Of Garrulity, or Talkativeness (5-6)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg101.perseus-eng4:5-6

Refs	`{'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}}`
Ancestors	`[]`
Children	`[]`

plain text • XML

Lysias had given to a certain accused criminal an oration of his own writing. He, having read it several times over, came to Lysias very much dejected, and told him that, upon his first perusal of it, it seemed to him to be a most admirable piece; but after he had read it three or four times over, he could see nothing in it but what was very dull and insipid. To whom Lysias, smiling: What, said he, is not once enough to speak it before the judges? And yet do but consider the persuasive eloquence and grace that is in Lysias’s writing, and then I may be bold to affirm,

That no man living e’er was favored more

By sacred Muse that violet garlands wore.

Certain it is that, of all the commendations that were ever given to Homer, this is the truest, that he alone avoided being irksome to his readers, as one that was always new and still flourishing, as it were in the prime of poetic beauty. And yet in speaking thus of himself,

I hate vain repetitions, fondly made,

Of what has been already plainly said,
[*]

he shows how careful he is to shun that satiety which, as it were, lies in wait for all speech, alluring the ear from one relation into another, and still recreating the reader with fresh variety, in such a manner that he never thinks himself satisfied. Whereas men that let their tongues run at random rend and tear the ears with their tautologies, like those that, after writing-tables have been newly cleansed and wiped, deface them again with their impertinent scrawls and scratches.

And therefore we would have them to remember this in the first place, that, as they who constrain men to guzzle down wine unmixed with water, and to excess, are the occasion that what was bestowed at first on men as a blessing, to excite mirth and rejoice the heart, becomes a mischief, creating sadness and causing drunkenness; so they that make an ill and inconsiderate use of speech, which is the most delightful means of human converse, render it both troublesome and unsociable, molesting those whom they think to gratify, derided by those whose esteem and admiration they covet, and offensive to such whose love and friendship they seek. And therefore, as he may be truly said to be no favorite of Venus, who with the girdle of the Goddess, wherein are all manner of allurements, drives and chases away his familiar acquaintance from his society; so he that vexes others with his loose and extravagant talk may be as truly said to be a rustic, wanting altogether education and breeding.

Tokens

Lysias	1	w	6
had	1	w	9
given	1	w	14
to	1	w	16
a	3	w	17
certain	1	w	24
accused	1	w	31
criminal	1	w	39
an	1	w	41
oration	1	w	48
of	1	w	50
his	1	w	53
own	1	w	56
writing	1	w	63
He	1	w	66
having	1	w	73
read	1	w	77
it	2	w	79
several	1	w	86
times	1	w	91
over	1	w	95
came	1	w	100
to	2	w	102
Lysias	2	w	108
very	1	w	112
much	1	w	116
dejected	1	w	124
and	1	w	128
told	1	w	132
him	1	w	135
that	1	w	139
upon	1	w	144
his	2	w	147
first	1	w	152
perusal	1	w	159
of	2	w	161
it	3	w	163
it	4	w	166
seemed	1	w	172
to	4	w	174
him	2	w	177
to	5	w	179
be	1	w	181
a	17	w	182
most	1	w	186
admirable	1	w	195
piece	1	w	200
but	1	w	204
after	1	w	209
he	1	w	211
had	2	w	214
read	2	w	218
it	5	w	220
three	1	w	225
or	2	w	227
four	1	w	231
times	2	w	236
over	2	w	240
he	2	w	243
could	1	w	248
see	2	w	251
nothing	1	w	258
in	6	w	260
it	6	w	262
but	2	w	265
what	1	w	269
was	1	w	272
very	2	w	276
dull	1	w	280
and	2	w	283
insipid	1	w	290
To	1	w	293
whom	1	w	297
Lysias	3	w	303
smiling	1	w	311
What	1	w	316
said	1	w	321
he	3	w	323
is	3	w	326
not	2	w	329
once	1	w	333
enough	1	w	339
to	6	w	341
speak	1	w	346
it	7	w	348
before	1	w	354
the	1	w	357
judges	1	w	363
And	1	w	367
yet	1	w	370
do	1	w	372
but	3	w	375
consider	1	w	383
the	2	w	386
persuasive	1	w	396
eloquence	1	w	405
and	3	w	408
grace	1	w	413
that	2	w	417
is	4	w	419
in	9	w	421
Lysias	4	w	427
s	31	w	429
writing	2	w	436
and	4	w	440
then	1	w	444
I	1	w	445
may	1	w	448
be	3	w	450
bold	1	w	454
to	7	w	456
affirm	1	w	462
That	1	w	467
no	4	w	469
man	1	w	472
living	1	w	478
e	53	w	479
er	11	w	482
was	2	w	485
favored	1	w	492
more	1	w	496
By	1	w	498
sacred	1	w	504
Muse	1	w	508
that	3	w	512
violet	1	w	518
garlands	1	w	526
wore	1	w	530
Certain	1	w	538
it	9	w	540
is	5	w	542
that	4	w	546
of	3	w	549
all	1	w	552
the	4	w	555
commendations	1	w	568
that	5	w	572
were	1	w	576
ever	2	w	580
given	2	w	585
to	8	w	587
Homer	1	w	592
this	1	w	597
is	7	w	599
the	5	w	602
truest	1	w	608
that	6	w	613
he	9	w	615
alone	1	w	620
avoided	1	w	627
being	1	w	632
irksome	1	w	639
to	9	w	641
his	4	w	644
readers	1	w	651
as	8	w	654
one	2	w	657
that	7	w	661
was	3	w	664
always	1	w	670
new	1	w	673
and	6	w	676
still	1	w	681
flourishing	1	w	692
as	10	w	695
it	10	w	697
were	2	w	701
in	15	w	703
the	6	w	706
prime	1	w	711
of	4	w	713
poetic	1	w	719
beauty	1	w	725
And	2	w	729
yet	2	w	732
in	16	w	734
speaking	1	w	742
thus	1	w	746
of	5	w	748
himself	1	w	755
I	2	w	757
hate	1	w	761
vain	1	w	765
repetitions	1	w	776
fondly	1	w	783
made	1	w	787
Of	1	w	790
what	2	w	794
has	1	w	797
been	1	w	801
already	1	w	808
plainly	1	w	815
said	2	w	819
Odyss	1	w	825
XII	1	w	829
452	1	w	833
he	11	w	836
shows	1	w	841
how	2	w	844
careful	1	w	851
he	12	w	853
is	10	w	855
to	10	w	857
shun	1	w	861
that	8	w	865
satiety	1	w	872
which	1	w	877
as	12	w	880
it	12	w	882
were	3	w	886
lies	1	w	891
in	20	w	893
wait	1	w	897
for	2	w	900
all	2	w	903
speech	1	w	909
alluring	1	w	918
the	7	w	921
ear	1	w	924
from	1	w	928
one	3	w	931
relation	1	w	939
into	1	w	943
another	1	w	950
and	7	w	954
still	2	w	959
recreating	1	w	969
the	9	w	972
reader	2	w	978
with	1	w	982
fresh	1	w	987
variety	1	w	994
in	24	w	997
such	1	w	1001
a	87	w	1002
manner	1	w	1008
that	9	w	1012
he	16	w	1014
never	1	w	1019
thinks	1	w	1025
himself	2	w	1032
satisfied	1	w	1041
Whereas	1	w	1049
men	2	w	1052
that	10	w	1056
let	2	w	1059
their	1	w	1064
tongues	1	w	1071
run	1	w	1074
at	22	w	1076
random	1	w	1082
rend	1	w	1086
and	9	w	1089
tear	1	w	1093
the	11	w	1096
ears	1	w	1100
with	2	w	1104
their	2	w	1109
tautologies	1	w	1120
like	1	w	1125
those	1	w	1130
that	11	w	1134
after	2	w	1140
writing-tables	1	w	1154
have	1	w	1158
been	2	w	1162
newly	1	w	1167
cleansed	1	w	1175
and	10	w	1178
wiped	1	w	1183
deface	1	w	1190
them	1	w	1194
again	1	w	1199
with	3	w	1203
their	3	w	1208
impertinent	1	w	1219
scrawls	1	w	1226
and	11	w	1229
scratches	1	w	1238
And	3	w	1242
therefore	1	w	1251
we	4	w	1253
would	1	w	1258
have	2	w	1262
them	2	w	1266
to	14	w	1268
remember	1	w	1276
this	2	w	1280
in	29	w	1282
the	17	w	1285
first	2	w	1290
place	1	w	1295
that	12	w	1300
as	14	w	1303
they	1	w	1307
who	2	w	1310
constrain	1	w	1319
men	3	w	1322
to	15	w	1324
guzzle	1	w	1330
down	1	w	1334
wine	1	w	1338
unmixed	1	w	1345
with	4	w	1349
water	1	w	1354
and	12	w	1358
to	16	w	1360
excess	1	w	1366
are	2	w	1370
the	19	w	1373
occasion	1	w	1381
that	13	w	1385
what	3	w	1389
was	4	w	1392
bestowed	1	w	1400
at	29	w	1402
first	3	w	1407
on	15	w	1409
men	4	w	1412
as	17	w	1414
a	125	w	1415
blessing	1	w	1423
to	18	w	1426
excite	1	w	1432
mirth	1	w	1437
and	13	w	1440
rejoice	1	w	1447
the	20	w	1450
heart	1	w	1455
becomes	1	w	1463
a	128	w	1464
mischief	1	w	1472
creating	2	w	1481
sadness	1	w	1488
and	14	w	1491
causing	1	w	1498
drunkenness	1	w	1509
so	2	w	1512
they	2	w	1516
that	14	w	1520
make	1	w	1524
an	20	w	1526
ill	3	w	1529
and	15	w	1532
inconsiderate	1	w	1545
use	3	w	1548
of	6	w	1550
speech	2	w	1556
which	2	w	1562
is	14	w	1564
the	22	w	1567
most	2	w	1571
delightful	1	w	1581
means	1	w	1586
of	7	w	1588
human	1	w	1593
converse	1	w	1601
render	1	w	1608
it	20	w	1610
both	1	w	1614
troublesome	1	w	1625
and	16	w	1628
unsociable	1	w	1638
molesting	1	w	1648
those	2	w	1653
whom	2	w	1657
they	3	w	1661
think	2	w	1666
to	19	w	1668
gratify	1	w	1675
derided	1	w	1683
by	1	w	1685
those	3	w	1690
whose	1	w	1695
esteem	1	w	1701
and	17	w	1704
admiration	1	w	1714
they	4	w	1718
covet	1	w	1723
and	18	w	1727
offensive	1	w	1736
to	20	w	1738
such	2	w	1742
whose	2	w	1747
love	1	w	1751
and	19	w	1754
friendship	1	w	1764
they	5	w	1768
seek	1	w	1772
And	4	w	1776
therefore	2	w	1785
as	18	w	1788
he	37	w	1790
may	2	w	1793
be	11	w	1795
truly	1	w	1800
said	3	w	1804
to	21	w	1806
be	12	w	1808
no	6	w	1810
favorite	1	w	1818
of	9	w	1820
Venus	1	w	1825
who	6	w	1829
with	5	w	1833
the	27	w	1836
girdle	1	w	1842
of	10	w	1844
the	28	w	1847
Goddess	1	w	1854
wherein	1	w	1862
are	3	w	1865
all	4	w	1868
manner	2	w	1874
of	11	w	1876
allurements	1	w	1887
drives	1	w	1894
and	20	w	1897
chases	1	w	1903
away	1	w	1907
his	6	w	1910
familiar	1	w	1918
acquaintance	1	w	1930
from	2	w	1934
his	7	w	1937
society	1	w	1944
so	6	w	1947
he	41	w	1949
that	15	w	1953
vexes	1	w	1958
others	1	w	1964
with	6	w	1968
his	8	w	1971
loose	1	w	1976
and	21	w	1979
extravagant	1	w	1990
talk	1	w	1994
may	3	w	1997
be	13	w	1999
as	20	w	2001
truly	2	w	2006
said	4	w	2010
to	22	w	2012
be	14	w	2014
a	174	w	2015
rustic	1	w	2021
wanting	1	w	2029
altogether	1	w	2039
education	1	w	2048
and	22	w	2051
breeding	1	w	2059