Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Symposiacs

Symposiacs (1.9.1)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg112.perseus-eng2:1.9.1
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.9.1', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 9 Section 1'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.9'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

THEON the grammarian, when Metrius Florus gave us an entertainment, asked Themistocles the Stoic, why Chrysippus, though he frequently mentioned some strange phenomena in nature (as that salt fish soaked in salt water grows fresher than before, fleeces of wool are more easily separated by a gentle than a quick and violent force, and men that are fasting eat slower than those who took a breakfast), yet never gave any reason for the appearance. And Themistocles replied, that Chrysippus only proposed such things by the by, as instances to correct us, who easily and without any reason assent to what seems likely,

and disbelieve every thing that seems unlikely at the first sight. But why, sir, are you concerned at this? For if you are speculative and would enquire into the causes of things, you need not want subjects in your own profession; but pray tell me why Homer makes Nausicaa wash in the river rather than the sea, though it was near, and in all likelihood hotter, clearer, and fitter to wash with than that?

Tokens

THEON 1 w 5
the 1 w 8
grammarian 1 w 18
when 1 w 23
Metrius 1 w 30
Florus 1 w 36
gave 1 w 40
us 3 w 42
an 2 w 44
entertainment 1 w 57
asked 1 w 63
Themistocles 1 w 75
the 2 w 78
Stoic 1 w 83
why 1 w 87
Chrysippus 1 w 97
though 1 w 104
he 5 w 106
frequently 1 w 116
mentioned 1 w 125
some 1 w 129
strange 1 w 136
phenomena 1 w 145
in 2 w 147
nature 1 w 153
as 2 w 156
that 1 w 160
salt 1 w 164
fish 1 w 168
soaked 1 w 174
in 3 w 176
salt 2 w 180
water 1 w 185
grows 1 w 190
fresher 1 w 197
than 1 w 201
before 1 w 207
fleeces 1 w 215
of 1 w 217
wool 1 w 221
are 1 w 224
more 1 w 228
easily 1 w 234
separated 1 w 243
by 1 w 245
a 22 w 246
gentle 1 w 252
than 2 w 256
a 24 w 257
quick 1 w 262
and 1 w 265
violent 1 w 272
force 1 w 277
and 2 w 281
men 4 w 284
that 2 w 288
are 2 w 291
fasting 1 w 298
eat 1 w 301
slower 1 w 307
than 3 w 311
those 1 w 316
who 1 w 319
took 1 w 323
a 32 w 324
breakfast 1 w 333
yet 1 w 338
never 1 w 343
gave 2 w 347
any 1 w 350
reason 1 w 356
for 3 w 359
the 3 w 362
appearance 1 w 372
And 1 w 376
Themistocles 2 w 388
replied 1 w 395
that 3 w 400
Chrysippus 2 w 410
only 1 w 414
proposed 1 w 422
such 1 w 426
things 1 w 432
by 2 w 434
the 4 w 437
by 3 w 439
as 7 w 442
instances 1 w 451
to 5 w 453
correct 1 w 460
us 6 w 462
who 2 w 466
easily 2 w 472
and 3 w 475
without 1 w 482
any 2 w 485
reason 2 w 491
assent 1 w 497
to 6 w 499
what 1 w 503
seems 1 w 508
likely 1 w 514
and 4 w 518
disbelieve 1 w 528
every 1 w 533
thing 2 w 538
that 4 w 542
seems 2 w 547
unlikely 1 w 555
at 10 w 557
the 5 w 560
first 1 w 565
sight 1 w 570
But 1 w 574
why 2 w 577
sir 1 w 581
are 3 w 585
you 1 w 588
concerned 1 w 597
at 11 w 599
this 1 w 603
For 1 w 607
if 1 w 609
you 2 w 612
are 4 w 615
speculative 1 w 626
and 5 w 629
would 1 w 634
enquire 1 w 641
into 1 w 645
the 6 w 648
causes 1 w 654
of 2 w 656
things 2 w 662
you 3 w 666
need 1 w 670
not 1 w 673
want 1 w 677
subjects 1 w 685
in 10 w 687
your 1 w 691
own 1 w 694
profession 1 w 704
but 1 w 708
pray 1 w 712
tell 1 w 716
me 6 w 718
why 3 w 721
Homer 1 w 726
makes 1 w 731
Nausicaa 1 w 739
wash 1 w 743
in 11 w 745
the 7 w 748
river 1 w 753
rather 1 w 759
than 4 w 763
the 9 w 766
sea 1 w 769
though 2 w 776
it 2 w 778
was 2 w 781
near 1 w 785
and 6 w 789
in 12 w 791
all 1 w 794
likelihood 1 w 804
hotter 1 w 810
clearer 1 w 818
and 7 w 822
fitter 1 w 828
to 8 w 830
wash 2 w 834
with 2 w 838
than 5 w 842
that 5 w 846