Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the eating of flesh II

On the eating of flesh II (4)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg132.perseus-eng3:4
Refs {'start': {'reference': '4', 'human_reference': 'Section 4'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Who, then, were they who later decreed this?

The first to forge the highways murderous sword,
And first to eat the flesh of ploughing ox.[*]
This is the way, you may be sure, in which tyrants begin their course of bloody slaughters. Just as, for instance, at Athens[*] they put to death initially the worst of the sycophants, and likewise in the second and third instances; but next, having become accustomed to bloodshed they allowed Niceratus,[*] the
son of Nicias, to be killed and the general Theramenes[*] and the philosopher Polemarchus.[*] Just so, at the beginning it was some wild and harmful animal that was eaten, then a bird or fish that had its flesh torn. And so when our murderous instincts had tasted blood and grew practised on wild animals, they advanced to the labouring ox and the well-behaved sheep and the house-warding cock; thus, little by little giving a hard edge to our insatiable appetite, we have advanced to wars and the slaughter and murder of human beings. Yet if someone once demonstrates that souls in their rebirths make use of common bodies and that what is now rational reverts to the irrational, and again what is now wild becomes tame, and that Nature changes everything and assigns new dwellings
Clothing souls with unfamiliar coat of flesh[*];
will not this deter the unruly element in those who have adopted the doctrine from implanting disease and indigestion[*] in our bodies and perverting our souls to an ever more cruel lawlessness, as soon as we are broken of the habit of not entertaining a guest or celebrating a marriage or consorting with our friends without bloodshed and murder?

Tokens

Who 1 w 3
then 1 w 8
were 1 w 13
they 1 w 17
who 1 w 20
later 1 w 25
decreed 1 w 32
this 1 w 36
The 1 w 40
first 1 w 45
to 1 w 47
forge 1 w 52
the 3 w 55
highway 1 w 62
s 3 w 64
murderous 1 w 73
sword 1 w 78
And 1 w 82
first 2 w 87
to 2 w 89
eat 1 w 92
the 4 w 95
flesh 1 w 100
of 1 w 102
ploughing 1 w 111
ox 1 w 113
Aratus 1 w 120
Phaenomena 1 w 131
131 1 w 135
f 6 w 136
cf 1 w 140
Lucilius 1 w 149
parody 1 w 156
in 2 w 158
the 5 w 161
Palatine 1 w 169
Anthology 1 w 178
xi 1 w 181
136 1 w 185
This 1 w 190
is 3 w 192
the 6 w 195
way 2 w 198
you 1 w 202
may 1 w 205
be 1 w 207
sure 1 w 211
in 4 w 214
which 1 w 219
tyrants 1 w 226
begin 1 w 231
their 1 w 236
course 1 w 242
of 2 w 244
bloody 1 w 250
slaughters 1 w 260
Just 1 w 265
as 1 w 267
for 2 w 271
instance 1 w 279
at 5 w 282
Athens 1 w 288
Cf 1 w 290
959 1 w 294
d 8 w 295
supra 1 w 300
and 1 w 303
the 9 w 306
note 1 w 310
they 2 w 315
put 1 w 318
to 3 w 320
death 1 w 325
initially 1 w 334
the 11 w 337
worst 1 w 342
of 3 w 344
the 12 w 347
sycophants 1 w 357
and 2 w 361
likewise 1 w 369
in 8 w 371
the 13 w 374
second 1 w 380
and 3 w 383
third 1 w 388
instances 1 w 397
but 1 w 401
next 1 w 405
having 1 w 412
become 1 w 418
accustomed 1 w 428
to 5 w 430
bloodshed 1 w 439
they 3 w 443
allowed 1 w 450
Niceratus 1 w 459
Cf 2 w 462
Xenophon 1 w 471
Hellenica 1 w 481
ii 1 w 484
3 3 w 486
39 1 w 489
the 15 w 493
son 1 w 496
of 4 w 498
Nicias 1 w 504
to 6 w 507
be 4 w 509
killed 1 w 515
and 4 w 518
the 16 w 521
general 1 w 528
Theramenes 1 w 538
Cf 3 w 540
Xenophon 2 w 549
Hellenica 2 w 559
ii 2 w 562
3 5 w 564
56 1 w 567
and 5 w 571
the 17 w 574
philosopher 1 w 585
Polemarchus 1 w 596
The 3 w 600
son 2 w 603
of 5 w 605
Cephalus 1 w 613
and 6 w 616
brother 1 w 623
of 6 w 625
Lysias 1 w 631
a 40 w 633
prominent 1 w 642
character 1 w 651
in 12 w 653
Plato 1 w 658
Republic 1 w 667
i 42 w 669
For 1 w 673
the 19 w 676
circumstances 1 w 689
of 7 w 691
his 3 w 694
death 2 w 699
see 1 w 702
Lysias 2 w 708
oration 1 w 716
Against 1 w 723
Eratosthenes 1 w 735
It 1 w 738
is 6 w 740
however 1 w 748
somewhat 1 w 757
unlikely 1 w 765
that 1 w 769
Plutarch 1 w 777
should 1 w 783
call 1 w 787
Polemarchus 2 w 798
the 21 w 801
philosopher 2 w 812
even 1 w 816
though 1 w 822
he 28 w 824
appeared 1 w 832
in 14 w 834
the 22 w 837
Republic 2 w 845
and 7 w 848
his 4 w 851
philosophic 1 w 862
bent 1 w 866
was 1 w 869
mentioned 1 w 878
in 15 w 880
the 23 w 883
Phaedrus 1 w 891
257 1 w 895
b 12 w 896
so 7 w 900
that 2 w 904
once 1 w 909
again 1 w 914
we 4 w 917
may 2 w 920
be 6 w 922
faced 1 w 927
with 1 w 931
interpolation 1 w 944
Just 2 w 949
so 8 w 951
at 16 w 954
the 24 w 957
beginning 1 w 966
it 3 w 968
was 2 w 971
some 2 w 975
wild 1 w 979
and 8 w 982
harmful 1 w 989
animal 1 w 995
that 3 w 999
was 3 w 1002
eaten 1 w 1007
then 4 w 1012
a 75 w 1013
bird 1 w 1017
or 7 w 1019
fish 1 w 1023
that 4 w 1027
had 1 w 1030
its 1 w 1033
flesh 2 w 1038
torn 1 w 1042
And 2 w 1046
so 10 w 1048
when 1 w 1052
our 2 w 1055
murderous 2 w 1064
instincts 1 w 1073
had 2 w 1076
tasted 1 w 1082
blood 3 w 1087
and 9 w 1090
grew 1 w 1094
practised 1 w 1103
on 10 w 1105
wild 2 w 1109
animals 1 w 1116
they 4 w 1121
advanced 1 w 1129
to 10 w 1131
the 27 w 1134
labouring 1 w 1143
ox 2 w 1145
and 10 w 1148
the 28 w 1151
well-behaved 1 w 1163
sheep 1 w 1168
and 11 w 1171
the 29 w 1174
house-warding 1 w 1187
cock 1 w 1191
thus 1 w 1196
little 1 w 1203
by 1 w 1205
little 2 w 1211
giving 1 w 1217
a 91 w 1218
hard 1 w 1222
edge 1 w 1226
to 11 w 1228
our 4 w 1231
insatiable 1 w 1241
appetite 1 w 1249
we 6 w 1252
have 2 w 1256
advanced 2 w 1264
to 12 w 1266
wars 1 w 1270
and 12 w 1273
the 30 w 1276
slaughter 2 w 1285
and 13 w 1288
murder 3 w 1294
of 8 w 1296
human 1 w 1301
beings 1 w 1307
Yet 1 w 1311
if 1 w 1313
someone 1 w 1320
once 2 w 1324
demonstrates 1 w 1336
that 5 w 1340
souls 1 w 1345
in 27 w 1347
their 2 w 1352
rebirths 1 w 1360
make 1 w 1364
use 2 w 1367
of 9 w 1369
common 1 w 1375
bodies 1 w 1381
and 14 w 1384
that 6 w 1388
what 2 w 1392
is 10 w 1394
now 1 w 1397
rational 1 w 1405
reverts 1 w 1412
to 13 w 1414
the 32 w 1417
irrational 1 w 1427
and 15 w 1431
again 2 w 1436
what 3 w 1440
is 11 w 1442
now 2 w 1445
wild 3 w 1449
becomes 1 w 1456
tame 1 w 1460
and 16 w 1464
that 7 w 1468
Nature 1 w 1474
changes 1 w 1481
everything 1 w 1491
and 17 w 1494
assigns 1 w 1501
new 1 w 1504
dwellings 1 w 1513
Clothing 1 w 1521
souls 2 w 1526
with 2 w 1530
unfamiliar 1 w 1540
coat 1 w 1544
of 10 w 1546
flesh 3 w 1551
Diels-Kranz 1 w 1562
Frag 1 w 1567
der 4 w 1571
Vorsok 1 w 1577
i 105 w 1579
p 25 w 1581
362 1 w 1585
Empedocles 1 w 1596
frag 1 w 1601
126 1 w 1605
will 1 w 1611
not 2 w 1614
this 2 w 1618
deter 1 w 1623
the 33 w 1626
unruly 1 w 1632
element 1 w 1639
in 32 w 1641
those 1 w 1646
who 2 w 1649
have 3 w 1653
adopted 1 w 1660
the 34 w 1663
doctrine 1 w 1671
from 1 w 1675
implanting 1 w 1685
disease 1 w 1692
and 18 w 1695
indigestion 1 w 1706
Cf 4 w 1708
Mor 1 w 1712
128 1 w 1716
b-e 1 w 1719
in 36 w 1722
our 5 w 1725
bodies 2 w 1731
and 19 w 1734
perverting 1 w 1744
our 6 w 1747
souls 3 w 1752
to 14 w 1754
an 33 w 1756
ever 4 w 1760
more 1 w 1764
cruel 1 w 1769
lawlessness 1 w 1780
as 11 w 1783
soon 1 w 1787
as 12 w 1789
we 8 w 1791
are 2 w 1794
broken 1 w 1800
of 11 w 1802
the 35 w 1805
habit 1 w 1810
of 12 w 1812
not 3 w 1815
entertaining 1 w 1827
a 144 w 1828
guest 1 w 1833
or 12 w 1835
celebrating 1 w 1846
a 146 w 1847
marriage 1 w 1855
or 13 w 1857
consorting 1 w 1867
with 3 w 1871
our 7 w 1874
friends 1 w 1881
without 1 w 1888
bloodshed 2 w 1897
and 20 w 1900
murder 4 w 1906