Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (32-35)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:32-35
Refs {'start': {'reference': '32', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 32'}, 'end': {'reference': '35', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 35'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
XXXII.[*]
WHY DOTH THE PALM ALONE OF ALL TREES BEND UPWARD WHEN A WEIGHT IS LAID THEREUPON?

Is it that the fiery and spiritual power which it hath, being once provoked and (as it were) angered, putteth forth itself so much the more, and mounteth upward? Or is it because the weight, forcing the boughs suddenly, oppresseth and keepeth down the airy substance which they have, and driveth all of it inward; but the same afterwards, having resumed strength again, maketh head afresh, and more eagerly withstandeth the weight? Or, lastly, is it that the softer and more tender branches, not able to sustain the violence at first, so soon as the burden resteth quiet, by little and little lift up themselves, and make a show as if they rose up against it?

XXXIII.
WHAT IS THE REASON THAT PIT-WATER IS LESS NUTRITIVE THAN EITHER THAT WHICH ARISETH OUT OF SPRINGS OR THAT WHICH FALLETH DOWN FROM HEAVEN?

Is it because it is more cold, and withal hath less air in it? Or because it containeth much salt from the earth mingled therewith?—now it is well known that salt above all other things causeth leanness. Or because standing still, and not exercised with running and stirring, it getteth a certain malignant quality, which is hurtful to both plants and animals, and is the cause that it is neither well concocted nor able to feed and nourish any thing? Hence it

is that all dead waters of pools are unwholesome, for that they cannot digest and despatch those harmful qualities which they borrow of the evil property of the air or of the earth.

XXXIV.
WHY IS THE WEST WIND HELD COMMONLY TO BE THE SWIFTEST, ACCORDING TO THIS VERSE OF HOMER:

Let us likewise bestir our feet,
As fast as Western winds do fleet.
[*]

Is it not because this wind is wont to blow when the sky is very well cleansed, and the air is exceeding clear and without all clouds?—for the thickness and impurity of the air doth not a little impeach and interrupt the course of the winds. Or is it rather because the sun, striking through a cold wind with his beams, is the cause that it passeth the faster away?—for whatsoever of cold is drawn in by the force of the winds, when the same is overcome by heat, as it were its enemy, we must think, is driven and set forward further and with greater celerity.

XXXV.
WHY CANNOT BEES ABIDE SMOKE?

WHETHER is it because the passages of their vital spirits are exceeding strait, and, if it chance that smoke be gotten into them and there kept in and intercepted, it is enough to stop the poor bees breath,—yea, and to strangle them quite? Or is not the acrimony and bitterness (think you) of the smoke in causefor bees are delighted with sweet things, and in very truth they have no other nourishment; and therefore no marvel if they detest and abhor

smoke, as a thing for the bitterness most adverse and contrary unto them. Therefore honey-masters, when they make a smoke for to drive away bees, are wont to burn bitter herbs, as hemlock, centaury, etc.

Tokens

XXXII 1 w 5
The 1 w 9
Questions 1 w 18
which 1 w 23
follow 1 w 29
XXXII-XXXIX 1 w 41
are 1 w 45
not 1 w 48
found 1 w 53
in 1 w 55
the 1 w 58
Greek 1 w 63
but 1 w 67
are 2 w 70
restored 1 w 78
from 1 w 82
the 2 w 85
Latin 1 w 90
translation 1 w 101
said 1 w 106
to 2 w 108
have 1 w 112
been 1 w 116
made 1 w 120
in 3 w 122
the 3 w 125
16th 1 w 129
century 1 w 136
from 2 w 140
a 9 w 141
Greek 2 w 146
manuscript 1 w 156
now 1 w 159
lost 1 w 163
The 2 w 167
version 1 w 174
here 1 w 178
given 1 w 183
is 1 w 185
based 1 w 190
upon 1 w 194
that 1 w 198
of 1 w 200
Holland 1 w 207
G 3 w 210
WHY 1 w 215
DOTH 1 w 219
THE 1 w 222
PALM 1 w 226
ALONE 1 w 231
OF 1 w 233
ALL 1 w 236
TREES 1 w 241
BEND 1 w 245
UPWARD 1 w 251
WHEN 1 w 255
A 5 w 256
WEIGHT 1 w 262
IS 1 w 264
LAID 1 w 268
THEREUPON 1 w 277
Is 1 w 280
it 1 w 282
that 2 w 286
the 4 w 289
fiery 1 w 294
and 2 w 297
spiritual 1 w 306
power 1 w 311
which 2 w 316
it 3 w 318
hath 1 w 322
being 1 w 328
once 1 w 332
provoked 1 w 340
and 3 w 343
as 2 w 346
it 4 w 348
were 1 w 352
angered 1 w 360
putteth 1 w 368
forth 1 w 373
itself 1 w 379
so 1 w 381
much 1 w 385
the 5 w 388
more 1 w 392
and 4 w 396
mounteth 1 w 404
upward 1 w 410
Or 1 w 413
is 2 w 415
it 6 w 417
because 1 w 424
the 6 w 427
weight 1 w 433
forcing 1 w 441
the 7 w 444
boughs 1 w 450
suddenly 1 w 458
oppresseth 1 w 469
and 5 w 472
keepeth 1 w 479
down 1 w 483
the 8 w 486
airy 1 w 490
substance 1 w 499
which 3 w 504
they 1 w 508
have 2 w 512
and 6 w 516
driveth 1 w 523
all 1 w 526
of 2 w 528
it 7 w 530
inward 1 w 536
but 2 w 540
the 10 w 543
same 1 w 547
afterwards 1 w 557
having 1 w 564
resumed 1 w 571
strength 1 w 579
again 1 w 584
maketh 1 w 591
head 1 w 595
afresh 1 w 601
and 7 w 605
more 2 w 609
eagerly 1 w 616
withstandeth 1 w 628
the 11 w 631
weight 2 w 637
Or 2 w 640
lastly 1 w 647
is 3 w 650
it 9 w 652
that 3 w 656
the 12 w 659
softer 1 w 665
and 9 w 668
more 3 w 672
tender 1 w 678
branches 1 w 686
not 2 w 690
able 1 w 694
to 3 w 696
sustain 1 w 703
the 13 w 706
violence 1 w 714
at 7 w 716
first 1 w 721
so 3 w 724
soon 1 w 728
as 4 w 730
the 14 w 733
burden 1 w 739
resteth 1 w 746
quiet 1 w 751
by 1 w 754
little 1 w 760
and 10 w 763
little 2 w 769
lift 1 w 773
up 3 w 775
themselves 1 w 785
and 11 w 789
make 2 w 793
a 54 w 794
show 1 w 798
as 5 w 800
if 2 w 802
they 2 w 806
rose 1 w 810
up 4 w 812
against 1 w 819
it 12 w 821
XXXIII 1 w 828
WHAT 1 w 833
IS 2 w 835
THE 3 w 838
REASON 1 w 844
THAT 1 w 848
PIT-WATER 1 w 857
IS 3 w 859
LESS 1 w 863
NUTRITIVE 1 w 872
THAN 1 w 876
EITHER 1 w 882
THAT 2 w 886
WHICH 1 w 891
ARISETH 1 w 898
OUT 1 w 901
OF 2 w 903
SPRINGS 1 w 910
OR 1 w 912
THAT 3 w 916
WHICH 2 w 921
FALLETH 1 w 928
DOWN 1 w 932
FROM 1 w 936
HEAVEN 1 w 942
Is 2 w 945
it 13 w 947
because 2 w 954
it 14 w 956
is 4 w 958
more 4 w 962
cold 1 w 966
and 12 w 970
withal 1 w 976
hath 2 w 980
less 1 w 984
air 2 w 987
in 11 w 989
it 16 w 991
Or 3 w 994
because 3 w 1001
it 17 w 1003
containeth 1 w 1013
much 2 w 1017
salt 1 w 1021
from 3 w 1025
the 17 w 1028
earth 1 w 1033
mingled 1 w 1040
therewith 1 w 1049
now 2 w 1054
it 19 w 1056
is 5 w 1058
well 1 w 1062
known 1 w 1067
that 4 w 1071
salt 2 w 1075
above 1 w 1080
all 2 w 1083
other 1 w 1088
things 1 w 1094
causeth 1 w 1101
leanness 1 w 1109
Or 4 w 1112
because 4 w 1119
standing 1 w 1127
still 1 w 1132
and 14 w 1136
not 3 w 1139
exercised 1 w 1148
with 4 w 1152
running 1 w 1159
and 15 w 1162
stirring 1 w 1170
it 21 w 1173
getteth 1 w 1180
a 77 w 1181
certain 1 w 1188
malignant 1 w 1197
quality 1 w 1204
which 4 w 1210
is 7 w 1212
hurtful 1 w 1219
to 4 w 1221
both 1 w 1225
plants 1 w 1231
and 16 w 1234
animals 1 w 1241
and 17 w 1245
is 8 w 1247
the 20 w 1250
cause 6 w 1255
that 5 w 1259
it 23 w 1261
is 9 w 1263
neither 1 w 1270
well 2 w 1274
concocted 1 w 1283
nor 1 w 1286
able 2 w 1290
to 5 w 1292
feed 1 w 1296
and 18 w 1299
nourish 1 w 1306
any 1 w 1309
thing 2 w 1314
Hence 1 w 1320
it 25 w 1322
is 11 w 1324
that 6 w 1328
all 3 w 1331
dead 1 w 1335
waters 1 w 1341
of 4 w 1343
pools 1 w 1348
are 3 w 1351
unwholesome 1 w 1362
for 3 w 1366
that 7 w 1370
they 3 w 1374
cannot 1 w 1380
digest 1 w 1386
and 19 w 1389
despatch 1 w 1397
those 1 w 1402
harmful 1 w 1409
qualities 1 w 1418
which 5 w 1423
they 4 w 1427
borrow 1 w 1433
of 5 w 1435
the 24 w 1438
evil 1 w 1442
property 1 w 1450
of 6 w 1452
the 25 w 1455
air 3 w 1458
or 11 w 1460
of 7 w 1462
the 26 w 1465
earth 2 w 1470
XXXIV 1 w 1476
WHY 2 w 1480
IS 5 w 1482
THE 5 w 1485
WEST 1 w 1489
WIND 1 w 1493
HELD 1 w 1497
COMMONLY 1 w 1505
TO 1 w 1507
BE 2 w 1509
THE 6 w 1512
SWIFTEST 1 w 1520
ACCORDING 1 w 1530
TO 2 w 1532
THIS 1 w 1536
VERSE 1 w 1541
OF 3 w 1543
HOMER 1 w 1548
Let 1 w 1552
us 9 w 1554
likewise 1 w 1562
bestir 1 w 1568
our 2 w 1571
feet 1 w 1575
As 1 w 1578
fast 1 w 1582
as 7 w 1584
Western 1 w 1591
winds 1 w 1596
do 2 w 1598
fleet 1 w 1603
Il 1 w 1606
XIX 2 w 1610
415 1 w 1614
Is 3 w 1617
it 27 w 1619
not 5 w 1622
because 5 w 1629
this 1 w 1633
wind 2 w 1637
is 14 w 1639
wont 1 w 1643
to 6 w 1645
blow 1 w 1649
when 1 w 1653
the 27 w 1656
sky 1 w 1659
is 15 w 1661
very 1 w 1665
well 3 w 1669
cleansed 1 w 1677
and 20 w 1681
the 28 w 1684
air 4 w 1687
is 16 w 1689
exceeding 1 w 1698
clear 1 w 1703
and 21 w 1706
without 1 w 1713
all 4 w 1716
clouds 1 w 1722
for 4 w 1727
the 29 w 1730
thickness 1 w 1739
and 22 w 1742
impurity 1 w 1750
of 8 w 1752
the 30 w 1755
air 5 w 1758
doth 1 w 1762
not 6 w 1765
a 116 w 1766
little 3 w 1772
impeach 1 w 1779
and 23 w 1782
interrupt 1 w 1791
the 31 w 1794
course 1 w 1800
of 9 w 1802
the 32 w 1805
winds 2 w 1810
Or 5 w 1813
is 17 w 1815
it 31 w 1817
rather 1 w 1823
because 6 w 1830
the 34 w 1833
sun 1 w 1836
striking 1 w 1845
through 1 w 1852
a 121 w 1853
cold 2 w 1857
wind 4 w 1861
with 6 w 1865
his 2 w 1868
beams 1 w 1873
is 19 w 1876
the 35 w 1879
cause 9 w 1884
that 8 w 1888
it 33 w 1890
passeth 1 w 1897
the 36 w 1900
faster 1 w 1906
away 1 w 1910
for 5 w 1915
whatsoever 1 w 1925
of 10 w 1927
cold 3 w 1931
is 20 w 1933
drawn 1 w 1938
in 27 w 1940
by 2 w 1942
the 37 w 1945
force 1 w 1950
of 11 w 1952
the 38 w 1955
winds 3 w 1960
when 2 w 1965
the 39 w 1968
same 2 w 1972
is 21 w 1974
overcome 1 w 1982
by 3 w 1984
heat 1 w 1988
as 10 w 1991
it 34 w 1993
were 2 w 1997
its 2 w 2000
enemy 1 w 2005
we 9 w 2008
must 1 w 2012
think 1 w 2017
is 22 w 2020
driven 1 w 2026
and 24 w 2029
set 4 w 2032
forward 1 w 2039
further 1 w 2046
and 25 w 2049
with 7 w 2053
greater 1 w 2060
celerity 1 w 2068
XXXV 1 w 2073
WHY 3 w 2077
CANNOT 1 w 2083
BEES 1 w 2087
ABIDE 1 w 2092
SMOKE 1 w 2097
WHETHER 1 w 2105
is 23 w 2107
it 38 w 2109
because 7 w 2116
the 41 w 2119
passages 1 w 2127
of 12 w 2129
their 1 w 2134
vital 1 w 2139
spirits 1 w 2146
are 4 w 2149
exceeding 2 w 2158
strait 1 w 2164
and 26 w 2168
if 3 w 2171
it 42 w 2173
chance 1 w 2179
that 9 w 2183
smoke 1 w 2188
be 12 w 2190
gotten 1 w 2196
into 1 w 2200
them 2 w 2204
and 27 w 2207
there 2 w 2212
kept 1 w 2216
in 32 w 2218
and 28 w 2221
intercepted 1 w 2232
it 43 w 2235
is 24 w 2237
enough 1 w 2243
to 8 w 2245
stop 1 w 2249
the 45 w 2252
poor 1 w 2256
bees 1 w 2260
breath 1 w 2267
yea 1 w 2272
and 29 w 2276
to 10 w 2278
strangle 1 w 2286
them 3 w 2290
quite 1 w 2295
Or 6 w 2298
is 25 w 2300
not 7 w 2303
the 47 w 2306
acrimony 1 w 2314
and 30 w 2317
bitterness 1 w 2327
think 2 w 2333
you 1 w 2336
of 13 w 2339
the 48 w 2342
smoke 2 w 2347
in 35 w 2349
cause 11 w 2354
for 8 w 2358
bees 2 w 2362
are 5 w 2365
delighted 1 w 2374
with 8 w 2378
sweet 1 w 2383
things 2 w 2389
and 31 w 2393
in 37 w 2395
very 2 w 2399
truth 1 w 2404
they 5 w 2408
have 3 w 2412
no 14 w 2414
other 2 w 2419
nourishment 1 w 2430
and 32 w 2434
therefore 1 w 2443
no 16 w 2445
marvel 1 w 2451
if 4 w 2453
they 6 w 2457
detest 1 w 2463
and 33 w 2466
abhor 1 w 2471
smoke 3 w 2476
as 12 w 2479
a 164 w 2480
thing 4 w 2485
for 10 w 2488
the 53 w 2491
bitterness 2 w 2501
most 1 w 2505
adverse 1 w 2512
and 34 w 2515
contrary 1 w 2523
unto 1 w 2527
them 4 w 2531
Therefore 1 w 2541
honey-masters 1 w 2554
when 3 w 2559
they 7 w 2563
make 3 w 2567
a 170 w 2568
smoke 4 w 2573
for 12 w 2576
to 12 w 2578
drive 3 w 2583
away 2 w 2587
bees 3 w 2591
are 6 w 2595
wont 2 w 2599
to 13 w 2601
burn 1 w 2605
bitter 3 w 2611
herbs 1 w 2616
as 14 w 2619
hemlock 1 w 2626
centaury 1 w 2635
etc 1 w 2639