Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / A breviate of a discourse, showing that the Stoics speak greater improbabilities than the poets.

A breviate of a discourse, showing that the Stoics speak greater improbabilities than the poets. (1-5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg137.perseus-eng2:1-5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'Section 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Pindars Caeneus hath been taken to task by several, being improbably feigned, impenetrable by steel and impassible in his body, and so

Descending into hell without a wound,
And with sound foot parting in two the ground.

But the Stoics Lapithes, as if they had carved him out of the very adamantine matter of impassibility itself, though he is not invulnerable, nor exempt from either sickness or pain, yet remains fearless, regretless, invincible, and unconstrainable in the midst of wounds, dolors, and torments, and in the very subversions of the walls of his native city, and other such like great calamities. Again, Pindars Caeneus is not wounded when struck; but the Stoics wise man is not detained when shut up in a prison, suffers no compulsion by being thrown down a precipice, is not tortured when on the rack, takes no hurt by being maimed, and when he catches a fall in wrestling he is still unconquered; when he is encompassed with a rampire, he is not besieged; and when sold by his enemies, he is still not made a prisoner. The wonderful man is like to those ships that have inscribed upon them A PROSPEROUS VOYAGE, or PROTECTING PROVIDENCE, or A PRESERVATIVE AGAINST DANGERS, and yet for all that endure storms, and are miserably shattered and overturned.

Euripidess Iolaus of a feeble, superannuated old man, by means of a certain prayer, became on a sudden youthful

and strong for battle; but the Stoics wise man was yesterday most detestable and the worst of villains, but today is changed on a sudden into a state of virtue, and is become of a wrinkled, pale fellow, and, as Aeschylus speaks,
Of an old sickly wretch with stitch ins back,
Distent with rending pains as on a rack,
a gallant, god-like, and beauteous person.

The Goddess Minerva took from Ulysses his wrinkles, baldness, and deformity, to make him appear a handsome man. But these mens wise man, though old age quits not his body, but contrariwise still lays on and heaps more upon it, though he remains (for instance) hump-backed, toothless, one-eyed, is yet neither deformed, disfigured, nor ill-favored. For as beetles are said to relinquish perfumes and to pursue after ill scents; so Stoical love, having used itself to the most foul and deformed persons, if by means of philosophy they change into good form and comeliness, becomes presently disgusted.

He that in the Stoics account was in the forenoon (for example) the worst man in the world is in the afternoon best of men; and he that falls asleep a very sot, dunce, miscreant, and brute, nay, by Jove, a slave and a beggar to boot, rises up the same day a prince, a rich and a happy man, and (which is yet more) a continent, just, determined, and unprepossessed person;—not by shooting forth out of a young and tender body a downy beard or the sprouting tokens of mature youth, but by having in a feeble, soft, unmanful, and undetermined mind, a perfect intellect, a consummate prudence, a godlike disposition, an unprejudiced science, and an unalterable habit. All this time his viciousness gives not the least ground in order to it, but he becomes in an instant, I had almost said, of the vilest brute, a sort of hero, genius, or God. For he that receives his virtue from the Stoics portico may say,

Ask what thou wilt, it shall be granted thee.[*]
It brings wealth along with it, it contains kingship in it, it confers fortune; it renders men prosperous, and makes them to want nothing and to have a sufficiency of every thing. though they have not one drachm of silver in the house.

The fabular relations of the poets are so careful of decorum, that they never leave a Hercules destitute of necessaries; but those still spring, as out of some fountain, as well for him as for his companions. But he that hath received of the Stoics Amalthaea becomes indeed a rich man, but he begs his victuals of other men; he is a king, but resolves syllogisms for hire; he is the only man that hath all things, but yet he pays rent for the house he lives in, and oftentimes buys bread with borrowed money, or else begs it of those that have nothing themselves.

Pindar 1 w 6
s 1 w 8
Caeneus 1 w 15
hath 1 w 19
been 1 w 23
taken 1 w 28
to 1 w 30
task 1 w 34
by 1 w 36
several 1 w 43
being 1 w 49
improbably 1 w 59
feigned 1 w 66
impenetrable 1 w 79
by 2 w 81
steel 1 w 86
and 1 w 89
impassible 1 w 99
in 3 w 101
his 1 w 104
body 1 w 108
and 2 w 112
so 1 w 114
Descending 1 w 124
into 1 w 128
hell 1 w 132
without 1 w 139
a 12 w 140
wound 1 w 145
And 1 w 149
with 2 w 153
sound 1 w 158
foot 1 w 162
parting 1 w 169
in 7 w 171
two 1 w 174
the 1 w 177
ground 1 w 183
But 1 w 187
the 2 w 190
Stoics 1 w 196
Lapithes 1 w 205
as 3 w 208
if 1 w 210
they 1 w 214
had 1 w 217
carved 1 w 223
him 1 w 226
out 2 w 229
of 1 w 231
the 5 w 234
very 1 w 238
adamantine 1 w 248
matter 1 w 254
of 2 w 256
impassibility 1 w 269
itself 1 w 275
though 1 w 282
he 7 w 284
is 2 w 286
not 1 w 289
invulnerable 1 w 301
nor 1 w 305
exempt 1 w 311
from 1 w 315
either 1 w 321
sickness 1 w 329
or 2 w 331
pain 1 w 335
yet 1 w 339
remains 1 w 346
fearless 1 w 354
regretless 1 w 365
invincible 1 w 376
and 3 w 380
unconstrainable 1 w 395
in 15 w 397
the 7 w 400
midst 1 w 405
of 3 w 407
wounds 1 w 413
dolors 1 w 420
and 4 w 424
torments 1 w 432
and 5 w 436
in 16 w 438
the 8 w 441
very 2 w 445
subversions 1 w 456
of 4 w 458
the 9 w 461
walls 1 w 466
of 5 w 468
his 2 w 471
native 1 w 477
city 1 w 481
and 6 w 485
other 1 w 490
such 1 w 494
like 1 w 498
great 1 w 503
calamities 1 w 513
Again 1 w 519
Pindar 2 w 526
s 39 w 528
Caeneus 2 w 535
is 4 w 537
not 2 w 540
wounded 1 w 547
when 1 w 551
struck 1 w 557
but 1 w 561
the 11 w 564
Stoics 2 w 570
wise 1 w 575
man 2 w 578
is 6 w 580
not 3 w 583
detained 1 w 591
when 2 w 595
shut 1 w 599
up 1 w 601
in 20 w 603
a 43 w 604
prison 1 w 610
suffers 1 w 618
no 5 w 620
compulsion 1 w 630
by 3 w 632
being 2 w 637
thrown 1 w 643
down 1 w 647
a 44 w 648
precipice 1 w 657
is 8 w 660
not 4 w 663
tortured 1 w 671
when 3 w 675
on 5 w 677
the 12 w 680
rack 1 w 684
takes 1 w 690
no 7 w 692
hurt 1 w 696
by 4 w 698
being 3 w 703
maimed 1 w 709
and 7 w 713
when 4 w 717
he 19 w 719
catches 1 w 726
a 50 w 727
fall 1 w 731
in 23 w 733
wrestling 1 w 742
he 21 w 744
is 9 w 746
still 1 w 751
unconquered 1 w 762
when 5 w 767
he 23 w 769
is 10 w 771
encompassed 1 w 782
with 3 w 786
a 53 w 787
rampire 1 w 794
he 24 w 797
is 11 w 799
not 5 w 802
besieged 1 w 810
and 8 w 814
when 6 w 818
sold 1 w 822
by 5 w 824
his 3 w 827
enemies 1 w 834
he 26 w 837
is 13 w 839
still 2 w 844
not 6 w 847
made 1 w 851
a 57 w 852
prisoner 1 w 860
The 1 w 864
wonderful 1 w 873
man 3 w 876
is 15 w 878
like 2 w 882
to 7 w 884
those 1 w 889
ships 1 w 894
that 1 w 898
have 1 w 902
inscribed 1 w 911
upon 1 w 915
them 1 w 919
A 3 w 920
PROSPEROUS 1 w 930
VOYAGE 1 w 936
or 6 w 939
PROTECTING 1 w 949
PROVIDENCE 1 w 959
or 7 w 962
A 5 w 963
PRESERVATIVE 1 w 975
AGAINST 1 w 982
DANGERS 1 w 989
and 9 w 993
yet 2 w 996
for 1 w 999
all 3 w 1002
that 2 w 1006
endure 1 w 1012
storms 1 w 1018
and 10 w 1022
are 1 w 1025
miserably 1 w 1034
shattered 1 w 1043
and 11 w 1046
overturned 1 w 1056
Euripides 1 w 1066
s 78 w 1068
Iolaus 1 w 1074
of 6 w 1076
a 70 w 1077
feeble 1 w 1083
superannuated 1 w 1097
old 2 w 1100
man 4 w 1103
by 6 w 1106
means 1 w 1111
of 7 w 1113
a 75 w 1114
certain 1 w 1121
prayer 1 w 1127
became 1 w 1134
on 10 w 1136
a 79 w 1137
sudden 1 w 1143
youthful 1 w 1151
and 12 w 1154
strong 1 w 1160
for 2 w 1163
battle 1 w 1169
but 2 w 1173
the 14 w 1176
Stoics 3 w 1182
wise 2 w 1187
man 5 w 1190
was 1 w 1193
yesterday 1 w 1202
most 1 w 1206
detestable 1 w 1216
and 13 w 1219
the 15 w 1222
worst 1 w 1227
of 8 w 1229
villains 1 w 1237
but 3 w 1241
today 1 w 1246
is 18 w 1248
changed 1 w 1255
on 12 w 1257
a 90 w 1258
sudden 2 w 1264
into 2 w 1268
a 91 w 1269
state 1 w 1274
of 9 w 1276
virtue 1 w 1282
and 14 w 1286
is 19 w 1288
become 1 w 1294
of 10 w 1296
a 94 w 1297
wrinkled 1 w 1305
pale 1 w 1310
fellow 1 w 1316
and 15 w 1320
as 7 w 1323
Aeschylus 1 w 1332
speaks 1 w 1338
Of 1 w 1341
an 24 w 1343
old 3 w 1346
sickly 1 w 1352
wretch 1 w 1358
with 4 w 1362
stitch 1 w 1368
in 30 w 1370
s 103 w 1372
back 1 w 1376
Distent 1 w 1384
with 5 w 1388
rending 1 w 1395
pains 1 w 1400
as 8 w 1402
on 13 w 1404
a 103 w 1405
rack 2 w 1409
a 105 w 1411
gallant 1 w 1418
god-like 1 w 1427
and 16 w 1431
beauteous 1 w 1440
person 1 w 1446
The 2 w 1450
Goddess 1 w 1457
Minerva 1 w 1464
took 1 w 1468
from 2 w 1472
Ulysses 1 w 1479
his 4 w 1482
wrinkles 1 w 1490
baldness 1 w 1499
and 17 w 1503
deformity 1 w 1512
to 13 w 1515
make 1 w 1519
him 2 w 1522
appear 1 w 1528
a 116 w 1529
handsome 1 w 1537
man 6 w 1540
But 2 w 1544
these 1 w 1549
men 2 w 1552
s 120 w 1554
wise 3 w 1558
man 7 w 1561
though 2 w 1568
old 4 w 1571
age 1 w 1574
quits 1 w 1579
not 7 w 1582
his 5 w 1585
body 2 w 1589
but 4 w 1593
contrariwise 1 w 1605
still 3 w 1610
lays 1 w 1614
on 16 w 1616
and 19 w 1619
heaps 1 w 1624
more 1 w 1628
upon 2 w 1632
it 15 w 1634
though 3 w 1641
he 34 w 1643
remains 2 w 1650
for 4 w 1654
instance 1 w 1662
hump-backed 1 w 1674
toothless 1 w 1684
one-eyed 1 w 1693
is 25 w 1696
yet 3 w 1699
neither 1 w 1706
deformed 1 w 1714
disfigured 1 w 1725
nor 2 w 1729
ill-favored 1 w 1740
For 1 w 1744
as 9 w 1746
beetles 1 w 1753
are 2 w 1756
said 1 w 1760
to 15 w 1762
relinquish 1 w 1772
perfumes 1 w 1780
and 20 w 1783
to 16 w 1785
pursue 1 w 1791
after 1 w 1796
ill 6 w 1799
scents 1 w 1805
so 8 w 1808
Stoical 1 w 1815
love 1 w 1819
having 1 w 1826
used 1 w 1830
itself 2 w 1836
to 18 w 1838
the 18 w 1841
most 2 w 1845
foul 1 w 1849
and 21 w 1852
deformed 2 w 1860
persons 1 w 1867
if 2 w 1870
by 7 w 1872
means 2 w 1877
of 11 w 1879
philosophy 1 w 1889
they 2 w 1893
change 2 w 1899
into 3 w 1903
good 1 w 1907
form 4 w 1911
and 22 w 1914
comeliness 1 w 1924
becomes 1 w 1932
presently 1 w 1941
disgusted 1 w 1950
He 1 w 1953
that 3 w 1957
in 41 w 1959
the 20 w 1962
Stoics 4 w 1968
account 1 w 1976
was 2 w 1979
in 42 w 1981
the 21 w 1984
forenoon 1 w 1992
for 9 w 1996
example 1 w 2003
the 22 w 2007
worst 2 w 2012
man 8 w 2015
in 43 w 2017
the 23 w 2020
world 1 w 2025
is 29 w 2027
in 44 w 2029
the 24 w 2032
afternoon 1 w 2041
best 1 w 2045
of 12 w 2047
men 3 w 2050
and 23 w 2054
he 43 w 2056
that 4 w 2060
falls 1 w 2065
asleep 1 w 2071
a 150 w 2072
very 3 w 2076
sot 1 w 2079
dunce 1 w 2085
miscreant 1 w 2095
and 24 w 2099
brute 1 w 2104
nay 1 w 2108
by 8 w 2111
Jove 1 w 2115
a 154 w 2117
slave 1 w 2122
and 25 w 2125
a 157 w 2126
beggar 1 w 2132
to 21 w 2134
boot 1 w 2138
rises 1 w 2144
up 5 w 2146
the 25 w 2149
same 1 w 2153
day 3 w 2156
a 161 w 2157
prince 1 w 2163
a 162 w 2165
rich 1 w 2169
and 26 w 2172
a 164 w 2173
happy 1 w 2178
man 9 w 2181
and 27 w 2185
which 1 w 2191
is 32 w 2193
yet 4 w 2196
more 2 w 2200
a 168 w 2202
continent 1 w 2211
just 1 w 2216
determined 1 w 2227
and 28 w 2231
unprepossessed 1 w 2245
person 3 w 2251
not 8 w 2256
by 9 w 2258
shooting 1 w 2266
forth 1 w 2271
out 4 w 2274
of 13 w 2276
a 170 w 2277
young 1 w 2282
and 29 w 2285
tender 1 w 2291
body 3 w 2295
a 172 w 2296
downy 1 w 2301
beard 1 w 2306
or 27 w 2308
the 26 w 2311
sprouting 1 w 2320
tokens 1 w 2326
of 14 w 2328
mature 1 w 2334
youth 2 w 2339
but 5 w 2343
by 10 w 2345
having 2 w 2351
in 51 w 2353
a 176 w 2354
feeble 2 w 2360
soft 1 w 2365
unmanful 1 w 2374
and 30 w 2378
undetermined 1 w 2390
mind 1 w 2394
a 179 w 2396
perfect 1 w 2403
intellect 1 w 2412
a 180 w 2414
consummate 1 w 2424
prudence 1 w 2432
a 182 w 2434
godlike 1 w 2441
disposition 1 w 2452
an 50 w 2455
unprejudiced 1 w 2467
science 1 w 2474
and 31 w 2478
an 52 w 2480
unalterable 1 w 2491
habit 1 w 2496
All 1 w 2500
this 1 w 2504
time 1 w 2508
his 7 w 2511
viciousness 1 w 2522
gives 1 w 2527
not 9 w 2530
the 27 w 2533
least 1 w 2538
ground 2 w 2544
in 55 w 2546
order 1 w 2551
to 23 w 2553
it 20 w 2555
but 6 w 2559
he 47 w 2561
becomes 2 w 2568
in 56 w 2570
an 53 w 2572
instant 1 w 2579
I 6 w 2581
had 2 w 2584
almost 1 w 2590
said 2 w 2594
of 16 w 2597
the 28 w 2600
vilest 1 w 2606
brute 2 w 2611
a 195 w 2613
sort 1 w 2617
of 17 w 2619
hero 1 w 2623
genius 1 w 2630
or 30 w 2633
God 2 w 2636
For 2 w 2640
he 50 w 2642
that 5 w 2646
receives 1 w 2654
his 8 w 2657
virtue 2 w 2663
from 3 w 2667
the 29 w 2670
Stoics 5 w 2676
portico 1 w 2684
may 1 w 2687
say 1 w 2690
Ask 1 w 2694
what 1 w 2698
thou 5 w 2702
wilt 1 w 2706
it 21 w 2709
shall 1 w 2714
be 16 w 2716
granted 1 w 2723
thee 1 w 2727
From 1 w 2732
Menander 1 w 2740
It 1 w 2743
brings 1 w 2749
wealth 1 w 2755
along 1 w 2760
with 6 w 2764
it 23 w 2766
it 24 w 2769
contains 1 w 2777
kingship 1 w 2785
in 61 w 2787
it 25 w 2789
it 26 w 2792
confers 1 w 2799
fortune 1 w 2806
it 27 w 2809
renders 1 w 2816
men 4 w 2819
prosperous 1 w 2829
and 33 w 2833
makes 1 w 2838
them 2 w 2842
to 25 w 2844
want 1 w 2848
nothing 1 w 2855
and 34 w 2858
to 26 w 2860
have 2 w 2864
a 211 w 2865
sufficiency 1 w 2876
of 18 w 2878
every 1 w 2883
thing 2 w 2888
though 4 w 2895
they 3 w 2899
have 3 w 2903
not 11 w 2906
one 3 w 2909
drachm 1 w 2915
of 19 w 2917
silver 1 w 2923
in 64 w 2925
the 33 w 2928
house 1 w 2933
The 3 w 2937
fabular 1 w 2944
relations 1 w 2953
of 20 w 2955
the 34 w 2958
poets 1 w 2963
are 3 w 2966
so 15 w 2968
careful 1 w 2975
of 21 w 2977
decorum 1 w 2984
that 6 w 2989
they 4 w 2993
never 1 w 2998
leave 1 w 3003
a 221 w 3004
Hercules 1 w 3012
destitute 1 w 3021
of 22 w 3023
necessaries 1 w 3034
but 7 w 3038
those 2 w 3043
still 4 w 3048
spring 1 w 3054
as 13 w 3057
out 7 w 3060
of 23 w 3062
some 2 w 3066
fountain 1 w 3074
as 14 w 3077
well 1 w 3081
for 12 w 3084
him 3 w 3087
as 15 w 3089
for 13 w 3092
his 9 w 3095
companions 1 w 3105
But 3 w 3109
he 59 w 3111
that 7 w 3115
hath 2 w 3119
received 1 w 3127
of 24 w 3129
the 36 w 3132
Stoics 6 w 3138
Amalthaea 1 w 3147
becomes 3 w 3154
indeed 1 w 3160
a 233 w 3161
rich 2 w 3165
man 11 w 3168
but 8 w 3172
he 61 w 3174
begs 1 w 3178
his 10 w 3181
victuals 1 w 3189
of 25 w 3191
other 2 w 3196
men 5 w 3199
he 63 w 3202
is 39 w 3204
a 236 w 3205
king 2 w 3209
but 9 w 3213
resolves 1 w 3221
syllogisms 1 w 3231
for 14 w 3234
hire 1 w 3238
he 64 w 3241
is 41 w 3243
the 38 w 3246
only 1 w 3250
man 12 w 3253
that 8 w 3257
hath 3 w 3261
all 7 w 3264
things 1 w 3270
but 10 w 3274
yet 5 w 3277
he 66 w 3279
pays 1 w 3283
rent 1 w 3287
for 15 w 3290
the 39 w 3293
house 2 w 3298
he 68 w 3300
lives 1 w 3305
in 70 w 3307
and 35 w 3311
oftentimes 1 w 3321
buys 1 w 3325
bread 1 w 3330
with 7 w 3334
borrowed 1 w 3342
money 1 w 3347
or 40 w 3350
else 1 w 3354
begs 2 w 3358
it 30 w 3360
of 27 w 3362
those 3 w 3367
that 9 w 3371
have 4 w 3375
nothing 2 w 3382
themselves 1 w 3392