Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (8.4)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:8.4
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8.4', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 8 Section 4'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '8'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And so much the rather might we consider whether the sun is not absurdly and without probability said to be made for the distinction of time, with the moon and the rest of the planets. For as in other respects the dignity

of the sun is great; so by Plato in his Republic[*] the sun is called the king and lord of the whole sensible nature, as the Chief Good is of the intelligible. For it is said to be the offspring of Good, it giving both generation and appearance to things visible; as it is from Good that things intelligible both are and are understood. But that this God, having such a nature and so great power, should be only an instrument of time, and a sure measure of the difference that happens among the eight orbs, as they are slow or swift in motion, seems neither decent nor highly rational. It must therefore be said to such as are startled at these things, that it is their ignorance to think that time is the measure of motion in respect of sooner or later, as Aristotle calls it; or quantity in motion, as Speusippus; or an interval of motion and nothing more, as some of the Stoics define it, by an accident, not comprehending its essence and power, which Pindar has not ineptly expressed in these words: Time, who surpasses all in the seats of the blest. Pythagoras also, when he was asked what time was, answered, it was the soul of this world. For time is no affection or accident of motion, but the cause, power, and principle of that symmetry and order that confines all created beings, by which the animated nature of the universe is moved. Or rather, this order and symmetry itselfso far as it is motionis called time. For this,
Walking by still and silent ways,
Mortal affairs with justice guides.
[*]

According to the ancients, the essence of the soul is a number moving itself. Therefore Plato says that time and heaven were coexistent, but that motion was before heaven had being. But time was not. For then there neither was order, nor measure, nor determination; but indefinite motion, as it were, the formless and rude matter of time.

But when matter was informed with figures, and motion with circuitions, from that came the world, from this time. Both are representations of God; the world, of his essence; time, of his eternity in the form of motion, as the world is God in creation. Therefore they say heaven and motion, being bred together, will perish together, if ever they do perish. For nothing is generated without time, nor is any thing intelligible without eternity; if this is to endure for ever, and that never to die when once bred. Time therefore, having a necessary connection and affinity with heaven, cannot be called simple motion, but (as it were) motion in order having terms and periods; whereof since the sun is prefect and overseer, to determine, moderate, produce, and observe changes and seasons, which (according to Heraclitus) produce all things, he is coadjutor to the governing and chief God, not in trivial things, but in the greatest and most momentous affairs.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
so 1 w 5
much 1 w 9
the 1 w 12
rather 1 w 18
might 1 w 23
we 1 w 25
consider 1 w 33
whether 1 w 40
the 4 w 43
sun 1 w 46
is 1 w 48
not 1 w 51
absurdly 1 w 59
and 1 w 62
without 1 w 69
probability 1 w 80
said 1 w 84
to 1 w 86
be 1 w 88
made 1 w 92
for 1 w 95
the 5 w 98
distinction 1 w 109
of 1 w 111
time 1 w 115
with 2 w 120
the 6 w 123
moon 1 w 127
and 2 w 130
the 7 w 133
rest 1 w 137
of 2 w 139
the 8 w 142
planets 1 w 149
For 1 w 153
as 1 w 155
in 2 w 157
other 1 w 162
respects 1 w 170
the 10 w 173
dignity 1 w 180
of 3 w 182
the 11 w 185
sun 2 w 188
is 3 w 190
great 1 w 195
so 2 w 198
by 1 w 200
Plato 1 w 205
in 3 w 207
his 1 w 210
Republic 1 w 218
Plato 2 w 223
Republic 2 w 232
VI 1 w 235
pp 1 w 238
508 1 w 242
509 1 w 246
the 12 w 250
sun 3 w 253
is 5 w 255
called 1 w 261
the 13 w 264
king 1 w 268
and 3 w 271
lord 1 w 275
of 4 w 277
the 14 w 280
whole 1 w 285
sensible 1 w 293
nature 1 w 299
as 2 w 302
the 15 w 305
Chief 1 w 310
Good 1 w 314
is 6 w 316
of 5 w 318
the 16 w 321
intelligible 1 w 333
For 2 w 337
it 5 w 339
is 7 w 341
said 2 w 345
to 4 w 347
be 2 w 349
the 17 w 352
offspring 1 w 361
of 7 w 363
Good 2 w 367
it 6 w 370
giving 1 w 376
both 1 w 380
generation 1 w 390
and 4 w 393
appearance 1 w 403
to 5 w 405
things 1 w 411
visible 1 w 418
as 3 w 421
it 7 w 423
is 9 w 425
from 1 w 429
Good 3 w 433
that 1 w 437
things 2 w 443
intelligible 2 w 455
both 2 w 459
are 1 w 462
and 5 w 465
are 2 w 468
understood 1 w 478
But 1 w 482
that 2 w 486
this 1 w 490
God 1 w 493
having 1 w 500
such 1 w 504
a 30 w 505
nature 2 w 511
and 6 w 514
so 3 w 516
great 2 w 521
power 1 w 526
should 1 w 533
be 3 w 535
only 1 w 539
an 9 w 541
instrument 1 w 551
of 8 w 553
time 2 w 557
and 7 w 561
a 36 w 562
sure 1 w 566
measure 1 w 573
of 9 w 575
the 18 w 578
difference 1 w 588
that 3 w 592
happens 1 w 599
among 1 w 604
the 19 w 607
eight 1 w 612
orbs 1 w 616
as 5 w 619
they 1 w 623
are 3 w 626
slow 1 w 630
or 6 w 632
swift 1 w 637
in 13 w 639
motion 1 w 645
seems 1 w 651
neither 1 w 658
decent 1 w 664
nor 1 w 667
highly 1 w 673
rational 1 w 681
It 1 w 684
must 1 w 688
therefore 1 w 697
be 4 w 699
said 3 w 703
to 7 w 705
such 2 w 709
as 6 w 711
are 4 w 714
startled 1 w 722
at 13 w 724
these 1 w 729
things 3 w 735
that 4 w 740
it 9 w 742
is 11 w 744
their 1 w 749
ignorance 1 w 758
to 8 w 760
think 1 w 765
that 5 w 769
time 3 w 773
is 12 w 775
the 25 w 778
measure 2 w 785
of 10 w 787
motion 2 w 793
in 16 w 795
respect 2 w 802
of 11 w 804
sooner 1 w 810
or 10 w 812
later 1 w 817
as 8 w 820
Aristotle 1 w 829
calls 1 w 834
it 10 w 836
or 11 w 839
quantity 1 w 847
in 17 w 849
motion 3 w 855
as 9 w 858
Speusippus 1 w 868
or 12 w 871
an 13 w 873
interval 1 w 881
of 12 w 883
motion 4 w 889
and 8 w 892
nothing 1 w 899
more 1 w 903
as 10 w 906
some 1 w 910
of 13 w 912
the 26 w 915
Stoics 1 w 921
define 1 w 927
it 12 w 929
by 2 w 932
an 15 w 934
accident 1 w 942
not 3 w 946
comprehending 1 w 959
its 1 w 962
essence 1 w 969
and 9 w 972
power 2 w 977
which 1 w 983
Pindar 1 w 989
has 1 w 992
not 4 w 995
ineptly 1 w 1002
expressed 1 w 1011
in 24 w 1013
these 2 w 1018
words 1 w 1023
Time 1 w 1028
who 2 w 1032
surpasses 1 w 1041
all 3 w 1044
in 25 w 1046
the 28 w 1049
seats 1 w 1054
of 14 w 1056
the 29 w 1059
blest 1 w 1064
Pythagoras 1 w 1075
also 1 w 1079
when 1 w 1084
he 33 w 1086
was 1 w 1089
asked 1 w 1094
what 1 w 1098
time 4 w 1102
was 2 w 1105
answered 1 w 1114
it 14 w 1117
was 3 w 1120
the 30 w 1123
soul 1 w 1127
of 15 w 1129
this 2 w 1133
world 1 w 1138
For 3 w 1142
time 5 w 1146
is 15 w 1148
no 7 w 1150
affection 1 w 1159
or 18 w 1161
accident 2 w 1169
of 16 w 1171
motion 5 w 1177
but 1 w 1181
the 31 w 1184
cause 1 w 1189
power 3 w 1195
and 10 w 1199
principle 1 w 1208
of 17 w 1210
that 6 w 1214
symmetry 1 w 1222
and 11 w 1225
order 1 w 1230
that 7 w 1234
confines 1 w 1242
all 4 w 1245
created 1 w 1252
beings 1 w 1258
by 3 w 1261
which 2 w 1266
the 32 w 1269
animated 1 w 1277
nature 3 w 1283
of 18 w 1285
the 33 w 1288
universe 1 w 1296
is 16 w 1298
moved 1 w 1303
Or 1 w 1306
rather 2 w 1312
this 3 w 1317
order 2 w 1322
and 12 w 1325
symmetry 2 w 1333
itself 1 w 1339
so 8 w 1342
far 1 w 1345
as 18 w 1347
it 16 w 1349
is 18 w 1351
motion 6 w 1357
is 19 w 1360
called 2 w 1366
time 6 w 1370
For 4 w 1374
this 4 w 1378
Walking 1 w 1386
by 4 w 1388
still 1 w 1393
and 13 w 1396
silent 1 w 1402
ways 1 w 1406
Mortal 1 w 1413
affairs 1 w 1420
with 3 w 1424
justice 1 w 1431
guides 1 w 1437
Euripides 1 w 1447
Troad 1 w 1453
887 1 w 1457
According 1 w 1467
to 11 w 1469
the 35 w 1472
ancients 1 w 1480
the 36 w 1484
essence 2 w 1491
of 19 w 1493
the 37 w 1496
soul 2 w 1500
is 21 w 1502
a 105 w 1503
number 1 w 1509
moving 1 w 1515
itself 2 w 1521
Therefore 1 w 1531
Plato 3 w 1536
says 1 w 1540
that 8 w 1544
time 7 w 1548
and 14 w 1551
heaven 1 w 1557
were 2 w 1561
coexistent 1 w 1571
but 2 w 1575
that 9 w 1579
motion 7 w 1585
was 4 w 1588
before 1 w 1594
heaven 2 w 1600
had 1 w 1603
being 2 w 1608
But 2 w 1612
time 8 w 1616
was 5 w 1619
not 5 w 1622
For 5 w 1626
then 1 w 1630
there 2 w 1635
neither 2 w 1642
was 6 w 1645
order 3 w 1650
nor 3 w 1654
measure 3 w 1661
nor 4 w 1665
determination 1 w 1678
but 3 w 1682
indefinite 1 w 1692
motion 8 w 1698
as 23 w 1701
it 21 w 1703
were 3 w 1707
the 41 w 1711
formless 1 w 1719
and 15 w 1722
rude 1 w 1726
matter 1 w 1732
of 20 w 1734
time 9 w 1738
But 3 w 1742
when 2 w 1746
matter 2 w 1752
was 7 w 1755
informed 1 w 1763
with 4 w 1767
figures 1 w 1774
and 16 w 1778
motion 9 w 1784
with 5 w 1788
circuitions 1 w 1799
from 2 w 1804
that 10 w 1808
came 1 w 1812
the 42 w 1815
world 2 w 1820
from 3 w 1825
this 5 w 1829
time 10 w 1833
Both 1 w 1838
are 5 w 1841
representations 1 w 1856
of 21 w 1858
God 2 w 1861
the 43 w 1865
world 3 w 1870
of 22 w 1873
his 7 w 1876
essence 3 w 1883
time 11 w 1888
of 23 w 1891
his 8 w 1894
eternity 1 w 1902
in 37 w 1904
the 44 w 1907
form 3 w 1911
of 24 w 1913
motion 10 w 1919
as 25 w 1922
the 45 w 1925
world 4 w 1930
is 26 w 1932
God 3 w 1935
in 38 w 1937
creation 1 w 1945
Therefore 2 w 1955
they 2 w 1959
say 2 w 1962
heaven 3 w 1968
and 17 w 1971
motion 11 w 1977
being 3 w 1983
bred 1 w 1987
together 1 w 1995
will 1 w 2000
perish 1 w 2006
together 2 w 2014
if 3 w 2017
ever 1 w 2021
they 3 w 2025
do 1 w 2027
perish 2 w 2033
For 6 w 2037
nothing 2 w 2044
is 29 w 2046
generated 1 w 2055
without 2 w 2062
time 12 w 2066
nor 5 w 2070
is 30 w 2072
any 1 w 2075
thing 6 w 2080
intelligible 3 w 2092
without 3 w 2099
eternity 2 w 2107
if 4 w 2110
this 6 w 2114
is 32 w 2116
to 15 w 2118
endure 1 w 2124
for 9 w 2127
ever 2 w 2131
and 18 w 2135
that 11 w 2139
never 1 w 2144
to 16 w 2146
die 1 w 2149
when 3 w 2153
once 1 w 2157
bred 2 w 2161
Time 2 w 2166
therefore 2 w 2175
having 2 w 2182
a 139 w 2183
necessary 1 w 2192
connection 1 w 2202
and 19 w 2205
affinity 1 w 2213
with 8 w 2217
heaven 4 w 2223
cannot 1 w 2230
be 10 w 2232
called 3 w 2238
simple 1 w 2244
motion 12 w 2250
but 4 w 2254
as 26 w 2257
it 31 w 2259
were 4 w 2263
motion 13 w 2270
in 45 w 2272
order 4 w 2277
having 3 w 2283
terms 1 w 2288
and 20 w 2291
periods 1 w 2298
whereof 1 w 2306
since 1 w 2311
the 51 w 2314
sun 4 w 2317
is 33 w 2319
prefect 1 w 2326
and 21 w 2329
overseer 1 w 2337
to 17 w 2340
determine 1 w 2349
moderate 1 w 2358
produce 1 w 2366
and 22 w 2370
observe 1 w 2377
changes 1 w 2384
and 23 w 2387
seasons 1 w 2394
which 3 w 2400
according 1 w 2410
to 18 w 2412
Heraclitus 1 w 2422
produce 2 w 2430
all 7 w 2433
things 4 w 2439
he 65 w 2442
is 34 w 2444
coadjutor 1 w 2453
to 20 w 2455
the 52 w 2458
governing 1 w 2467
and 24 w 2470
chief 1 w 2475
God 4 w 2478
not 8 w 2482
in 52 w 2484
trivial 1 w 2491
things 5 w 2497
but 5 w 2501
in 54 w 2503
the 53 w 2506
greatest 1 w 2514
and 25 w 2517
most 1 w 2521
momentous 1 w 2530
affairs 2 w 2537