Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Of Herodotus's Malice.

Of Herodotus's Malice. (14-16)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg123.perseus-eng2:14-16
Refs {'start': {'reference': '14', 'human_reference': 'Section 14'}, 'end': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Section 16'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Nor is this impious enough; but moreover, deriving the pedigree of Hercules from Perseus, he says that Perseus was an Assyrian, as the Persians affirm. But the leaders, says he, of the Dorians may appear to be descended in a right line from the Egyptians, reckoning their ancestors from before Danae and Acrisius. [*] Here he has wholly passed by Epaphus, Io, Iasus, and Argus, being ambitious not only to make the other Herculeses Egyptians and Phoenicians, but to carry this also, whom himself affirms to have been the third, out of Greece to the barbarians. But of the ancient learned writers, neither Homer, nor Hesiod, or Archilochus, nor Pisander, nor Stesichorus, nor Alcman, nor Pindar, makes any mention of the Egyptian or the Phoenician Hercules, but all acknowledge this our own Boeotian and Argive Hercules.

Now of the seven sages, whom he calls Sophisters, he affirms Thales to have been a barbarian, descended of the Phoenicians.[*] Speaking ill also of the Gods under the person of Solon, he has these words: Thou, O Croesus, askest me concerning human affairs, who know that every one of the Deities is envious and tumultuous. [*] Thus attributing to Solon what himself thinks of the Gods, he joins malice to blasphemy. Having made use also of Pittacus in some trivial matters, not worth the mentioning, he has passed over the greatest and gallantest action that was ever done by him. For when the Athenians and

Mitylenaeans were at war about Sigaeum, Phrynon, the Athenian general, challenging whoever would come forth to a single combat, Pittacus advanced to meet him, and catching him in a net, slew that stout and giant-like man; for which when the Mitylenaeans offered him great presents, darting his javelin as far as he could out of his hand, he desired only so much ground as he should reach with that throw; and the place is to this day called Pittacium. Now what does Herodotus, when he comes to this? Instead of Pittacuss valiant act, he tells us the fight of Alcaeus the poet, who throwing away his arms ran out of the battle; by thus not writing of honorable deeds and not passing over such as are dishonorable, he gives his testimony to those who say, that from one and the same malice proceed both envy and a rejoicing at other mens harms.[*]

After this, he accuses of treason the Alcmaeonidae, who showed themselves generous men, and delivered their country from tyranny.[*] He says, that they received Pisistratus after his banishment and got him called home, on condition he should marry the daughter of Megacles; but the damsel saying to her mother, Do you see, mother, how I am not known by Pisistratus according to nature? the Alcmaeonidae were so offended at this villany, that they expelled the tyrant.

Tokens

Nor 1 w 3
is 1 w 5
this 1 w 9
impious 1 w 16
enough 1 w 22
but 1 w 26
moreover 1 w 34
deriving 1 w 43
the 1 w 46
pedigree 1 w 54
of 1 w 56
Hercules 1 w 64
from 1 w 68
Perseus 1 w 75
he 2 w 78
says 1 w 82
that 1 w 86
Perseus 2 w 93
was 1 w 96
an 1 w 98
Assyrian 1 w 106
as 2 w 109
the 2 w 112
Persians 1 w 120
affirm 1 w 126
But 1 w 130
the 3 w 133
leaders 1 w 140
says 2 w 145
he 5 w 147
of 2 w 150
the 4 w 153
Dorians 1 w 160
may 1 w 163
appear 1 w 169
to 1 w 171
be 1 w 173
descended 1 w 182
in 2 w 184
a 15 w 185
right 1 w 190
line 1 w 194
from 2 w 198
the 5 w 201
Egyptians 1 w 210
reckoning 1 w 220
their 1 w 225
ancestors 1 w 234
from 3 w 238
before 1 w 244
Danae 1 w 249
and 1 w 252
Acrisius 1 w 260
Herod 1 w 266
VI 1 w 269
53 1 w 272
54 1 w 275
Here 1 w 280
he 9 w 282
has 1 w 285
wholly 1 w 291
passed 1 w 297
by 1 w 299
Epaphus 1 w 306
Io 1 w 309
Iasus 1 w 315
and 2 w 319
Argus 1 w 324
being 1 w 330
ambitious 1 w 339
not 1 w 342
only 1 w 346
to 3 w 348
make 1 w 352
the 7 w 355
other 1 w 360
Herculeses 1 w 370
Egyptians 2 w 379
and 3 w 382
Phoenicians 1 w 393
but 2 w 397
to 4 w 399
carry 1 w 404
this 2 w 408
also 1 w 412
whom 1 w 417
himself 1 w 424
affirms 1 w 431
to 5 w 433
have 1 w 437
been 1 w 441
the 9 w 444
third 1 w 449
out 1 w 453
of 3 w 455
Greece 1 w 461
to 6 w 463
the 10 w 466
barbarians 1 w 476
But 2 w 480
of 4 w 482
the 11 w 485
ancient 1 w 492
learned 1 w 499
writers 1 w 506
neither 1 w 514
Homer 1 w 519
nor 1 w 523
Hesiod 1 w 529
or 7 w 532
Archilochus 1 w 543
nor 2 w 547
Pisander 1 w 555
nor 3 w 559
Stesichorus 1 w 570
nor 4 w 574
Alcman 1 w 580
nor 5 w 584
Pindar 1 w 590
makes 1 w 596
any 1 w 599
mention 1 w 606
of 5 w 608
the 13 w 611
Egyptian 3 w 619
or 13 w 621
the 14 w 624
Phoenician 2 w 634
Hercules 3 w 642
but 3 w 646
all 1 w 649
acknowledge 1 w 660
this 3 w 664
our 1 w 667
own 1 w 670
Boeotian 1 w 678
and 5 w 681
Argive 1 w 687
Hercules 4 w 695
Now 1 w 699
of 6 w 701
the 15 w 704
seven 1 w 709
sages 1 w 714
whom 2 w 719
he 19 w 721
calls 1 w 726
Sophisters 1 w 736
he 20 w 739
affirms 2 w 746
Thales 1 w 752
to 7 w 754
have 2 w 758
been 2 w 762
a 56 w 763
barbarian 2 w 772
descended 2 w 782
of 7 w 784
the 16 w 787
Phoenicians 2 w 798
Herod 2 w 804
I 4 w 806
170 1 w 810
Speaking 1 w 819
ill 1 w 822
also 2 w 826
of 8 w 828
the 17 w 831
Gods 1 w 835
under 1 w 840
the 18 w 843
person 1 w 849
of 9 w 851
Solon 1 w 856
he 24 w 859
has 2 w 862
these 1 w 867
words 1 w 872
Thou 1 w 877
O 1 w 879
Croesus 1 w 886
askest 1 w 893
me 3 w 895
concerning 1 w 905
human 1 w 910
affairs 1 w 917
who 4 w 921
know 2 w 925
that 2 w 929
every 1 w 934
one 1 w 937
of 10 w 939
the 20 w 942
Deities 1 w 949
is 8 w 951
envious 1 w 958
and 6 w 961
tumultuous 1 w 971
Herod 3 w 977
I 5 w 979
32 1 w 982
Thus 1 w 987
attributing 1 w 998
to 8 w 1000
Solon 2 w 1005
what 1 w 1009
himself 2 w 1016
thinks 1 w 1022
of 11 w 1024
the 21 w 1027
Gods 2 w 1031
he 28 w 1034
joins 1 w 1039
malice 1 w 1045
to 9 w 1047
blasphemy 1 w 1056
Having 1 w 1063
made 1 w 1067
use 1 w 1070
also 3 w 1074
of 12 w 1076
Pittacus 1 w 1084
in 13 w 1086
some 1 w 1090
trivial 1 w 1097
matters 1 w 1104
not 2 w 1108
worth 1 w 1113
the 22 w 1116
mentioning 1 w 1126
he 31 w 1129
has 3 w 1132
passed 2 w 1138
over 2 w 1142
the 23 w 1145
greatest 1 w 1153
and 7 w 1156
gallantest 1 w 1166
action 1 w 1172
that 3 w 1176
was 2 w 1179
ever 2 w 1183
done 1 w 1187
by 2 w 1189
him 3 w 1192
For 1 w 1196
when 1 w 1200
the 24 w 1203
Athenians 1 w 1212
and 8 w 1215
Mitylenaeans 1 w 1227
were 1 w 1231
at 8 w 1233
war 1 w 1236
about 1 w 1241
Sigaeum 1 w 1248
Phrynon 1 w 1256
the 26 w 1260
Athenian 2 w 1268
general 1 w 1275
challenging 1 w 1287
whoever 1 w 1294
would 1 w 1299
come 1 w 1303
forth 1 w 1308
to 10 w 1310
a 100 w 1311
single 1 w 1317
combat 1 w 1323
Pittacus 2 w 1332
advanced 1 w 1340
to 11 w 1342
meet 1 w 1346
him 4 w 1349
and 9 w 1353
catching 1 w 1361
him 5 w 1364
in 18 w 1366
a 107 w 1367
net 1 w 1370
slew 1 w 1375
that 4 w 1379
stout 1 w 1384
and 10 w 1387
giant-like 1 w 1397
man 3 w 1400
for 3 w 1404
which 1 w 1409
when 2 w 1413
the 28 w 1416
Mitylenaeans 2 w 1428
offered 1 w 1435
him 6 w 1438
great 2 w 1443
presents 1 w 1451
darting 1 w 1459
his 5 w 1462
javelin 1 w 1469
as 12 w 1471
far 1 w 1474
as 13 w 1476
he 40 w 1478
could 1 w 1483
out 4 w 1486
of 14 w 1488
his 6 w 1491
hand 1 w 1495
he 41 w 1498
desired 1 w 1505
only 2 w 1509
so 6 w 1511
much 1 w 1515
ground 1 w 1521
as 14 w 1523
he 42 w 1525
should 1 w 1531
reach 1 w 1536
with 1 w 1540
that 5 w 1544
throw 1 w 1549
and 12 w 1553
the 29 w 1556
place 1 w 1561
is 11 w 1563
to 13 w 1565
this 4 w 1569
day 1 w 1572
called 1 w 1578
Pittacium 1 w 1587
Now 2 w 1591
what 2 w 1595
does 1 w 1599
Herodotus 1 w 1608
when 3 w 1613
he 45 w 1615
comes 1 w 1620
to 14 w 1622
this 5 w 1626
Instead 1 w 1634
of 15 w 1636
Pittacus 3 w 1644
s 121 w 1646
valiant 1 w 1653
act 2 w 1656
he 46 w 1659
tells 1 w 1664
us 20 w 1666
the 30 w 1669
fight 1 w 1674
of 16 w 1676
Alcaeus 1 w 1683
the 31 w 1686
poet 1 w 1690
who 6 w 1694
throwing 1 w 1702
away 1 w 1706
his 9 w 1709
arms 1 w 1713
ran 1 w 1716
out 5 w 1719
of 17 w 1721
the 32 w 1724
battle 1 w 1730
by 3 w 1733
thus 1 w 1737
not 3 w 1740
writing 1 w 1747
of 18 w 1749
honorable 1 w 1758
deeds 1 w 1763
and 13 w 1766
not 4 w 1769
passing 1 w 1776
over 3 w 1780
such 1 w 1784
as 16 w 1786
are 1 w 1789
dishonorable 1 w 1801
he 50 w 1804
gives 1 w 1809
his 10 w 1812
testimony 1 w 1821
to 15 w 1823
those 1 w 1828
who 7 w 1831
say 3 w 1834
that 6 w 1839
from 4 w 1843
one 3 w 1846
and 14 w 1849
the 33 w 1852
same 1 w 1856
malice 2 w 1862
proceed 1 w 1869
both 1 w 1873
envy 1 w 1877
and 15 w 1880
a 153 w 1881
rejoicing 1 w 1890
at 17 w 1892
other 2 w 1897
men 3 w 1900
s 140 w 1902
harms 1 w 1907
Herod 5 w 1913
V 2 w 1915
95 1 w 1918
After 1 w 1924
this 6 w 1928
he 53 w 1931
accuses 1 w 1938
of 19 w 1940
treason 1 w 1947
the 35 w 1950
Alcmaeonidae 1 w 1962
who 8 w 1966
showed 1 w 1972
themselves 1 w 1982
generous 1 w 1990
men 4 w 1993
and 16 w 1997
delivered 1 w 2006
their 2 w 2011
country 1 w 2018
from 5 w 2022
tyranny 1 w 2029
Herod 6 w 2035
I 7 w 2037
61 1 w 2040
He 13 w 2043
says 3 w 2047
that 7 w 2052
they 1 w 2056
received 1 w 2064
Pisistratus 1 w 2075
after 1 w 2080
his 12 w 2083
banishment 1 w 2093
and 17 w 2096
got 1 w 2099
him 7 w 2102
called 2 w 2108
home 1 w 2112
on 20 w 2115
condition 1 w 2124
he 58 w 2126
should 2 w 2132
marry 1 w 2137
the 39 w 2140
daughter 1 w 2148
of 20 w 2150
Megacles 1 w 2158
but 5 w 2162
the 40 w 2165
damsel 1 w 2171
saying 1 w 2177
to 16 w 2179
her 4 w 2182
mother 1 w 2188
Do 2 w 2191
you 1 w 2194
see 1 w 2197
mother 2 w 2204
how 2 w 2208
I 8 w 2209
am 4 w 2211
not 5 w 2214
known 1 w 2219
by 4 w 2221
Pisistratus 2 w 2232
according 1 w 2241
to 17 w 2243
nature 1 w 2249
the 43 w 2253
Alcmaeonidae 2 w 2265
were 2 w 2269
so 8 w 2271
offended 1 w 2279
at 22 w 2281
this 7 w 2285
villany 1 w 2292
that 8 w 2297
they 2 w 2301
expelled 1 w 2309
the 45 w 2312
tyrant 1 w 2318