Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Leptines

Against Leptines (126-127)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0014.tlg020.perseus-eng2:126-127
Refs {'start': {'reference': '126', 'human_reference': 'Section 126'}, 'end': {'reference': '127', 'human_reference': 'Section 127'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

For if by appealing to the name of the gods they try to justify a robbery which they cannot justify otherwise, will not that be most impious and monstrous conduct? In my opinion, whenever a man appeals solemnly to the gods, his conduct ought to be clearly such as would not appear base even if supported only by human authority. Now that there is a difference between exemption from religious duties and exemption from public services, and that the defendants are trying to deceive you by transferring the name of public services to religious acts, I shall adduce Leptines himself as my witness.

For the first clause of the law says Leptines proposed that, to the end that the wealthiest citizens may perform the public services, none shall be immune save and except the descendants of Harmodius and Aristogiton. But if immunity from religious duties were the same as immunity from public services, what was the object of that clause? For immunity from religious duties has never been granted even to the persons here named. To prove that this is so, please take and read the copy of the inscription and then the beginning of the law of Leptines.

[The copy of the inscription is read]

Tokens

For 1 w 3
if 1 w 5
by 1 w 7
appealing 1 w 16
to 1 w 18
the 1 w 21
name 1 w 25
of 1 w 27
the 2 w 30
gods 1 w 34
they 1 w 38
try 1 w 41
to 2 w 43
justify 1 w 50
a 4 w 51
robbery 1 w 58
which 1 w 63
they 2 w 67
cannot 1 w 73
justify 2 w 80
otherwise 1 w 89
will 1 w 94
not 2 w 97
that 1 w 101
be 2 w 103
most 1 w 107
impious 1 w 114
and 1 w 117
monstrous 1 w 126
conduct 1 w 133
In 1 w 136
my 1 w 138
opinion 1 w 145
whenever 1 w 154
a 8 w 155
man 1 w 158
appeals 1 w 165
solemnly 1 w 173
to 3 w 175
the 6 w 178
gods 2 w 182
his 1 w 186
conduct 2 w 193
ought 1 w 198
to 4 w 200
be 3 w 202
clearly 1 w 209
such 1 w 213
as 1 w 215
would 1 w 220
not 3 w 223
appear 1 w 229
base 1 w 233
even 1 w 237
if 4 w 239
supported 1 w 248
only 1 w 252
by 2 w 254
human 1 w 259
authority 1 w 268
Now 1 w 272
that 2 w 276
there 1 w 281
is 3 w 283
a 20 w 284
difference 1 w 294
between 1 w 301
exemption 1 w 310
from 1 w 314
religious 1 w 323
duties 1 w 329
and 2 w 332
exemption 2 w 341
from 2 w 345
public 1 w 351
services 1 w 359
and 3 w 363
that 3 w 367
the 8 w 370
defendants 1 w 380
are 1 w 383
trying 1 w 389
to 5 w 391
deceive 1 w 398
you 1 w 401
by 3 w 403
transferring 1 w 415
the 9 w 418
name 2 w 422
of 2 w 424
public 2 w 430
services 2 w 438
to 6 w 440
religious 2 w 449
acts 1 w 453
I 2 w 455
shall 1 w 460
adduce 1 w 466
Leptines 1 w 474
himself 1 w 481
as 3 w 483
my 2 w 485
witness 1 w 492
For 2 w 496
the 10 w 499
first 1 w 504
clause 1 w 510
of 3 w 512
the 11 w 515
law 1 w 518
says 1 w 522
Leptines 2 w 530
proposed 1 w 538
that 4 w 542
to 7 w 545
the 12 w 548
end 2 w 551
that 5 w 555
the 13 w 558
wealthiest 1 w 568
citizens 1 w 576
may 1 w 579
perform 1 w 586
the 14 w 589
public 3 w 595
services 3 w 603
none 1 w 608
shall 2 w 613
be 5 w 615
immune 1 w 621
save 1 w 625
and 4 w 628
except 1 w 634
the 15 w 637
descendants 1 w 648
of 4 w 650
Harmodius 1 w 659
and 5 w 662
Aristogiton 1 w 673
But 1 w 677
if 6 w 679
immunity 1 w 687
from 3 w 691
religious 3 w 700
duties 2 w 706
were 1 w 710
the 16 w 713
same 1 w 717
as 4 w 719
immunity 2 w 727
from 4 w 731
public 4 w 737
services 4 w 745
what 1 w 750
was 1 w 753
the 17 w 756
object 1 w 762
of 5 w 764
that 6 w 768
clause 2 w 774
For 3 w 778
immunity 3 w 786
from 5 w 790
religious 4 w 799
duties 3 w 805
has 1 w 808
never 2 w 813
been 1 w 817
granted 1 w 824
even 2 w 828
to 10 w 830
the 18 w 833
persons 1 w 840
here 2 w 844
named 1 w 849
To 1 w 852
prove 1 w 857
that 7 w 861
this 1 w 865
is 6 w 867
so 3 w 869
please 1 w 876
take 1 w 880
and 6 w 883
read 1 w 887
the 19 w 890
copy 1 w 894
of 6 w 896
the 20 w 899
inscription 1 w 910
and 7 w 913
then 1 w 917
the 22 w 920
beginning 1 w 929
of 7 w 931
the 23 w 934
law 2 w 937
of 8 w 939
Leptines 3 w 947
The 1 w 952
copy 2 w 956
of 9 w 958
the 24 w 961
inscription 2 w 972
is 7 w 974
read 2 w 978