Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (8.2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:8.2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8.2', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 8 Section 2'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '8'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Or is this contradictory to Platos opinion elsewhere, and in the Greek instead of χρόνου should it be written χρόνῳ, taking the dative case instead of the genitive, so that the stars will not be said to be instruments, but the bodies of animals So Aristotle has defined the soul to be the actual being of a natural organic body, having the power of life. [*] The sense then must be this, that souls are dispersed into meet organical bodies in time. But this is far besides his opinion. For it is not once, but several times, that he calls the stars instruments of time; as when he says, the sun was made, as well as other planets, for the distinction and conservation of the numbers of time.

Tokens

Or 1 w 2
is 1 w 4
this 1 w 8
contradictory 1 w 21
to 2 w 23
Plato 1 w 28
s 3 w 30
opinion 1 w 37
elsewhere 1 w 46
and 1 w 50
in 2 w 52
the 1 w 55
Greek 1 w 60
instead 1 w 67
of 1 w 69
χρόνου 1 w 75
should 1 w 81
it 1 w 83
be 1 w 85
written 1 w 92
χρόνῳ 1 w 97
taking 1 w 104
the 2 w 107
dative 1 w 113
case 1 w 117
instead 2 w 124
of 2 w 126
the 3 w 129
genitive 1 w 137
so 1 w 140
that 1 w 144
the 4 w 147
stars 1 w 152
will 1 w 156
not 1 w 159
be 2 w 161
said 1 w 165
to 4 w 167
be 3 w 169
instruments 1 w 180
but 1 w 184
the 5 w 187
bodies 1 w 193
of 3 w 195
animals 1 w 202
So 1 w 204
Aristotle 1 w 213
has 1 w 216
defined 1 w 223
the 6 w 226
soul 1 w 230
to 6 w 232
be 4 w 234
the 7 w 237
actual 1 w 243
being 1 w 248
of 4 w 250
a 17 w 251
natural 1 w 258
organic 1 w 265
body 1 w 269
having 1 w 276
the 8 w 279
power 1 w 284
of 5 w 286
life 1 w 290
See 1 w 294
Aristotle 2 w 303
on 3 w 305
the 9 w 308
Soul 1 w 312
II 1 w 315
1 1 w 317
with 1 w 322
Trendelenburg 1 w 335
s 21 w 337
note 1 w 341
G 2 w 344
The 1 w 349
sense 1 w 354
then 1 w 358
must 1 w 362
be 6 w 364
this 2 w 368
that 2 w 373
souls 1 w 378
are 1 w 381
dispersed 1 w 390
into 1 w 394
meet 1 w 398
organical 1 w 407
bodies 2 w 413
in 11 w 415
time 1 w 419
But 1 w 423
this 3 w 427
is 8 w 429
far 1 w 432
besides 1 w 439
his 4 w 442
opinion 2 w 449
For 1 w 453
it 5 w 455
is 10 w 457
not 3 w 460
once 1 w 464
but 2 w 468
several 1 w 475
times 1 w 480
that 3 w 485
he 13 w 487
calls 1 w 492
the 11 w 495
stars 2 w 500
instruments 2 w 511
of 6 w 513
time 3 w 517
as 3 w 520
when 1 w 524
he 16 w 526
says 1 w 530
the 12 w 534
sun 1 w 537
was 1 w 540
made 1 w 544
as 5 w 547
well 1 w 551
as 6 w 553
other 1 w 558
planets 1 w 565
for 1 w 569
the 14 w 572
distinction 1 w 583
and 2 w 586
conservation 1 w 598
of 7 w 600
the 15 w 603
numbers 1 w 610
of 8 w 612
time 4 w 616