Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Whether water or fire be most useful.

Whether water or fire be most useful. (5-7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg128.perseus-eng4:5-7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '7', 'human_reference': 'Section 7'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Then again, that is most useful which is no way detrimental. Now fire easily becomes most pernicious, but the nature of water is never prejudicial. In the next place, that is most useful which affords the benefit which it brings with least expense, and without any preparation. But the benefit of fire requires cost and materials, and therefore the rich make more use of it than the poor, and princes than private persons; but water has that kindness for mankind, that it freely offers itself to all alike, a benefit perfect in itself, indigent of nothing, and wanting neither tools nor implements.

Moreover, that which by augmentation loses its benefit is of least use. Such is fire, which like a devouring beast ravages all before it, useful rather by art and skilful moderation, than of its own nature. But from water there is nothing to be feared. Furthermore, that is most useful which may be joined with another. But fire will not admit of water, neither is it any way profitable by conjunction with it. But water becomes profitable by joining with fire; and therefore hot waters are wholesome, and sensibly cure several diseases. Neither shall you ever find moist fire; but water both cold and hot is profitable for the body of man.

Then again, there being four elements, water produces a fifth out of itself, which is the sea, no less beneficial than the rest, as well for commerce as for many other things. So that it may be said, this element united and perfected our manner of living, which before was wild and unsociable, correcting it by mutual assistance, and

creating community of friendship by reciprocal exchanges of one good turn for another. And as Heraclitus said, If there were no sun, it would be perpetual night; so may we say, If there were no sea, man would be the most savage and shameless of all creature. But the sea brought the vine from India into Greece, and out of Greece transmitted the use of corn to foreign parts; from Phoenicia translated the knowledge of letters, the memorials that prevent oblivion; furnished the world with wine and fruit, and prevented the greatest part of mankind from being illiterate and void of education. How is it possible then but that water should be the most useful, when it thus furnishes us with an entirely new element?

Tokens

Then 1 w 4
again 1 w 9
that 1 w 14
is 1 w 16
most 1 w 20
useful 1 w 26
which 1 w 31
is 2 w 33
no 1 w 35
way 1 w 38
detrimental 1 w 49
Now 1 w 53
fire 1 w 57
easily 1 w 63
becomes 1 w 70
most 2 w 74
pernicious 1 w 84
but 1 w 88
the 1 w 91
nature 1 w 97
of 1 w 99
water 1 w 104
is 3 w 106
never 1 w 111
prejudicial 1 w 122
In 1 w 125
the 2 w 128
next 1 w 132
place 1 w 137
that 2 w 142
is 4 w 144
most 3 w 148
useful 2 w 154
which 2 w 159
affords 1 w 166
the 3 w 169
benefit 1 w 176
which 3 w 181
it 2 w 183
brings 1 w 189
with 1 w 193
least 1 w 198
expense 1 w 205
and 1 w 209
without 1 w 216
any 1 w 219
preparation 1 w 230
But 1 w 234
the 4 w 237
benefit 2 w 244
of 2 w 246
fire 2 w 250
requires 1 w 258
cost 1 w 262
and 2 w 265
materials 1 w 274
and 3 w 278
therefore 1 w 287
the 6 w 290
rich 1 w 294
make 1 w 298
more 1 w 302
use 3 w 305
of 3 w 307
it 6 w 309
than 1 w 313
the 7 w 316
poor 1 w 320
and 4 w 324
princes 1 w 331
than 2 w 335
private 1 w 342
persons 1 w 349
but 2 w 353
water 2 w 358
has 1 w 361
that 3 w 365
kindness 1 w 373
for 3 w 376
mankind 1 w 383
that 4 w 388
it 7 w 390
freely 1 w 396
offers 1 w 402
itself 1 w 408
to 1 w 410
all 1 w 413
alike 1 w 418
a 34 w 420
benefit 3 w 427
perfect 1 w 434
in 6 w 436
itself 2 w 442
indigent 1 w 451
of 5 w 453
nothing 1 w 460
and 5 w 464
wanting 1 w 471
neither 1 w 478
tools 1 w 483
nor 1 w 486
implements 1 w 496
Moreover 1 w 505
that 5 w 510
which 4 w 515
by 1 w 517
augmentation 1 w 529
loses 1 w 534
its 3 w 537
benefit 4 w 544
is 5 w 546
of 6 w 548
least 2 w 553
use 4 w 556
Such 1 w 561
is 6 w 563
fire 3 w 567
which 5 w 573
like 2 w 577
a 41 w 578
devouring 1 w 587
beast 1 w 592
ravages 1 w 599
all 2 w 602
before 1 w 608
it 14 w 610
useful 3 w 617
rather 1 w 623
by 2 w 625
art 1 w 628
and 6 w 631
skilful 1 w 638
moderation 1 w 648
than 3 w 653
of 7 w 655
its 4 w 658
own 1 w 661
nature 2 w 667
But 2 w 671
from 1 w 675
water 3 w 680
there 2 w 685
is 7 w 687
nothing 2 w 694
to 3 w 696
be 8 w 698
feared 1 w 704
Furthermore 1 w 716
that 6 w 721
is 8 w 723
most 4 w 727
useful 4 w 733
which 6 w 738
may 1 w 741
be 9 w 743
joined 1 w 749
with 3 w 753
another 1 w 760
But 3 w 764
fire 4 w 768
will 1 w 772
not 4 w 775
admit 1 w 780
of 8 w 782
water 4 w 787
neither 2 w 795
is 9 w 797
it 19 w 799
any 2 w 802
way 2 w 805
profitable 1 w 815
by 3 w 817
conjunction 1 w 828
with 4 w 832
it 22 w 834
But 4 w 838
water 5 w 843
becomes 2 w 850
profitable 2 w 860
by 4 w 862
joining 1 w 869
with 5 w 873
fire 5 w 877
and 7 w 881
therefore 2 w 890
hot 1 w 893
waters 1 w 899
are 2 w 902
wholesome 1 w 911
and 8 w 915
sensibly 1 w 923
cure 1 w 927
several 1 w 934
diseases 1 w 942
Neither 1 w 950
shall 1 w 955
you 1 w 958
ever 3 w 962
find 1 w 966
moist 1 w 971
fire 6 w 975
but 3 w 979
water 7 w 984
both 1 w 988
cold 1 w 992
and 9 w 995
hot 2 w 998
is 12 w 1000
profitable 3 w 1010
for 6 w 1013
the 16 w 1016
body 1 w 1020
of 12 w 1022
man 2 w 1025
Then 2 w 1030
again 2 w 1035
there 4 w 1041
being 1 w 1046
four 1 w 1050
elements 1 w 1058
water 8 w 1064
produces 1 w 1072
a 78 w 1073
fifth 1 w 1078
out 2 w 1081
of 13 w 1083
itself 3 w 1089
which 7 w 1095
is 13 w 1097
the 18 w 1100
sea 2 w 1103
no 7 w 1106
less 1 w 1110
beneficial 1 w 1120
than 4 w 1124
the 19 w 1127
rest 1 w 1131
as 7 w 1134
well 1 w 1138
for 7 w 1141
commerce 1 w 1149
as 8 w 1151
for 8 w 1154
many 1 w 1158
other 2 w 1163
things 1 w 1169
So 1 w 1172
that 7 w 1176
it 28 w 1178
may 2 w 1181
be 13 w 1183
said 1 w 1187
this 1 w 1192
element 2 w 1199
united 1 w 1205
and 10 w 1208
perfected 1 w 1217
our 3 w 1220
manner 1 w 1226
of 14 w 1228
living 1 w 1234
which 8 w 1240
before 2 w 1246
was 1 w 1249
wild 1 w 1253
and 11 w 1256
unsociable 1 w 1266
correcting 1 w 1277
it 30 w 1279
by 5 w 1281
mutual 1 w 1287
assistance 1 w 1297
and 12 w 1301
creating 1 w 1309
community 1 w 1318
of 15 w 1320
friendship 1 w 1330
by 6 w 1332
reciprocal 1 w 1342
exchanges 1 w 1351
of 16 w 1353
one 1 w 1356
good 1 w 1360
turn 1 w 1364
for 10 w 1367
another 2 w 1374
And 1 w 1378
as 11 w 1380
Heraclitus 1 w 1390
said 2 w 1394
If 1 w 1397
there 5 w 1402
were 1 w 1406
no 9 w 1408
sun 1 w 1411
it 33 w 1414
would 1 w 1419
be 15 w 1421
perpetual 1 w 1430
night 1 w 1435
so 4 w 1438
may 3 w 1441
we 3 w 1443
say 1 w 1446
If 2 w 1449
there 6 w 1454
were 2 w 1458
no 10 w 1460
sea 3 w 1463
man 5 w 1467
would 2 w 1472
be 16 w 1474
the 24 w 1477
most 5 w 1481
savage 1 w 1487
and 13 w 1490
shameless 1 w 1499
of 17 w 1501
all 4 w 1504
creature 1 w 1512
But 5 w 1516
the 25 w 1519
sea 4 w 1522
brought 1 w 1529
the 26 w 1532
vine 1 w 1536
from 2 w 1540
India 1 w 1545
into 1 w 1549
Greece 1 w 1555
and 14 w 1559
out 3 w 1562
of 18 w 1564
Greece 2 w 1570
transmitted 1 w 1581
the 27 w 1584
use 7 w 1587
of 19 w 1589
corn 1 w 1593
to 5 w 1595
foreign 1 w 1602
parts 1 w 1607
from 3 w 1612
Phoenicia 1 w 1621
translated 1 w 1631
the 28 w 1634
knowledge 1 w 1643
of 20 w 1645
letters 1 w 1652
the 29 w 1656
memorials 1 w 1665
that 8 w 1669
prevent 1 w 1676
oblivion 1 w 1684
furnished 1 w 1694
the 30 w 1697
world 1 w 1702
with 6 w 1706
wine 1 w 1710
and 15 w 1713
fruit 1 w 1718
and 16 w 1722
prevented 1 w 1731
the 31 w 1734
greatest 1 w 1742
part 2 w 1746
of 21 w 1748
mankind 2 w 1755
from 4 w 1759
being 2 w 1764
illiterate 1 w 1774
and 17 w 1777
void 1 w 1781
of 22 w 1783
education 1 w 1792
How 1 w 1796
is 17 w 1798
it 38 w 1800
possible 1 w 1808
then 1 w 1812
but 4 w 1815
that 9 w 1819
water 9 w 1824
should 1 w 1830
be 18 w 1832
the 33 w 1835
most 6 w 1839
useful 5 w 1845
when 1 w 1850
it 39 w 1852
thus 1 w 1856
furnishes 1 w 1865
us 12 w 1867
with 7 w 1871
an 37 w 1873
entirely 1 w 1881
new 1 w 1884
element 3 w 1891