Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The contradictions of the Stoics

The contradictions of the Stoics (24)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg136.perseus-eng2:24
Refs {'start': {'reference': '24', 'human_reference': 'Section 24'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

In his Third Book of Dialectics, having said that Plato, Aristotle, and those who came after them, even to Polemon and Straton, but especially Socrates, diligently studied dialectics, and having cried out that one would even choose to err with such and so great men as these, he brings in these words: For if they had spoken of these things cursorily, one might perhaps have cavilled at this place; but having treated of dialectic skill as one of the greatest and most necessary faculties, it is not probable they should have been so much mistaken, having been such in all the parts of philosophy as we esteem them. Why then (might some one say to him) do you never cease to oppose and argue against such and so great men, as if you thought them to err in the principal and greatest matters? For it is not probable that they writ seriously of dialectics, and only transitorily and in sport of the beginning, end, Gods, and justice, in which you affirm their discourse to be blind and contradictory to itself, and to have a thousand other faults.

Tokens

In 1 w 2
his 1 w 5
Third 1 w 10
Book 1 w 14
of 1 w 16
Dialectics 1 w 26
having 1 w 33
said 1 w 37
that 1 w 41
Plato 1 w 46
Aristotle 1 w 56
and 1 w 60
those 1 w 65
who 1 w 68
came 1 w 72
after 1 w 77
them 1 w 81
even 1 w 86
to 3 w 88
Polemon 1 w 95
and 2 w 98
Straton 1 w 105
but 1 w 109
especially 1 w 119
Socrates 1 w 127
diligently 1 w 138
studied 1 w 145
dialectics 1 w 155
and 3 w 159
having 2 w 165
cried 1 w 170
out 1 w 173
that 2 w 177
one 1 w 180
would 1 w 185
even 2 w 189
choose 1 w 195
to 5 w 197
err 1 w 200
with 1 w 204
such 1 w 208
and 4 w 211
so 1 w 213
great 1 w 218
men 1 w 221
as 1 w 223
these 1 w 228
he 3 w 231
brings 1 w 237
in 4 w 239
these 2 w 244
words 1 w 249
For 1 w 253
if 1 w 255
they 1 w 259
had 1 w 262
spoken 1 w 268
of 2 w 270
these 3 w 275
things 1 w 281
cursorily 1 w 290
one 2 w 294
might 1 w 299
perhaps 1 w 306
have 1 w 310
cavilled 1 w 318
at 7 w 320
this 1 w 324
place 1 w 329
but 2 w 333
having 3 w 339
treated 1 w 346
of 3 w 348
dialectic 2 w 357
skill 1 w 362
as 2 w 364
one 3 w 367
of 4 w 369
the 6 w 372
greatest 1 w 380
and 5 w 383
most 1 w 387
necessary 1 w 396
faculties 1 w 405
it 2 w 408
is 4 w 410
not 1 w 413
probable 1 w 421
they 2 w 425
should 1 w 431
have 2 w 435
been 1 w 439
so 3 w 441
much 1 w 445
mistaken 1 w 453
having 4 w 460
been 2 w 464
such 2 w 468
in 8 w 470
all 2 w 473
the 8 w 476
parts 1 w 481
of 5 w 483
philosophy 1 w 493
as 3 w 495
we 1 w 497
esteem 1 w 503
them 2 w 507
Why 1 w 511
then 1 w 515
might 2 w 521
some 1 w 525
one 4 w 528
say 1 w 531
to 6 w 533
him 1 w 536
do 1 w 539
you 1 w 542
never 1 w 547
cease 1 w 552
to 7 w 554
oppose 1 w 560
and 6 w 563
argue 1 w 568
against 1 w 575
such 3 w 579
and 7 w 582
so 6 w 584
great 3 w 589
men 2 w 592
as 5 w 595
if 2 w 597
you 2 w 600
thought 1 w 607
them 3 w 611
to 8 w 613
err 2 w 616
in 10 w 618
the 12 w 621
principal 1 w 630
and 8 w 633
greatest 2 w 641
matters 1 w 648
For 2 w 652
it 3 w 654
is 6 w 656
not 2 w 659
probable 2 w 667
that 3 w 671
they 3 w 675
writ 1 w 679
seriously 1 w 688
of 6 w 690
dialectics 2 w 700
and 9 w 704
only 1 w 708
transitorily 1 w 720
and 10 w 723
in 12 w 725
sport 1 w 730
of 7 w 732
the 14 w 735
beginning 1 w 744
end 1 w 748
Gods 1 w 753
and 11 w 757
justice 1 w 764
in 15 w 767
which 1 w 772
you 3 w 775
affirm 1 w 781
their 1 w 786
discourse 1 w 795
to 10 w 797
be 4 w 799
blind 1 w 804
and 12 w 807
contradictory 1 w 820
to 12 w 822
itself 1 w 828
and 13 w 832
to 13 w 834
have 3 w 838
a 66 w 839
thousand 1 w 847
other 1 w 852
faults 1 w 858