Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Whether fire or water is most useful

Whether fire or water is most useful (12-13)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg128.perseus-eng3:12-13
Refs {'start': {'reference': '12', 'human_reference': 'Section 12'}, 'end': {'reference': '13', 'human_reference': 'Section 13'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And since we have arrived at this point in our argument: What is more profitable to life than Art? And it was fire that discovered and still preserves all the arts. That is why they make Hephaestus the first of artificers. Man has been granted but a little time to live and, as Ariston[*] says, sleep, like a taxcollector, takes away half of that. But I would rather say that it is a question of darkness; for although a man might stay awake all night, yet no good would come of his wakefulness if fire did not give him the benefits of day and remove the difference between day and night.[*] If, then, there is nothing more advantageous to man than life and life is many times increased by fire, how should fire not be the most useful of all things?

And, to be sure, will not that be the most advantageous of which each of the senses has the greatest proportion? Do you not perceive, then, that there is no one of the senses which uses moisture by itself without an admixture of air or fire; and that every sense partakes of fire inasmuch as it supplies the vital energy; and especially that sight, the keenest of the physical senses,[*] is an ignited mass of fire[*] and is that which has made us believe[*] in the gods? And further, through sight, as Plato[*] says, we are able to conform our souls to the movements of the celestial bodies.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
since 1 w 8
we 1 w 10
have 1 w 14
arrived 1 w 21
at 1 w 23
this 1 w 27
point 1 w 32
in 3 w 34
our 1 w 37
argument 1 w 45
What 1 w 50
is 2 w 52
more 1 w 56
profitable 1 w 66
to 1 w 68
life 1 w 72
than 1 w 76
Art 1 w 79
And 2 w 83
it 2 w 85
was 1 w 88
fire 1 w 92
that 1 w 96
discovered 1 w 106
and 1 w 109
still 1 w 114
preserves 1 w 123
all 1 w 126
the 1 w 129
arts 1 w 133
That 1 w 138
is 4 w 140
why 1 w 143
they 1 w 147
make 1 w 151
Hephaestus 1 w 161
the 3 w 164
first 1 w 169
of 2 w 171
artificers 1 w 181
Man 1 w 185
has 1 w 188
been 1 w 192
granted 1 w 199
but 1 w 202
a 20 w 203
little 1 w 209
time 1 w 213
to 2 w 215
live 1 w 219
and 2 w 222
as 3 w 225
Ariston 1 w 232
Von 1 w 235
Arnim 1 w 240
S 1 w 242
V 2 w 244
F 1 w 246
i 22 w 248
p 5 w 250
90 1 w 253
frag 1 w 258
403 1 w 262
cf 1 w 265
Aristotle 1 w 275
Nicomachean 1 w 287
Ethics 1 w 293
i 26 w 295
13 1 w 298
12 1 w 301
1102 1 w 306
b 4 w 307
7 1 w 308
says 1 w 314
sleep 1 w 320
like 1 w 325
a 27 w 326
taxcollector 1 w 338
takes 1 w 344
away 1 w 348
half 1 w 352
of 3 w 354
that 2 w 358
But 1 w 362
I 1 w 363
would 1 w 368
rather 1 w 374
say 2 w 377
that 3 w 381
it 4 w 383
is 7 w 385
a 37 w 386
question 1 w 394
of 4 w 396
darkness 1 w 404
for 1 w 408
although 1 w 416
a 40 w 417
man 1 w 420
might 1 w 425
stay 1 w 429
awake 1 w 434
all 2 w 437
night 1 w 442
yet 1 w 446
no 1 w 448
good 1 w 452
would 2 w 457
come 1 w 461
of 5 w 463
his 2 w 466
wakefulness 1 w 477
if 3 w 479
fire 2 w 483
did 1 w 486
not 1 w 489
give 1 w 493
him 1 w 496
the 5 w 499
benefits 1 w 507
of 6 w 509
day 1 w 512
and 3 w 515
remove 1 w 521
the 6 w 524
difference 1 w 534
between 1 w 541
day 2 w 544
and 4 w 547
night 2 w 552
A 7 w 554
very 1 w 558
corrupt 1 w 565
passage 1 w 572
Adler 1 w 578
s 36 w 580
reconstruction 1 w 594
Wien 1 w 599
Stud 1 w 604
xxxi 1 w 609
308 1 w 613
with 1 w 619
additions 1 w 628
by 1 w 630
Post 1 w 634
has 2 w 638
been 2 w 642
followed 1 w 650
If 1 w 653
then 1 w 658
there 1 w 664
is 9 w 666
nothing 1 w 673
more 2 w 677
advantageous 1 w 689
to 6 w 691
man 2 w 694
than 2 w 698
life 2 w 702
and 5 w 705
life 3 w 709
is 10 w 711
many 1 w 715
times 1 w 720
increased 1 w 729
by 2 w 731
fire 3 w 735
how 1 w 739
should 1 w 745
fire 4 w 749
not 3 w 752
be 5 w 754
the 9 w 757
most 1 w 761
useful 1 w 767
of 7 w 769
all 3 w 772
things 1 w 778
And 3 w 782
to 7 w 785
be 6 w 787
sure 1 w 791
will 1 w 796
not 4 w 799
that 4 w 803
be 7 w 805
the 10 w 808
most 2 w 812
advantageous 2 w 824
of 8 w 826
which 1 w 831
each 1 w 835
of 9 w 837
the 11 w 840
senses 1 w 846
has 3 w 849
the 12 w 852
greatest 1 w 860
proportion 1 w 870
Do 1 w 873
you 1 w 876
not 5 w 879
perceive 1 w 887
then 2 w 892
that 5 w 897
there 2 w 902
is 11 w 904
no 7 w 906
one 1 w 909
of 10 w 911
the 15 w 914
senses 2 w 920
which 2 w 925
uses 1 w 929
moisture 1 w 937
by 3 w 939
itself 1 w 945
without 1 w 952
an 16 w 954
admixture 1 w 963
of 11 w 965
air 1 w 968
or 7 w 970
fire 5 w 974
and 6 w 978
that 6 w 982
every 1 w 987
sense 3 w 992
partakes 1 w 1000
of 12 w 1002
fire 6 w 1006
inasmuch 1 w 1014
as 9 w 1016
it 10 w 1018
supplies 1 w 1026
the 16 w 1029
vital 1 w 1034
energy 1 w 1040
and 7 w 1044
especially 1 w 1054
that 7 w 1058
sight 1 w 1063
the 17 w 1067
keenest 1 w 1074
of 13 w 1076
the 18 w 1079
physical 1 w 1087
senses 3 w 1093
Cf 1 w 1096
Plato 1 w 1102
Phaedrus 1 w 1111
250 1 w 1115
d 35 w 1116
cf 2 w 1119
Mor 1 w 1123
654 1 w 1127
d-e 1 w 1130
681 1 w 1134
e 128 w 1135
is 13 w 1138
an 19 w 1140
ignited 1 w 1147
mass 1 w 1151
of 14 w 1153
fire 7 w 1157
Cf 2 w 1159
von 1 w 1163
Arnim 2 w 1168
S 3 w 1170
V 3 w 1172
F 2 w 1174
ii 1 w 1177
pp 2 w 1180
196 1 w 1184
199 1 w 1188
but 2 w 1192
Post 2 w 1196
believes 1 w 1204
the 19 w 1207
words 1 w 1212
may 1 w 1215
mean 1 w 1219
a 92 w 1220
chain 1 w 1225
of 15 w 1227
fire 8 w 1231
linking 1 w 1238
the 20 w 1241
eye 1 w 1244
with 3 w 1248
its 3 w 1251
object 1 w 1257
and 8 w 1261
is 14 w 1263
that 8 w 1267
which 3 w 1272
has 4 w 1275
made 1 w 1279
us 7 w 1281
believe 2 w 1288
It 1 w 1290
is 15 w 1292
the 21 w 1295
visible 1 w 1302
heavens 1 w 1309
and 9 w 1312
their 1 w 1317
fire 9 w 1321
that 9 w 1325
make 2 w 1329
us 8 w 1331
believe 3 w 1338
by 4 w 1340
declaring 1 w 1349
the 23 w 1352
glory 1 w 1357
of 16 w 1359
the 24 w 1362
celestial 1 w 1371
gods 1 w 1375
See 1 w 1379
A 11 w 1380
S 5 w 1382
Pease 1 w 1388
Caeli 1 w 1394
Enarrant 1 w 1402
Harvard 1 w 1410
Theological 1 w 1421
Review 1 w 1427
xxxiv 1 w 1433
1941 1 w 1438
pp 3 w 1442
163-200 1 w 1450
in 12 w 1453
the 25 w 1456
gods 2 w 1460
And 4 w 1464
further 1 w 1471
through 1 w 1479
sight 2 w 1484
as 13 w 1487
Plato 2 w 1492
Timaeus 1 w 1499
47 1 w 1502
a-b 1 w 1505
says 2 w 1510
we 4 w 1513
are 1 w 1516
able 2 w 1520
to 10 w 1522
conform 1 w 1529
our 2 w 1532
souls 1 w 1537
to 11 w 1539
the 27 w 1542
movements 1 w 1551
of 17 w 1553
the 28 w 1556
celestial 2 w 1565
bodies 1 w 1571