Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / That it is Not Possible to Live Pleasurably According to the Doctrine of Epicurus

That it is Not Possible to Live Pleasurably According to the Doctrine of Epicurus (11)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg139.perseus-eng2:11
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'Section 11'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But now these appertain all solely to the mind. But they chase away from them the delights that accrue from the mathematics also. Though the satisfactions we receive from history have in them something simple and equal, but those that come from geometry, astronomy, and music inveigle and allure us with a sort of nimbleness and variety, and want nothing that is tempting and engaging; their figures attracting us as so many charms, whereof whoever

hath once tasted, if he be but competently skilled, will run about singing that in Sophocles,
Im mad; the Muses with new rage inspire me.
Ill mount the hill; my lyre, my numbers fire me.
[*]
Nor doth Thamyras break out into poetic raptures upon any other score; nor, by Jove, Eudoxus, Aristarchus, or Archimedes. And when the lovers of the art of painting are so enamored with the charmingness of their own performances, that Nicias, as he was drawing the Evocation of Ghosts in Homer, often asked his servants whether he had dined or no, and when King Ptolemy had sent him threescore talents for his piece, after it was finished, he neither would accept the money nor part with his work; what and how great satisfactions may we then suppose to have been reaped from geometry and astronomy by Euclid when he wrote his Dioptrics, by Philippus when he had perfected his demonstration of the figure of the moon, by Archimedes when with the help of a certain angle he had found the suns diameter to make the same part of the largest circle that that angle made of four right angles, and by Apollonius and Aristarchus who were the inventors of some other things of the like nature? The bare contemplating and comprehending of these now engender in the learners both unspeakable delights and a marvellous height of spirit. And it doth in no wise beseem me, by comparing with these the fulsome debauchees of victualling-houses and stews, to contaminate Helicon and the Muses,—
Where swain his flock neer fed,
Nor tree by hatchet bled.
[*]
But these are the verdant and untrampled pastures of ingenious bees; but those are more like the mange of lecherous boars and he-goats. And though a voluptuous temper of mind be naturally fantastic and precipitate, yet
never any yet sacrificed an ox for joy that he had gained his will of his mistress; nor did any ever wish to die immediately, might he but once satiate himself with the costly dishes and comfits at the table of his prince. But now Eudoxus wished he might stand by the sun, and inform himself of the figure, magnitude, and beauty of that luminary, though he were, like Phaethon, consumed by it. And Pythagoras offered an ox in sacrifice for having completed the lines of a certain geometric diagram; as Apollodotus tells us,
When the famed lines Pythagoras devised,
For which a splendid ox he sacrificed.
Whether it was that by which he showed that the [square of the] line that regards the right angle in a triangle is equivalent to the [squares of the] two lines that contain that angle, or the problem about the area of the parabolic section of a cone. And Archimedess servants were forced to hale him away from his draughts, to be anointed in the bath; but he notwithstanding drew the lines upon his belly with his strigil. And when, as he was washing (as the story goes of him), he thought of a manner of computing the proportion of gold in King Hieros crown by seeing the water flowing over the bathing-stool, he leaped up as one possessed or inspired, crying, I have found it (εὕρηκα); which after he had several times repeated, he went his way. But we never yet heard of a glutton that exclaimed with such vehemence, I have eaten, or of an amorous gallant that ever cried, I have kissed, among the many millions of dissolute debauchees that both this and preceding ages have produced. Yea, we abominate those that make mention of their great suppers with too luscious a gust, as men overmuch taken with mean and abject delights. But we find ourselves in one and the same ecstasy with Eudoxus, Archimedes, and Hipparchus; and we readily give assent to Plato when he saith of the mathematics, that while ignorance
and unskilledness make men despise them, they still thrive notwithstanding by reason of their charming ness, in despite of contempt.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
now 1 w 6
these 1 w 11
appertain 1 w 20
all 1 w 23
solely 1 w 29
to 1 w 31
the 2 w 34
mind 1 w 38
But 2 w 42
they 1 w 46
chase 1 w 51
away 1 w 55
from 1 w 59
them 1 w 63
the 5 w 66
delights 1 w 74
that 1 w 78
accrue 1 w 84
from 2 w 88
the 6 w 91
mathematics 1 w 102
also 1 w 106
Though 1 w 113
the 8 w 116
satisfactions 1 w 129
we 1 w 131
receive 1 w 138
from 3 w 142
history 1 w 149
have 1 w 153
in 3 w 155
them 3 w 159
something 1 w 168
simple 1 w 174
and 1 w 177
equal 1 w 182
but 1 w 186
those 1 w 191
that 2 w 195
come 1 w 199
from 4 w 203
geometry 1 w 211
astronomy 1 w 221
and 2 w 225
music 1 w 230
inveigle 1 w 238
and 3 w 241
allure 1 w 247
us 2 w 249
with 1 w 253
a 22 w 254
sort 1 w 258
of 1 w 260
nimbleness 1 w 270
and 4 w 273
variety 1 w 280
and 5 w 284
want 1 w 288
nothing 1 w 295
that 3 w 299
is 3 w 301
tempting 1 w 309
and 6 w 312
engaging 1 w 320
their 1 w 326
figures 1 w 333
attracting 1 w 343
us 3 w 345
as 3 w 347
so 5 w 349
many 1 w 353
charms 1 w 359
whereof 1 w 367
whoever 1 w 374
hath 1 w 378
once 1 w 382
tasted 1 w 388
if 1 w 391
he 12 w 393
be 1 w 395
but 2 w 398
competently 1 w 409
skilled 1 w 416
will 1 w 421
run 1 w 424
about 1 w 429
singing 1 w 436
that 4 w 440
in 12 w 442
Sophocles 1 w 451
I 1 w 453
m 21 w 455
mad 1 w 458
the 11 w 462
Muses 1 w 467
with 2 w 471
new 1 w 474
rage 1 w 478
inspire 1 w 485
me 4 w 487
I 2 w 489
ll 5 w 492
mount 1 w 497
the 12 w 500
hill 1 w 504
my 2 w 507
lyre 1 w 511
my 3 w 514
numbers 1 w 521
fire 1 w 525
me 5 w 527
From 1 w 532
the 13 w 535
Thamyras 1 w 543
of 3 w 545
Sophocles 2 w 554
Frag 1 w 559
225 1 w 563
Nor 1 w 567
doth 1 w 571
Thamyras 2 w 579
break 1 w 584
out 2 w 587
into 1 w 591
poetic 1 w 597
raptures 1 w 605
upon 1 w 609
any 2 w 612
other 1 w 617
score 1 w 622
nor 1 w 626
by 1 w 629
Jove 1 w 633
Eudoxus 1 w 641
Aristarchus 1 w 653
or 6 w 656
Archimedes 1 w 666
And 1 w 670
when 1 w 674
the 15 w 677
lovers 1 w 683
of 4 w 685
the 16 w 688
art 1 w 691
of 5 w 693
painting 1 w 701
are 1 w 704
so 6 w 706
enamored 1 w 714
with 3 w 718
the 17 w 721
charmingness 1 w 733
of 6 w 735
their 2 w 740
own 1 w 743
performances 1 w 755
that 5 w 760
Nicias 1 w 766
as 8 w 769
he 22 w 771
was 1 w 774
drawing 1 w 781
the 19 w 784
Evocation 1 w 793
of 7 w 795
Ghosts 1 w 801
in 19 w 803
Homer 1 w 808
often 1 w 814
asked 1 w 819
his 2 w 822
servants 1 w 830
whether 1 w 837
he 26 w 839
had 1 w 842
dined 1 w 847
or 9 w 849
no 5 w 851
and 7 w 855
when 2 w 859
King 1 w 863
Ptolemy 1 w 870
had 2 w 873
sent 1 w 877
him 2 w 880
threescore 1 w 890
talents 1 w 897
for 2 w 900
his 3 w 903
piece 1 w 908
after 1 w 914
it 4 w 916
was 2 w 919
finished 1 w 927
he 29 w 930
neither 1 w 937
would 1 w 942
accept 1 w 948
the 22 w 951
money 1 w 956
nor 2 w 959
part 1 w 963
with 4 w 967
his 4 w 970
work 1 w 974
what 1 w 979
and 8 w 982
how 1 w 985
great 1 w 990
satisfactions 2 w 1003
may 1 w 1006
we 2 w 1008
then 1 w 1012
suppose 1 w 1019
to 5 w 1021
have 2 w 1025
been 1 w 1029
reaped 1 w 1035
from 5 w 1039
geometry 2 w 1047
and 9 w 1050
astronomy 2 w 1059
by 2 w 1061
Euclid 1 w 1067
when 3 w 1071
he 34 w 1073
wrote 1 w 1078
his 5 w 1081
Dioptrics 1 w 1090
by 3 w 1093
Philippus 1 w 1102
when 4 w 1106
he 36 w 1108
had 3 w 1111
perfected 1 w 1120
his 6 w 1123
demonstration 1 w 1136
of 9 w 1138
the 24 w 1141
figure 2 w 1147
of 10 w 1149
the 25 w 1152
moon 1 w 1156
by 4 w 1159
Archimedes 2 w 1169
when 5 w 1173
with 5 w 1177
the 26 w 1180
help 1 w 1184
of 11 w 1186
a 84 w 1187
certain 1 w 1194
angle 1 w 1199
he 42 w 1201
had 4 w 1204
found 1 w 1209
the 27 w 1212
sun 1 w 1215
s 77 w 1217
diameter 1 w 1225
to 6 w 1227
make 1 w 1231
the 28 w 1234
same 1 w 1238
part 2 w 1242
of 12 w 1244
the 29 w 1247
largest 1 w 1254
circle 1 w 1260
that 6 w 1264
that 7 w 1268
angle 2 w 1273
made 1 w 1277
of 13 w 1279
four 1 w 1283
right 1 w 1288
angles 1 w 1294
and 10 w 1298
by 5 w 1300
Apollonius 1 w 1310
and 11 w 1313
Aristarchus 2 w 1324
who 2 w 1327
were 1 w 1331
the 30 w 1334
inventors 1 w 1343
of 14 w 1345
some 2 w 1349
other 2 w 1354
things 1 w 1360
of 15 w 1362
the 32 w 1365
like 1 w 1369
nature 1 w 1375
The 1 w 1379
bare 1 w 1383
contemplating 1 w 1396
and 12 w 1399
comprehending 1 w 1412
of 16 w 1414
these 2 w 1419
now 2 w 1422
engender 1 w 1430
in 28 w 1432
the 34 w 1435
learners 1 w 1443
both 1 w 1447
unspeakable 1 w 1458
delights 2 w 1466
and 13 w 1469
a 109 w 1470
marvellous 1 w 1480
height 1 w 1486
of 17 w 1488
spirit 1 w 1494
And 2 w 1498
it 9 w 1500
doth 2 w 1504
in 29 w 1506
no 9 w 1508
wise 1 w 1512
beseem 1 w 1518
me 13 w 1520
by 6 w 1523
comparing 1 w 1532
with 6 w 1536
these 3 w 1541
the 36 w 1544
fulsome 1 w 1551
debauchees 1 w 1561
of 18 w 1563
victualling-houses 1 w 1581
and 14 w 1584
stews 1 w 1589
to 8 w 1592
contaminate 1 w 1603
Helicon 1 w 1610
and 15 w 1613
the 37 w 1616
Muses 2 w 1621
Where 1 w 1628
swain 1 w 1633
his 7 w 1636
flock 1 w 1641
ne 8 w 1643
er 21 w 1646
fed 1 w 1649
Nor 2 w 1653
tree 1 w 1657
by 7 w 1659
hatchet 1 w 1666
bled 1 w 1670
Eurip 1 w 1676
Hippol 1 w 1683
75 1 w 1686
But 3 w 1690
these 4 w 1695
are 3 w 1698
the 39 w 1701
verdant 1 w 1708
and 16 w 1711
untrampled 1 w 1721
pastures 1 w 1729
of 19 w 1731
ingenious 1 w 1740
bees 1 w 1744
but 3 w 1748
those 2 w 1753
are 4 w 1756
more 2 w 1760
like 2 w 1764
the 40 w 1767
mange 1 w 1772
of 20 w 1774
lecherous 1 w 1783
boars 1 w 1788
and 17 w 1791
he-goats 1 w 1799
And 3 w 1803
though 1 w 1809
a 130 w 1810
voluptuous 1 w 1820
temper 1 w 1826
of 21 w 1828
mind 2 w 1832
be 6 w 1834
naturally 1 w 1843
fantastic 1 w 1852
and 18 w 1855
precipitate 1 w 1866
yet 1 w 1870
never 1 w 1875
any 3 w 1878
yet 2 w 1881
sacrificed 1 w 1891
an 31 w 1893
ox 2 w 1895
for 3 w 1898
joy 1 w 1901
that 8 w 1905
he 65 w 1907
had 5 w 1910
gained 1 w 1916
his 8 w 1919
will 2 w 1923
of 22 w 1925
his 9 w 1928
mistress 1 w 1936
nor 3 w 1940
did 1 w 1943
any 4 w 1946
ever 3 w 1950
wish 1 w 1954
to 9 w 1956
die 1 w 1959
immediately 1 w 1970
might 1 w 1976
he 66 w 1978
but 4 w 1981
once 2 w 1985
satiate 1 w 1992
himself 1 w 1999
with 7 w 2003
the 41 w 2006
costly 1 w 2012
dishes 1 w 2018
and 19 w 2021
comfits 1 w 2028
at 29 w 2030
the 42 w 2033
table 1 w 2038
of 23 w 2040
his 10 w 2043
prince 1 w 2049
But 4 w 2053
now 3 w 2056
Eudoxus 2 w 2063
wished 1 w 2069
he 71 w 2071
might 2 w 2076
stand 1 w 2081
by 8 w 2083
the 43 w 2086
sun 2 w 2089
and 21 w 2093
inform 1 w 2099
himself 2 w 2106
of 24 w 2108
the 44 w 2111
figure 3 w 2117
magnitude 1 w 2127
and 22 w 2131
beauty 1 w 2137
of 25 w 2139
that 9 w 2143
luminary 1 w 2151
though 2 w 2158
he 74 w 2160
were 2 w 2164
like 3 w 2169
Phaethon 1 w 2177
consumed 1 w 2186
by 9 w 2188
it 15 w 2190
And 4 w 2194
Pythagoras 1 w 2204
offered 1 w 2211
an 37 w 2213
ox 4 w 2215
in 40 w 2217
sacrifice 2 w 2226
for 5 w 2229
having 1 w 2235
completed 1 w 2244
the 45 w 2247
lines 1 w 2252
of 27 w 2254
a 163 w 2255
certain 2 w 2262
geometric 1 w 2271
diagram 1 w 2278
as 16 w 2281
Apollodotus 1 w 2292
tells 1 w 2297
us 18 w 2299
When 1 w 2304
the 46 w 2307
famed 1 w 2312
lines 2 w 2317
Pythagoras 2 w 2327
devised 1 w 2334
For 1 w 2338
which 1 w 2343
a 171 w 2344
splendid 1 w 2352
ox 5 w 2354
he 78 w 2356
sacrificed 2 w 2366
Whether 1 w 2374
it 16 w 2376
was 3 w 2379
that 10 w 2383
by 10 w 2385
which 2 w 2390
he 81 w 2392
showed 1 w 2398
that 11 w 2402
the 48 w 2405
square 1 w 2412
of 28 w 2414
the 49 w 2417
line 3 w 2422
that 12 w 2426
regards 1 w 2433
the 50 w 2436
right 2 w 2441
angle 4 w 2446
in 46 w 2448
a 180 w 2449
triangle 1 w 2457
is 23 w 2459
equivalent 1 w 2469
to 10 w 2471
the 51 w 2474
squares 1 w 2482
of 29 w 2484
the 52 w 2487
two 1 w 2491
lines 3 w 2496
that 13 w 2500
contain 1 w 2507
that 14 w 2511
angle 6 w 2516
or 24 w 2519
the 53 w 2522
problem 1 w 2529
about 2 w 2534
the 54 w 2537
area 1 w 2541
of 30 w 2543
the 55 w 2546
parabolic 1 w 2555
section 1 w 2562
of 31 w 2564
a 193 w 2565
cone 1 w 2569
And 5 w 2573
Archimedes 3 w 2583
s 159 w 2585
servants 2 w 2593
were 3 w 2597
forced 1 w 2603
to 11 w 2605
hale 1 w 2609
him 7 w 2612
away 2 w 2616
from 6 w 2620
his 11 w 2623
draughts 1 w 2631
to 12 w 2634
be 8 w 2636
anointed 1 w 2644
in 50 w 2646
the 56 w 2649
bath 1 w 2653
but 5 w 2657
he 91 w 2659
notwithstanding 1 w 2674
drew 1 w 2678
the 57 w 2681
lines 4 w 2686
upon 2 w 2690
his 12 w 2693
belly 1 w 2698
with 9 w 2702
his 13 w 2705
strigil 1 w 2712
And 6 w 2716
when 6 w 2720
as 19 w 2723
he 94 w 2725
was 4 w 2728
washing 1 w 2735
as 22 w 2738
the 58 w 2741
story 2 w 2746
goes 1 w 2750
of 32 w 2752
him 8 w 2755
he 96 w 2759
thought 1 w 2766
of 33 w 2768
a 206 w 2769
manner 1 w 2775
of 34 w 2777
computing 1 w 2786
the 59 w 2789
proportion 1 w 2799
of 35 w 2801
gold 1 w 2805
in 55 w 2807
King 2 w 2811
Hiero 1 w 2816
s 175 w 2818
crown 1 w 2823
by 11 w 2825
seeing 1 w 2831
the 60 w 2834
water 1 w 2839
flowing 1 w 2846
over 2 w 2850
the 61 w 2853
bathing-stool 1 w 2866
he 100 w 2869
leaped 1 w 2875
up 5 w 2877
as 23 w 2879
one 3 w 2882
possessed 1 w 2891
or 28 w 2893
inspired 1 w 2901
crying 1 w 2908
I 3 w 2910
have 3 w 2914
found 2 w 2919
it 19 w 2921
εὕρηκα 1 w 2928
which 3 w 2935
after 2 w 2940
he 101 w 2942
had 6 w 2945
several 1 w 2952
times 1 w 2957
repeated 1 w 2965
he 102 w 2968
went 1 w 2972
his 14 w 2975
way 3 w 2978
But 5 w 2982
we 8 w 2984
never 2 w 2989
yet 3 w 2992
heard 1 w 2997
of 36 w 2999
a 219 w 3000
glutton 1 w 3007
that 15 w 3011
exclaimed 1 w 3020
with 10 w 3024
such 1 w 3028
vehemence 1 w 3037
I 4 w 3039
have 4 w 3043
eaten 1 w 3048
or 29 w 3051
of 37 w 3053
an 45 w 3055
amorous 1 w 3062
gallant 1 w 3069
that 16 w 3073
ever 6 w 3077
cried 1 w 3082
I 5 w 3084
have 5 w 3088
kissed 1 w 3094
among 1 w 3100
the 62 w 3103
many 2 w 3107
millions 1 w 3115
of 38 w 3117
dissolute 1 w 3126
debauchees 2 w 3136
that 17 w 3140
both 2 w 3144
this 1 w 3148
and 24 w 3151
preceding 1 w 3160
ages 1 w 3164
have 6 w 3168
produced 1 w 3176
Yea 1 w 3180
we 9 w 3183
abominate 1 w 3192
those 3 w 3197
that 18 w 3201
make 2 w 3205
mention 1 w 3212
of 39 w 3214
their 3 w 3219
great 2 w 3224
suppers 1 w 3231
with 11 w 3235
too 2 w 3238
luscious 1 w 3246
a 243 w 3247
gust 1 w 3251
as 24 w 3254
men 3 w 3257
overmuch 1 w 3265
taken 1 w 3270
with 12 w 3274
mean 1 w 3278
and 25 w 3281
abject 1 w 3287
delights 3 w 3295
But 6 w 3299
we 10 w 3301
find 1 w 3305
ourselves 1 w 3314
in 65 w 3316
one 4 w 3319
and 26 w 3322
the 64 w 3325
same 2 w 3329
ecstasy 1 w 3336
with 13 w 3340
Eudoxus 3 w 3347
Archimedes 4 w 3358
and 27 w 3362
Hipparchus 1 w 3372
and 28 w 3376
we 11 w 3378
readily 1 w 3385
give 1 w 3389
assent 1 w 3395
to 17 w 3397
Plato 1 w 3402
when 7 w 3406
he 110 w 3408
saith 1 w 3413
of 40 w 3415
the 65 w 3418
mathematics 2 w 3429
that 19 w 3434
while 1 w 3439
ignorance 1 w 3448
and 29 w 3451
unskilledness 1 w 3464
make 3 w 3468
men 4 w 3471
despise 1 w 3478
them 5 w 3482
they 2 w 3487
still 1 w 3492
thrive 1 w 3498
notwithstanding 2 w 3513
by 12 w 3515
reason 1 w 3521
of 41 w 3523
their 4 w 3528
charming 2 w 3536
ness 4 w 3540
in 68 w 3543
despite 1 w 3550
of 42 w 3552
contempt 1 w 3560