Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Chersonese

On the Chersonese (56-60)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0014.tlg008.perseus-eng2:56-60
Refs {'start': {'reference': '56', 'human_reference': 'Section 56'}, 'end': {'reference': '60', 'human_reference': 'Section 60'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

What then is the reason, men of Athens, why these speakers never admit that Philip is provoking war, when he is thus openly conducting campaigns, violating rights, and subduing cities, but when others urge you not to give way to Philip nor submit to these losses, they accuse them of trying to provoke war? I will explain.

It is because they want the natural anger that you would feel at any sufferings in the war to be diverted against your wisest counsellors, so that you may bring them to trial instead of punishing Philip, and that they may themselves be the accusers instead of paying the penalty for their present wrong-doings. That is the meaning of their suggestion that there is a party among you that desires war, and that that is the question you now have to decide.[*]

But I am absolutely certain that, without waiting for any Athenian to propose a declaration of war, Philip is in possession of much of our territory and has just dispatched a force against Cardia. If, however, we like to pretend that he is not at war with us, he would be the greatest fool alive if he tried to disprove that.

But when our turn comes, what shall we say then? For of course he will deny that he is attacking us, just as he denied that he was attacking the men of Oreus, when his troops were already in their territory, or the Pheraeans before that, when he was actually assaulting their walls, or the Olynthians at the start, until he was inside their frontiers with his army. Or shall we say, even at that hour, that those who bid us repel him are provoking war? If so, there is nothing left but slavery; for there is no alternative between that and being allowed neither to defend ourselves nor to remain at peace.

Moreover, you have not the same interests at stake as the other cities, for it is not our subjection that Philip aims at, but our annihilation. He is well assured that you will not consent to be slaves; or if you consent, will never learn how to be slaves, for you are accustomed to rule others; but that you will be able, if you seize your opportunity, to cause him more trouble than all the rest of the world.

Tokens

What 1 w 4
then 1 w 8
is 1 w 10
the 2 w 13
reason 1 w 19
men 1 w 23
of 1 w 25
Athens 1 w 31
why 1 w 35
these 1 w 40
speakers 1 w 48
never 1 w 53
admit 1 w 58
that 1 w 62
Philip 1 w 68
is 2 w 70
provoking 1 w 79
war 1 w 82
when 1 w 87
he 6 w 89
is 3 w 91
thus 1 w 95
openly 1 w 101
conducting 1 w 111
campaigns 1 w 120
violating 1 w 130
rights 1 w 136
and 1 w 140
subduing 1 w 148
cities 1 w 154
but 1 w 158
when 2 w 162
others 1 w 168
urge 1 w 172
you 1 w 175
not 1 w 178
to 1 w 180
give 1 w 184
way 1 w 187
to 2 w 189
Philip 2 w 195
nor 1 w 198
submit 1 w 204
to 3 w 206
these 2 w 211
losses 1 w 217
they 1 w 222
accuse 1 w 228
them 1 w 232
of 2 w 234
trying 1 w 240
to 4 w 242
provoke 1 w 249
war 2 w 252
I 1 w 254
will 1 w 258
explain 1 w 265
It 1 w 268
is 4 w 270
because 1 w 277
they 2 w 281
want 1 w 285
the 10 w 288
natural 1 w 295
anger 1 w 300
that 2 w 304
you 2 w 307
would 1 w 312
feel 1 w 316
at 6 w 318
any 1 w 321
sufferings 1 w 331
in 8 w 333
the 11 w 336
war 3 w 339
to 5 w 341
be 2 w 343
diverted 1 w 351
against 1 w 358
your 1 w 362
wisest 1 w 368
counsellors 1 w 379
so 2 w 382
that 3 w 386
you 4 w 389
may 1 w 392
bring 1 w 397
them 2 w 401
to 6 w 403
trial 1 w 408
instead 1 w 415
of 3 w 417
punishing 1 w 426
Philip 3 w 432
and 2 w 436
that 4 w 440
they 3 w 444
may 2 w 447
themselves 1 w 457
be 3 w 459
the 15 w 462
accusers 1 w 470
instead 2 w 477
of 4 w 479
paying 1 w 485
the 16 w 488
penalty 1 w 495
for 1 w 498
their 1 w 503
present 1 w 510
wrong-doings 1 w 522
That 1 w 527
is 7 w 529
the 18 w 532
meaning 1 w 539
of 5 w 541
their 2 w 546
suggestion 1 w 556
that 5 w 560
there 1 w 565
is 8 w 567
a 40 w 568
party 1 w 573
among 1 w 578
you 5 w 581
that 6 w 585
desires 1 w 592
war 4 w 595
and 3 w 599
that 7 w 603
that 8 w 607
is 9 w 609
the 21 w 612
question 1 w 620
you 6 w 623
now 1 w 626
have 1 w 630
to 7 w 632
decide 1 w 638
διαδικασία 1 w 649
is 10 w 651
a 49 w 652
lawsuit 1 w 659
between 1 w 666
rival 1 w 671
claimants 1 w 680
to 8 w 682
an 9 w 684
estate 1 w 690
etc 1 w 694
The 1 w 698
war-party 1 w 707
and 4 w 710
the 22 w 713
peace-party 1 w 724
are 1 w 727
here 2 w 731
rival 2 w 736
claimants 2 w 745
for 2 w 748
the 23 w 751
votes 1 w 756
of 6 w 758
the 24 w 761
Athenians 1 w 770
But 1 w 774
I 3 w 775
am 3 w 777
absolutely 1 w 787
certain 1 w 794
that 9 w 798
without 1 w 806
waiting 1 w 813
for 3 w 816
any 2 w 819
Athenian 2 w 827
to 9 w 829
propose 1 w 836
a 73 w 837
declaration 1 w 848
of 7 w 850
war 6 w 853
Philip 4 w 860
is 11 w 862
in 19 w 864
possession 1 w 874
of 8 w 876
much 1 w 880
of 9 w 882
our 2 w 885
territory 1 w 894
and 5 w 897
has 1 w 900
just 1 w 904
dispatched 1 w 914
a 80 w 915
force 1 w 920
against 2 w 927
Cardia 1 w 933
If 1 w 936
however 1 w 944
we 3 w 947
like 1 w 951
to 11 w 953
pretend 1 w 960
that 10 w 964
he 33 w 966
is 13 w 968
not 2 w 971
at 19 w 973
war 7 w 976
with 2 w 980
us 6 w 982
he 34 w 985
would 2 w 990
be 5 w 992
the 27 w 995
greatest 1 w 1003
fool 1 w 1007
alive 1 w 1012
if 1 w 1014
he 36 w 1016
tried 1 w 1021
to 12 w 1023
disprove 1 w 1031
that 11 w 1035
But 2 w 1039
when 3 w 1043
our 3 w 1046
turn 1 w 1050
comes 1 w 1055
what 1 w 1060
shall 1 w 1065
we 4 w 1067
say 1 w 1070
then 5 w 1074
For 1 w 1078
of 10 w 1080
course 1 w 1086
he 39 w 1088
will 2 w 1092
deny 1 w 1096
that 12 w 1100
he 40 w 1102
is 15 w 1104
attacking 1 w 1113
us 7 w 1115
just 2 w 1120
as 3 w 1122
he 41 w 1124
denied 1 w 1130
that 13 w 1134
he 42 w 1136
was 1 w 1139
attacking 2 w 1148
the 29 w 1151
men 2 w 1154
of 11 w 1156
Oreus 1 w 1161
when 4 w 1166
his 1 w 1169
troops 1 w 1175
were 1 w 1179
already 1 w 1186
in 23 w 1188
their 3 w 1193
territory 2 w 1202
or 10 w 1205
the 31 w 1208
Pheraeans 1 w 1217
before 1 w 1223
that 14 w 1227
when 5 w 1232
he 49 w 1234
was 2 w 1237
actually 1 w 1245
assaulting 1 w 1255
their 4 w 1260
walls 1 w 1265
or 12 w 1268
the 33 w 1271
Olynthians 1 w 1281
at 28 w 1283
the 34 w 1286
start 1 w 1291
until 1 w 1297
he 53 w 1299
was 3 w 1302
inside 1 w 1308
their 5 w 1313
frontiers 1 w 1322
with 3 w 1326
his 2 w 1329
army 1 w 1333
Or 2 w 1336
shall 2 w 1341
we 6 w 1343
say 2 w 1346
even 1 w 1351
at 29 w 1353
that 15 w 1357
hour 1 w 1361
that 16 w 1366
those 1 w 1371
who 1 w 1374
bid 1 w 1377
us 10 w 1379
repel 1 w 1384
him 1 w 1387
are 2 w 1390
provoking 2 w 1399
war 8 w 1402
If 2 w 1405
so 4 w 1407
there 2 w 1413
is 18 w 1415
nothing 1 w 1422
left 1 w 1426
but 2 w 1429
slavery 1 w 1436
for 6 w 1440
there 3 w 1445
is 19 w 1447
no 6 w 1449
alternative 1 w 1460
between 2 w 1467
that 17 w 1471
and 6 w 1474
being 1 w 1479
allowed 1 w 1486
neither 1 w 1493
to 14 w 1495
defend 1 w 1501
ourselves 1 w 1510
nor 2 w 1513
to 15 w 1515
remain 1 w 1521
at 34 w 1523
peace 2 w 1528
Moreover 1 w 1537
you 7 w 1541
have 2 w 1545
not 4 w 1548
the 39 w 1551
same 1 w 1555
interests 1 w 1564
at 35 w 1566
stake 1 w 1571
as 8 w 1573
the 40 w 1576
other 2 w 1581
cities 2 w 1587
for 7 w 1591
it 13 w 1593
is 20 w 1595
not 5 w 1598
our 7 w 1601
subjection 1 w 1611
that 18 w 1615
Philip 5 w 1621
aims 1 w 1625
at 37 w 1627
but 3 w 1631
our 8 w 1634
annihilation 1 w 1646
He 1 w 1649
is 21 w 1651
well 1 w 1655
assured 1 w 1662
that 19 w 1666
you 8 w 1669
will 3 w 1673
not 6 w 1676
consent 1 w 1683
to 16 w 1685
be 9 w 1687
slaves 1 w 1693
or 17 w 1696
if 2 w 1698
you 9 w 1701
consent 2 w 1708
will 4 w 1713
never 2 w 1718
learn 1 w 1723
how 2 w 1726
to 17 w 1728
be 10 w 1730
slaves 2 w 1736
for 8 w 1740
you 10 w 1743
are 3 w 1746
accustomed 1 w 1756
to 19 w 1758
rule 1 w 1762
others 2 w 1768
but 4 w 1772
that 20 w 1776
you 11 w 1779
will 5 w 1783
be 11 w 1785
able 1 w 1789
if 3 w 1792
you 12 w 1795
seize 1 w 1800
your 2 w 1804
opportunity 1 w 1815
to 20 w 1818
cause 2 w 1823
him 2 w 1826
more 1 w 1830
trouble 1 w 1837
than 1 w 1841
all 6 w 1844
the 43 w 1847
rest 2 w 1851
of 12 w 1853
the 44 w 1856
world 1 w 1861