Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Whether water or fire be most useful.

Whether water or fire be most useful. (7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg128.perseus-eng4:7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '7', 'human_reference': 'Section 7'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Then again, there being four elements, water produces a fifth out of itself, which is the sea, no less beneficial than the rest, as well for commerce as for many other things. So that it may be said, this element united and perfected our manner of living, which before was wild and unsociable, correcting it by mutual assistance, and

creating community of friendship by reciprocal exchanges of one good turn for another. And as Heraclitus said, If there were no sun, it would be perpetual night; so may we say, If there were no sea, man would be the most savage and shameless of all creature. But the sea brought the vine from India into Greece, and out of Greece transmitted the use of corn to foreign parts; from Phoenicia translated the knowledge of letters, the memorials that prevent oblivion; furnished the world with wine and fruit, and prevented the greatest part of mankind from being illiterate and void of education. How is it possible then but that water should be the most useful, when it thus furnishes us with an entirely new element?

Tokens

Then 1 w 4
again 1 w 9
there 1 w 15
being 1 w 20
four 1 w 24
elements 1 w 32
water 1 w 38
produces 1 w 46
a 4 w 47
fifth 1 w 52
out 1 w 55
of 1 w 57
itself 1 w 63
which 1 w 69
is 1 w 71
the 2 w 74
sea 1 w 77
no 1 w 80
less 1 w 84
beneficial 1 w 94
than 1 w 98
the 3 w 101
rest 1 w 105
as 1 w 108
well 1 w 112
for 1 w 115
commerce 1 w 123
as 2 w 125
for 2 w 128
many 1 w 132
other 1 w 137
things 1 w 143
So 1 w 146
that 1 w 150
it 2 w 152
may 1 w 155
be 3 w 157
said 1 w 161
this 1 w 166
element 2 w 173
united 1 w 179
and 1 w 182
perfected 1 w 191
our 2 w 194
manner 1 w 200
of 2 w 202
living 1 w 208
which 2 w 214
before 1 w 220
was 1 w 223
wild 1 w 227
and 2 w 230
unsociable 1 w 240
correcting 1 w 251
it 4 w 253
by 1 w 255
mutual 1 w 261
assistance 1 w 271
and 3 w 275
creating 1 w 283
community 1 w 292
of 3 w 294
friendship 1 w 304
by 2 w 306
reciprocal 1 w 316
exchanges 1 w 325
of 4 w 327
one 1 w 330
good 1 w 334
turn 1 w 338
for 4 w 341
another 1 w 348
And 1 w 352
as 5 w 354
Heraclitus 1 w 364
said 2 w 368
If 1 w 371
there 2 w 376
were 1 w 380
no 3 w 382
sun 1 w 385
it 7 w 388
would 1 w 393
be 5 w 395
perpetual 1 w 404
night 1 w 409
so 2 w 412
may 2 w 415
we 3 w 417
say 1 w 420
If 2 w 423
there 3 w 428
were 2 w 432
no 4 w 434
sea 2 w 437
man 3 w 441
would 2 w 446
be 6 w 448
the 8 w 451
most 1 w 455
savage 1 w 461
and 4 w 464
shameless 1 w 473
of 5 w 475
all 1 w 478
creature 1 w 486
But 1 w 490
the 9 w 493
sea 3 w 496
brought 1 w 503
the 10 w 506
vine 1 w 510
from 1 w 514
India 1 w 519
into 1 w 523
Greece 1 w 529
and 5 w 533
out 2 w 536
of 6 w 538
Greece 2 w 544
transmitted 1 w 555
the 11 w 558
use 1 w 561
of 7 w 563
corn 1 w 567
to 2 w 569
foreign 1 w 576
parts 1 w 581
from 2 w 586
Phoenicia 1 w 595
translated 1 w 605
the 12 w 608
knowledge 1 w 617
of 8 w 619
letters 1 w 626
the 13 w 630
memorials 1 w 639
that 2 w 643
prevent 1 w 650
oblivion 1 w 658
furnished 1 w 668
the 14 w 671
world 1 w 676
with 1 w 680
wine 1 w 684
and 6 w 687
fruit 1 w 692
and 7 w 696
prevented 1 w 705
the 15 w 708
greatest 1 w 716
part 2 w 720
of 9 w 722
mankind 1 w 729
from 3 w 733
being 2 w 738
illiterate 1 w 748
and 8 w 751
void 1 w 755
of 10 w 757
education 1 w 766
How 1 w 770
is 5 w 772
it 12 w 774
possible 1 w 782
then 1 w 786
but 1 w 789
that 3 w 793
water 2 w 798
should 1 w 804
be 8 w 806
the 17 w 809
most 2 w 813
useful 1 w 819
when 1 w 824
it 13 w 826
thus 1 w 830
furnishes 1 w 839
us 5 w 841
with 2 w 845
an 19 w 847
entirely 1 w 855
new 1 w 858
element 3 w 865