Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Symposiacs

Symposiacs (1.1.3)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg112.perseus-eng2:1.1.3
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.1.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 1 Section 3'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And when you affirmed that none ought to oppose what Crato said, but determine what sorts of philosophical topics were to be admitted as fit companions at a feast, and so avoid that just and pleasant taunt put upon the wrangling disputers of the age,

Come now to supper, that we may contend;
and when you seemed concerned and urged us to speak to that head, I first replied: Sir, we must consider what company we have; for if the greater part of the guests are learned men,—as for instance, at Agathos entertainment, men like Socrates, Phaedrus, Pausanias, Euryximachus; or at Calliass board, Charmides, Antisthenes, Hermogenes, and the like,—we will permit them to philosophize, and to mix Bacchus with the Muses as well as with the Nymphs; for the latter make him wholesome
and gentle to the body, and the other pleasant and agreeable to the soul. And if there are some few illiterate persons present, they, as mute consonants with vowels, in the midst of the other learned, will participate in a voice not altogether inarticulate and insignificant. But if the greater part consists of such who can better endure the noise of any bird, fiddle-string, or piece of wood than the voice of a philosopher, Pisistratus hath shown us what to do; for being at difference with his sons, when he heard his enemies rejoiced at it, in a full assembly he declared that he had endeavored to persuade his sons to submit to him, but since he found them obstinate, he was resolved to yield and submit to their humors. So a philosopher, midst those companions that slight his excellent discourse, will lay aside his gravity, follow them, and comply with their humor as far as decency will permit; knowing very well that men cannot exercise their rhetoric unless they speak, but may their philosophy even whilst they are silent or jest merrily, nay, whilst they are piqued upon or repartee. For it is not only (as Plato says) the highest degree of injustice not to be just and yet seem so; but it is the top of wisdom to philosophize, yet not appear to do it; and in mirth to do the same with those that are serious, and yet seem in earnest. For as in Euripides, the Bacchae, though unprovided of iron weapons and unarmed, wounded their invaders with their boughs, thus the very jests and merry talk of true philosophers move and correct in some sort those that are not altogether insensible.

And 1 w 3
when 1 w 7
you 1 w 10
affirmed 1 w 18
that 1 w 22
none 1 w 26
ought 1 w 31
to 1 w 33
oppose 1 w 39
what 1 w 43
Crato 1 w 48
said 1 w 52
but 1 w 56
determine 1 w 65
what 2 w 69
sorts 1 w 74
of 1 w 76
philosophical 1 w 89
topics 1 w 95
were 1 w 99
to 4 w 101
be 1 w 103
admitted 1 w 111
as 1 w 113
fit 1 w 116
companions 1 w 126
at 5 w 128
a 12 w 129
feast 1 w 134
and 1 w 138
so 3 w 140
avoid 1 w 145
that 2 w 149
just 1 w 153
and 2 w 156
pleasant 1 w 164
taunt 1 w 169
put 1 w 172
upon 1 w 176
the 1 w 179
wrangling 1 w 188
disputers 1 w 197
of 2 w 199
the 2 w 202
age 1 w 205
Come 1 w 210
now 1 w 213
to 5 w 215
supper 1 w 221
that 3 w 226
we 2 w 228
may 1 w 231
contend 1 w 238
and 3 w 242
when 2 w 246
you 2 w 249
seemed 1 w 255
concerned 1 w 264
and 4 w 267
urged 1 w 272
us 2 w 274
to 6 w 276
speak 1 w 281
to 7 w 283
that 4 w 287
head 1 w 291
I 1 w 293
first 1 w 298
replied 1 w 305
Sir 1 w 309
we 3 w 312
must 1 w 316
consider 1 w 324
what 3 w 328
company 1 w 335
we 4 w 337
have 1 w 341
for 1 w 345
if 1 w 347
the 3 w 350
greater 1 w 357
part 1 w 361
of 3 w 363
the 4 w 366
guests 1 w 372
are 1 w 375
learned 1 w 382
men 1 w 385
as 4 w 389
for 2 w 392
instance 1 w 400
at 11 w 403
Agatho 1 w 409
s 26 w 411
entertainment 1 w 424
men 3 w 428
like 1 w 432
Socrates 1 w 440
Phaedrus 1 w 449
Pausanias 1 w 459
Euryximachus 1 w 472
or 4 w 475
at 14 w 477
Callias 1 w 484
s 33 w 486
board 1 w 491
Charmides 1 w 501
Antisthenes 1 w 513
Hermogenes 1 w 524
and 5 w 528
the 6 w 531
like 2 w 535
we 5 w 539
will 1 w 543
permit 1 w 549
them 1 w 553
to 8 w 555
philosophize 1 w 567
and 6 w 571
to 9 w 573
mix 1 w 576
Bacchus 1 w 583
with 1 w 587
the 8 w 590
Muses 1 w 595
as 7 w 597
well 1 w 601
as 8 w 603
with 2 w 607
the 9 w 610
Nymphs 1 w 616
for 3 w 620
the 10 w 623
latter 1 w 629
make 1 w 633
him 1 w 636
wholesome 1 w 645
and 7 w 648
gentle 1 w 654
to 10 w 656
the 11 w 659
body 1 w 663
and 8 w 667
the 12 w 670
other 1 w 675
pleasant 2 w 683
and 9 w 686
agreeable 1 w 695
to 11 w 697
the 14 w 700
soul 1 w 704
And 2 w 708
if 2 w 710
there 1 w 715
are 2 w 718
some 2 w 722
few 1 w 725
illiterate 1 w 735
persons 1 w 742
present 1 w 749
they 1 w 754
as 10 w 757
mute 1 w 761
consonants 1 w 771
with 3 w 775
vowels 1 w 781
in 5 w 784
the 17 w 787
midst 1 w 792
of 4 w 794
the 18 w 797
other 2 w 802
learned 2 w 809
will 2 w 814
participate 1 w 825
in 6 w 827
a 74 w 828
voice 1 w 833
not 1 w 836
altogether 1 w 846
inarticulate 1 w 858
and 10 w 861
insignificant 1 w 874
But 1 w 878
if 4 w 880
the 21 w 883
greater 2 w 890
part 3 w 894
consists 1 w 902
of 5 w 904
such 1 w 908
who 2 w 911
can 2 w 914
better 1 w 920
endure 1 w 926
the 22 w 929
noise 1 w 934
of 6 w 936
any 2 w 939
bird 1 w 943
fiddle-string 1 w 957
or 6 w 960
piece 1 w 965
of 7 w 967
wood 1 w 971
than 1 w 975
the 23 w 978
voice 2 w 983
of 8 w 985
a 85 w 986
philosopher 1 w 997
Pisistratus 1 w 1009
hath 1 w 1013
shown 1 w 1018
us 10 w 1020
what 4 w 1024
to 13 w 1026
do 1 w 1028
for 4 w 1032
being 1 w 1037
at 23 w 1039
difference 1 w 1049
with 4 w 1053
his 1 w 1056
sons 2 w 1060
when 3 w 1065
he 29 w 1067
heard 1 w 1072
his 2 w 1075
enemies 1 w 1082
rejoiced 1 w 1090
at 24 w 1092
it 9 w 1094
in 11 w 1097
a 92 w 1098
full 1 w 1102
assembly 1 w 1110
he 31 w 1112
declared 1 w 1120
that 5 w 1124
he 32 w 1126
had 1 w 1129
endeavored 1 w 1139
to 14 w 1141
persuade 1 w 1149
his 3 w 1152
sons 3 w 1156
to 15 w 1158
submit 1 w 1164
to 16 w 1166
him 2 w 1169
but 2 w 1173
since 1 w 1178
he 33 w 1180
found 1 w 1185
them 2 w 1189
obstinate 1 w 1198
he 35 w 1201
was 1 w 1204
resolved 1 w 1212
to 17 w 1214
yield 1 w 1219
and 11 w 1222
submit 2 w 1228
to 18 w 1230
their 1 w 1235
humors 1 w 1241
So 2 w 1244
a 102 w 1245
philosopher 2 w 1256
midst 2 w 1262
those 1 w 1267
companions 2 w 1277
that 6 w 1281
slight 1 w 1287
his 4 w 1290
excellent 1 w 1299
discourse 1 w 1308
will 3 w 1313
lay 1 w 1316
aside 1 w 1321
his 5 w 1324
gravity 1 w 1331
follow 1 w 1338
them 3 w 1342
and 12 w 1346
comply 1 w 1352
with 5 w 1356
their 2 w 1361
humor 2 w 1366
as 14 w 1368
far 1 w 1371
as 15 w 1373
decency 1 w 1380
will 4 w 1384
permit 2 w 1390
knowing 1 w 1398
very 1 w 1402
well 2 w 1406
that 7 w 1410
men 4 w 1413
cannot 1 w 1419
exercise 1 w 1427
their 3 w 1432
rhetoric 1 w 1440
unless 1 w 1446
they 2 w 1450
speak 2 w 1455
but 3 w 1459
may 2 w 1462
their 4 w 1467
philosophy 1 w 1477
even 1 w 1481
whilst 1 w 1487
they 3 w 1491
are 4 w 1494
silent 1 w 1500
or 12 w 1502
jest 1 w 1506
merrily 1 w 1513
nay 1 w 1517
whilst 2 w 1524
they 4 w 1528
are 5 w 1531
piqued 1 w 1537
upon 2 w 1541
or 13 w 1543
repartee 1 w 1551
For 1 w 1555
it 15 w 1557
is 14 w 1559
not 3 w 1562
only 1 w 1566
as 16 w 1569
Plato 1 w 1574
says 1 w 1578
the 33 w 1582
highest 1 w 1589
degree 1 w 1595
of 9 w 1597
injustice 1 w 1606
not 4 w 1609
to 21 w 1611
be 4 w 1613
just 3 w 1617
and 13 w 1620
yet 1 w 1623
seem 2 w 1627
so 16 w 1629
but 4 w 1633
it 16 w 1635
is 15 w 1637
the 34 w 1640
top 2 w 1643
of 10 w 1645
wisdom 1 w 1651
to 23 w 1653
philosophize 2 w 1665
yet 2 w 1669
not 5 w 1672
appear 1 w 1678
to 24 w 1680
do 3 w 1682
it 17 w 1684
and 14 w 1688
in 16 w 1690
mirth 1 w 1695
to 25 w 1697
do 4 w 1699
the 35 w 1702
same 1 w 1706
with 6 w 1710
those 2 w 1715
that 8 w 1719
are 6 w 1722
serious 1 w 1729
and 15 w 1733
yet 3 w 1736
seem 3 w 1740
in 17 w 1742
earnest 1 w 1749
For 2 w 1753
as 17 w 1755
in 18 w 1757
Euripides 1 w 1766
the 36 w 1770
Bacchae 1 w 1777
though 1 w 1784
unprovided 1 w 1794
of 11 w 1796
iron 1 w 1800
weapons 1 w 1807
and 16 w 1810
unarmed 1 w 1817
wounded 1 w 1825
their 5 w 1830
invaders 1 w 1838
with 7 w 1842
their 6 w 1847
boughs 1 w 1853
thus 1 w 1858
the 39 w 1861
very 2 w 1865
jests 1 w 1870
and 17 w 1873
merry 1 w 1878
talk 1 w 1882
of 12 w 1884
true 1 w 1888
philosophers 1 w 1900
move 1 w 1904
and 18 w 1907
correct 1 w 1914
in 20 w 1916
some 3 w 1920
sort 2 w 1924
those 3 w 1929
that 9 w 1933
are 7 w 1936
not 6 w 1939
altogether 2 w 1949
insensible 1 w 1959