Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (1.1)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:1.1
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.1', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 1 Section 1'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

WHAT IS THE REASON THAT GOD BADE SOCRATES TO ACT THE MIDWIFES PART TO OTHERS, BUT CHARGED HIMSELF NOT TO GENERATE; AS HE SAYS IN THEAETETUS?[*]

FOR he would never have used the name of God in such a merry, jesting manner, though Plato in that book makes Socrates several times to talk with great boasting and arrogance, as he does now. There are many, dear friend, so affected towards me, that they are ready even to bite me, when I offer to cure them of the least madness. For they will not be persuaded that I do it out of goodwill, because they are ignorant that no God bears ill-will to man, and that therefore I wish ill to no man; but I cannot allow myself either to stand in a lie or to stifle the truth. [*] Whether therefore did he style his own nature, which was of a very strong and pregnant wit, by the name of God,—as Menander says, For our mind is God, and as Heraclitus, Mans genius is a Deity? Or did some divine cause or some Daemon or other impart this way of philosophizing to Socrates, whereby always interrogating others, he cleared them of pride, error, and ignorance, and of being troublesome both to themselves and to others? For about that time there happened to be in Greece several sophisters; to these some young men paid great sums of money, for which they purchased a strong

opinion of learning and wisdom, and of being stout disputants; but this sort of disputation spent much time in trifling squabblings, which were of no credit or profit. Now Socrates, using an argumentative discourse by way of a purgative remedy, procured belief and authority to what he said, because in refuting others he himself affirmed nothing; and he the sooner gained upon people, because he seemed rather to be inquisitive after the truth as well as they, than to maintain his own opinion.

Tokens

WHAT 1 w 4
IS 1 w 6
THE 1 w 9
REASON 1 w 15
THAT 1 w 19
GOD 1 w 22
BADE 1 w 26
SOCRATES 1 w 34
TO 1 w 36
ACT 1 w 39
THE 2 w 42
MIDWIFE 1 w 49
S 5 w 51
PART 1 w 55
TO 2 w 57
OTHERS 1 w 63
BUT 1 w 67
CHARGED 1 w 74
HIMSELF 1 w 81
NOT 1 w 84
TO 3 w 86
GENERATE 1 w 94
AS 2 w 97
HE 4 w 99
SAYS 1 w 103
IN 1 w 105
THEAETETUS 1 w 115
See 1 w 119
Plato 1 w 124
Theaet 1 w 131
p 1 w 133
149 1 w 137
B 3 w 138
FOR 1 w 142
he 2 w 144
would 1 w 149
never 1 w 154
have 1 w 158
used 1 w 162
the 1 w 165
name 1 w 169
of 1 w 171
God 1 w 174
in 1 w 176
such 1 w 180
a 5 w 181
merry 1 w 186
jesting 1 w 194
manner 1 w 200
though 1 w 207
Plato 2 w 212
in 3 w 214
that 1 w 218
book 1 w 222
makes 1 w 227
Socrates 1 w 235
several 1 w 242
times 1 w 247
to 3 w 249
talk 1 w 253
with 1 w 257
great 1 w 262
boasting 1 w 270
and 1 w 273
arrogance 1 w 282
as 2 w 285
he 4 w 287
does 1 w 291
now 1 w 294
There 1 w 300
are 1 w 303
many 1 w 307
dear 1 w 312
friend 1 w 318
so 1 w 321
affected 1 w 329
towards 1 w 336
me 4 w 338
that 2 w 343
they 1 w 347
are 2 w 350
ready 1 w 355
even 1 w 359
to 5 w 361
bite 1 w 365
me 5 w 367
when 1 w 372
I 6 w 373
offer 1 w 378
to 6 w 380
cure 1 w 384
them 1 w 388
of 3 w 390
the 4 w 393
least 1 w 398
madness 1 w 405
For 1 w 409
they 2 w 413
will 1 w 417
not 1 w 420
be 1 w 422
persuaded 1 w 431
that 3 w 435
I 7 w 436
do 2 w 438
it 3 w 440
out 1 w 443
of 4 w 445
goodwill 1 w 453
because 1 w 461
they 3 w 465
are 3 w 468
ignorant 1 w 476
that 4 w 480
no 4 w 482
God 2 w 485
bears 1 w 490
ill-will 1 w 498
to 7 w 500
man 3 w 503
and 2 w 507
that 5 w 511
therefore 1 w 520
I 8 w 521
wish 1 w 525
ill 5 w 528
to 8 w 530
no 5 w 532
man 4 w 535
but 1 w 539
I 9 w 540
cannot 1 w 546
allow 1 w 551
myself 1 w 557
either 1 w 563
to 9 w 565
stand 1 w 570
in 5 w 572
a 43 w 573
lie 1 w 576
or 4 w 578
to 10 w 580
stifle 1 w 586
the 9 w 589
truth 1 w 594
Theaet 2 w 601
p 3 w 603
161 1 w 607
C 4 w 608
Whether 1 w 616
therefore 2 w 625
did 1 w 628
he 19 w 630
style 1 w 635
his 1 w 638
own 1 w 641
nature 1 w 647
which 1 w 653
was 1 w 656
of 5 w 658
a 47 w 659
very 1 w 663
strong 1 w 669
and 4 w 672
pregnant 1 w 680
wit 2 w 683
by 1 w 686
the 12 w 689
name 2 w 693
of 6 w 695
God 3 w 698
as 5 w 702
Menander 1 w 710
says 1 w 714
For 2 w 718
our 1 w 721
mind 1 w 725
is 3 w 727
God 4 w 730
and 6 w 734
as 6 w 736
Heraclitus 1 w 746
Man 1 w 750
s 33 w 752
genius 1 w 758
is 4 w 760
a 58 w 761
Deity 1 w 766
Or 1 w 769
did 2 w 772
some 1 w 776
divine 1 w 782
cause 2 w 787
or 7 w 789
some 2 w 793
Daemon 1 w 799
or 8 w 801
other 1 w 806
impart 1 w 812
this 1 w 816
way 1 w 819
of 7 w 821
philosophizing 1 w 835
to 11 w 837
Socrates 2 w 845
whereby 1 w 853
always 1 w 859
interrogating 1 w 872
others 1 w 878
he 24 w 881
cleared 1 w 888
them 2 w 892
of 8 w 894
pride 1 w 899
error 1 w 905
and 7 w 909
ignorance 1 w 918
and 8 w 922
of 9 w 924
being 1 w 929
troublesome 1 w 940
both 1 w 944
to 12 w 946
themselves 1 w 956
and 9 w 959
to 13 w 961
others 2 w 967
For 3 w 971
about 1 w 976
that 6 w 980
time 2 w 984
there 3 w 989
happened 1 w 997
to 14 w 999
be 5 w 1001
in 12 w 1003
Greece 1 w 1009
several 2 w 1016
sophisters 1 w 1026
to 15 w 1029
these 1 w 1034
some 4 w 1038
young 1 w 1043
men 1 w 1046
paid 1 w 1050
great 2 w 1055
sums 1 w 1059
of 10 w 1061
money 1 w 1066
for 3 w 1070
which 2 w 1075
they 4 w 1079
purchased 1 w 1088
a 79 w 1089
strong 2 w 1095
opinion 1 w 1102
of 11 w 1104
learning 1 w 1112
and 10 w 1115
wisdom 1 w 1121
and 11 w 1125
of 12 w 1127
being 2 w 1132
stout 1 w 1137
disputants 1 w 1147
but 2 w 1151
this 2 w 1155
sort 1 w 1159
of 13 w 1161
disputation 1 w 1172
spent 1 w 1177
much 1 w 1181
time 3 w 1185
in 16 w 1187
trifling 1 w 1195
squabblings 1 w 1206
which 3 w 1212
were 1 w 1216
of 14 w 1218
no 8 w 1220
credit 1 w 1226
or 14 w 1228
profit 1 w 1234
Now 1 w 1238
Socrates 3 w 1246
using 1 w 1252
an 23 w 1254
argumentative 1 w 1267
discourse 1 w 1276
by 3 w 1278
way 3 w 1281
of 16 w 1283
a 91 w 1284
purgative 1 w 1293
remedy 1 w 1299
procured 1 w 1308
belief 1 w 1314
and 12 w 1317
authority 1 w 1326
to 17 w 1328
what 1 w 1332
he 31 w 1334
said 1 w 1338
because 2 w 1346
in 20 w 1348
refuting 1 w 1356
others 3 w 1362
he 33 w 1364
himself 1 w 1371
affirmed 1 w 1379
nothing 1 w 1386
and 13 w 1390
he 34 w 1392
the 22 w 1395
sooner 1 w 1401
gained 1 w 1407
upon 1 w 1411
people 1 w 1417
because 3 w 1425
he 36 w 1427
seemed 1 w 1433
rather 1 w 1439
to 18 w 1441
be 10 w 1443
inquisitive 1 w 1454
after 1 w 1459
the 24 w 1462
truth 2 w 1467
as 8 w 1469
well 1 w 1473
as 9 w 1475
they 5 w 1479
than 1 w 1484
to 19 w 1486
maintain 1 w 1494
his 5 w 1497
own 2 w 1500
opinion 2 w 1507