Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Beasts are rational

Beasts are rational (8)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg130.perseus-eng3:8
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8', 'human_reference': 'Section 8'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

GRYLLUS. Though men are so vile and incontinent where the desires I have spoken of are concerned, they can be proved to be even more so in the case of essential desires, being here far inferior to animals in temperance.[*] These are the desires for food and drink, in which we beasts always take our pleasure along with some sort of utility; whereas you, in your pursuit of pleasure rather than natural nourishment, are punished by many serious ailments which, welling up from one single source, the surfeit of your bodies, fill you with all manner of flatulence that is difficult to purge.[*] In the first place each species of animal has one single food proper to it, grass or some root or fruit. Those that are carnivorous resort to no other kind of nourishment, nor do they deprive those weaker than themselves of sustenance; but the lion lets the deer, and the wolf lets the sheep, feed in its natural pasture. But man in his pleasures is led
astray by gluttony to everything edible[*]; he tries and tastes everything as if he had not yet come to recognize what is suitable and proper for him; alone of all creatures he is omnivorous.[*]

In the first place his eating of flesh is caused by no lack of means or methods,[*] for he can always in season harvest and garner and gather in such a succession of plants and grains as will all but tire him out with their abundance; but driven on by luxurious desires and satiety with merely essential nourishment, he pursues illicit food, made unclean by the slaughter of beasts; and he does this in a much more cruel way than the most savage beasts of prey. Blood and gore and raw flesh are the proper diet of kite and wolf and snake; to man they are an appetizer.[*] Then, too, man makes use of every kind of food and does not, like beasts, abstain from most kinds and consequently make war on a few only that he must have for food. In a word, nothing that flies or swims or moves on land has escaped your so-called civilized and hospitable tables.

Tokens

GRYLLUS 1 w 7
Though 1 w 14
men 1 w 17
are 1 w 20
so 1 w 22
vile 1 w 26
and 1 w 29
incontinent 1 w 40
where 1 w 45
the 1 w 48
desires 1 w 55
I 1 w 56
have 1 w 60
spoken 1 w 66
of 1 w 68
are 2 w 71
concerned 1 w 80
they 1 w 85
can 1 w 88
be 1 w 90
proved 1 w 96
to 1 w 98
be 2 w 100
even 1 w 104
more 1 w 108
so 2 w 110
in 3 w 112
the 3 w 115
case 1 w 119
of 2 w 121
essential 1 w 130
desires 2 w 137
being 1 w 143
here 2 w 147
far 1 w 150
inferior 1 w 158
to 2 w 160
animals 1 w 167
in 6 w 169
temperance 1 w 179
Cf 1 w 182
Philo 1 w 188
47 1 w 191
p 4 w 193
122 1 w 197
These 1 w 204
are 3 w 207
the 4 w 210
desires 3 w 217
for 1 w 220
food 1 w 224
and 2 w 227
drink 1 w 232
in 8 w 235
which 1 w 240
we 1 w 242
beasts 1 w 248
always 1 w 254
take 1 w 258
our 1 w 261
pleasure 1 w 269
along 1 w 274
with 1 w 278
some 1 w 282
sort 1 w 286
of 3 w 288
utility 1 w 295
whereas 1 w 303
you 1 w 306
in 9 w 309
your 1 w 313
pursuit 1 w 320
of 4 w 322
pleasure 2 w 330
rather 1 w 336
than 1 w 340
natural 1 w 347
nourishment 1 w 358
are 4 w 362
punished 1 w 370
by 1 w 372
many 1 w 376
serious 1 w 383
ailments 1 w 391
which 2 w 396
welling 1 w 404
up 1 w 406
from 1 w 410
one 1 w 413
single 1 w 419
source 1 w 425
the 6 w 429
surfeit 1 w 436
of 5 w 438
your 2 w 442
bodies 1 w 448
fill 1 w 453
you 4 w 456
with 2 w 460
all 1 w 463
manner 1 w 469
of 6 w 471
flatulence 1 w 481
that 1 w 485
is 3 w 487
difficult 1 w 496
to 3 w 498
purge 1 w 503
Cf 2 w 506
Mor 1 w 510
131 1 w 514
f 19 w 515
In 1 w 518
the 7 w 521
first 1 w 526
place 1 w 531
each 1 w 535
species 1 w 542
of 7 w 544
animal 2 w 550
has 1 w 553
one 2 w 556
single 2 w 562
food 2 w 566
proper 1 w 572
to 4 w 574
it 6 w 576
grass 1 w 582
or 6 w 584
some 2 w 588
root 1 w 592
or 7 w 594
fruit 1 w 599
Those 1 w 605
that 2 w 609
are 5 w 612
carnivorous 1 w 623
resort 1 w 629
to 5 w 631
no 2 w 633
other 1 w 638
kind 1 w 642
of 8 w 644
nourishment 2 w 655
nor 1 w 659
do 1 w 661
they 2 w 665
deprive 1 w 672
those 1 w 677
weaker 1 w 683
than 2 w 687
themselves 1 w 697
of 9 w 699
sustenance 1 w 709
but 1 w 713
the 11 w 716
lion 1 w 720
lets 1 w 724
the 12 w 727
deer 1 w 731
and 3 w 735
the 13 w 738
wolf 1 w 742
lets 2 w 746
the 14 w 749
sheep 1 w 754
feed 1 w 759
in 14 w 761
its 1 w 764
natural 2 w 771
pasture 1 w 778
But 1 w 782
man 3 w 785
in 15 w 787
his 1 w 790
pleasures 1 w 799
is 6 w 801
led 1 w 804
astray 1 w 810
by 2 w 812
gluttony 1 w 820
to 7 w 822
everything 1 w 832
edible 1 w 838
Cf 3 w 840
964 1 w 844
f 29 w 845
supra 1 w 850
and 4 w 854
with 3 w 858
the 15 w 861
whole 1 w 866
passage 1 w 873
cf 1 w 875
the 16 w 879
impressive 1 w 889
proem 1 w 894
to 8 w 896
the 17 w 899
seventh 1 w 906
book 1 w 910
of 10 w 912
Pliny 1 w 917
s 67 w 919
Natural 1 w 926
History 1 w 933
he 24 w 937
tries 1 w 942
and 5 w 945
tastes 1 w 951
everything 2 w 961
as 13 w 963
if 2 w 965
he 25 w 967
had 1 w 970
not 1 w 973
yet 1 w 976
come 1 w 980
to 10 w 982
recognize 1 w 991
what 1 w 995
is 8 w 997
suitable 1 w 1005
and 6 w 1008
proper 2 w 1014
for 2 w 1017
him 1 w 1020
alone 1 w 1026
of 11 w 1028
all 2 w 1031
creatures 1 w 1040
he 26 w 1042
is 9 w 1044
omnivorous 1 w 1054
Man 1 w 1058
is 10 w 1060
the 18 w 1063
only 1 w 1067
animal 3 w 1073
liable 1 w 1079
to 11 w 1081
the 19 w 1084
disease 1 w 1091
of 12 w 1093
a 74 w 1094
continuously 1 w 1106
insatiable 1 w 1116
appetite 1 w 1124
Pliny 2 w 1130
Nat 2 w 1134
Hist 2 w 1139
xi 1 w 1142
283 1 w 1146
cf 2 w 1149
Philo 2 w 1155
62 1 w 1158
p 27 w 1160
136 1 w 1164
Lucan 1 w 1171
iv 5 w 1174
373-381 1 w 1182
al 13 w 1185
In 2 w 1188
the 20 w 1191
first 2 w 1196
place 2 w 1201
his 2 w 1204
eating 1 w 1210
of 13 w 1212
flesh 1 w 1217
is 14 w 1219
caused 1 w 1225
by 3 w 1227
no 6 w 1229
lack 1 w 1233
of 14 w 1235
means 1 w 1240
or 14 w 1242
methods 1 w 1249
Cf 4 w 1252
993 1 w 1256
d 29 w 1257
infra 1 w 1262
for 3 w 1266
he 30 w 1268
can 3 w 1271
always 2 w 1277
in 24 w 1279
season 1 w 1285
harvest 1 w 1292
and 7 w 1295
garner 1 w 1301
and 8 w 1304
gather 1 w 1310
in 25 w 1312
such 1 w 1316
a 96 w 1317
succession 1 w 1327
of 15 w 1329
plants 1 w 1335
and 9 w 1338
grains 1 w 1344
as 16 w 1346
will 1 w 1350
all 3 w 1353
but 2 w 1356
tire 1 w 1360
him 2 w 1363
out 1 w 1366
with 4 w 1370
their 1 w 1375
abundance 1 w 1384
but 3 w 1388
driven 1 w 1394
on 13 w 1396
by 4 w 1398
luxurious 1 w 1407
desires 4 w 1414
and 10 w 1417
satiety 1 w 1424
with 5 w 1428
merely 1 w 1434
essential 2 w 1443
nourishment 3 w 1454
he 33 w 1457
pursues 1 w 1464
illicit 1 w 1471
food 3 w 1475
made 1 w 1480
unclean 1 w 1487
by 5 w 1489
the 23 w 1492
slaughter 1 w 1501
of 16 w 1503
beasts 2 w 1509
and 11 w 1513
he 35 w 1515
does 1 w 1519
this 1 w 1523
in 27 w 1525
a 112 w 1526
much 1 w 1530
more 2 w 1534
cruel 1 w 1539
way 3 w 1542
than 3 w 1546
the 24 w 1549
most 1 w 1553
savage 1 w 1559
beasts 3 w 1565
of 17 w 1567
prey 1 w 1571
Blood 1 w 1577
and 12 w 1580
gore 1 w 1584
and 13 w 1587
raw 1 w 1590
flesh 2 w 1595
are 6 w 1598
the 25 w 1601
proper 3 w 1607
diet 1 w 1611
of 18 w 1613
kite 1 w 1617
and 14 w 1620
wolf 2 w 1624
and 15 w 1627
snake 1 w 1632
to 12 w 1635
man 4 w 1638
they 3 w 1642
are 7 w 1645
an 36 w 1647
appetizer 1 w 1656
Cf 5 w 1659
993 2 w 1663
d 47 w 1664
995 1 w 1668
c 36 w 1669
infra 2 w 1674
Then 1 w 1679
too 1 w 1683
man 5 w 1687
makes 1 w 1692
use 2 w 1695
of 19 w 1697
every 3 w 1702
kind 2 w 1706
of 20 w 1708
food 4 w 1712
and 16 w 1715
does 2 w 1719
not 2 w 1722
like 1 w 1727
beasts 4 w 1733
abstain 1 w 1741
from 2 w 1745
most 2 w 1749
kinds 1 w 1754
and 17 w 1757
consequently 1 w 1769
make 2 w 1773
war 1 w 1776
on 15 w 1778
a 139 w 1779
few 1 w 1782
only 2 w 1786
that 3 w 1790
he 40 w 1792
must 1 w 1796
have 2 w 1800
for 4 w 1803
food 5 w 1807
In 3 w 1810
a 142 w 1811
word 1 w 1815
nothing 1 w 1823
that 4 w 1827
flies 1 w 1832
or 20 w 1834
swims 1 w 1839
or 21 w 1841
moves 1 w 1846
on 17 w 1848
land 1 w 1852
has 2 w 1855
escaped 1 w 1862
your 3 w 1866
so-called 1 w 1875
civilized 1 w 1884
and 19 w 1887
hospitable 1 w 1897
tables 1 w 1903