Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Concerning the procreation of the soul as discoursed in Timaeus

Concerning the procreation of the soul as discoursed in Timaeus (19-21)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg134.perseus-eng2:19-21
Refs {'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'Section 19'}, 'end': {'reference': '21', 'human_reference': 'Section 21'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Others, placing the two extremes of the diatessaron, the acute part in 288, and the lower sound in 216, in all the rest observe the same proportions, only that they take the remainder between the two middle intervals. For the base, being forced up a whole tone, makes 243; and the upper note, screwed downward a full tone, begets 256. Moreover 243 carries a sesquioctave proportion to 216, and 288 to 256; so that each of the intervals contains a full tone, and the residue is that which remains between 243 and 256, which is not a semitone, but something less. For 288 exceeds 256 by 32, and 243 exceeds 216 by 27; but 256 exceeds 243 by 13. Now this excess is less than half of the former. So it is plain that the diatessaron consists of two tones and the residue, not of two tones and a half. Let this suffice for the demonstration of these things. Nor is it a difficult thing to believe, by what has been already said, wherefore Plato, after he had asserted that the intervals of sesquialter, sesquiterce, and sesquioctave had arisen, when he comes to fill up the intervals of sesquiterces with sesquioctaves, makes not the least mention of sesquialters; for that the sesquialter is soon filled up, by adding the sesquiterce

to the sesquioctave, or the sesquioctave to the sesquiterce.

Having therefore shown the manner how to fill up the intervals, and to place and dispose the medieties, had never any person taken the same pains before, I should have recommended the further consideration of it to the recreation of your fancies; but in regard that several most excellent musicians have made it their business to unfold these mysteries with a diligence more than usually exact,—more especially Crantor, Clearchus, and Theodorus, all born in Soli,—it shall suffice only to show how these men differed among themselves. For Theodorus, varying from the other two, and not observing two distinct files or rows of numbers, but placing the duples and triples in a direct line one before another, grounds himself upon that division of the substance which Plato calls the division in length, making two parts (as it were) out of one, not four out of two. Then he says, that the interposition of the mediums ought to take place in that manner, to avoid the trouble and confusion which must arise from transferring out of the first duple into the first triple the intervals which are ordained for the supplement of both. But as for those who take Crantors part, they so dispose their numbers as to place planes with planes, tetragons with tetragons, cubes with cubes, opposite to one another, not taking them in file, but alternatively odd to even. [Here is some great defect in the original.]

Which, being in themselves permanently the same, afford the form and species; but being subject to corporeal division, they become the matter and subject to receive the others impression, the common mixture being completed out of both. Now the indivisible substance, which is always one and the same, is not to be thought to be incapable of division by reason of its smallness, like the most minute of bodies, called atoms. But as it is unmixed,

and not to be any way affected, but pure and altogether of one sort, it is said not to consist of parts, but to be indivisible. By means of which purity, when it comes in any manner whatsoever to approach and gently touch compounded divisible and differing substances, all their variety ceases and they crowd together into one habit by sympathy and similitude. If now any one will call that substance which admits corporeal separation matter, as a nature subject to the former and partaking of it, the use of that equivocal term will nothing disadvantage our discourse. But they are under a mistake that believe the corporeal to be blended with the indivisible matter. First, for that Plato does not here make use of any one of its names; whereas in other places he calls it the receptacle and nurse, capable of both receiving and fostering the vast infinity of created beings; not divisible among bodies, but rather the body itself parted and divided into single individuals. Then again, what difference would there be between the creation of the world and that of the soul, if the composition of each proceeded from both matter and the intelligible essence? Certainly Plato, as endeavoring to separate the generation of the body from that of the soul, tells us that the corporeal part was by God seated and deposited within it, and that it was outwardly covered and enveloped by it; and after he had thus wrought the soul to its perfection out of proportion, he then proceeds to this argument concerning matter, of which he had no occasion to make mention before when he was producing the soul, as being that which had not its existence from matter.

Tokens

Others 1 w 6
placing 1 w 14
the 2 w 17
two 1 w 20
extremes 1 w 28
of 1 w 30
the 3 w 33
diatessaron 1 w 44
the 4 w 48
acute 1 w 53
part 1 w 57
in 2 w 59
288 1 w 62
and 1 w 66
the 5 w 69
lower 1 w 74
sound 1 w 79
in 3 w 81
216 1 w 84
in 4 w 87
all 1 w 90
the 6 w 93
rest 1 w 97
observe 1 w 104
the 7 w 107
same 1 w 111
proportions 1 w 122
only 1 w 127
that 1 w 131
they 1 w 135
take 1 w 139
the 9 w 142
remainder 1 w 151
between 1 w 158
the 10 w 161
two 2 w 164
middle 1 w 170
intervals 1 w 179
For 1 w 183
the 11 w 186
base 1 w 190
being 1 w 196
forced 1 w 202
up 1 w 204
a 14 w 205
whole 1 w 210
tone 1 w 214
makes 1 w 220
243 1 w 223
and 2 w 227
the 12 w 230
upper 1 w 235
note 1 w 239
screwed 1 w 247
downward 1 w 255
a 18 w 256
full 1 w 260
tone 2 w 264
begets 1 w 271
256 1 w 274
Moreover 1 w 283
243 2 w 286
carries 1 w 293
a 20 w 294
sesquioctave 1 w 306
proportion 2 w 316
to 3 w 318
216 2 w 321
and 3 w 325
288 2 w 328
to 4 w 330
256 2 w 333
so 2 w 336
that 2 w 340
each 1 w 344
of 2 w 346
the 13 w 349
intervals 2 w 358
contains 1 w 366
a 27 w 367
full 2 w 371
tone 3 w 375
and 4 w 379
the 14 w 382
residue 1 w 389
is 1 w 391
that 3 w 395
which 1 w 400
remains 1 w 407
between 2 w 414
243 3 w 417
and 5 w 420
256 3 w 423
which 2 w 429
is 2 w 431
not 2 w 434
a 32 w 435
semitone 1 w 443
but 1 w 447
something 1 w 456
less 1 w 460
For 2 w 464
288 3 w 467
exceeds 1 w 474
256 4 w 477
by 1 w 479
32 1 w 481
and 6 w 485
243 4 w 488
exceeds 2 w 495
216 3 w 498
by 2 w 500
27 1 w 502
but 2 w 506
256 5 w 509
exceeds 3 w 516
243 5 w 519
by 3 w 521
13 1 w 523
Now 1 w 527
this 1 w 531
excess 1 w 537
is 4 w 539
less 2 w 543
than 1 w 547
half 1 w 551
of 3 w 553
the 15 w 556
former 1 w 562
So 1 w 565
it 2 w 567
is 5 w 569
plain 1 w 574
that 4 w 578
the 16 w 581
diatessaron 2 w 592
consists 1 w 600
of 4 w 602
two 3 w 605
tones 1 w 610
and 7 w 613
the 17 w 616
residue 2 w 623
not 3 w 627
of 5 w 629
two 4 w 632
tones 2 w 637
and 8 w 640
a 42 w 641
half 2 w 645
Let 1 w 649
this 2 w 653
suffice 1 w 660
for 3 w 663
the 18 w 666
demonstration 1 w 679
of 6 w 681
these 1 w 686
things 1 w 692
Nor 1 w 696
is 8 w 698
it 3 w 700
a 45 w 701
difficult 1 w 710
thing 3 w 715
to 9 w 717
believe 1 w 724
by 4 w 727
what 1 w 731
has 1 w 734
been 1 w 738
already 1 w 745
said 1 w 749
wherefore 1 w 759
Plato 1 w 764
after 1 w 770
he 21 w 772
had 1 w 775
asserted 1 w 783
that 5 w 787
the 20 w 790
intervals 3 w 799
of 7 w 801
sesquialter 1 w 812
sesquiterce 1 w 824
and 9 w 828
sesquioctave 2 w 840
had 2 w 843
arisen 1 w 849
when 1 w 854
he 24 w 856
comes 1 w 861
to 11 w 863
fill 1 w 867
up 3 w 869
the 21 w 872
intervals 4 w 881
of 8 w 883
sesquiterces 1 w 895
with 1 w 899
sesquioctaves 1 w 912
makes 2 w 918
not 4 w 921
the 22 w 924
least 1 w 929
mention 1 w 936
of 9 w 938
sesquialters 1 w 950
for 5 w 954
that 6 w 958
the 23 w 961
sesquialter 3 w 972
is 10 w 974
soon 1 w 978
filled 1 w 984
up 4 w 986
by 5 w 989
adding 1 w 995
the 24 w 998
sesquiterce 3 w 1009
to 12 w 1011
the 25 w 1014
sesquioctave 4 w 1026
or 12 w 1029
the 26 w 1032
sesquioctave 5 w 1044
to 13 w 1046
the 27 w 1049
sesquiterce 4 w 1060
Having 1 w 1067
therefore 1 w 1076
shown 1 w 1081
the 29 w 1084
manner 1 w 1090
how 2 w 1093
to 14 w 1095
fill 3 w 1099
up 5 w 1101
the 30 w 1104
intervals 5 w 1113
and 10 w 1117
to 15 w 1119
place 1 w 1124
and 11 w 1127
dispose 1 w 1134
the 31 w 1137
medieties 1 w 1146
had 3 w 1150
never 1 w 1155
any 1 w 1158
person 1 w 1164
taken 1 w 1169
the 32 w 1172
same 2 w 1176
pains 1 w 1181
before 1 w 1187
I 1 w 1189
should 1 w 1195
have 1 w 1199
recommended 1 w 1210
the 33 w 1213
further 1 w 1220
consideration 1 w 1233
of 10 w 1235
it 9 w 1237
to 16 w 1239
the 35 w 1242
recreation 1 w 1252
of 11 w 1254
your 1 w 1258
fancies 1 w 1265
but 3 w 1269
in 21 w 1271
regard 1 w 1277
that 7 w 1281
several 1 w 1288
most 1 w 1292
excellent 1 w 1301
musicians 1 w 1310
have 2 w 1314
made 1 w 1318
it 10 w 1320
their 1 w 1325
business 1 w 1333
to 17 w 1335
unfold 1 w 1341
these 2 w 1346
mysteries 1 w 1355
with 2 w 1359
a 93 w 1360
diligence 1 w 1369
more 1 w 1373
than 2 w 1377
usually 1 w 1384
exact 1 w 1389
more 2 w 1395
especially 1 w 1405
Crantor 1 w 1412
Clearchus 1 w 1422
and 12 w 1426
Theodorus 1 w 1435
all 4 w 1439
born 1 w 1443
in 23 w 1445
Soli 1 w 1449
it 12 w 1453
shall 1 w 1458
suffice 2 w 1465
only 2 w 1469
to 19 w 1471
show 2 w 1475
how 4 w 1478
these 3 w 1483
men 3 w 1486
differed 1 w 1494
among 1 w 1499
themselves 1 w 1509
For 3 w 1513
Theodorus 2 w 1522
varying 1 w 1530
from 1 w 1534
the 40 w 1537
other 1 w 1542
two 5 w 1545
and 13 w 1549
not 5 w 1552
observing 1 w 1561
two 6 w 1564
distinct 1 w 1572
files 1 w 1577
or 22 w 1579
rows 1 w 1583
of 12 w 1585
numbers 1 w 1592
but 4 w 1596
placing 2 w 1603
the 42 w 1606
duples 1 w 1612
and 14 w 1615
triples 1 w 1622
in 28 w 1624
a 108 w 1625
direct 1 w 1631
line 1 w 1635
one 7 w 1638
before 2 w 1644
another 1 w 1651
grounds 1 w 1659
himself 1 w 1666
upon 1 w 1670
that 8 w 1674
division 1 w 1682
of 13 w 1684
the 44 w 1687
substance 1 w 1696
which 3 w 1701
Plato 2 w 1706
calls 1 w 1711
the 45 w 1714
division 2 w 1722
in 30 w 1724
length 1 w 1730
making 1 w 1737
two 7 w 1740
parts 1 w 1745
as 5 w 1748
it 13 w 1750
were 1 w 1754
out 1 w 1758
of 14 w 1760
one 8 w 1763
not 7 w 1767
four 1 w 1771
out 2 w 1774
of 15 w 1776
two 8 w 1779
Then 1 w 1784
he 53 w 1786
says 1 w 1790
that 9 w 1795
the 46 w 1798
interposition 1 w 1811
of 16 w 1813
the 47 w 1816
mediums 1 w 1823
ought 1 w 1828
to 21 w 1830
take 3 w 1834
place 2 w 1839
in 33 w 1841
that 10 w 1845
manner 2 w 1851
to 22 w 1854
avoid 1 w 1859
the 48 w 1862
trouble 1 w 1869
and 15 w 1872
confusion 1 w 1881
which 4 w 1886
must 1 w 1890
arise 2 w 1895
from 2 w 1899
transferring 1 w 1911
out 3 w 1914
of 17 w 1916
the 49 w 1919
first 1 w 1924
duple 2 w 1929
into 1 w 1933
the 50 w 1936
first 2 w 1941
triple 2 w 1947
the 51 w 1950
intervals 6 w 1959
which 5 w 1964
are 1 w 1967
ordained 1 w 1975
for 9 w 1978
the 52 w 1981
supplement 1 w 1991
of 18 w 1993
both 1 w 1997
But 1 w 2001
as 6 w 2003
for 10 w 2006
those 1 w 2011
who 2 w 2014
take 4 w 2018
Crantor 2 w 2025
s 152 w 2027
part 3 w 2031
they 2 w 2036
so 6 w 2038
dispose 2 w 2045
their 2 w 2050
numbers 2 w 2057
as 7 w 2059
to 25 w 2061
place 3 w 2066
planes 1 w 2072
with 3 w 2076
planes 2 w 2082
tetragons 1 w 2092
with 4 w 2096
tetragons 2 w 2105
cubes 1 w 2111
with 5 w 2115
cubes 2 w 2120
opposite 1 w 2129
to 26 w 2131
one 9 w 2134
another 2 w 2141
not 9 w 2145
taking 1 w 2151
them 2 w 2155
in 39 w 2157
file 2 w 2161
but 5 w 2165
alternatively 1 w 2178
odd 1 w 2181
to 27 w 2183
even 1 w 2187
Here 1 w 2193
is 17 w 2195
some 2 w 2199
great 1 w 2204
defect 1 w 2210
in 40 w 2212
the 57 w 2215
original 1 w 2223
Which 1 w 2230
being 2 w 2236
in 43 w 2238
themselves 2 w 2248
permanently 1 w 2259
the 59 w 2262
same 3 w 2266
afford 1 w 2273
the 60 w 2276
form 2 w 2280
and 16 w 2283
species 1 w 2290
but 6 w 2294
being 3 w 2299
subject 1 w 2306
to 28 w 2308
corporeal 1 w 2317
division 3 w 2325
they 3 w 2330
become 1 w 2336
the 62 w 2339
matter 1 w 2345
and 17 w 2348
subject 2 w 2355
to 29 w 2357
receive 1 w 2364
the 63 w 2367
other 4 w 2372
s 175 w 2374
impression 1 w 2384
the 65 w 2388
common 1 w 2394
mixture 1 w 2401
being 4 w 2406
completed 1 w 2415
out 4 w 2418
of 19 w 2420
both 2 w 2424
Now 2 w 2428
the 66 w 2431
indivisible 1 w 2442
substance 2 w 2451
which 6 w 2457
is 20 w 2459
always 1 w 2465
one 10 w 2468
and 18 w 2471
the 67 w 2474
same 4 w 2478
is 21 w 2481
not 10 w 2484
to 30 w 2486
be 17 w 2488
thought 1 w 2495
to 31 w 2497
be 18 w 2499
incapable 1 w 2508
of 20 w 2510
division 4 w 2518
by 6 w 2520
reason 1 w 2526
of 21 w 2528
its 1 w 2531
smallness 1 w 2540
like 1 w 2545
the 68 w 2548
most 2 w 2552
minute 1 w 2558
of 22 w 2560
bodies 1 w 2566
called 1 w 2573
atoms 1 w 2578
But 2 w 2582
as 9 w 2584
it 20 w 2586
is 23 w 2588
unmixed 1 w 2595
and 19 w 2599
not 11 w 2602
to 33 w 2604
be 19 w 2606
any 2 w 2609
way 2 w 2612
affected 1 w 2620
but 7 w 2624
pure 1 w 2628
and 20 w 2631
altogether 1 w 2641
of 23 w 2643
one 11 w 2646
sort 1 w 2650
it 21 w 2653
is 24 w 2655
said 2 w 2659
not 12 w 2662
to 35 w 2664
consist 2 w 2671
of 24 w 2673
parts 2 w 2678
but 8 w 2682
to 36 w 2684
be 20 w 2686
indivisible 2 w 2697
By 1 w 2700
means 1 w 2705
of 25 w 2707
which 7 w 2712
purity 1 w 2718
when 2 w 2723
it 23 w 2725
comes 2 w 2730
in 50 w 2732
any 3 w 2735
manner 3 w 2741
whatsoever 1 w 2751
to 37 w 2753
approach 1 w 2761
and 21 w 2764
gently 1 w 2770
touch 1 w 2775
compounded 1 w 2785
divisible 3 w 2794
and 22 w 2797
differing 1 w 2806
substances 1 w 2816
all 9 w 2820
their 3 w 2825
variety 1 w 2832
ceases 1 w 2838
and 23 w 2841
they 4 w 2845
crowd 1 w 2850
together 2 w 2858
into 2 w 2862
one 12 w 2865
habit 1 w 2870
by 7 w 2872
sympathy 1 w 2880
and 24 w 2883
similitude 1 w 2893
If 1 w 2896
now 1 w 2899
any 4 w 2902
one 13 w 2905
will 1 w 2909
call 3 w 2913
that 11 w 2917
substance 4 w 2926
which 8 w 2931
admits 1 w 2937
corporeal 2 w 2946
separation 1 w 2956
matter 2 w 2962
as 11 w 2965
a 199 w 2966
nature 1 w 2972
subject 3 w 2979
to 41 w 2981
the 73 w 2984
former 2 w 2990
and 25 w 2993
partaking 1 w 3002
of 26 w 3004
it 27 w 3006
the 74 w 3010
use 1 w 3013
of 27 w 3015
that 12 w 3019
equivocal 1 w 3028
term 1 w 3032
will 2 w 3036
nothing 1 w 3043
disadvantage 1 w 3055
our 3 w 3058
discourse 1 w 3067
But 3 w 3071
they 5 w 3075
are 2 w 3078
under 1 w 3083
a 210 w 3084
mistake 1 w 3091
that 13 w 3095
believe 2 w 3102
the 76 w 3105
corporeal 3 w 3114
to 42 w 3116
be 22 w 3118
blended 1 w 3125
with 6 w 3129
the 77 w 3132
indivisible 3 w 3143
matter 3 w 3149
First 1 w 3155
for 14 w 3159
that 14 w 3163
Plato 3 w 3168
does 1 w 3172
not 14 w 3175
here 3 w 3179
make 3 w 3183
use 2 w 3186
of 28 w 3188
any 5 w 3191
one 14 w 3194
of 29 w 3196
its 3 w 3199
names 1 w 3204
whereas 1 w 3212
in 56 w 3214
other 5 w 3219
places 1 w 3225
he 90 w 3227
calls 2 w 3232
it 30 w 3234
the 79 w 3237
receptacle 1 w 3247
and 26 w 3250
nurse 1 w 3255
capable 2 w 3263
of 30 w 3265
both 3 w 3269
receiving 1 w 3278
and 27 w 3281
fostering 1 w 3290
the 80 w 3293
vast 1 w 3297
infinity 1 w 3305
of 31 w 3307
created 1 w 3314
beings 1 w 3320
not 15 w 3324
divisible 5 w 3333
among 2 w 3338
bodies 2 w 3344
but 9 w 3348
rather 1 w 3354
the 82 w 3357
body 1 w 3361
itself 1 w 3367
parted 1 w 3373
and 28 w 3376
divided 1 w 3383
into 3 w 3387
single 1 w 3393
individuals 1 w 3404
Then 2 w 3409
again 1 w 3414
what 3 w 3419
difference 1 w 3429
would 1 w 3434
there 2 w 3439
be 24 w 3441
between 3 w 3448
the 84 w 3451
creation 2 w 3459
of 32 w 3461
the 85 w 3464
world 1 w 3469
and 29 w 3472
that 15 w 3476
of 33 w 3478
the 86 w 3481
soul 1 w 3485
if 5 w 3488
the 87 w 3491
composition 1 w 3502
of 34 w 3504
each 2 w 3508
proceeded 1 w 3517
from 3 w 3521
both 4 w 3525
matter 4 w 3531
and 30 w 3534
the 88 w 3537
intelligible 1 w 3549
essence 1 w 3556
Certainly 1 w 3566
Plato 4 w 3571
as 14 w 3574
endeavoring 1 w 3585
to 46 w 3587
separate 1 w 3595
the 89 w 3598
generation 1 w 3608
of 35 w 3610
the 90 w 3613
body 2 w 3617
from 4 w 3621
that 16 w 3625
of 36 w 3627
the 91 w 3630
soul 2 w 3634
tells 1 w 3640
us 11 w 3642
that 17 w 3646
the 92 w 3649
corporeal 4 w 3658
part 7 w 3662
was 1 w 3665
by 8 w 3667
God 1 w 3670
seated 1 w 3676
and 31 w 3679
deposited 1 w 3688
within 1 w 3694
it 36 w 3696
and 32 w 3700
that 18 w 3704
it 37 w 3706
was 2 w 3709
outwardly 1 w 3718
covered 1 w 3725
and 33 w 3728
enveloped 1 w 3737
by 9 w 3739
it 38 w 3741
and 34 w 3745
after 2 w 3750
he 106 w 3752
had 4 w 3755
thus 1 w 3759
wrought 1 w 3766
the 93 w 3769
soul 3 w 3773
to 47 w 3775
its 5 w 3778
perfection 1 w 3788
out 6 w 3791
of 37 w 3793
proportion 3 w 3803
he 108 w 3806
then 1 w 3810
proceeds 1 w 3818
to 48 w 3820
this 3 w 3824
argument 1 w 3832
concerning 1 w 3842
matter 5 w 3848
of 38 w 3851
which 9 w 3856
he 110 w 3858
had 5 w 3861
no 17 w 3863
occasion 1 w 3871
to 49 w 3873
make 4 w 3877
mention 2 w 3884
before 3 w 3890
when 3 w 3894
he 112 w 3896
was 3 w 3899
producing 1 w 3908
the 95 w 3911
soul 4 w 3915
as 19 w 3918
being 6 w 3923
that 19 w 3927
which 10 w 3932
had 6 w 3935
not 16 w 3938
its 6 w 3941
existence 1 w 3950
from 5 w 3954
matter 6 w 3960