Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Deipnosophists

The Deipnosophists (1.46)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0008.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.46
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.46', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 46'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And that they used to eat fish, Sarpedon proves plainly, when he compares the being taken prisoner to fish caught in a large net. Yet Eubulus, jesting in the way that the comic writers allow themselves, says

I pray you, where in Homer is the chief
Who e'er eat fish, or anything but beef?
And, though so much of liberty they boasted,
Their meat was never anything but roasted.
Nor did those heroes allow the birds the free enjoyment of the air; setting traps and nets for thrushes and doves. And they practised the art of taking birds, and, suspending a dove by a small string to the mast of a ship, then shot arrows at it from a distance, as is shown in the book describing the funeral games. But Homer passed over the use of vegetables, and fish, and birds, lest to mention them should seem like praising gluttony, thinking besides there would be a want of decorum in dwelling on the preparation of such things, which he considered beneath the dignity of gods and heroes. But that they did in reality eat their meat boiled as well as roasted, he shows when he says
But as a caldron boils with melting fat
Of well-fed pig;
v.1.p.42
and the foot of the ox which was thrown at Ulysses proves it too, for no one ever roasts oxen's feet. And the line too-
Then many a well-fill'd dish was duly set
On the full board, with every kind of meat;
as this not only speaks of the variety of meats, such as birds, pigs, kids, and beef; but it also speaks of the way in which they were dressed as having varied, and not having been all of one kind, but carefully arranged. So that you may see here the origin of the Sicilian and Sybaritic and Italian ways of giving feasts, and the Chian fashion also. For the Chians are reported not to have been less studious than the other nations just mentioned in the art of dressing their meat. Timocles says
The Chians
Are splendid hands at dressing viands.
And in Homer, not only the young men, but the old men too, such as Phœnix and Nestor, sleep with the women; and Menelaus is the only man who has no woman allotted to him, inasmuch as he had collected the whole expedition for the sake of his wife, who had been carried away from him.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
that 1 w 7
they 1 w 11
used 1 w 15
to 1 w 17
eat 1 w 20
fish 1 w 24
Sarpedon 1 w 33
proves 1 w 39
plainly 1 w 46
when 1 w 51
he 3 w 53
compares 1 w 61
the 2 w 64
being 1 w 69
taken 1 w 74
prisoner 1 w 82
to 2 w 84
fish 2 w 88
caught 1 w 94
in 3 w 96
a 8 w 97
large 1 w 102
net 1 w 105
Yet 1 w 109
Eubulus 1 w 116
jesting 1 w 124
in 5 w 126
the 3 w 129
way 1 w 132
that 2 w 136
the 4 w 139
comic 1 w 144
writers 1 w 151
allow 1 w 156
themselves 1 w 166
says 1 w 171
I 1 w 173
pray 1 w 177
you 1 w 180
where 1 w 186
in 6 w 188
Homer 1 w 193
is 4 w 195
the 6 w 198
chief 1 w 203
Who 1 w 206
e 28 w 207
er 5 w 210
eat 2 w 213
fish 3 w 217
or 1 w 220
anything 1 w 228
but 1 w 231
beef 1 w 235
And 2 w 239
though 1 w 246
so 2 w 248
much 1 w 252
of 1 w 254
liberty 1 w 261
they 2 w 265
boasted 1 w 272
Their 1 w 278
meat 1 w 282
was 1 w 285
never 1 w 290
anything 2 w 298
but 2 w 301
roasted 1 w 308
Nor 1 w 312
did 1 w 315
those 1 w 320
heroes 1 w 326
allow 2 w 331
the 8 w 334
birds 1 w 339
the 9 w 342
free 1 w 346
enjoyment 1 w 355
of 2 w 357
the 10 w 360
air 1 w 363
setting 1 w 371
traps 1 w 376
and 1 w 379
nets 1 w 383
for 1 w 386
thrushes 1 w 394
and 2 w 397
doves 1 w 402
And 3 w 406
they 3 w 410
practised 1 w 419
the 12 w 422
art 1 w 425
of 3 w 427
taking 1 w 433
birds 2 w 438
and 3 w 442
suspending 1 w 453
a 31 w 454
dove 2 w 458
by 1 w 460
a 32 w 461
small 1 w 466
string 1 w 472
to 3 w 474
the 13 w 477
mast 1 w 481
of 4 w 483
a 35 w 484
ship 1 w 488
then 1 w 493
shot 1 w 497
arrows 1 w 503
at 6 w 505
it 2 w 507
from 1 w 511
a 38 w 512
distance 1 w 520
as 5 w 523
is 8 w 525
shown 1 w 530
in 13 w 532
the 15 w 535
book 1 w 539
describing 1 w 549
the 16 w 552
funeral 1 w 559
games 1 w 564
But 1 w 568
Homer 2 w 573
passed 1 w 579
over 1 w 583
the 17 w 586
use 2 w 589
of 5 w 591
vegetables 1 w 601
and 4 w 605
fish 4 w 609
and 5 w 613
birds 3 w 618
lest 1 w 623
to 4 w 625
mention 1 w 632
them 2 w 636
should 1 w 642
seem 1 w 646
like 1 w 650
praising 1 w 658
gluttony 1 w 666
thinking 1 w 675
besides 1 w 682
there 1 w 687
would 1 w 692
be 5 w 694
a 48 w 695
want 1 w 699
of 6 w 701
decorum 1 w 708
in 18 w 710
dwelling 1 w 718
on 5 w 720
the 20 w 723
preparation 1 w 734
of 7 w 736
such 1 w 740
things 1 w 746
which 1 w 752
he 27 w 754
considered 1 w 764
beneath 1 w 771
the 21 w 774
dignity 1 w 781
of 8 w 783
gods 1 w 787
and 6 w 790
heroes 2 w 796
But 2 w 800
that 3 w 804
they 4 w 808
did 2 w 811
in 21 w 813
reality 1 w 820
eat 5 w 823
their 1 w 828
meat 2 w 832
boiled 1 w 838
as 7 w 840
well 2 w 844
as 8 w 846
roasted 2 w 853
he 32 w 856
shows 1 w 861
when 2 w 865
he 34 w 867
says 2 w 871
But 3 w 875
as 10 w 877
a 63 w 878
caldron 1 w 885
boils 1 w 890
with 1 w 894
melting 1 w 901
fat 1 w 904
Of 1 w 906
well-fed 1 w 914
pig 1 w 917
and 7 w 921
the 24 w 924
foot 1 w 928
of 9 w 930
the 25 w 933
ox 1 w 935
which 2 w 940
was 2 w 943
thrown 1 w 949
at 13 w 951
Ulysses 1 w 958
proves 2 w 964
it 6 w 966
too 1 w 969
for 2 w 973
no 1 w 975
one 2 w 978
ever 2 w 982
roasts 1 w 988
oxen 1 w 992
s 78 w 994
feet 1 w 998
And 4 w 1002
the 26 w 1005
line 1 w 1009
too- 1 w 1013
Then 1 w 1017
many 1 w 1021
a 71 w 1022
well-fill 1 w 1031
d 43 w 1033
dish 1 w 1037
was 3 w 1040
duly 1 w 1044
set 2 w 1047
On 1 w 1049
the 27 w 1052
full 1 w 1056
board 1 w 1061
with 2 w 1066
every 1 w 1071
kind 1 w 1075
of 10 w 1077
meat 3 w 1081
as 14 w 1084
this 1 w 1088
not 1 w 1091
only 1 w 1095
speaks 1 w 1101
of 11 w 1103
the 28 w 1106
variety 1 w 1113
of 12 w 1115
meats 1 w 1120
such 2 w 1125
as 15 w 1127
birds 4 w 1132
pigs 1 w 1137
kids 1 w 1142
and 8 w 1146
beef 2 w 1150
but 3 w 1154
it 8 w 1156
also 1 w 1160
speaks 2 w 1166
of 13 w 1168
the 29 w 1171
way 2 w 1174
in 25 w 1176
which 3 w 1181
they 5 w 1185
were 1 w 1189
dressed 1 w 1196
as 16 w 1198
having 1 w 1204
varied 1 w 1210
and 9 w 1214
not 2 w 1217
having 2 w 1223
been 1 w 1227
all 4 w 1230
of 14 w 1232
one 3 w 1235
kind 2 w 1239
but 4 w 1243
carefully 1 w 1252
arranged 1 w 1260
So 1 w 1263
that 4 w 1267
you 2 w 1270
may 1 w 1273
see 2 w 1276
here 3 w 1280
the 31 w 1283
origin 1 w 1289
of 15 w 1291
the 32 w 1294
Sicilian 1 w 1302
and 10 w 1305
Sybaritic 1 w 1314
and 11 w 1317
Italian 1 w 1324
ways 1 w 1328
of 16 w 1330
giving 1 w 1336
feasts 1 w 1342
and 12 w 1346
the 33 w 1349
Chian 1 w 1354
fashion 1 w 1361
also 2 w 1365
For 1 w 1369
the 34 w 1372
Chians 1 w 1378
are 3 w 1381
reported 1 w 1389
not 3 w 1392
to 8 w 1394
have 1 w 1398
been 2 w 1402
less 1 w 1406
studious 1 w 1414
than 1 w 1418
the 35 w 1421
other 1 w 1426
nations 1 w 1433
just 1 w 1437
mentioned 1 w 1446
in 31 w 1448
the 37 w 1451
art 2 w 1454
of 17 w 1456
dressing 1 w 1464
their 2 w 1469
meat 5 w 1473
Timocles 1 w 1482
says 3 w 1486
The 3 w 1490
Chians 2 w 1496
Are 1 w 1499
splendid 1 w 1507
hands 1 w 1512
at 19 w 1514
dressing 2 w 1522
viands 1 w 1528
And 5 w 1532
in 34 w 1534
Homer 3 w 1539
not 4 w 1543
only 2 w 1547
the 39 w 1550
young 1 w 1555
men 4 w 1558
but 5 w 1562
the 40 w 1565
old 1 w 1568
men 5 w 1571
too 3 w 1574
such 3 w 1579
as 19 w 1581
Phœnix 1 w 1587
and 15 w 1590
Nestor 1 w 1596
sleep 1 w 1602
with 3 w 1606
the 41 w 1609
women 1 w 1614
and 16 w 1618
Menelaus 1 w 1626
is 13 w 1628
the 42 w 1631
only 3 w 1635
man 2 w 1638
who 1 w 1641
has 1 w 1644
no 6 w 1646
woman 1 w 1651
allotted 1 w 1659
to 11 w 1661
him 1 w 1664
inasmuch 1 w 1673
as 22 w 1675
he 57 w 1677
had 1 w 1680
collected 1 w 1689
the 43 w 1692
whole 1 w 1697
expedition 1 w 1707
for 3 w 1710
the 44 w 1713
sake 1 w 1717
of 18 w 1719
his 2 w 1722
wife 1 w 1726
who 3 w 1730
had 2 w 1733
been 3 w 1737
carried 1 w 1744
away 1 w 1748
from 2 w 1752
him 2 w 1755