Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The contradictions of the Stoics

The contradictions of the Stoics (46)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg136.perseus-eng2:46
Refs {'start': {'reference': '46', 'human_reference': 'Section 46'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now, as for his doctrine of possibles, how can it but be repugnant to his doctrine of Fate? For if that is not possible which either is true or shall be true, as Diodorus has it, but every thing which is capable of being, though it never shall be, is possible, there will be many things possible which will never be according to invincible, inviolable, and all-conquering Fate. And thus either Fate will lose its power; or if that, as Chrysippus thinks, has

existence, that which is susceptible of being will often fall out to be impossible. And every thing indeed which is true will be necessary, being comprehended by the principal of all necessities; and every thing that is false will be impossible, having the greatest cause to oppose its ever being true. For how is it possible that he should be susceptible of dying on the land, who is destined to die at sea? And how is it possible for him who is at Megara to come to Athens, if he is prohibited by Fate?

Tokens

Now 1 w 3
as 1 w 6
for 1 w 9
his 1 w 12
doctrine 1 w 20
of 1 w 22
possibles 1 w 31
how 1 w 35
can 1 w 38
it 1 w 40
but 1 w 43
be 1 w 45
repugnant 1 w 54
to 1 w 56
his 2 w 59
doctrine 2 w 67
of 2 w 69
Fate 1 w 73
For 1 w 77
if 1 w 79
that 1 w 83
is 3 w 85
not 1 w 88
possible 2 w 96
which 1 w 101
either 1 w 107
is 4 w 109
true 1 w 113
or 3 w 115
shall 1 w 120
be 2 w 122
true 2 w 126
as 2 w 129
Diodorus 1 w 137
has 1 w 140
it 3 w 142
but 2 w 146
every 1 w 151
thing 1 w 156
which 2 w 161
is 5 w 163
capable 1 w 170
of 3 w 172
being 1 w 177
though 1 w 184
it 4 w 186
never 1 w 191
shall 2 w 196
be 4 w 198
is 6 w 201
possible 3 w 209
there 1 w 215
will 1 w 219
be 5 w 221
many 1 w 225
things 1 w 231
possible 4 w 239
which 3 w 244
will 2 w 248
never 2 w 253
be 6 w 255
according 1 w 264
to 2 w 266
invincible 1 w 276
inviolable 1 w 287
and 1 w 291
all-conquering 1 w 305
Fate 2 w 309
And 1 w 313
thus 1 w 317
either 2 w 323
Fate 3 w 327
will 3 w 331
lose 1 w 335
its 1 w 338
power 1 w 343
or 6 w 346
if 2 w 348
that 2 w 352
as 4 w 355
Chrysippus 1 w 365
thinks 1 w 371
has 2 w 375
existence 1 w 384
that 3 w 389
which 4 w 394
is 8 w 396
susceptible 1 w 407
of 4 w 409
being 2 w 414
will 4 w 418
often 1 w 423
fall 1 w 427
out 1 w 430
to 3 w 432
be 8 w 434
impossible 1 w 444
And 2 w 448
every 2 w 453
thing 3 w 458
indeed 1 w 464
which 5 w 469
is 9 w 471
true 3 w 475
will 5 w 479
be 9 w 481
necessary 1 w 490
being 3 w 496
comprehended 1 w 508
by 1 w 510
the 4 w 513
principal 1 w 522
of 6 w 524
all 5 w 527
necessities 1 w 538
and 2 w 542
every 3 w 547
thing 4 w 552
that 4 w 556
is 10 w 558
false 1 w 563
will 6 w 567
be 11 w 569
impossible 2 w 579
having 1 w 586
the 5 w 589
greatest 1 w 597
cause 1 w 602
to 4 w 604
oppose 1 w 610
its 2 w 613
ever 6 w 617
being 4 w 622
true 4 w 626
For 2 w 630
how 2 w 633
is 11 w 635
it 9 w 637
possible 7 w 645
that 5 w 649
he 7 w 651
should 1 w 657
be 13 w 659
susceptible 2 w 670
of 7 w 672
dying 1 w 677
on 2 w 679
the 6 w 682
land 1 w 686
who 1 w 690
is 12 w 692
destined 1 w 700
to 5 w 702
die 1 w 705
at 10 w 707
sea 1 w 710
And 3 w 714
how 3 w 717
is 13 w 719
it 10 w 721
possible 8 w 729
for 2 w 732
him 1 w 735
who 2 w 738
is 14 w 740
at 11 w 742
Megara 1 w 748
to 6 w 750
come 1 w 754
to 7 w 756
Athens 1 w 762
if 3 w 765
he 10 w 767
is 15 w 769
prohibited 1 w 779
by 2 w 781
Fate 4 w 785