Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Beasts are rational

Beasts are rational (5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg130.perseus-eng3:5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

ODYSSEUS. Bless me, Gryllus, you must once have been a very clever sophist,[*] one may judge, since even as things are, and speaking from your swinishness, you can attack the subject with such fervent ardour. But why have you failed to discuss temperance, the next in order?

GRYLLUS. Because I thought that you would first wish to take exception to what I have said. But you are eager to hear about temperance since you are the husband of a model of chastity and believe that you yourself have given a proof of self-control by rejecting the embraces of Circe. And in this you are no more continent than any of the beasts; for neither do they desire to consort with their betters, but pursue both pleasure and love with mates of like species. So it is no wonder that, like the Mendesian[*] goat in Egypt which, when shut up with many beautiful women, is said not to be eager to consort with them, but is far more excited about nannies, you likewise are contented with the kind of love that is familiar to you and, being a mortal, are not eager to sleep with a goddess. As for the chastity of Penelope, the cawing of countless crows will pour laughter and contempt upon it; for every crow, if her mate dies, remains a widow, not merely for a
short time, but for nine generations of men.[*] It follows that your fair Penelope is nine times inferior in chastity to any crow you please.

Tokens

ODYSSEUS 1 w 8
Bless 1 w 14
me 1 w 16
Gryllus 1 w 24
you 1 w 28
must 1 w 32
once 1 w 36
have 1 w 40
been 1 w 44
a 2 w 45
very 1 w 49
clever 1 w 55
sophist 1 w 62
Gryllus 2 w 70
acknowledges 1 w 82
the 1 w 85
truth 1 w 90
of 1 w 92
this 1 w 96
soft 1 w 100
impeachment 1 w 111
later 1 w 116
on 2 w 118
989 1 w 122
b 2 w 123
infra 1 w 129
one 1 w 133
may 1 w 136
judge 1 w 141
since 1 w 147
even 1 w 151
as 1 w 153
things 1 w 159
are 1 w 162
and 1 w 166
speaking 1 w 174
from 1 w 178
your 1 w 182
swinishness 1 w 193
you 3 w 197
can 1 w 200
attack 1 w 206
the 2 w 209
subject 1 w 216
with 1 w 220
such 1 w 224
fervent 1 w 231
ardour 1 w 237
But 1 w 241
why 1 w 244
have 2 w 248
you 4 w 251
failed 1 w 257
to 1 w 259
discuss 1 w 266
temperance 1 w 276
the 3 w 280
next 1 w 284
in 6 w 286
order 1 w 291
GRYLLUS 1 w 299
Because 1 w 307
I 1 w 308
thought 1 w 315
that 1 w 319
you 5 w 322
would 1 w 327
first 1 w 332
wish 1 w 336
to 2 w 338
take 1 w 342
exception 1 w 351
to 3 w 353
what 1 w 357
I 2 w 358
have 3 w 362
said 1 w 366
But 2 w 370
you 6 w 373
are 2 w 376
eager 1 w 381
to 4 w 383
hear 1 w 387
about 1 w 392
temperance 2 w 402
since 2 w 407
you 7 w 410
are 3 w 413
the 4 w 416
husband 1 w 423
of 3 w 425
a 32 w 426
model 1 w 431
of 4 w 433
chastity 1 w 441
and 3 w 444
believe 1 w 451
that 2 w 455
you 8 w 458
yourself 1 w 466
have 4 w 470
given 1 w 475
a 37 w 476
proof 1 w 481
of 6 w 483
self-control 1 w 495
by 1 w 497
rejecting 1 w 506
the 5 w 509
embraces 1 w 517
of 7 w 519
Circe 1 w 524
And 1 w 528
in 9 w 530
this 2 w 534
you 10 w 537
are 4 w 540
no 2 w 542
more 1 w 546
continent 1 w 555
than 1 w 559
any 1 w 562
of 8 w 564
the 6 w 567
beasts 1 w 573
for 1 w 577
neither 1 w 584
do 2 w 586
they 1 w 590
desire 1 w 596
to 5 w 598
consort 1 w 605
with 2 w 609
their 1 w 614
betters 1 w 621
but 1 w 625
pursue 1 w 631
both 1 w 635
pleasure 1 w 643
and 4 w 646
love 1 w 650
with 3 w 654
mates 1 w 659
of 9 w 661
like 1 w 665
species 1 w 672
So 1 w 675
it 6 w 677
is 7 w 679
no 3 w 681
wonder 1 w 687
that 3 w 691
like 2 w 696
the 10 w 699
Mendesian 1 w 708
Cf 1 w 710
Herodotus 1 w 720
ii 1 w 723
46 1 w 726
Strabo 1 w 733
xvii 1 w 737
19 1 w 740
and 5 w 744
contrast 1 w 752
Aelian 1 w 758
De 1 w 761
Natura 1 w 767
Animal 1 w 773
vii 2 w 777
19 2 w 780
goat 1 w 785
in 11 w 787
Egypt 1 w 792
which 1 w 797
when 1 w 802
shut 1 w 806
up 1 w 808
with 4 w 812
many 1 w 816
beautiful 1 w 825
women 1 w 830
is 8 w 833
said 2 w 837
not 1 w 840
to 6 w 842
be 6 w 844
eager 2 w 849
to 7 w 851
consort 2 w 858
with 5 w 862
them 1 w 866
but 2 w 870
is 9 w 872
far 1 w 875
more 2 w 879
excited 1 w 886
about 2 w 891
nannies 1 w 898
you 11 w 902
likewise 1 w 910
are 5 w 913
contented 1 w 922
with 6 w 926
the 12 w 929
kind 1 w 933
of 10 w 935
love 2 w 939
that 4 w 943
is 11 w 945
familiar 1 w 953
to 8 w 955
you 12 w 958
and 6 w 961
being 1 w 967
a 68 w 968
mortal 1 w 974
are 6 w 978
not 2 w 981
eager 3 w 986
to 9 w 988
sleep 1 w 993
with 7 w 997
a 72 w 998
goddess 1 w 1005
As 1 w 1008
for 2 w 1011
the 13 w 1014
chastity 2 w 1022
of 11 w 1024
Penelope 1 w 1032
the 14 w 1036
cawing 1 w 1042
of 12 w 1044
countless 1 w 1053
crows 1 w 1058
will 1 w 1062
pour 1 w 1066
laughter 1 w 1074
and 7 w 1077
contempt 1 w 1085
upon 1 w 1089
it 13 w 1091
for 3 w 1095
every 1 w 1100
crow 2 w 1104
if 2 w 1107
her 2 w 1110
mate 2 w 1114
dies 1 w 1118
remains 1 w 1126
a 79 w 1127
widow 1 w 1132
not 3 w 1136
merely 1 w 1142
for 4 w 1145
a 80 w 1146
short 1 w 1151
time 1 w 1155
but 3 w 1159
for 5 w 1162
nine 1 w 1166
generations 1 w 1177
of 13 w 1179
men 3 w 1182
Cf 2 w 1185
Mor 1 w 1189
415 1 w 1193
c 35 w 1194
and 8 w 1197
the 15 w 1200
note 1 w 1204
there 1 w 1209
It 1 w 1212
follows 1 w 1219
that 5 w 1223
your 3 w 1227
fair 1 w 1231
Penelope 2 w 1239
is 12 w 1241
nine 2 w 1245
times 1 w 1250
inferior 1 w 1258
in 19 w 1260
chastity 3 w 1268
to 10 w 1270
any 3 w 1273
crow 3 w 1277
you 14 w 1280
please 1 w 1286