Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (10-12)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:10-12
Refs {'start': {'reference': '10', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 10'}, 'end': {'reference': '12', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 12'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
X.
WHY DO MEN POUR SEA-WATER UPON WINE, AND SAY THE FISHERMEN HAD AN ORACLE GIVEN THEM, WHEREBY THEY WERE BID TO DIP BACCHUS INTO THE SEA? AND WHY DO THEY THAT LIVE FAR FROM THE SEA CAST IN SOME ZACYNTHIAN EARTH TOASTED?

WHETHER that heat is good against cold? Or that it quenches heat, by diluting the wine and destroying its strength? Or that the aqueous and aerial part of wine (which is therefore prone to mutation) is stayed by the throwing in of terrene parts, whose nature it is to constipate and condense? Moreover, salts with the sea-water, attenuating and colliquating whatever is foreign and superfluous, suffer no fetidness or putrefaction to breed. Besides, the gross and terrene parts, being entangled with the heavy and sinking together, make a sediment or lees, and so make the wine fine.

XI.
WHY ARE THEY SICKER THAT SAIL ON THE SEA THAN THEY THAT SAIL IN FRESH RIVERS, EVEN IN CALM WEATHER?

OF all the senses, smelling causes nauseousness the most, and of all the passions of the mind, fear. For men tremble and shake and bewray themselves upon apprehension of great danger. They that sail in a river are troubled with neither of these. And the smell of sweet and potable water is familiar to all, and the voyage is without danger. On the sea an unusual smell is troublesome; and men are afraid, not knowing what the issue may be. Therefore tranquillity abroad avails not, while an estuating and disturbed mind disorders the body.

XII.
WHY DOES POURING OIL ON THE SEA MAKE IT CLEAR AND CALM?

Is it for that the winds, slipping the smooth oil, have no force, nor cause any waves? This may be probably said in respect of things external; but they say that divers take oil in their mouths, and when they spout it out they have light at the bottom, and it makes the water transparent; so that the slipping of the winds will not hold good here for an argument. Therefore it is to be considered, whether the sea, which is terrene and uneven, is not compacted and made smooth by the dense oil; and so the sea, being compact in itself, leaves passes, and a pellucidity penetrable by the sight. Or whether that the air, which is naturally mixed with the sea, is lucid, but by being troubled grows unequal and shady; and so by the oils density, smoothing its inequality, the sea recovers its evenness and pellucidity.

Tokens

X 1 w 1
WHY 1 w 5
DO 1 w 7
MEN 1 w 10
POUR 1 w 14
SEA-WATER 1 w 23
UPON 1 w 27
WINE 1 w 31
AND 1 w 35
SAY 1 w 38
THE 1 w 41
FISHERMEN 1 w 50
HAD 1 w 53
AN 2 w 55
ORACLE 1 w 61
GIVEN 1 w 66
THEM 1 w 70
WHEREBY 1 w 78
THEY 1 w 82
WERE 1 w 86
BID 1 w 89
TO 1 w 91
DIP 1 w 94
BACCHUS 1 w 101
INTO 1 w 105
THE 4 w 108
SEA 2 w 111
AND 2 w 115
WHY 2 w 118
DO 2 w 120
THEY 2 w 124
THAT 1 w 128
LIVE 1 w 132
FAR 1 w 135
FROM 1 w 139
THE 6 w 142
SEA 3 w 145
CAST 1 w 149
IN 3 w 151
SOME 1 w 155
ZACYNTHIAN 1 w 165
EARTH 1 w 170
TOASTED 1 w 177
WHETHER 1 w 185
that 1 w 189
heat 1 w 193
is 1 w 195
good 1 w 199
against 1 w 206
cold 1 w 210
Or 1 w 213
that 2 w 217
it 1 w 219
quenches 1 w 227
heat 2 w 231
by 1 w 234
diluting 1 w 242
the 1 w 245
wine 1 w 249
and 1 w 252
destroying 1 w 262
its 1 w 265
strength 1 w 273
Or 2 w 276
that 3 w 280
the 2 w 283
aqueous 1 w 290
and 2 w 293
aerial 1 w 299
part 1 w 303
of 1 w 305
wine 2 w 309
which 1 w 315
is 2 w 317
therefore 1 w 326
prone 1 w 331
to 1 w 333
mutation 1 w 341
is 3 w 344
stayed 1 w 350
by 2 w 352
the 4 w 355
throwing 1 w 363
in 7 w 365
of 2 w 367
terrene 1 w 374
parts 1 w 379
whose 1 w 385
nature 1 w 391
it 3 w 393
is 4 w 395
to 2 w 397
constipate 1 w 407
and 3 w 410
condense 1 w 418
Moreover 1 w 427
salts 1 w 433
with 1 w 437
the 5 w 440
sea-water 1 w 449
attenuating 1 w 461
and 4 w 464
colliquating 1 w 476
whatever 1 w 484
is 5 w 486
foreign 1 w 493
and 5 w 496
superfluous 1 w 507
suffer 1 w 514
no 1 w 516
fetidness 1 w 525
or 4 w 527
putrefaction 1 w 539
to 3 w 541
breed 1 w 546
Besides 1 w 554
the 6 w 558
gross 1 w 563
and 6 w 566
terrene 2 w 573
parts 2 w 578
being 1 w 584
entangled 1 w 593
with 2 w 597
the 7 w 600
heavy 1 w 605
and 7 w 608
sinking 1 w 615
together 1 w 623
make 1 w 628
a 36 w 629
sediment 1 w 637
or 5 w 639
lees 1 w 643
and 8 w 647
so 1 w 649
make 2 w 653
the 9 w 656
wine 3 w 660
fine 1 w 664
XI 1 w 667
WHY 3 w 671
ARE 1 w 674
THEY 3 w 678
SICKER 1 w 684
THAT 2 w 688
SAIL 1 w 692
ON 2 w 694
THE 9 w 697
SEA 4 w 700
THAN 1 w 704
THEY 4 w 708
THAT 3 w 712
SAIL 2 w 716
IN 4 w 718
FRESH 1 w 723
RIVERS 1 w 729
EVEN 1 w 734
IN 5 w 736
CALM 1 w 740
WEATHER 1 w 747
OF 1 w 750
all 1 w 753
the 10 w 756
senses 1 w 762
smelling 1 w 771
causes 1 w 777
nauseousness 1 w 789
the 11 w 792
most 1 w 796
and 9 w 800
of 3 w 802
all 2 w 805
the 12 w 808
passions 1 w 816
of 4 w 818
the 13 w 821
mind 1 w 825
fear 1 w 830
For 1 w 834
men 2 w 837
tremble 1 w 844
and 10 w 847
shake 1 w 852
and 11 w 855
bewray 1 w 861
themselves 1 w 871
upon 1 w 875
apprehension 1 w 887
of 5 w 889
great 1 w 894
danger 1 w 900
They 1 w 905
that 4 w 909
sail 1 w 913
in 17 w 915
a 55 w 916
river 1 w 921
are 1 w 924
troubled 1 w 932
with 3 w 936
neither 1 w 943
of 6 w 945
these 1 w 950
And 1 w 954
the 17 w 957
smell 2 w 962
of 7 w 964
sweet 1 w 969
and 12 w 972
potable 1 w 979
water 2 w 984
is 6 w 986
familiar 1 w 994
to 5 w 996
all 3 w 999
and 13 w 1003
the 18 w 1006
voyage 1 w 1012
is 7 w 1014
without 1 w 1021
danger 2 w 1027
On 1 w 1030
the 19 w 1033
sea 2 w 1036
an 17 w 1038
unusual 1 w 1045
smell 3 w 1050
is 8 w 1052
troublesome 1 w 1063
and 14 w 1067
men 3 w 1070
are 2 w 1073
afraid 1 w 1079
not 1 w 1083
knowing 1 w 1090
what 2 w 1094
the 20 w 1097
issue 1 w 1102
may 1 w 1105
be 3 w 1107
Therefore 1 w 1117
tranquillity 1 w 1129
abroad 1 w 1135
avails 1 w 1141
not 2 w 1144
while 1 w 1150
an 20 w 1152
estuating 1 w 1161
and 15 w 1164
disturbed 1 w 1173
mind 2 w 1177
disorders 1 w 1186
the 21 w 1189
body 1 w 1193
XII 1 w 1197
WHY 4 w 1201
DOES 1 w 1205
POURING 1 w 1212
OIL 1 w 1215
ON 3 w 1217
THE 12 w 1220
SEA 5 w 1223
MAKE 1 w 1227
IT 1 w 1229
CLEAR 1 w 1234
AND 3 w 1237
CALM 2 w 1241
Is 1 w 1244
it 10 w 1246
for 4 w 1249
that 5 w 1253
the 22 w 1256
winds 1 w 1261
slipping 1 w 1270
the 23 w 1273
smooth 1 w 1279
oil 1 w 1282
have 1 w 1287
no 5 w 1289
force 1 w 1294
nor 1 w 1298
cause 2 w 1303
any 1 w 1306
waves 1 w 1311
This 1 w 1316
may 2 w 1319
be 5 w 1321
probably 1 w 1329
said 1 w 1333
in 23 w 1335
respect 1 w 1342
of 8 w 1344
things 1 w 1350
external 1 w 1358
but 1 w 1362
they 1 w 1366
say 1 w 1369
that 6 w 1373
divers 1 w 1379
take 1 w 1383
oil 2 w 1386
in 25 w 1388
their 1 w 1393
mouths 1 w 1399
and 16 w 1403
when 1 w 1407
they 2 w 1411
spout 1 w 1416
it 11 w 1418
out 4 w 1421
they 3 w 1425
have 2 w 1429
light 1 w 1434
at 21 w 1436
the 28 w 1439
bottom 1 w 1445
and 17 w 1449
it 12 w 1451
makes 1 w 1456
the 29 w 1459
water 3 w 1464
transparent 1 w 1475
so 4 w 1478
that 7 w 1482
the 30 w 1485
slipping 2 w 1493
of 9 w 1495
the 31 w 1498
winds 2 w 1503
will 1 w 1507
not 3 w 1510
hold 1 w 1514
good 2 w 1518
here 3 w 1522
for 6 w 1525
an 26 w 1527
argument 1 w 1535
Therefore 2 w 1545
it 13 w 1547
is 13 w 1549
to 7 w 1551
be 6 w 1553
considered 1 w 1563
whether 1 w 1571
the 33 w 1574
sea 3 w 1577
which 2 w 1583
is 14 w 1585
terrene 3 w 1592
and 18 w 1595
uneven 1 w 1601
is 15 w 1604
not 4 w 1607
compacted 1 w 1616
and 19 w 1619
made 1 w 1623
smooth 2 w 1629
by 3 w 1631
the 34 w 1634
dense 2 w 1639
oil 3 w 1642
and 20 w 1646
so 5 w 1648
the 35 w 1651
sea 4 w 1654
being 2 w 1660
compact 2 w 1667
in 29 w 1669
itself 1 w 1675
leaves 1 w 1682
passes 1 w 1688
and 21 w 1692
a 117 w 1693
pellucidity 1 w 1704
penetrable 1 w 1714
by 4 w 1716
the 36 w 1719
sight 1 w 1724
Or 3 w 1727
whether 2 w 1734
that 8 w 1738
the 38 w 1741
air 1 w 1744
which 3 w 1750
is 16 w 1752
naturally 1 w 1761
mixed 1 w 1766
with 5 w 1770
the 39 w 1773
sea 5 w 1776
is 17 w 1779
lucid 2 w 1784
but 2 w 1788
by 5 w 1790
being 3 w 1795
troubled 2 w 1803
grows 1 w 1808
unequal 1 w 1815
and 22 w 1818
shady 1 w 1823
and 23 w 1827
so 6 w 1829
by 6 w 1831
the 40 w 1834
oil 4 w 1837
s 110 w 1839
density 1 w 1846
smoothing 1 w 1856
its 3 w 1859
inequality 1 w 1869
the 41 w 1873
sea 6 w 1876
recovers 1 w 1884
its 4 w 1887
evenness 1 w 1895
and 24 w 1898
pellucidity 2 w 1909