Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Androtion

Against Androtion (28-30)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0014.tlg022.perseus-eng2:28-30
Refs {'start': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}, 'end': {'reference': '30', 'human_reference': 'Section 30'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now just suppose that a man, instead of rebutting the charge of crime or impiety or whatever else he may be tried for, should claim his acquittal on these grounds-in the case of an arrest, that you might have brought an action before an arbitrator and that you ought to have indicted him, or, if he is defendant in an arbitrators court, that you ought to have arrested him, so that you might risk a fine of a thousand drachmas. Surely that would be a farce. A defendant, if innocent, need not dispute the method by which he is brought.to justice: he ought to prove hat he is innocent.

In just the same way, if you, Androtion, propose a decree after having been guilty of prostitution, do not imagine that you ought to escape punishment because we might also have denounced you to the Thesmothetae, but either prove that you are innocent or submit to punishment for any decrees that you have proposed, being what you are; or you have no right to propose them. If we do not punish you by every process that the laws allow, be grateful to us for those that we omit: do not on that ground claim to pay no penalty at all.

Now it is worth your while, men of Athens, to study too the character of Solon, who framed this law, and to observe what care he took of the constitution in all the laws, how much more zealous indeed he was for the constitution than for the matter on which he was legislating. This may be seen in many ways, but especially from this law, which forbids persons guilty of prostitution to make speeches or to propose measures. For he saw that the majority of you do not avail yourselves of your right to speak, so that the prohibition seemed no great hardship, and he could have laid down many harsher penalties, if his object had been the chastisement of these offenders.

Tokens

Now 1 w 3
just 1 w 7
suppose 1 w 14
that 1 w 18
a 2 w 19
man 1 w 22
instead 1 w 30
of 1 w 32
rebutting 1 w 41
the 1 w 44
charge 1 w 50
of 2 w 52
crime 1 w 57
or 1 w 59
impiety 1 w 66
or 2 w 68
whatever 1 w 76
else 1 w 80
he 2 w 82
may 1 w 85
be 1 w 87
tried 1 w 92
for 1 w 95
should 1 w 102
claim 1 w 107
his 1 w 110
acquittal 1 w 119
on 1 w 121
these 1 w 126
grounds-in 1 w 136
the 3 w 139
case 1 w 143
of 3 w 145
an 2 w 147
arrest 1 w 153
that 2 w 158
you 1 w 161
might 1 w 166
have 1 w 170
brought 1 w 177
an 3 w 179
action 1 w 185
before 1 w 191
an 4 w 193
arbitrator 1 w 203
and 1 w 206
that 3 w 210
you 2 w 213
ought 2 w 218
to 2 w 220
have 2 w 224
indicted 1 w 232
him 1 w 235
or 6 w 238
if 1 w 241
he 5 w 243
is 2 w 245
defendant 1 w 254
in 5 w 256
an 7 w 258
arbitrator 2 w 268
s 13 w 270
court 1 w 275
that 4 w 280
you 3 w 283
ought 3 w 288
to 4 w 290
have 3 w 294
arrested 1 w 302
him 2 w 305
so 1 w 308
that 5 w 312
you 4 w 315
might 2 w 320
risk 1 w 324
a 32 w 325
fine 1 w 329
of 4 w 331
a 33 w 332
thousand 1 w 340
drachmas 1 w 348
Surely 1 w 355
that 6 w 359
would 1 w 364
be 3 w 366
a 38 w 367
farce 1 w 372
A 1 w 374
defendant 2 w 383
if 2 w 386
innocent 1 w 394
need 1 w 399
not 1 w 402
dispute 1 w 409
the 4 w 412
method 1 w 418
by 1 w 420
which 1 w 425
he 7 w 427
is 5 w 429
brought 2 w 436
to 5 w 439
justice 1 w 446
he 8 w 449
ought 5 w 454
to 6 w 456
prove 1 w 461
hat 8 w 464
he 9 w 466
is 6 w 468
innocent 2 w 476
In 1 w 479
just 3 w 483
the 5 w 486
same 1 w 490
way 1 w 493
if 3 w 496
you 5 w 499
Androtion 1 w 509
propose 1 w 517
a 44 w 518
decree 1 w 524
after 1 w 529
having 1 w 535
been 1 w 539
guilty 1 w 545
of 5 w 547
prostitution 1 w 559
do 1 w 562
not 2 w 565
imagine 1 w 572
that 7 w 576
you 6 w 579
ought 6 w 584
to 7 w 586
escape 1 w 592
punishment 1 w 602
because 1 w 609
we 1 w 611
might 3 w 616
also 1 w 620
have 4 w 624
denounced 1 w 633
you 7 w 636
to 8 w 638
the 6 w 641
Thesmothetae 1 w 653
but 2 w 657
either 1 w 663
prove 2 w 668
that 8 w 672
you 8 w 675
are 1 w 678
innocent 3 w 686
or 8 w 688
submit 1 w 694
to 9 w 696
punishment 2 w 706
for 3 w 709
any 1 w 712
decrees 1 w 719
that 9 w 723
you 9 w 726
have 5 w 730
proposed 1 w 738
being 1 w 744
what 2 w 748
you 10 w 751
are 2 w 754
or 10 w 757
you 11 w 760
have 6 w 764
no 7 w 766
right 1 w 771
to 10 w 773
propose 3 w 780
them 1 w 784
If 1 w 787
we 2 w 789
do 2 w 791
not 3 w 794
punish 3 w 800
you 12 w 803
by 2 w 805
every 1 w 810
process 1 w 817
that 10 w 821
the 10 w 824
laws 1 w 828
allow 1 w 833
be 7 w 836
grateful 1 w 844
to 11 w 846
us 6 w 848
for 4 w 851
those 1 w 856
that 11 w 860
we 3 w 862
omit 1 w 866
do 3 w 869
not 4 w 872
on 5 w 874
that 12 w 878
ground 2 w 884
claim 2 w 889
to 12 w 891
pay 1 w 894
no 10 w 896
penalty 1 w 903
at 19 w 905
all 2 w 908
Now 2 w 912
it 8 w 914
is 10 w 916
worth 1 w 921
your 1 w 925
while 1 w 930
men 3 w 934
of 6 w 936
Athens 1 w 942
to 13 w 945
study 1 w 950
too 1 w 953
the 12 w 956
character 1 w 965
of 7 w 967
Solon 1 w 972
who 1 w 976
framed 1 w 982
this 1 w 986
law 2 w 989
and 3 w 993
to 15 w 995
observe 1 w 1002
what 3 w 1006
care 1 w 1010
he 19 w 1012
took 1 w 1016
of 8 w 1018
the 13 w 1021
constitution 1 w 1033
in 13 w 1035
all 3 w 1038
the 14 w 1041
laws 2 w 1045
how 1 w 1049
much 1 w 1053
more 1 w 1057
zealous 1 w 1064
indeed 1 w 1070
he 22 w 1072
was 1 w 1075
for 5 w 1078
the 15 w 1081
constitution 2 w 1093
than 1 w 1097
for 6 w 1100
the 16 w 1103
matter 1 w 1109
on 11 w 1111
which 2 w 1116
he 25 w 1118
was 2 w 1121
legislating 1 w 1132
This 1 w 1137
may 2 w 1140
be 8 w 1142
seen 1 w 1146
in 16 w 1148
many 1 w 1152
ways 1 w 1156
but 3 w 1160
especially 1 w 1170
from 1 w 1174
this 2 w 1178
law 4 w 1181
which 3 w 1187
forbids 1 w 1194
persons 1 w 1201
guilty 2 w 1207
of 9 w 1209
prostitution 2 w 1221
to 17 w 1223
make 1 w 1227
speeches 1 w 1235
or 17 w 1237
to 18 w 1239
propose 4 w 1246
measures 1 w 1254
For 1 w 1258
he 27 w 1260
saw 1 w 1263
that 13 w 1267
the 17 w 1270
majority 1 w 1278
of 10 w 1280
you 14 w 1283
do 4 w 1285
not 5 w 1288
avail 1 w 1293
yourselves 1 w 1303
of 11 w 1305
your 3 w 1309
right 2 w 1314
to 19 w 1316
speak 1 w 1321
so 4 w 1324
that 14 w 1328
the 18 w 1331
prohibition 1 w 1342
seemed 1 w 1348
no 12 w 1350
great 1 w 1355
hardship 1 w 1363
and 4 w 1367
he 30 w 1369
could 1 w 1374
have 7 w 1378
laid 1 w 1382
down 1 w 1386
many 2 w 1390
harsher 1 w 1397
penalties 1 w 1406
if 4 w 1409
his 5 w 1412
object 1 w 1418
had 1 w 1421
been 2 w 1425
the 19 w 1428
chastisement 1 w 1440
of 12 w 1442
these 2 w 1447
offenders 1 w 1456