 1660
be 5 w 1662
feared 1 w 1668
is 15 w 1670
not 3 w 1674
that 12 w 1678
I 6 w 1679
should 2 w 1685
fail 1 w 1689
to 11 w 1691
obtain 1 w 1697
justice 1 w 1704
in 28 w 1706
your 2 w 1710
court 2 w 1715
but 1 w 1719
that 13 w 1723
a 147 w 1724
just 3 w 1728
practice 1 w 1736
established 1 w 1748
from 3 w 1752
the 33 w 1755
beginning 1 w 1764
of 9 w 1766
time 2 w 1770
should 3 w 1777
now 3 w 1780
be 7 w 1782
done 1 w 1786
away 1 w 1790
with 4 w 1794