Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Whether water or fire be most useful.

Whether water or fire be most useful. (8-10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg128.perseus-eng4:8-10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8', 'human_reference': 'Section 8'}, 'end': {'reference': '10', 'human_reference': 'Section 10'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Or can any man speak as follows in defence of the contrary? We say then that God, as a master workman, had before him the four elements, to complete the fabric of the universe; and these again were different one from another. But earth and water were placed at the foundation, like matter, to be formed and fashioned, participating of form and order and of power to procreate and bring forth, so far as they are assisted by air and fire, the great artificers that mould them into various shapes, and lying dead till roused by them to act and generate. Of these two latter, fire is the ruling agent. This is manifest by induction. For earth without warmth and heat is altogether barren and unfruitful; but fire, by virtue of its rousing and inflaming quality, renders it diffusive, and swells it into generation. Nor can any man find out any other cause why rocks and the dry tops of mountains are not productive, but because they participate either nothing at all or very little of fire.

Then generally for water, it is so far from being sufficient of itself for the generation and preservation of other things, that it is itself destroyed for want of fire. But fire is that which upholds every thing in its proper being, and

preserves it in its proper substance, as well water itself as all other things; so that when fire leaves it, water will stink, and it may be said that the want of fire is the death and destruction of water. And thus we find in regard to pools and all manner of standing waters, and such as are settled in pits and holes without issue, what an offensive and dead stench they send forth, and all for want of motion; for this kindles and preserves heat in all things, and more especially in running waters and swift streams, which being thus agitated and enlivened by heat, we commonly say such waters live. Why then should not that be accounted the most useful of the two, that affords to the other the cause of its being, as fire does to water? Moreover, that is the most useful, of which if an animal be wholly deprived, it must perish; for it is evident, that anything without which an animal cannot live affords the reason and cause why it exists. There is moisture also in things after they are dead, nor are they altogether dried up; for otherwise moist bodies would never putrefy; since putrefaction is the alteration of dry into moist, or rather the corruption of moisture in flesh. Neither is death any other than an absolute defect and want of heat, and therefore dead carcasses are the coldest of all; so that if you do but touch them with a razor, they will blunt the edge of it through excess of coldness. Also in living creatures, those parts that least partake of heat are most insensible, as the bones and hair, and those parts which are most distant from the heart. Nay, to some of the most important things the absence of fire and the presence of water are destructive. For plants and fruits are not produced by moisture, but by the warmth of the moisture; and cold waters are most certainly either less productive, or altogether barren. For if water were fruitful in itself, it would always, and that spontaneously too, bear fruit. But the contrary is apparent, and it is rather baneful to generation.

Let us begin anew. As to the use of fire, considered as fire, we have no need of water. Rather the contrary is to be made out; for water extinguishes fire. And as for water, there is no use to be made of it in most things without fire. For water heated becomes more usefill, whereas otherwise it is prejudicial. So that, of the two, that is to be accounted best which is profitable of itself without the assistance of another. Besides, water is beneficial only to the feeling, when you either wash with it or touch it; but fire is profitable to all the senses, being not only felt, but also seen at a distance; so that you may add this to the rest of the virtues of it, that its uses are manifold.

Tokens

Or 1 w 2
can 1 w 5
any 1 w 8
man 1 w 11
speak 1 w 16
as 1 w 18
follows 1 w 25
in 1 w 27
defence 1 w 34
of 1 w 36
the 1 w 39
contrary 1 w 47
We 1 w 50
say 1 w 53
then 1 w 57
that 1 w 61
God 1 w 64
as 2 w 67
a 10 w 68
master 1 w 74
workman 1 w 81
had 1 w 85
before 1 w 91
him 1 w 94
the 3 w 97
four 1 w 101
elements 1 w 109
to 1 w 112
complete 1 w 120
the 4 w 123
fabric 1 w 129
of 2 w 131
the 5 w 134
universe 1 w 142
and 1 w 146
these 1 w 151
again 1 w 156
were 1 w 160
different 1 w 169
one 1 w 172
from 1 w 176
another 1 w 183
But 1 w 187
earth 1 w 192
and 2 w 195
water 1 w 200
were 2 w 204
placed 1 w 210
at 3 w 212
the 8 w 215
foundation 1 w 225
like 1 w 230
matter 1 w 236
to 2 w 239
be 2 w 241
formed 1 w 247
and 3 w 250
fashioned 1 w 259
participating 1 w 273
of 3 w 275
form 2 w 279
and 4 w 282
order 1 w 287
and 5 w 290
of 4 w 292
power 1 w 297
to 3 w 299
procreate 1 w 308
and 6 w 311
bring 1 w 316
forth 1 w 321
so 1 w 324
far 1 w 327
as 5 w 329
they 1 w 333
are 1 w 336
assisted 1 w 344
by 1 w 346
air 1 w 349
and 7 w 352
fire 1 w 356
the 10 w 361
great 1 w 366
artificers 1 w 376
that 2 w 380
mould 1 w 385
them 1 w 389
into 1 w 393
various 1 w 400
shapes 1 w 406
and 8 w 411
lying 1 w 416
dead 1 w 420
till 1 w 424
roused 1 w 430
by 2 w 432
them 2 w 436
to 5 w 438
act 1 w 441
and 9 w 444
generate 1 w 452
Of 1 w 455
these 2 w 460
two 1 w 463
latter 1 w 469
fire 2 w 474
is 2 w 476
the 14 w 479
ruling 1 w 485
agent 1 w 490
This 1 w 495
is 4 w 497
manifest 1 w 505
by 3 w 507
induction 1 w 516
For 1 w 520
earth 2 w 525
without 1 w 532
warmth 1 w 538
and 10 w 541
heat 1 w 545
is 5 w 547
altogether 1 w 557
barren 1 w 563
and 11 w 566
unfruitful 1 w 576
but 1 w 580
fire 3 w 584
by 4 w 587
virtue 1 w 593
of 5 w 595
its 1 w 598
rousing 1 w 605
and 12 w 608
inflaming 1 w 617
quality 1 w 624
renders 1 w 632
it 5 w 634
diffusive 1 w 643
and 13 w 647
swells 1 w 653
it 6 w 655
into 2 w 659
generation 1 w 669
Nor 1 w 673
can 2 w 676
any 2 w 679
man 4 w 682
find 1 w 686
out 2 w 689
any 3 w 692
other 2 w 697
cause 1 w 702
why 1 w 705
rocks 1 w 710
and 14 w 713
the 17 w 716
dry 1 w 719
tops 1 w 723
of 6 w 725
mountains 1 w 734
are 2 w 737
not 2 w 740
productive 1 w 750
but 2 w 754
because 1 w 761
they 2 w 765
participate 1 w 776
either 1 w 782
nothing 1 w 789
at 15 w 791
all 1 w 794
or 9 w 796
very 1 w 800
little 1 w 806
of 7 w 808
fire 4 w 812
Then 1 w 817
generally 1 w 826
for 5 w 829
water 2 w 834
it 9 w 837
is 6 w 839
so 2 w 841
far 2 w 844
from 2 w 848
being 1 w 853
sufficient 1 w 863
of 8 w 865
itself 1 w 871
for 6 w 874
the 20 w 877
generation 2 w 887
and 15 w 890
preservation 1 w 902
of 9 w 904
other 3 w 909
things 1 w 915
that 3 w 920
it 11 w 922
is 7 w 924
itself 2 w 930
destroyed 1 w 939
for 7 w 942
want 1 w 946
of 10 w 948
fire 5 w 952
But 2 w 956
fire 6 w 960
is 8 w 962
that 4 w 966
which 1 w 971
upholds 1 w 978
every 1 w 983
thing 3 w 988
in 19 w 990
its 4 w 993
proper 1 w 999
being 2 w 1004
and 16 w 1008
preserves 1 w 1017
it 14 w 1019
in 21 w 1021
its 5 w 1024
proper 2 w 1030
substance 1 w 1039
as 7 w 1042
well 2 w 1046
water 3 w 1051
itself 3 w 1057
as 8 w 1059
all 3 w 1062
other 4 w 1067
things 2 w 1073
so 3 w 1076
that 5 w 1080
when 1 w 1084
fire 7 w 1088
leaves 1 w 1094
it 17 w 1096
water 4 w 1102
will 1 w 1106
stink 1 w 1111
and 17 w 1115
it 18 w 1117
may 1 w 1120
be 6 w 1122
said 1 w 1126
that 6 w 1130
the 23 w 1133
want 2 w 1137
of 11 w 1139
fire 8 w 1143
is 9 w 1145
the 24 w 1148
death 1 w 1153
and 18 w 1156
destruction 1 w 1167
of 12 w 1169
water 5 w 1174
And 1 w 1178
thus 1 w 1182
we 6 w 1184
find 2 w 1188
in 25 w 1190
regard 1 w 1196
to 9 w 1198
pools 1 w 1203
and 19 w 1206
all 4 w 1209
manner 1 w 1215
of 13 w 1217
standing 1 w 1225
waters 1 w 1231
and 21 w 1235
such 1 w 1239
as 9 w 1241
are 3 w 1244
settled 1 w 1251
in 27 w 1253
pits 1 w 1257
and 22 w 1260
holes 1 w 1265
without 2 w 1272
issue 1 w 1277
what 1 w 1282
an 37 w 1284
offensive 1 w 1293
and 23 w 1296
dead 2 w 1300
stench 1 w 1306
they 3 w 1310
send 1 w 1314
forth 2 w 1319
and 24 w 1323
all 5 w 1326
for 9 w 1329
want 3 w 1333
of 15 w 1335
motion 1 w 1341
for 10 w 1345
this 1 w 1349
kindles 1 w 1356
and 25 w 1359
preserves 2 w 1368
heat 2 w 1372
in 29 w 1374
all 6 w 1377
things 3 w 1383
and 26 w 1387
more 1 w 1391
especially 1 w 1401
in 31 w 1403
running 1 w 1410
waters 2 w 1416
and 27 w 1419
swift 1 w 1424
streams 1 w 1431
which 2 w 1437
being 3 w 1442
thus 2 w 1446
agitated 1 w 1454
and 28 w 1457
enlivened 1 w 1466
by 5 w 1468
heat 3 w 1472
we 7 w 1475
commonly 1 w 1483
say 2 w 1486
such 2 w 1490
waters 3 w 1496
live 2 w 1500
Why 1 w 1504
then 2 w 1508
should 1 w 1514
not 4 w 1517
that 7 w 1521
be 8 w 1523
accounted 1 w 1532
the 27 w 1535
most 1 w 1539
useful 1 w 1545
of 16 w 1547
the 28 w 1550
two 2 w 1553
that 8 w 1558
affords 1 w 1565
to 10 w 1567
the 29 w 1570
other 5 w 1575
the 31 w 1578
cause 3 w 1583
of 17 w 1585
its 8 w 1588
being 4 w 1593
as 10 w 1596
fire 9 w 1600
does 1 w 1604
to 11 w 1606
water 9 w 1611
Moreover 1 w 1620
that 9 w 1625
is 12 w 1627
the 32 w 1630
most 2 w 1634
useful 2 w 1640
of 18 w 1643
which 3 w 1648
if 6 w 1650
an 45 w 1652
animal 1 w 1658
be 10 w 1660
wholly 1 w 1666
deprived 1 w 1674
it 23 w 1677
must 1 w 1681
perish 1 w 1687
for 12 w 1691
it 24 w 1693
is 14 w 1695
evident 1 w 1702
that 10 w 1707
anything 1 w 1715
without 3 w 1722
which 4 w 1727
an 48 w 1729
animal 2 w 1735
cannot 1 w 1741
live 3 w 1745
affords 2 w 1752
the 33 w 1755
reason 1 w 1761
and 29 w 1764
cause 4 w 1769
why 2 w 1772
it 26 w 1774
exists 1 w 1780
There 1 w 1786
is 16 w 1788
moisture 1 w 1796
also 1 w 1800
in 36 w 1802
things 4 w 1808
after 1 w 1813
they 4 w 1817
are 4 w 1820
dead 3 w 1824
nor 1 w 1828
are 5 w 1831
they 5 w 1835
altogether 2 w 1845
dried 1 w 1850
up 2 w 1852
for 14 w 1856
otherwise 1 w 1865
moist 2 w 1870
bodies 1 w 1876
would 1 w 1881
never 1 w 1886
putrefy 1 w 1893
since 1 w 1899
putrefaction 1 w 1911
is 20 w 1913
the 38 w 1916
alteration 1 w 1926
of 19 w 1928
dry 2 w 1931
into 3 w 1935
moist 3 w 1940
or 23 w 1943
rather 1 w 1949
the 40 w 1952
corruption 1 w 1962
of 20 w 1964
moisture 2 w 1972
in 40 w 1974
flesh 1 w 1979
Neither 1 w 1987
is 23 w 1989
death 2 w 1994
any 5 w 1997
other 7 w 2002
than 1 w 2006
an 54 w 2008
absolute 1 w 2016
defect 1 w 2022
and 30 w 2025
want 4 w 2029
of 21 w 2031
heat 4 w 2035
and 31 w 2039
therefore 1 w 2048
dead 4 w 2052
carcasses 1 w 2061
are 6 w 2064
the 44 w 2067
coldest 1 w 2074
of 22 w 2076
all 8 w 2079
so 7 w 2082
that 11 w 2086
if 7 w 2088
you 1 w 2091
do 2 w 2093
but 3 w 2096
touch 1 w 2101
them 3 w 2105
with 4 w 2109
a 181 w 2110
razor 1 w 2115
they 6 w 2120
will 2 w 2124
blunt 1 w 2129
the 47 w 2132
edge 1 w 2136
of 23 w 2138
it 29 w 2140
through 1 w 2147
excess 1 w 2153
of 24 w 2155
coldness 1 w 2163
Also 1 w 2168
in 41 w 2170
living 1 w 2176
creatures 1 w 2185
those 1 w 2191
parts 1 w 2196
that 12 w 2200
least 1 w 2205
partake 1 w 2212
of 25 w 2214
heat 5 w 2218
are 7 w 2221
most 3 w 2225
insensible 1 w 2235
as 14 w 2238
the 48 w 2241
bones 1 w 2246
and 32 w 2249
hair 1 w 2253
and 33 w 2257
those 2 w 2262
parts 2 w 2267
which 5 w 2272
are 8 w 2275
most 4 w 2279
distant 1 w 2286
from 3 w 2290
the 49 w 2293
heart 1 w 2298
Nay 1 w 2302
to 15 w 2305
some 1 w 2309
of 26 w 2311
the 50 w 2314
most 5 w 2318
important 1 w 2327
things 5 w 2333
the 51 w 2336
absence 1 w 2343
of 27 w 2345
fire 10 w 2349
and 34 w 2352
the 52 w 2355
presence 1 w 2363
of 28 w 2365
water 10 w 2370
are 9 w 2373
destructive 1 w 2384
For 2 w 2388
plants 1 w 2394
and 35 w 2397
fruits 1 w 2403
are 10 w 2406
not 6 w 2409
produced 1 w 2417
by 6 w 2419
moisture 3 w 2427
but 4 w 2431
by 7 w 2433
the 53 w 2436
warmth 2 w 2442
of 29 w 2444
the 54 w 2447
moisture 4 w 2455
and 36 w 2459
cold 3 w 2463
waters 4 w 2469
are 11 w 2472
most 6 w 2476
certainly 1 w 2485
either 3 w 2491
less 1 w 2495
productive 2 w 2505
or 29 w 2508
altogether 3 w 2518
barren 2 w 2524
For 3 w 2528
if 8 w 2530
water 12 w 2535
were 3 w 2539
fruitful 2 w 2547
in 46 w 2549
itself 4 w 2555
it 34 w 2558
would 2 w 2563
always 1 w 2569
and 37 w 2573
that 13 w 2577
spontaneously 1 w 2590
too 1 w 2593
bear 1 w 2598
fruit 4 w 2603
But 3 w 2607
the 57 w 2610
contrary 2 w 2618
is 27 w 2620
apparent 1 w 2628
and 38 w 2632
it 36 w 2634
is 28 w 2636
rather 2 w 2642
baneful 1 w 2649
to 18 w 2651
generation 3 w 2661
Let 1 w 2665
us 15 w 2667
begin 1 w 2672
anew 1 w 2676
As 1 w 2679
to 19 w 2681
the 59 w 2684
use 8 w 2687
of 30 w 2689
fire 11 w 2693
considered 1 w 2704
as 15 w 2706
fire 12 w 2710
we 9 w 2713
have 1 w 2717
no 8 w 2719
need 1 w 2723
of 31 w 2725
water 13 w 2730
Rather 1 w 2737
the 61 w 2740
contrary 3 w 2748
is 29 w 2750
to 20 w 2752
be 13 w 2754
made 1 w 2758
out 5 w 2761
for 16 w 2765
water 14 w 2770
extinguishes 1 w 2782
fire 13 w 2786
And 2 w 2790
as 16 w 2792
for 17 w 2795
water 15 w 2800
there 2 w 2806
is 31 w 2808
no 9 w 2810
use 9 w 2813
to 21 w 2815
be 14 w 2817
made 2 w 2821
of 32 w 2823
it 37 w 2825
in 49 w 2827
most 7 w 2831
things 6 w 2837
without 4 w 2844
fire 14 w 2848
For 4 w 2852
water 16 w 2857
heated 1 w 2863
becomes 1 w 2870
more 2 w 2874
usefill 1 w 2881
whereas 1 w 2889
otherwise 2 w 2898
it 39 w 2900
is 33 w 2902
prejudicial 1 w 2913
So 1 w 2916
that 14 w 2920
of 33 w 2923
the 64 w 2926
two 3 w 2929
that 15 w 2934
is 34 w 2936
to 22 w 2938
be 16 w 2940
accounted 2 w 2949
best 1 w 2953
which 6 w 2958
is 35 w 2960
profitable 1 w 2970
of 35 w 2972
itself 5 w 2978
without 5 w 2985
the 65 w 2988
assistance 1 w 2998
of 36 w 3000
another 2 w 3007
Besides 1 w 3015
water 17 w 3021
is 37 w 3023
beneficial 1 w 3033
only 2 w 3037
to 23 w 3039
the 67 w 3042
feeling 1 w 3049
when 2 w 3054
you 2 w 3057
either 4 w 3063
wash 1 w 3067
with 7 w 3071
it 45 w 3073
or 35 w 3075
touch 2 w 3080
it 46 w 3082
but 5 w 3086
fire 15 w 3090
is 38 w 3092
profitable 2 w 3102
to 25 w 3104
all 9 w 3107
the 69 w 3110
senses 1 w 3116
being 5 w 3122
not 8 w 3125
only 3 w 3129
felt 1 w 3133
but 6 w 3137
also 2 w 3141
seen 1 w 3145
at 62 w 3147
a 258 w 3148
distance 1 w 3156
so 11 w 3159
that 16 w 3163
you 3 w 3166
may 2 w 3169
add 1 w 3172
this 2 w 3176
to 26 w 3178
the 70 w 3181
rest 1 w 3185
of 38 w 3187
the 71 w 3190
virtues 1 w 3197
of 39 w 3199
it 48 w 3201
that 17 w 3206
its 12 w 3209
uses 1 w 3213
are 13 w 3216
manifold 1 w 3224