Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Of Moral Virtue

Of Moral Virtue (1-2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg094.perseus-eng4:1-2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'Section 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '2', 'human_reference': 'Section 2'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

MY design in this essay is to treat of that virtue which is called and accounted moral, and is chiefly distinguished from the contemplative, in its having for the matter thereof the passions of the mind, and for its form, right reason; and herein to consider the nature of it and how it subsists, and whether that part of the soul wherein it resides be endowed with reason of its own, inherent in itself, or whether it participates of that which is foreign; and if the latter, whether it does this after the manner of those things which are mingled with what is better than themselves, or whether, as being distinct itself but yet under the dominion and superintendency of another, it may be said to partake of the power of the predominant faculty. For that it is possible for virtue to exist and continue altogether independent of matter, and free from all mixture, I take to be most manifest. But in the first place I. conceive it may be very useful briefly to run over the opinions of other philosophers, not so much for the vanity of giving an historical account thereof, as that, they being premised, ours may thence receive the greater light and be more firmly established.

To begin then with Menedemus of Eretria, he took away both the number and the differences of virtue, by asserting it to be but one, although distinguished by several names; holding that, in the same manner as a mortal and a man are all one, so what we call temperance, fortitude,

and justice are but one and the same thing. As for Ariston of Chios, he likewise made virtue to be but one in substance, and called it sanity, which, as it had respect to this or that, was to be variously multiplied and distinguished; just after the same manner as if any one should call our sight, when applied to any white object, by the name of white-look; when to one that is black, by the name of black-look; and so in other matters. For according to him, virtue, when it considers such things as we ought to do or not to do, is called prudence; when it moderates our desires, and prescribes the measure and season for our pleasures, temperance; and when it governs the commerce and mutual contracts of mankind, justice;—in the same manner, for instance, as a knife is one and the same knife still, notwithstanding sometimes it cuts one thing, sometimes another, and just as fire does operate upon different matter, and yet retain the very same nature. Unto which opinion it seems also as if Zeno the Citian did in some measure incline; he defining prudence, while it distributes to every man his own, to be justice; when it teaches what we are to choose and what to reject or avoid, temperance; and with respect to what is to be borne or suffered, fortitude. But it is to be observed, that they who take upon them the defence of Zenos notions do suppose him to mean science by what he calls prudence. But then Chrysippus, whilst he imagined from every distinct quality a several and peculiar virtue to be formed, before he was aware, raised (as Plato hath it) a whole swarm of virtues never before known or used among the philosophers. For as from brave he derived bravery; from mild, mildness; and from just, justice; so from pleasant he fetched pleasantness; from good, goodness; from grand, grandeur; and from honest, honesty; placing these and all kind of dexterous application of discourse, all kind of facetiousness of conversation, and all witty turns of expression in the
number of virtues, thereby over-running philosophy, which requires nothing less, with a multitude of uncouth, absurd, and barbarous terms.

Tokens

MY 1 w 2
design 1 w 8
in 1 w 10
this 1 w 14
essay 1 w 19
is 2 w 21
to 1 w 23
treat 1 w 28
of 1 w 30
that 1 w 34
virtue 1 w 40
which 1 w 45
is 3 w 47
called 1 w 53
and 1 w 56
accounted 1 w 65
moral 1 w 70
and 2 w 74
is 4 w 76
chiefly 1 w 83
distinguished 1 w 96
from 1 w 100
the 1 w 103
contemplative 1 w 116
in 3 w 119
its 1 w 122
having 1 w 128
for 1 w 131
the 2 w 134
matter 1 w 140
thereof 1 w 147
the 4 w 150
passions 1 w 158
of 3 w 160
the 5 w 163
mind 1 w 167
and 3 w 171
for 2 w 174
its 2 w 177
form 1 w 181
right 1 w 187
reason 1 w 193
and 4 w 197
herein 1 w 203
to 2 w 205
consider 1 w 213
the 6 w 216
nature 1 w 222
of 4 w 224
it 3 w 226
and 5 w 229
how 1 w 232
it 4 w 234
subsists 1 w 242
and 6 w 246
whether 1 w 253
that 2 w 257
part 1 w 261
of 5 w 263
the 8 w 266
soul 1 w 270
wherein 1 w 277
it 5 w 279
resides 1 w 286
be 1 w 288
endowed 1 w 295
with 1 w 299
reason 2 w 305
of 6 w 307
its 3 w 310
own 1 w 313
inherent 1 w 322
in 9 w 324
itself 1 w 330
or 5 w 333
whether 2 w 340
it 9 w 342
participates 1 w 354
of 7 w 356
that 3 w 360
which 2 w 365
is 8 w 367
foreign 1 w 374
and 7 w 378
if 1 w 380
the 10 w 383
latter 1 w 389
whether 3 w 397
it 10 w 399
does 1 w 403
this 2 w 407
after 1 w 412
the 12 w 415
manner 1 w 421
of 8 w 423
those 1 w 428
things 1 w 434
which 3 w 439
are 1 w 442
mingled 1 w 449
with 2 w 453
what 1 w 457
is 10 w 459
better 1 w 465
than 1 w 469
themselves 1 w 479
or 7 w 482
whether 4 w 489
as 4 w 492
being 1 w 497
distinct 1 w 505
itself 2 w 511
but 1 w 514
yet 1 w 517
under 1 w 522
the 15 w 525
dominion 1 w 533
and 8 w 536
superintendency 1 w 551
of 9 w 553
another 1 w 560
it 13 w 563
may 1 w 566
be 4 w 568
said 1 w 572
to 3 w 574
partake 1 w 581
of 10 w 583
the 17 w 586
power 1 w 591
of 11 w 593
the 18 w 596
predominant 1 w 607
faculty 1 w 614
For 1 w 618
that 4 w 622
it 14 w 624
is 12 w 626
possible 1 w 634
for 5 w 637
virtue 2 w 643
to 4 w 645
exist 1 w 650
and 9 w 653
continue 1 w 661
altogether 1 w 671
independent 1 w 682
of 12 w 684
matter 2 w 690
and 10 w 694
free 1 w 698
from 2 w 702
all 2 w 705
mixture 1 w 712
I 1 w 714
take 2 w 718
to 6 w 720
be 5 w 722
most 1 w 726
manifest 1 w 734
But 1 w 738
in 19 w 740
the 20 w 743
first 1 w 748
place 1 w 753
I 2 w 754
conceive 1 w 763
it 15 w 765
may 2 w 768
be 6 w 770
very 1 w 774
useful 1 w 780
briefly 1 w 787
to 7 w 789
run 1 w 792
over 1 w 796
the 21 w 799
opinions 1 w 807
of 13 w 809
other 2 w 814
philosophers 1 w 826
not 2 w 830
so 5 w 832
much 1 w 836
for 6 w 839
the 23 w 842
vanity 1 w 848
of 14 w 850
giving 1 w 856
an 17 w 858
historical 1 w 868
account 2 w 875
thereof 2 w 882
as 5 w 885
that 5 w 889
they 1 w 894
being 2 w 899
premised 1 w 907
ours 1 w 912
may 3 w 915
thence 1 w 921
receive 1 w 928
the 27 w 931
greater 1 w 938
light 1 w 943
and 11 w 946
be 8 w 948
more 1 w 952
firmly 1 w 958
established 1 w 969
To 1 w 972
begin 1 w 977
then 2 w 981
with 3 w 985
Menedemus 1 w 994
of 16 w 996
Eretria 1 w 1003
he 39 w 1006
took 1 w 1010
away 1 w 1014
both 1 w 1018
the 29 w 1021
number 1 w 1027
and 12 w 1030
the 30 w 1033
differences 1 w 1044
of 17 w 1046
virtue 3 w 1052
by 1 w 1055
asserting 1 w 1064
it 18 w 1066
to 10 w 1068
be 11 w 1070
but 2 w 1073
one 1 w 1076
although 1 w 1085
distinguished 2 w 1098
by 2 w 1100
several 1 w 1107
names 1 w 1112
holding 1 w 1120
that 6 w 1124
in 27 w 1127
the 31 w 1130
same 1 w 1134
manner 2 w 1140
as 7 w 1142
a 73 w 1143
mortal 1 w 1149
and 13 w 1152
a 76 w 1153
man 4 w 1156
are 2 w 1159
all 3 w 1162
one 2 w 1165
so 6 w 1168
what 2 w 1172
we 3 w 1174
call 2 w 1178
temperance 1 w 1188
fortitude 1 w 1198
and 14 w 1202
justice 1 w 1209
are 3 w 1212
but 3 w 1215
one 3 w 1218
and 15 w 1221
the 32 w 1224
same 2 w 1228
thing 2 w 1233
As 1 w 1236
for 8 w 1239
Ariston 1 w 1246
of 18 w 1248
Chios 1 w 1253
he 45 w 1256
likewise 1 w 1264
made 1 w 1268
virtue 4 w 1274
to 12 w 1276
be 12 w 1278
but 4 w 1281
one 4 w 1284
in 29 w 1286
substance 1 w 1295
and 16 w 1299
called 2 w 1305
it 20 w 1307
sanity 1 w 1313
which 4 w 1319
as 8 w 1322
it 22 w 1324
had 1 w 1327
respect 1 w 1334
to 13 w 1336
this 3 w 1340
or 16 w 1342
that 7 w 1346
was 1 w 1350
to 14 w 1352
be 13 w 1354
variously 1 w 1363
multiplied 1 w 1373
and 17 w 1376
distinguished 3 w 1389
just 2 w 1394
after 2 w 1399
the 33 w 1402
same 3 w 1406
manner 3 w 1412
as 10 w 1414
if 4 w 1416
any 1 w 1419
one 5 w 1422
should 1 w 1428
call 4 w 1432
our 2 w 1435
sight 1 w 1440
when 1 w 1445
applied 1 w 1452
to 15 w 1454
any 2 w 1457
white 1 w 1462
object 1 w 1468
by 3 w 1471
the 34 w 1474
name 2 w 1478
of 19 w 1480
white-look 1 w 1490
when 2 w 1495
to 16 w 1497
one 6 w 1500
that 8 w 1504
is 24 w 1506
black 1 w 1511
by 4 w 1514
the 35 w 1517
name 3 w 1521
of 20 w 1523
black-look 1 w 1533
and 18 w 1537
so 7 w 1539
in 31 w 1541
other 3 w 1546
matters 1 w 1553
For 2 w 1557
according 1 w 1566
to 17 w 1568
him 1 w 1571
virtue 5 w 1578
when 3 w 1583
it 25 w 1585
considers 1 w 1594
such 1 w 1598
things 2 w 1604
as 11 w 1606
we 4 w 1608
ought 1 w 1613
to 18 w 1615
do 5 w 1617
or 19 w 1619
not 3 w 1622
to 19 w 1624
do 6 w 1626
is 25 w 1629
called 3 w 1635
prudence 1 w 1643
when 4 w 1648
it 26 w 1650
moderates 1 w 1659
our 3 w 1662
desires 1 w 1669
and 19 w 1673
prescribes 1 w 1683
the 37 w 1686
measure 1 w 1693
and 20 w 1696
season 1 w 1702
for 9 w 1705
our 4 w 1708
pleasures 1 w 1717
temperance 2 w 1728
and 21 w 1732
when 5 w 1736
it 27 w 1738
governs 1 w 1745
the 38 w 1748
commerce 1 w 1756
and 22 w 1759
mutual 1 w 1765
contracts 1 w 1774
of 21 w 1776
mankind 1 w 1783
justice 2 w 1791
in 35 w 1795
the 39 w 1798
same 4 w 1802
manner 4 w 1808
for 10 w 1812
instance 1 w 1820
as 15 w 1823
a 132 w 1824
knife 1 w 1829
is 26 w 1831
one 7 w 1834
and 23 w 1837
the 40 w 1840
same 5 w 1844
knife 2 w 1849
still 1 w 1854
notwithstanding 1 w 1870
sometimes 1 w 1879
it 29 w 1881
cuts 1 w 1885
one 8 w 1888
thing 4 w 1893
sometimes 2 w 1903
another 2 w 1910
and 25 w 1914
just 4 w 1918
as 16 w 1920
fire 1 w 1924
does 2 w 1928
operate 1 w 1935
upon 1 w 1939
different 1 w 1948
matter 4 w 1954
and 26 w 1958
yet 2 w 1961
retain 1 w 1967
the 42 w 1970
very 2 w 1974
same 6 w 1978
nature 2 w 1984
Unto 1 w 1989
which 5 w 1994
opinion 2 w 2001
it 30 w 2003
seems 1 w 2008
also 1 w 2012
as 17 w 2014
if 8 w 2016
Zeno 1 w 2020
the 43 w 2023
Citian 1 w 2029
did 1 w 2032
in 41 w 2034
some 3 w 2038
measure 2 w 2045
incline 1 w 2052
he 63 w 2055
defining 1 w 2063
prudence 2 w 2071
while 1 w 2077
it 32 w 2079
distributes 1 w 2090
to 21 w 2092
every 1 w 2097
man 8 w 2100
his 5 w 2103
own 2 w 2106
to 22 w 2109
be 15 w 2111
justice 3 w 2118
when 6 w 2123
it 33 w 2125
teaches 1 w 2132
what 3 w 2136
we 5 w 2138
are 4 w 2141
to 23 w 2143
choose 1 w 2149
and 27 w 2152
what 4 w 2156
to 24 w 2158
reject 1 w 2164
or 22 w 2166
avoid 1 w 2171
temperance 3 w 2182
and 28 w 2186
with 5 w 2190
respect 2 w 2197
to 25 w 2199
what 5 w 2203
is 29 w 2205
to 26 w 2207
be 16 w 2209
borne 1 w 2214
or 24 w 2216
suffered 1 w 2224
fortitude 2 w 2234
But 2 w 2238
it 36 w 2240
is 30 w 2242
to 27 w 2244
be 17 w 2246
observed 1 w 2254
that 9 w 2259
they 2 w 2263
who 1 w 2266
take 3 w 2270
upon 2 w 2274
them 2 w 2278
the 46 w 2281
defence 1 w 2288
of 22 w 2290
Zeno 2 w 2294
s 146 w 2296
notions 1 w 2303
do 8 w 2305
suppose 1 w 2312
him 2 w 2315
to 28 w 2317
mean 1 w 2321
science 1 w 2328
by 5 w 2330
what 6 w 2334
he 69 w 2336
calls 1 w 2341
prudence 3 w 2349
But 3 w 2353
then 3 w 2357
Chrysippus 1 w 2367
whilst 1 w 2374
he 71 w 2376
imagined 1 w 2384
from 3 w 2388
every 2 w 2393
distinct 2 w 2401
quality 1 w 2408
a 166 w 2409
several 2 w 2416
and 29 w 2419
peculiar 1 w 2427
virtue 6 w 2433
to 29 w 2435
be 18 w 2437
formed 1 w 2443
before 1 w 2450
he 72 w 2452
was 2 w 2455
aware 1 w 2460
raised 1 w 2467
as 20 w 2470
Plato 1 w 2475
hath 1 w 2479
it 38 w 2481
a 177 w 2483
whole 1 w 2488
swarm 1 w 2493
of 23 w 2495
virtues 1 w 2502
never 1 w 2507
before 2 w 2513
known 1 w 2518
or 29 w 2520
used 1 w 2524
among 1 w 2529
the 48 w 2532
philosophers 2 w 2544
For 3 w 2548
as 21 w 2550
from 4 w 2554
brave 1 w 2559
he 75 w 2561
derived 1 w 2568
bravery 1 w 2575
from 5 w 2580
mild 1 w 2584
mildness 1 w 2593
and 30 w 2597
from 6 w 2601
just 6 w 2605
justice 4 w 2613
so 14 w 2616
from 7 w 2620
pleasant 1 w 2628
he 76 w 2630
fetched 1 w 2637
pleasantness 1 w 2649
from 8 w 2654
good 1 w 2658
goodness 1 w 2667
from 9 w 2672
grand 1 w 2677
grandeur 1 w 2686
and 33 w 2690
from 10 w 2694
honest 1 w 2700
honesty 1 w 2708
placing 1 w 2716
these 1 w 2721
and 34 w 2724
all 9 w 2727
kind 2 w 2731
of 24 w 2733
dexterous 1 w 2742
application 1 w 2753
of 25 w 2755
discourse 1 w 2764
all 10 w 2768
kind 3 w 2772
of 26 w 2774
facetiousness 1 w 2787
of 27 w 2789
conversation 1 w 2801
and 35 w 2805
all 11 w 2808
witty 1 w 2813
turns 1 w 2818
of 28 w 2820
expression 1 w 2830
in 51 w 2832
the 50 w 2835
number 2 w 2841
of 29 w 2843
virtues 2 w 2850
thereby 1 w 2858
over-running 1 w 2870
philosophy 1 w 2880
which 6 w 2886
requires 1 w 2894
nothing 1 w 2901
less 1 w 2905
with 6 w 2910
a 201 w 2911
multitude 1 w 2920
of 30 w 2922
uncouth 1 w 2929
absurd 1 w 2936
and 36 w 2940
barbarous 1 w 2949
terms 1 w 2954