Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The contradictions of the Stoics

The contradictions of the Stoics (28-29)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg136.perseus-eng2:28-29
Refs {'start': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}, 'end': {'reference': '29', 'human_reference': 'Section 29'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

He defines Rhetoric to be an art concerning the ornament and the ordering of a discourse that is pronounced. And farther in his First Book he has written thus: And I am not only of opinion that a regard ought to be had to a liberal and simple adorning of words, but also that care is. to be taken for proper delivery, as regards the right elevation of the voice and the compositions of the countenance and hands. Yet he, who is in this place so curious and exact, again in the same book, speaking of the collision of the vowels, says: We ought not only to let these things pass, minding somewhat that is better, but also to neglect certain obscurities and defects, nay, solecisms also, of which others, and those not a few, would be ashamed. Certainly, in one place to allow those who would speak eloquently so carefully to dispose their speech as even to observe a decorum in the very composition of their mouth and hands, and in another place to forbid the taking care of defects and obscurities, and the being ashamed even of committing solecisms, is the property of a man who little cares what he says, but rashly utters whatever comes first into his mouth.

Moreover, in his Natural Positions having warned us not to trouble ourselves but to be at quiet about such things as require experience and investigation, he says: Let us not think after the same manner with Plato, that liquid nourishment is conveyed to the lungs, and dry to the stomach; nor let us embrace other errors like to these. Now it is my opinion, that to reprehend others, and then

not to keep ones self from falling into those things which one has reprehended, is the greatest of contradictions and shamefullest of errors. But he says, that the connections made by ten axioms amount to above a million in number, having neither searched diligently into it by himself nor attained to the truth by men experienced in it. Yet Plato had to testify for him the most renowned of the physicians, Hippocrates, Philistion, and Dioxippus the disciple of Hippocrates; and of the poets, Euripides, Alcaeus, Eupolis, and Eratosthenes, who all say that the drink passes through the lungs. But all the arithmeticians refel Chrysippus, amongst whom also is Hipparchus, demonstrating that the error of his computation is very great; since the affirmative makes of the ten axioms one hundred and three. thousand forty and nine connections, and the negative three hundred and ten thousand nine hundred fifty and two.

Tokens

He 1 w 2
defines 1 w 9
Rhetoric 1 w 17
to 2 w 19
be 1 w 21
an 1 w 23
art 1 w 26
concerning 1 w 36
the 1 w 39
ornament 1 w 47
and 1 w 50
the 2 w 53
ordering 1 w 61
of 1 w 63
a 5 w 64
discourse 1 w 73
that 1 w 77
is 2 w 79
pronounced 1 w 89
And 1 w 93
farther 1 w 100
in 4 w 102
his 1 w 105
First 1 w 110
Book 1 w 114
he 5 w 116
has 1 w 119
written 1 w 126
thus 1 w 130
And 2 w 134
I 1 w 135
am 2 w 137
not 1 w 140
only 1 w 144
of 2 w 146
opinion 1 w 153
that 2 w 157
a 11 w 158
regard 1 w 164
ought 1 w 169
to 3 w 171
be 2 w 173
had 1 w 176
to 4 w 178
a 14 w 179
liberal 1 w 186
and 2 w 189
simple 1 w 195
adorning 1 w 203
of 3 w 205
words 1 w 210
but 1 w 214
also 1 w 218
that 3 w 222
care 1 w 226
is 4 w 228
to 5 w 231
be 4 w 233
taken 1 w 238
for 1 w 241
proper 1 w 247
delivery 1 w 255
as 2 w 258
regards 1 w 265
the 4 w 268
right 1 w 273
elevation 1 w 282
of 4 w 284
the 5 w 287
voice 1 w 292
and 3 w 295
the 6 w 298
compositions 1 w 310
of 5 w 312
the 7 w 315
countenance 1 w 326
and 4 w 329
hands 1 w 334
Yet 1 w 338
he 10 w 340
who 1 w 344
is 5 w 346
in 7 w 348
this 1 w 352
place 1 w 357
so 2 w 359
curious 1 w 366
and 6 w 369
exact 1 w 374
again 1 w 380
in 9 w 382
the 8 w 385
same 1 w 389
book 1 w 393
speaking 1 w 402
of 6 w 404
the 9 w 407
collision 1 w 416
of 7 w 418
the 10 w 421
vowels 1 w 427
says 1 w 432
We 1 w 435
ought 2 w 440
not 2 w 443
only 2 w 447
to 6 w 449
let 1 w 452
these 1 w 457
things 1 w 463
pass 1 w 467
minding 1 w 475
somewhat 1 w 483
that 4 w 487
is 8 w 489
better 1 w 495
but 2 w 499
also 2 w 503
to 7 w 505
neglect 1 w 512
certain 1 w 519
obscurities 1 w 530
and 7 w 533
defects 1 w 540
nay 1 w 544
solecisms 1 w 554
also 3 w 558
of 8 w 561
which 1 w 566
others 1 w 572
and 8 w 576
those 1 w 581
not 3 w 584
a 46 w 585
few 1 w 588
would 1 w 594
be 6 w 596
ashamed 1 w 603
Certainly 1 w 613
in 16 w 616
one 1 w 619
place 2 w 624
to 8 w 626
allow 1 w 631
those 2 w 636
who 2 w 639
would 2 w 644
speak 2 w 649
eloquently 1 w 659
so 7 w 661
carefully 1 w 670
to 9 w 672
dispose 1 w 679
their 1 w 684
speech 1 w 690
as 5 w 692
even 1 w 696
to 10 w 698
observe 1 w 705
a 55 w 706
decorum 1 w 713
in 17 w 715
the 14 w 718
very 2 w 722
composition 2 w 733
of 9 w 735
their 2 w 740
mouth 1 w 745
and 9 w 748
hands 2 w 753
and 11 w 757
in 18 w 759
another 1 w 766
place 3 w 771
to 11 w 773
forbid 1 w 779
the 17 w 782
taking 1 w 788
care 3 w 792
of 10 w 794
defects 2 w 801
and 12 w 804
obscurities 2 w 815
and 13 w 819
the 18 w 822
being 1 w 827
ashamed 2 w 834
even 2 w 838
of 11 w 840
committing 1 w 850
solecisms 2 w 859
is 12 w 862
the 19 w 865
property 1 w 873
of 12 w 875
a 67 w 876
man 1 w 879
who 3 w 882
little 1 w 888
cares 1 w 893
what 2 w 897
he 23 w 899
says 2 w 903
but 3 w 907
rashly 1 w 913
utters 1 w 919
whatever 1 w 927
comes 1 w 932
first 1 w 937
into 1 w 941
his 3 w 944
mouth 2 w 949
Moreover 1 w 958
in 23 w 961
his 4 w 964
Natural 1 w 971
Positions 1 w 980
having 1 w 986
warned 1 w 992
us 3 w 994
not 5 w 997
to 13 w 999
trouble 1 w 1006
ourselves 1 w 1015
but 4 w 1018
to 14 w 1020
be 8 w 1022
at 10 w 1024
quiet 1 w 1029
about 1 w 1034
such 1 w 1038
things 2 w 1044
as 8 w 1046
require 1 w 1053
experience 1 w 1063
and 14 w 1066
investigation 1 w 1079
he 24 w 1082
says 3 w 1086
Let 1 w 1090
us 4 w 1092
not 6 w 1095
think 1 w 1100
after 1 w 1105
the 20 w 1108
same 2 w 1112
manner 1 w 1118
with 1 w 1122
Plato 1 w 1127
that 5 w 1132
liquid 1 w 1138
nourishment 1 w 1149
is 16 w 1151
conveyed 1 w 1159
to 16 w 1161
the 21 w 1164
lungs 1 w 1169
and 15 w 1173
dry 1 w 1176
to 17 w 1178
the 22 w 1181
stomach 1 w 1188
nor 1 w 1192
let 2 w 1195
us 5 w 1197
embrace 1 w 1204
other 3 w 1209
errors 1 w 1215
like 1 w 1219
to 19 w 1221
these 2 w 1226
Now 1 w 1230
it 10 w 1232
is 17 w 1234
my 1 w 1236
opinion 2 w 1243
that 6 w 1248
to 20 w 1250
reprehend 1 w 1259
others 2 w 1265
and 16 w 1269
then 1 w 1273
not 7 w 1276
to 21 w 1278
keep 1 w 1282
one 2 w 1285
s 94 w 1287
self 1 w 1291
from 1 w 1295
falling 1 w 1302
into 2 w 1306
those 3 w 1311
things 3 w 1317
which 2 w 1322
one 3 w 1325
has 2 w 1328
reprehended 1 w 1339
is 18 w 1342
the 27 w 1345
greatest 1 w 1353
of 13 w 1355
contradictions 1 w 1369
and 17 w 1372
shamefullest 1 w 1384
of 14 w 1386
errors 2 w 1392
But 1 w 1396
he 35 w 1398
says 4 w 1402
that 7 w 1407
the 28 w 1410
connections 1 w 1421
made 1 w 1425
by 1 w 1427
ten 3 w 1430
axioms 1 w 1436
amount 1 w 1442
to 23 w 1444
above 1 w 1449
a 106 w 1450
million 1 w 1457
in 32 w 1459
number 1 w 1465
having 2 w 1472
neither 1 w 1479
searched 1 w 1487
diligently 1 w 1497
into 3 w 1501
it 12 w 1503
by 2 w 1505
himself 1 w 1512
nor 2 w 1515
attained 1 w 1523
to 25 w 1525
the 30 w 1528
truth 1 w 1533
by 3 w 1535
men 3 w 1538
experienced 1 w 1549
in 36 w 1551
it 13 w 1553
Yet 2 w 1557
Plato 2 w 1562
had 2 w 1565
to 27 w 1567
testify 1 w 1574
for 3 w 1577
him 2 w 1580
the 31 w 1583
most 1 w 1587
renowned 1 w 1595
of 15 w 1597
the 32 w 1600
physicians 1 w 1610
Hippocrates 1 w 1622
Philistion 1 w 1633
and 18 w 1637
Dioxippus 1 w 1646
the 33 w 1649
disciple 1 w 1657
of 16 w 1659
Hippocrates 2 w 1670
and 19 w 1674
of 17 w 1676
the 34 w 1679
poets 1 w 1684
Euripides 1 w 1694
Alcaeus 1 w 1702
Eupolis 1 w 1710
and 20 w 1714
Eratosthenes 1 w 1726
who 4 w 1730
all 3 w 1733
say 5 w 1736
that 8 w 1740
the 36 w 1743
drink 1 w 1748
passes 1 w 1754
through 1 w 1761
the 37 w 1764
lungs 2 w 1769
But 2 w 1773
all 4 w 1776
the 38 w 1779
arithmeticians 1 w 1793
refel 1 w 1798
Chrysippus 1 w 1808
amongst 1 w 1816
whom 1 w 1820
also 4 w 1824
is 22 w 1826
Hipparchus 1 w 1836
demonstrating 1 w 1850
that 9 w 1854
the 39 w 1857
error 3 w 1862
of 18 w 1864
his 5 w 1867
computation 1 w 1878
is 24 w 1880
very 3 w 1884
great 2 w 1889
since 1 w 1895
the 40 w 1898
affirmative 1 w 1909
makes 1 w 1914
of 19 w 1916
the 41 w 1919
ten 4 w 1922
axioms 2 w 1928
one 4 w 1931
hundred 1 w 1938
and 21 w 1941
three 1 w 1946
thousand 1 w 1955
forty 1 w 1960
and 23 w 1963
nine 1 w 1967
connections 2 w 1978
and 24 w 1982
the 42 w 1985
negative 1 w 1993
three 2 w 1998
hundred 2 w 2005
and 25 w 2008
ten 5 w 2011
thousand 2 w 2019
nine 2 w 2023
hundred 3 w 2030
fifty 1 w 2035
and 27 w 2038
two 1 w 2041