Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (1.3-1.4)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:1.3-1.4
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.3', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 1 Section 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.4', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 1 Section 4'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Furthermore, if men can comprehend and know nothing, God did justly interdict Socrates the procreation of false and unstable discourses, which are like wind-eggs, and bid him convince others who were of any other opinion. And reasoning, which rids us of the greatest of evils, error and vanity of mind, is none of the least benefit to us; For God has not granted this to the Esculapians. [*] Nor did Socrates give physic to the body; indeed he purged the mind of secret corruption. But if there be any knowledge of the truth, and if the truth be one, he has as much that learns it of him that invented it, as the inventor himself. Now he the most easily attains the truth, that is persuaded he has it not; and he chooses best, just as he that has no children of his own adopts the best.

Mark this well, that poetry, mathematics, oratory, and sophistry, which are the things the Deity forbade Socrates to generate, are of no value; and that of the sole wisdom about what is divine and intelligible (which Socrates called amiable and eligible for itself), there is neither generation nor invention by man, but reminiscence. Wherefore Socrates taught nothing, but suggesting principles of doubt, as birth-pains, to young men, he excited and at the same time confirmed the innate notions. This he called his Art of Midwifery, which did not (as others professed) extrinsically confer intelligence upon his auditors; but demonstrated it to be innate, yet imperfect and confused, and in want of a nurse to feed and strengthen it.

Furthermore 1 w 11
if 1 w 14
men 1 w 17
can 1 w 20
comprehend 1 w 30
and 1 w 33
know 1 w 37
nothing 1 w 44
God 1 w 48
did 1 w 51
justly 1 w 57
interdict 1 w 66
Socrates 1 w 74
the 2 w 77
procreation 1 w 88
of 1 w 90
false 1 w 95
and 2 w 98
unstable 1 w 106
discourses 1 w 116
which 1 w 122
are 1 w 125
like 1 w 129
wind-eggs 1 w 138
and 3 w 142
bid 1 w 145
him 1 w 148
convince 1 w 156
others 1 w 162
who 1 w 165
were 1 w 169
of 2 w 171
any 1 w 174
other 2 w 179
opinion 1 w 186
And 1 w 190
reasoning 1 w 199
which 2 w 205
rids 1 w 209
us 2 w 211
of 3 w 213
the 5 w 216
greatest 1 w 224
of 4 w 226
evils 1 w 231
error 1 w 237
and 4 w 240
vanity 1 w 246
of 5 w 248
mind 1 w 252
is 2 w 255
none 1 w 259
of 6 w 261
the 6 w 264
least 1 w 269
benefit 1 w 276
to 1 w 278
us 3 w 280
For 1 w 284
God 2 w 287
has 1 w 290
not 2 w 293
granted 1 w 300
this 1 w 304
to 2 w 306
the 7 w 309
Esculapians 1 w 320
Theognis 1 w 329
vs 1 w 332
482 1 w 336
Nor 1 w 340
did 2 w 343
Socrates 2 w 351
give 1 w 355
physic 1 w 361
to 3 w 363
the 8 w 366
body 1 w 370
indeed 1 w 377
he 11 w 379
purged 1 w 385
the 9 w 388
mind 2 w 392
of 7 w 394
secret 1 w 400
corruption 1 w 410
But 1 w 414
if 2 w 416
there 1 w 421
be 2 w 423
any 2 w 426
knowledge 1 w 435
of 8 w 437
the 11 w 440
truth 1 w 445
and 5 w 449
if 3 w 451
the 12 w 454
truth 2 w 459
be 3 w 461
one 2 w 464
he 16 w 467
has 2 w 470
as 5 w 472
much 1 w 476
that 1 w 480
learns 1 w 486
it 3 w 488
of 9 w 490
him 2 w 493
that 2 w 497
invented 1 w 505
it 4 w 507
as 6 w 510
the 13 w 513
inventor 1 w 521
himself 1 w 528
Now 1 w 532
he 18 w 534
the 14 w 537
most 1 w 541
easily 1 w 547
attains 1 w 554
the 15 w 557
truth 3 w 562
that 3 w 567
is 5 w 569
persuaded 1 w 578
he 21 w 580
has 3 w 583
it 5 w 585
not 3 w 588
and 6 w 592
he 22 w 594
chooses 1 w 601
best 1 w 605
just 2 w 610
as 9 w 612
he 23 w 614
that 4 w 618
has 4 w 621
no 7 w 623
children 1 w 631
of 10 w 633
his 2 w 636
own 1 w 639
adopts 1 w 645
the 16 w 648
best 2 w 652
Mark 1 w 657
this 2 w 661
well 1 w 665
that 5 w 670
poetry 1 w 676
mathematics 1 w 688
oratory 1 w 696
and 7 w 700
sophistry 1 w 709
which 3 w 715
are 2 w 718
the 18 w 721
things 1 w 727
the 19 w 730
Deity 1 w 735
forbade 1 w 742
Socrates 3 w 750
to 6 w 752
generate 1 w 760
are 3 w 764
of 11 w 766
no 8 w 768
value 1 w 773
and 8 w 777
that 6 w 781
of 12 w 783
the 20 w 786
sole 1 w 790
wisdom 1 w 796
about 1 w 801
what 1 w 805
is 10 w 807
divine 1 w 813
and 9 w 816
intelligible 1 w 828
which 4 w 834
Socrates 4 w 842
called 1 w 848
amiable 1 w 855
and 10 w 858
eligible 1 w 866
for 2 w 869
itself 1 w 875
there 2 w 882
is 11 w 884
neither 1 w 891
generation 1 w 901
nor 1 w 904
invention 1 w 913
by 1 w 915
man 1 w 918
but 1 w 922
reminiscence 1 w 934
Wherefore 1 w 944
Socrates 5 w 952
taught 1 w 958
nothing 2 w 965
but 2 w 969
suggesting 1 w 979
principles 1 w 989
of 13 w 991
doubt 1 w 996
as 11 w 999
birth-pains 1 w 1010
to 7 w 1013
young 1 w 1018
men 2 w 1021
he 32 w 1024
excited 1 w 1031
and 11 w 1034
at 21 w 1036
the 23 w 1039
same 1 w 1043
time 1 w 1047
confirmed 1 w 1056
the 24 w 1059
innate 1 w 1065
notions 1 w 1072
This 1 w 1077
he 35 w 1079
called 2 w 1085
his 6 w 1088
Art 1 w 1091
of 14 w 1093
Midwifery 1 w 1102
which 5 w 1108
did 3 w 1111
not 6 w 1114
as 12 w 1117
others 2 w 1123
professed 1 w 1132
extrinsically 1 w 1146
confer 1 w 1152
intelligence 1 w 1164
upon 1 w 1168
his 7 w 1171
auditors 1 w 1179
but 3 w 1183
demonstrated 1 w 1195
it 11 w 1197
to 9 w 1199
be 6 w 1201
innate 2 w 1207
yet 1 w 1211
imperfect 1 w 1220
and 12 w 1223
confused 1 w 1231
and 13 w 1235
in 26 w 1237
want 1 w 1241
of 16 w 1243
a 81 w 1244
nurse 1 w 1249
to 10 w 1251
feed 1 w 1255
and 14 w 1258
strengthen 1 w 1268
it 12 w 1270