Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Whether water or fire be most useful.

Whether water or fire be most useful. (1)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg128.perseus-eng4:1
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'Section 1'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Water is the best of things, but gold is like burning fire, says Pindar.[*] Therefore he positively assigns the second place to fire; with whom Hesiod agrees, where he says,

First of all Chaos being had.
[*]
For most believe that by the word chaos he meant water, from χύσις, signifying diffusion. But the balance of argument as to this point seems to be equal. For there are some who will have it that fire is the principle of all things, and that like sperm it begets all things out of itself, and resolves all things again by conflagration. Therefore, not to mention the persons, let us consider the arguments on both sides, which are to us the most convincing.

Tokens

Water 1 w 5
is 1 w 7
the 1 w 10
best 1 w 14
of 1 w 16
things 1 w 22
but 1 w 26
gold 1 w 30
is 2 w 32
like 1 w 36
burning 1 w 43
fire 1 w 47
says 1 w 52
Pindar 1 w 58
Pindar 2 w 65
Olymp 1 w 71
I 1 w 73
1 1 w 75
Therefore 1 w 85
he 3 w 87
positively 1 w 97
assigns 1 w 104
the 2 w 107
second 1 w 113
place 1 w 118
to 1 w 120
fire 2 w 124
with 1 w 129
whom 1 w 133
Hesiod 1 w 139
agrees 1 w 145
where 1 w 151
he 6 w 153
says 2 w 157
First 1 w 163
of 2 w 165
all 1 w 168
Chaos 1 w 173
being 1 w 178
had 1 w 181
Hesiod 2 w 188
Theog 1 w 194
116 1 w 198
For 1 w 202
most 1 w 206
believe 1 w 213
that 1 w 217
by 1 w 219
the 3 w 222
word 1 w 226
chaos 1 w 231
he 9 w 233
meant 1 w 238
water 1 w 243
from 1 w 248
χύσις 1 w 253
signifying 1 w 264
diffusion 1 w 273
But 1 w 277
the 4 w 280
balance 1 w 287
of 3 w 289
argument 1 w 297
as 2 w 299
to 2 w 301
this 1 w 305
point 1 w 310
seems 1 w 315
to 3 w 317
be 4 w 319
equal 1 w 324
For 2 w 328
there 1 w 333
are 1 w 336
some 1 w 340
who 2 w 343
will 1 w 347
have 1 w 351
it 3 w 353
that 2 w 357
fire 3 w 361
is 4 w 363
the 6 w 366
principle 1 w 375
of 4 w 377
all 2 w 380
things 2 w 386
and 1 w 390
that 3 w 394
like 2 w 398
sperm 1 w 403
it 4 w 405
begets 1 w 411
all 3 w 414
things 3 w 420
out 1 w 423
of 5 w 425
itself 1 w 431
and 2 w 435
resolves 1 w 443
all 4 w 446
things 4 w 452
again 1 w 457
by 2 w 459
conflagration 1 w 472
Therefore 2 w 482
not 1 w 486
to 4 w 488
mention 1 w 495
the 7 w 498
persons 1 w 505
let 1 w 509
us 2 w 511
consider 1 w 519
the 8 w 522
arguments 1 w 531
on 8 w 533
both 1 w 537
sides 1 w 542
which 1 w 548
are 2 w 551
to 5 w 553
us 3 w 555
the 9 w 558
most 2 w 562
convincing 1 w 572