The contradictions of the Stoics (42-43)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg136.perseus-eng2:42-43

Refs	`{'start': {'reference': '42', 'human_reference': 'Section 42'}, 'end': {'reference': '43', 'human_reference': 'Section 43'}}`
Ancestors	`[]`
Children	`[]`

plain text • XML

He says sometimes, that the air is light and mounts upwards, and sometimes, that it is neither heavy nor light. For in his Second Book of Motion he says, that the fire, being without gravity, ascends upwards, and the air like to that; the water approaching more to the earth, and the air to the fire. But in his Physical Arts he inclines to the other opinion, that the air of itself has neither gravity nor levity.

He says that the air is by nature dark, and uses this

as an argument of its being also the first cold; for that its darkness is opposite to the brightness, and its coldness to the heat of fire. Moving this in his First Book of Natural Questions, he again in his treatise of Habits says, that habits are nothing else but airs; for bodies are contained by these, and the cause that every one of the bodies contained in any habit is such as it is, is the containing air, which they call in iron hardness, in stone solidness, in silver whiteness. These words have in them much absurdity and contradiction. For if the air remains such as it is of its own nature, how comes black, in that which is not white, to be made whiteness; and soft, in that which is not hard, to be made hardness; and rare, in that which is not thick, to be made thickness? But if, being mixed with these, it is altered and made like to them, how is it a habit or power or cause of these things by which it is subdued? For such a change, by which it loses its own qualities, is the property of a patient, not of an agent, and not of a thing containing, but of a thing languishing. Yet they everywhere affirm, that matter, being of its own nature idle and motionless, is subjected to qualities, and that the qualities are spirits, which, being also aerial tensions, give a form and figure to every part of matter to which they adhere. These things they cannot rationally say, supposing the air to be such as they affirm it. For if it is a habit and tension, it will assimilate every body to itself, so that it shall be black and soft. But if by the mixture with these things it receives forms contrary to those it has, it will be in some sort the matter, and not the cause or power of matter.

Tokens

He	1	w	2
says	1	w	6
sometimes	1	w	15
that	1	w	20
the	1	w	23
air	1	w	26
is	1	w	28
light	1	w	33
and	1	w	36
mounts	1	w	42
upwards	1	w	49
and	2	w	53
sometimes	2	w	62
that	2	w	67
it	1	w	69
is	2	w	71
neither	1	w	78
heavy	1	w	83
nor	1	w	86
light	2	w	91
For	1	w	95
in	1	w	97
his	1	w	100
Second	1	w	106
Book	1	w	110
of	1	w	112
Motion	1	w	118
he	4	w	120
says	2	w	124
that	3	w	129
the	3	w	132
fire	1	w	136
being	1	w	142
without	1	w	149
gravity	1	w	156
ascends	1	w	164
upwards	2	w	171
and	3	w	175
the	4	w	178
air	2	w	181
like	1	w	185
to	1	w	187
that	4	w	191
the	5	w	195
water	1	w	200
approaching	1	w	211
more	1	w	215
to	2	w	217
the	6	w	220
earth	1	w	225
and	4	w	229
the	7	w	232
air	3	w	235
to	3	w	237
the	8	w	240
fire	2	w	244
But	1	w	248
in	4	w	250
his	2	w	253
Physical	1	w	261
Arts	1	w	265
he	11	w	267
inclines	1	w	275
to	4	w	277
the	9	w	280
other	1	w	285
opinion	1	w	292
that	5	w	297
the	11	w	300
air	4	w	303
of	2	w	305
itself	1	w	311
has	1	w	314
neither	2	w	321
gravity	2	w	328
nor	2	w	331
levity	1	w	337
He	2	w	340
says	3	w	344
that	6	w	348
the	13	w	351
air	5	w	354
is	5	w	356
by	1	w	358
nature	1	w	364
dark	1	w	368
and	5	w	372
uses	1	w	376
this	1	w	380
as	3	w	382
an	6	w	384
argument	1	w	392
of	3	w	394
its	2	w	397
being	2	w	402
also	1	w	406
the	14	w	409
first	1	w	414
cold	1	w	418
for	1	w	422
that	7	w	426
its	3	w	429
darkness	1	w	437
is	7	w	439
opposite	1	w	447
to	5	w	449
the	15	w	452
brightness	1	w	462
and	6	w	466
its	4	w	469
coldness	1	w	477
to	6	w	479
the	16	w	482
heat	1	w	486
of	4	w	488
fire	3	w	492
Moving	1	w	499
this	2	w	503
in	10	w	505
his	5	w	508
First	1	w	513
Book	2	w	517
of	5	w	519
Natural	1	w	526
Questions	1	w	535
he	21	w	538
again	1	w	543
in	12	w	545
his	6	w	548
treatise	1	w	556
of	6	w	558
Habits	1	w	564
says	4	w	568
that	8	w	573
habits	1	w	579
are	1	w	582
nothing	1	w	589
else	1	w	593
but	1	w	596
airs	1	w	600
for	2	w	604
bodies	1	w	610
are	2	w	613
contained	1	w	622
by	2	w	624
these	1	w	629
and	7	w	633
the	18	w	636
cause	1	w	641
that	9	w	645
every	1	w	650
one	1	w	653
of	7	w	655
the	19	w	658
bodies	2	w	664
contained	2	w	673
in	16	w	675
any	1	w	678
habit	2	w	683
is	12	w	685
such	1	w	689
as	4	w	691
it	16	w	693
is	13	w	695
is	14	w	698
the	20	w	701
containing	1	w	711
air	7	w	714
which	1	w	720
they	1	w	724
call	1	w	728
in	19	w	730
iron	1	w	734
hardness	1	w	742
in	20	w	745
stone	1	w	750
solidness	1	w	759
in	21	w	762
silver	1	w	768
whiteness	1	w	777
These	1	w	783
words	1	w	788
have	1	w	792
in	22	w	794
them	1	w	798
much	1	w	802
absurdity	1	w	811
and	8	w	814
contradiction	1	w	827
For	2	w	831
if	1	w	833
the	23	w	836
air	8	w	839
remains	1	w	846
such	2	w	850
as	5	w	852
it	19	w	854
is	15	w	856
of	8	w	858
its	7	w	861
own	1	w	864
nature	2	w	870
how	1	w	874
comes	1	w	879
black	1	w	884
in	24	w	887
that	10	w	891
which	2	w	896
is	16	w	898
not	2	w	901
white	2	w	906
to	8	w	909
be	3	w	911
made	1	w	915
whiteness	2	w	924
and	9	w	928
soft	1	w	932
in	25	w	935
that	11	w	939
which	3	w	944
is	17	w	946
not	3	w	949
hard	2	w	953
to	9	w	956
be	4	w	958
made	2	w	962
hardness	2	w	970
and	10	w	974
rare	1	w	978
in	26	w	981
that	12	w	985
which	4	w	990
is	18	w	992
not	4	w	995
thick	1	w	1000
to	10	w	1003
be	5	w	1005
made	3	w	1009
thickness	1	w	1018
But	2	w	1022
if	2	w	1024
being	3	w	1030
mixed	1	w	1035
with	2	w	1039
these	2	w	1044
it	24	w	1047
is	19	w	1049
altered	1	w	1056
and	11	w	1059
made	4	w	1063
like	2	w	1067
to	11	w	1069
them	2	w	1073
how	2	w	1077
is	20	w	1079
it	25	w	1081
a	89	w	1082
habit	3	w	1087
or	9	w	1089
power	1	w	1094
or	10	w	1096
cause	2	w	1101
of	10	w	1103
these	3	w	1108
things	1	w	1114
by	3	w	1116
which	5	w	1121
it	27	w	1123
is	21	w	1125
subdued	1	w	1132
For	3	w	1136
such	3	w	1140
a	92	w	1141
change	1	w	1147
by	4	w	1150
which	6	w	1155
it	28	w	1157
loses	1	w	1162
its	8	w	1165
own	2	w	1168
qualities	1	w	1177
is	22	w	1180
the	27	w	1183
property	1	w	1191
of	11	w	1193
a	95	w	1194
patient	1	w	1201
not	5	w	1205
of	12	w	1207
an	15	w	1209
agent	1	w	1214
and	12	w	1218
not	6	w	1221
of	13	w	1223
a	100	w	1224
thing	3	w	1229
containing	2	w	1239
but	2	w	1243
of	14	w	1245
a	102	w	1246
thing	4	w	1251
languishing	1	w	1262
Yet	1	w	1266
they	2	w	1270
everywhere	1	w	1280
affirm	1	w	1286
that	13	w	1291
matter	1	w	1297
being	4	w	1303
of	15	w	1305
its	9	w	1308
own	3	w	1311
nature	3	w	1317
idle	1	w	1321
and	13	w	1324
motionless	1	w	1334
is	24	w	1337
subjected	1	w	1346
to	12	w	1348
qualities	2	w	1357
and	14	w	1361
that	14	w	1365
the	29	w	1368
qualities	3	w	1377
are	4	w	1380
spirits	1	w	1387
which	7	w	1393
being	5	w	1399
also	2	w	1403
aerial	1	w	1409
tensions	1	w	1417
give	1	w	1422
a	117	w	1423
form	1	w	1427
and	15	w	1430
figure	1	w	1436
to	13	w	1438
every	3	w	1443
part	1	w	1447
of	16	w	1449
matter	2	w	1455
to	14	w	1457
which	8	w	1462
they	3	w	1466
adhere	1	w	1472
These	2	w	1478
things	2	w	1484
they	4	w	1488
cannot	1	w	1494
rationally	1	w	1504
say	5	w	1507
supposing	1	w	1517
the	32	w	1520
air	9	w	1523
to	15	w	1525
be	9	w	1527
such	4	w	1531
as	6	w	1533
they	5	w	1537
affirm	2	w	1543
it	35	w	1545
For	4	w	1549
if	3	w	1551
it	36	w	1553
is	25	w	1555
a	129	w	1556
habit	4	w	1561
and	16	w	1564
tension	2	w	1571
it	38	w	1574
will	1	w	1578
assimilate	1	w	1588
every	4	w	1593
body	1	w	1597
to	16	w	1599
itself	2	w	1605
so	7	w	1608
that	15	w	1612
it	40	w	1614
shall	1	w	1619
be	10	w	1621
black	2	w	1626
and	17	w	1629
soft	2	w	1633
But	3	w	1637
if	4	w	1639
by	5	w	1641
the	34	w	1644
mixture	1	w	1651
with	3	w	1655
these	4	w	1660
things	3	w	1666
it	42	w	1668
receives	1	w	1676
forms	1	w	1681
contrary	1	w	1689
to	17	w	1691
those	1	w	1696
it	43	w	1698
has	2	w	1701
it	44	w	1704
will	2	w	1708
be	11	w	1710
in	39	w	1712
some	3	w	1716
sort	1	w	1720
the	36	w	1723
matter	3	w	1729
and	18	w	1733
not	8	w	1736
the	37	w	1739
cause	3	w	1744
or	16	w	1746
power	2	w	1751
of	18	w	1753
matter	4	w	1759