The Obsolesence of Oracles (40-44)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg092.perseus-eng3:40-44

Refs	`{'start': {'reference': '40', 'human_reference': 'Section 40'}, 'end': {'reference': '44', 'human_reference': 'Section 44'}}`
Ancestors	`[]`
Children	`[]`

plain text • XML

Souls therefore, all possessed of this power, which is innate but dim and hardly manifest, nevertheless oftentimes disclose its flower and radiance in

v.5.p.469

dreams, and some in the hour of death,[*] when the body becomes cleansed of all impurities and attains a temperament adapted to this end, a temperament through which the reasoning and thinking faculty of the souls is relaxed and released from their present state as they range amid the irrational and imaginative realms of the future. It is not true, as Euripides[*] says, that

The best of seers is he that guesses well;

no, the best of seers is the intelligent man, following the guidance of that in his soul which possesses sense and which, with the help of reasonable probability, leads him on his way. But that which foretells the future, like a tablet without writing, is both irrational and indeterminate in itself, but receptive of impressions and presentiments through what may be done to it, and inconsequently grasps at the future when it is farthest withdrawn from the present. Its withdrawal is brought about by a temperament and disposition of the body as it is subjected to a change which we call inspiration. Often the body of itself alone attains this disposition. Moreover the earth sends forth for men streams of many other potencies, some of them producing derangements, diseases, or deaths; others helpful, benignant, and beneficial, as is plain from the experience of persons who have come upon them. But the prophetic current and breath is most divine and holy, whether it issue by itself through the air or come in the company of

running waters; for when it is instilled into the body, it creates in souls an unaccustomed and unusual temperament, the peculiarity of which it is hard to describe with exactness, but analogy offers many comparisons. It is likely that by warmth and diffusion it opens up certain passages through which impressions of the future are transmitted, just as wine, when its fumes rise to the head, reveals many unusual movements and also words stored away and unperceived.

For Bacchic rout

And frenzied mind contain much prophecy,

according to Euripides,[*] when the soul becomes hot and fiery, and throw’s aside the caution that human intelligence lays upon it, and thus often diverts and extinguishes the inspiration.

At the same time one might assert, not without reason, that a dryness engendered with the heat subtilizes the spirit of prophecy and renders it ethereal and pure; for this is the dry soul, as Heracleitus has it.[*] Moisture not only dulls sight and hearing, but when it touches mirrors and combines with air, it takes away their brightness and sheen.[*] But again the very opposite of this may not be impossible: that by a sort of chilling and compacting of the spirit of inspiration the prophetic element in the soul, as when steel is dipped in cold water, is rendered tense and keen. And further, just as tin

when alloyed with copper, which is loose and porous in texture, binds it together and compacts it,[*] and at the same time makes it brighter and cleaner, even so there is nothing to prevent the prophetic vapour, which contains some affinity and relationship to souls, from filling up the vacant spaces and cementing all together by fitting itself in. For one thing has affinity and adaptability for one thing, another for another, just as the bean[*] seems to further the dyeing of purple and sodium carbonate[*] that of scarlet, when mixed with the dye;

All in the linen is blended the splendour of glorious scarlet,

as Empedocles[*] has said. But regarding the Cydnus and the sacred sword of Apollo in Tarsus we used to hear you say, my dear Demetrius, that the Cydnus will cleanse no steel but that, and no other water will cleanse that sword. There is a similar phenomenon at Olympia, where they pile the ashes against the altar and make them adhere all around by pouring on them water from the Alpheius; but, although they have tried the waters of other rivers, there is none with which they can make the ashes cohere and stay fixed in their place.

It is not, therefore, anything to excite amazement if, although the earth sends up many streams, it is only such as these that dispose souls to inspiration and impressions of the future. Certainly the voice of legend also is in accord with my statement;

for they record that here the power hovering about this spot was first made manifest when a certain shepherd fell in by accident and later gave forth inspired utterances, which those who came into contact with him at first treated with disdain; but later, when what he had foretold came to pass, they were amazed. The most learned of the people of Delphi still preserve the tradition of his name, which they say was Coretas. But I incline most to the opinion that the soul acquires towards the prophetic spirit a close and intimate connexion of the sort that vision has towards light, which possesses similar properties. For, although the eye has the power of vision, there is no function for it to perform without light[*]; and so the prophetic power of the soul, like an eye, has need of something kindred to help to kindle it and stimulate it further. Hence many among earlier generations regarded Apollo and the Sun as one and the same god; but those who understood and respected fair and wise analogy conjectured that as body is to soul, vision to intellect, and light to truth, so is the power of the sun to the nature of Apollo; and they would make it appear that the sun is his offspring and progeny, being for ever born of him that is for ever. For the sun kindles and promotes and helps to keep in activity the power of vision in our perceptive senses, just as the god does for the power of prophecy in the soul.

Those, however, who had reached the conclusion that the two are one and the same god very naturally dedicated the oracle to Apollo and Earth in common, thinking that the sun creates the disposition and temperament in the earth from which the prophet-inspiring

vapours are wafted forth. As Hesiod,[*] then, with a better understanding than some philosophers, spoke of the Earth itself as

Of All the unshaken foundation,

so we believe it to be everlasting and imperishable. But in the case of the powers associated with the earth it is reasonable that there should come to pass disappearances in one place and generation in another place, and elsewrhere shifting of location and, from some other source, changes in current,[*] and that such cycles should complete many revolutions within it in the whole course of time, as we may judge from what happens before our eyes. For in the case of lakes and rivers, and even more frequently in hot springs, there have occurred disappearances and complete extinction in some places, and in others a stealing away, as it were, and sinking under ground[*]; later they came back, appearing after a time in the same places or flowing out from below somewhere near. We know also of the exhaustion of mines, some of which have given out recently, as for example the silver mines of Attica and the copper ore in Euboea from which the cold-forged sword-blades used to be wrought, as Aeschylus[*] has said,

Euboean sword, self-sharpened, in his hand.

And it is no long time since the rock in Euboea ceased to yield, among its other products, soft petrous

filaments like yarn.[*] I think some of you have seen towels, nets, and women’s head-coverings from there, which cannot be burned by fire; but if any become soiled by use, their owners throw them into a blazing fire and take them out bright and clear. To-day all this has disappeared, and there are scarcely any attenuated fibres or hairs, as it were, running through the mines.

And yet the school of Aristotle[*] would make it appear that exhalation is the author of all these changes that have taken place in the earth, and that things of this nature must of necessity follow with it in disappearing, changing their locality, and bursting forth once more in full vigour. Plainly the same sober opinion is to be held regarding the spirits that inspire prophecy; the power that they possess is not everlasting and ageless, but is subject to changes. For excessive rains most likely extinguish them, and they probably are dispersed by thunderbolts, and especially, when the earth is shaken beneath by an earthquake and suffers subsidence and ruinous confusion in its depths, the exhalations shift their site or find completely blind outlets, as in this place they say that there are still traces of that great earthquake which overthrew the city. And in Orchomenos they relate that a pestilence raged and many persons died of it, and the oracle of Teiresias become altogether obsolescent and even to this day remains idle and mute. And if a like fate has befallen those in Cilicia, as we have been told, there is nobody, Demetrius, who could give us more certain information than you.

Tokens

Souls	1	w	5
therefore	1	w	14
all	1	w	18
possessed	1	w	27
of	1	w	29
this	1	w	33
power	1	w	38
which	1	w	44
is	2	w	46
innate	1	w	52
but	1	w	55
dim	1	w	58
and	1	w	61
hardly	1	w	67
manifest	1	w	75
nevertheless	1	w	88
oftentimes	1	w	98
disclose	1	w	106
its	1	w	109
flower	1	w	115
and	2	w	118
radiance	1	w	126
in	2	w	128
dreams	1	w	134
and	3	w	138
some	1	w	142
in	3	w	144
the	3	w	147
hour	1	w	151
of	3	w	153
death	1	w	158
Cf	1	w	161
Plato	1	w	167
Apology	1	w	175
39	1	w	178
b	2	w	179
when	1	w	184
the	4	w	187
body	1	w	191
becomes	1	w	198
cleansed	1	w	206
of	4	w	208
all	2	w	211
impurities	1	w	221
and	4	w	224
attains	1	w	231
a	18	w	232
temperament	1	w	243
adapted	1	w	250
to	2	w	252
this	2	w	256
end	1	w	259
a	22	w	261
temperament	2	w	272
through	1	w	279
which	2	w	284
the	5	w	287
reasoning	1	w	296
and	5	w	299
thinking	1	w	307
faculty	1	w	314
of	5	w	316
the	6	w	319
souls	1	w	324
is	5	w	326
relaxed	1	w	333
and	6	w	336
released	1	w	344
from	1	w	348
their	1	w	353
present	1	w	360
state	1	w	365
as	3	w	367
they	1	w	371
range	1	w	376
amid	1	w	380
the	9	w	383
irrational	1	w	393
and	7	w	396
imaginative	1	w	407
realms	1	w	413
of	6	w	415
the	10	w	418
future	1	w	424
It	1	w	427
is	6	w	429
not	1	w	432
true	1	w	436
as	4	w	439
Euripides	1	w	448
Cf	2	w	450
Nauck	1	w	456
Trag	1	w	461
Graec	1	w	467
Frag	1	w	472
p	10	w	474
674	1	w	478
Euripides	2	w	488
no	2	w	491
973	1	w	495
cf	1	w	498
Moralia	1	w	506
399	1	w	510
a	47	w	511
supra	1	w	517
says	1	w	522
that	1	w	527
The	1	w	530
best	1	w	534
of	7	w	536
seers	1	w	541
is	7	w	543
he	13	w	545
that	2	w	549
guesses	1	w	556
well	1	w	560
no	3	w	563
the	11	w	567
best	2	w	571
of	8	w	573
seers	2	w	578
is	8	w	580
the	12	w	583
intelligent	1	w	594
man	2	w	597
following	1	w	607
the	13	w	610
guidance	1	w	618
of	9	w	620
that	3	w	624
in	11	w	626
his	3	w	629
soul	2	w	633
which	3	w	638
possesses	1	w	647
sense	1	w	652
and	8	w	655
which	4	w	660
with	1	w	665
the	14	w	668
help	1	w	672
of	10	w	674
reasonable	1	w	684
probability	1	w	695
leads	1	w	701
him	1	w	704
on	4	w	706
his	4	w	709
way	1	w	712
But	1	w	716
that	4	w	720
which	5	w	725
foretells	1	w	734
the	15	w	737
future	2	w	743
like	1	w	748
a	62	w	749
tablet	1	w	755
without	1	w	762
writing	1	w	769
is	11	w	772
both	1	w	776
irrational	2	w	786
and	9	w	789
indeterminate	1	w	802
in	15	w	804
itself	1	w	810
but	2	w	814
receptive	1	w	823
of	11	w	825
impressions	1	w	836
and	10	w	839
presentiments	1	w	852
through	2	w	859
what	1	w	863
may	1	w	866
be	4	w	868
done	1	w	872
to	3	w	874
it	8	w	876
and	11	w	880
inconsequently	1	w	894
grasps	1	w	900
at	15	w	902
the	16	w	905
future	3	w	911
when	2	w	915
it	9	w	917
is	12	w	919
farthest	1	w	927
withdrawn	1	w	936
from	2	w	940
the	18	w	943
present	3	w	950
Its	1	w	954
withdrawal	1	w	964
is	13	w	966
brought	1	w	973
about	1	w	978
by	1	w	980
a	79	w	981
temperament	3	w	992
and	12	w	995
disposition	1	w	1006
of	12	w	1008
the	19	w	1011
body	2	w	1015
as	7	w	1017
it	13	w	1019
is	15	w	1021
subjected	1	w	1030
to	4	w	1032
a	83	w	1033
change	1	w	1039
which	6	w	1044
we	4	w	1046
call	1	w	1050
inspiration	1	w	1061
Often	1	w	1067
the	20	w	1070
body	3	w	1074
of	13	w	1076
itself	2	w	1082
alone	1	w	1087
attains	2	w	1094
this	3	w	1098
disposition	2	w	1109
Moreover	1	w	1118
the	21	w	1121
earth	1	w	1126
sends	1	w	1131
forth	1	w	1136
for	4	w	1139
men	5	w	1142
streams	1	w	1149
of	14	w	1151
many	1	w	1155
other	1	w	1160
potencies	1	w	1169
some	2	w	1174
of	15	w	1176
them	1	w	1180
producing	1	w	1189
derangements	1	w	1201
diseases	1	w	1210
or	7	w	1213
deaths	1	w	1219
others	1	w	1226
helpful	1	w	1233
benignant	1	w	1243
and	13	w	1247
beneficial	1	w	1257
as	9	w	1260
is	19	w	1262
plain	1	w	1267
from	3	w	1271
the	25	w	1274
experience	1	w	1284
of	16	w	1286
persons	1	w	1293
who	1	w	1296
have	1	w	1300
come	2	w	1304
upon	1	w	1308
them	2	w	1312
But	2	w	1316
the	27	w	1319
prophetic	1	w	1328
current	1	w	1335
and	14	w	1338
breath	1	w	1344
is	20	w	1346
most	1	w	1350
divine	1	w	1356
and	15	w	1359
holy	1	w	1363
whether	1	w	1371
it	16	w	1373
issue	1	w	1378
by	2	w	1380
itself	3	w	1386
through	3	w	1393
the	29	w	1396
air	1	w	1399
or	8	w	1401
come	3	w	1405
in	22	w	1407
the	30	w	1410
company	1	w	1417
of	17	w	1419
running	1	w	1426
waters	1	w	1432
for	5	w	1436
when	3	w	1440
it	18	w	1442
is	22	w	1444
instilled	1	w	1453
into	1	w	1457
the	31	w	1460
body	4	w	1464
it	19	w	1467
creates	1	w	1474
in	26	w	1476
souls	2	w	1481
an	27	w	1483
unaccustomed	1	w	1495
and	16	w	1498
unusual	1	w	1505
temperament	4	w	1516
the	32	w	1520
peculiarity	1	w	1531
of	18	w	1533
which	7	w	1538
it	21	w	1540
is	23	w	1542
hard	2	w	1546
to	7	w	1548
describe	1	w	1556
with	5	w	1560
exactness	1	w	1569
but	3	w	1573
analogy	1	w	1580
offers	1	w	1586
many	2	w	1590
comparisons	1	w	1601
It	3	w	1604
is	25	w	1606
likely	1	w	1612
that	5	w	1616
by	3	w	1618
warmth	1	w	1624
and	17	w	1627
diffusion	1	w	1636
it	23	w	1638
opens	1	w	1643
up	3	w	1645
certain	1	w	1652
passages	1	w	1660
through	4	w	1667
which	8	w	1672
impressions	2	w	1683
of	20	w	1685
the	33	w	1688
future	4	w	1694
are	1	w	1697
transmitted	1	w	1708
just	1	w	1713
as	11	w	1715
wine	1	w	1719
when	4	w	1724
its	5	w	1727
fumes	1	w	1732
rise	1	w	1736
to	8	w	1738
the	34	w	1741
head	1	w	1745
reveals	1	w	1753
many	3	w	1757
unusual	2	w	1764
movements	1	w	1773
and	18	w	1776
also	1	w	1780
words	1	w	1785
stored	1	w	1791
away	1	w	1795
and	19	w	1798
unperceived	1	w	1809
For	1	w	1813
Bacchic	1	w	1820
rout	1	w	1824
And	1	w	1827
frenzied	1	w	1835
mind	1	w	1839
contain	1	w	1846
much	1	w	1850
prophecy	1	w	1858
according	1	w	1868
to	10	w	1870
Euripides	3	w	1879
Bacchae	1	w	1887
298	1	w	1891
when	5	w	1896
the	35	w	1899
soul	4	w	1903
becomes	2	w	1910
hot	1	w	1913
and	20	w	1916
fiery	1	w	1921
and	21	w	1925
throw	1	w	1930
s	148	w	1932
aside	1	w	1937
the	36	w	1940
caution	1	w	1947
that	6	w	1951
human	1	w	1956
intelligence	1	w	1968
lays	1	w	1972
upon	2	w	1976
it	26	w	1978
and	22	w	1982
thus	1	w	1986
often	2	w	1991
diverts	1	w	1998
and	23	w	2001
extinguishes	1	w	2013
the	37	w	2016
inspiration	2	w	2027
At	1	w	2030
the	38	w	2033
same	1	w	2037
time	3	w	2041
one	3	w	2044
might	1	w	2049
assert	1	w	2055
not	2	w	2059
without	2	w	2066
reason	3	w	2072
that	7	w	2077
a	158	w	2078
dryness	1	w	2085
engendered	1	w	2095
with	7	w	2099
the	39	w	2102
heat	1	w	2106
subtilizes	1	w	2116
the	40	w	2119
spirit	1	w	2125
of	22	w	2127
prophecy	2	w	2135
and	24	w	2138
renders	1	w	2145
it	30	w	2147
ethereal	1	w	2155
and	25	w	2158
pure	1	w	2162
for	6	w	2166
this	4	w	2170
is	29	w	2172
the	42	w	2175
dry	2	w	2178
soul	5	w	2182
as	15	w	2185
Heracleitus	1	w	2196
has	1	w	2199
it	32	w	2201
A	4	w	2203
dry	3	w	2206
soul	6	w	2210
is	30	w	2212
best	3	w	2216
and	26	w	2220
or	15	w	2223
wisest	1	w	2229
is	32	w	2232
the	43	w	2235
dictum	1	w	2241
of	23	w	2243
Heracleitus	2	w	2254
which	9	w	2260
is	33	w	2262
often	3	w	2267
quoted	1	w	2273
see	3	w	2277
Diels	1	w	2282
Frag	2	w	2287
der	4	w	2291
Vorsokratiker	1	w	2304
i	178	w	2306
p	52	w	2308
100	1	w	2312
Heracleitus	3	w	2324
no	5	w	2327
b	31	w	2329
118	1	w	2332
Cf	3	w	2335
also	2	w	2340
Moralia	2	w	2347
995	1	w	2351
e	269	w	2352
and	27	w	2356
Life	1	w	2360
of	25	w	2362
Romulus	1	w	2369
chap	1	w	2374
xxviii	1	w	2381
36	1	w	2385
a	176	w	2386
Moisture	1	w	2396
not	3	w	2399
only	1	w	2403
dulls	1	w	2408
sight	1	w	2413
and	28	w	2416
hearing	1	w	2423
but	4	w	2427
when	6	w	2431
it	35	w	2433
touches	1	w	2440
mirrors	1	w	2447
and	29	w	2450
combines	1	w	2458
with	8	w	2462
air	2	w	2465
it	37	w	2468
takes	1	w	2473
away	2	w	2477
their	2	w	2482
brightness	1	w	2492
and	30	w	2495
sheen	1	w	2500
Cf	4	w	2503
Plutarch	1	w	2512
Moralia	3	w	2520
736	1	w	2524
a-b	1	w	2527
But	3	w	2531
again	1	w	2536
the	45	w	2539
very	1	w	2543
opposite	1	w	2551
of	26	w	2553
this	5	w	2557
may	2	w	2560
not	4	w	2563
be	10	w	2565
impossible	1	w	2575
that	8	w	2580
by	4	w	2582
a	193	w	2583
sort	1	w	2587
of	27	w	2589
chilling	1	w	2597
and	31	w	2600
compacting	1	w	2610
of	28	w	2612
the	46	w	2615
spirit	2	w	2621
of	29	w	2623
inspiration	3	w	2634
the	47	w	2637
prophetic	2	w	2646
element	1	w	2653
in	41	w	2655
the	48	w	2658
soul	7	w	2662
as	17	w	2665
when	7	w	2669
steel	1	w	2674
is	36	w	2676
dipped	1	w	2682
in	42	w	2684
cold	1	w	2688
water	2	w	2693
is	37	w	2696
rendered	1	w	2704
tense	1	w	2709
and	32	w	2712
keen	1	w	2716
And	2	w	2720
further	1	w	2727
just	2	w	2732
as	18	w	2734
tin	4	w	2737
when	8	w	2741
alloyed	1	w	2748
with	9	w	2752
copper	1	w	2758
which	10	w	2764
is	38	w	2766
loose	1	w	2771
and	33	w	2774
porous	1	w	2780
in	44	w	2782
texture	1	w	2789
binds	1	w	2795
it	41	w	2797
together	1	w	2805
and	34	w	2808
compacts	1	w	2816
it	42	w	2818
Cf	5	w	2821
Aristotle	1	w	2831
De	1	w	2834
Generatione	1	w	2845
Animalium	1	w	2854
ii	3	w	2857
8	3	w	2859
747	1	w	2863
a	207	w	2864
34	1	w	2866
and	35	w	2871
at	32	w	2873
the	51	w	2876
same	2	w	2880
time	4	w	2884
makes	1	w	2889
it	43	w	2891
brighter	1	w	2899
and	36	w	2902
cleaner	1	w	2909
even	1	w	2914
so	19	w	2916
there	3	w	2921
is	40	w	2923
nothing	1	w	2930
to	14	w	2932
prevent	1	w	2939
the	53	w	2942
prophetic	3	w	2951
vapour	1	w	2957
which	11	w	2963
contains	1	w	2971
some	3	w	2975
affinity	1	w	2983
and	37	w	2986
relationship	1	w	2998
to	15	w	3000
souls	3	w	3005
from	4	w	3010
filling	1	w	3017
up	5	w	3019
the	54	w	3022
vacant	1	w	3028
spaces	1	w	3034
and	38	w	3037
cementing	1	w	3046
all	5	w	3049
together	2	w	3057
by	5	w	3059
fitting	1	w	3066
itself	4	w	3072
in	52	w	3074
For	2	w	3078
one	5	w	3081
thing	2	w	3086
has	2	w	3089
affinity	2	w	3097
and	39	w	3100
adaptability	1	w	3112
for	7	w	3115
one	6	w	3118
thing	3	w	3123
another	1	w	3131
for	8	w	3134
another	2	w	3141
just	3	w	3146
as	20	w	3148
the	58	w	3151
bean	1	w	3155
Cf	6	w	3157
H	4	w	3159
Blümner	1	w	3167
Gewerbe	1	w	3175
und	1	w	3178
Künste	1	w	3184
bei	1	w	3187
Griechen	1	w	3195
und	2	w	3198
Römern	1	w	3204
Leipzig	1	w	3212
1875	1	w	3217
i	259	w	3220
236	1	w	3224
seems	1	w	3230
to	17	w	3232
further	2	w	3239
the	60	w	3242
dyeing	1	w	3248
of	30	w	3250
purple	1	w	3256
and	40	w	3259
sodium	1	w	3265
carbonate	1	w	3274
Ibid	1	w	3278
238	1	w	3282
that	9	w	3287
of	31	w	3289
scarlet	1	w	3296
when	9	w	3301
mixed	1	w	3306
with	10	w	3310
the	61	w	3313
dye	2	w	3316
All	1	w	3320
in	57	w	3322
the	62	w	3325
linen	1	w	3330
is	41	w	3332
blended	1	w	3339
the	63	w	3342
splendour	1	w	3351
of	32	w	3353
glorious	1	w	3361
scarlet	2	w	3368
as	21	w	3371
Empedocles	1	w	3381
Cf	7	w	3383
Diels	2	w	3389
Frag	3	w	3394
der	6	w	3398
Vorsokratiker	2	w	3411
i	271	w	3413
p	81	w	3415
255	1	w	3419
Empedocles	2	w	3430
no	11	w	3433
b	49	w	3435
93	1	w	3437
has	3	w	3441
said	1	w	3445
But	4	w	3449
regarding	1	w	3458
the	64	w	3461
Cydnus	1	w	3467
and	41	w	3470
the	65	w	3473
sacred	1	w	3479
sword	1	w	3484
of	33	w	3486
Apollo	1	w	3492
in	60	w	3494
Tarsus	1	w	3500
we	6	w	3502
used	1	w	3506
to	18	w	3508
hear	2	w	3512
you	1	w	3515
say	2	w	3518
my	1	w	3521
dear	1	w	3525
Demetrius	1	w	3534
that	10	w	3539
the	66	w	3542
Cydnus	2	w	3548
will	1	w	3552
cleanse	2	w	3559
no	12	w	3561
steel	2	w	3566
but	5	w	3569
that	11	w	3573
and	42	w	3577
no	13	w	3579
other	5	w	3584
water	3	w	3589
will	2	w	3593
cleanse	3	w	3600
that	12	w	3604
sword	2	w	3609
There	1	w	3615
is	42	w	3617
a	259	w	3618
similar	1	w	3625
phenomenon	1	w	3635
at	41	w	3637
Olympia	1	w	3644
where	1	w	3650
they	2	w	3654
pile	1	w	3658
the	69	w	3661
ashes	1	w	3666
against	1	w	3673
the	70	w	3676
altar	1	w	3681
and	43	w	3684
make	2	w	3688
them	3	w	3692
adhere	1	w	3698
all	6	w	3701
around	1	w	3707
by	6	w	3709
pouring	1	w	3716
on	33	w	3718
them	4	w	3722
water	4	w	3727
from	5	w	3731
the	73	w	3734
Alpheius	1	w	3742
but	6	w	3746
although	1	w	3755
they	3	w	3759
have	2	w	3763
tried	1	w	3768
the	75	w	3771
waters	2	w	3777
of	34	w	3779
other	6	w	3784
rivers	1	w	3790
there	4	w	3796
is	43	w	3798
none	1	w	3802
with	11	w	3806
which	12	w	3811
they	4	w	3815
can	2	w	3818
make	3	w	3822
the	79	w	3825
ashes	2	w	3830
cohere	1	w	3836
and	44	w	3839
stay	1	w	3843
fixed	1	w	3848
in	63	w	3850
their	3	w	3855
place	1	w	3860
It	4	w	3863
is	44	w	3865
not	8	w	3868
therefore	2	w	3878
anything	1	w	3887
to	19	w	3889
excite	1	w	3895
amazement	1	w	3904
if	4	w	3906
although	2	w	3915
the	82	w	3918
earth	2	w	3923
sends	2	w	3928
up	6	w	3930
many	4	w	3934
streams	2	w	3941
it	52	w	3944
is	45	w	3946
only	2	w	3950
such	1	w	3954
as	25	w	3956
these	1	w	3961
that	13	w	3965
dispose	1	w	3972
souls	4	w	3977
to	20	w	3979
inspiration	4	w	3990
and	45	w	3993
impressions	3	w	4004
of	35	w	4006
the	84	w	4009
future	5	w	4015
Certainly	1	w	4025
the	85	w	4028
voice	1	w	4033
of	36	w	4035
legend	1	w	4041
also	3	w	4045
is	47	w	4047
in	67	w	4049
accord	2	w	4055
with	12	w	4059
my	2	w	4061
statement	1	w	4070
for	10	w	4074
they	5	w	4078
record	1	w	4084
that	14	w	4088
here	10	w	4092
the	87	w	4095
power	2	w	4100
hovering	1	w	4108
about	2	w	4113
this	6	w	4117
spot	1	w	4121
was	1	w	4124
first	1	w	4129
made	1	w	4133
manifest	2	w	4141
when	10	w	4145
a	303	w	4146
certain	2	w	4153
shepherd	1	w	4161
fell	1	w	4165
in	70	w	4167
by	7	w	4169
accident	1	w	4177
and	46	w	4180
later	1	w	4185
gave	1	w	4189
forth	2	w	4194
inspired	1	w	4202
utterances	1	w	4212
which	13	w	4218
those	1	w	4223
who	2	w	4226
came	1	w	4230
into	2	w	4234
contact	1	w	4241
with	13	w	4245
him	2	w	4248
at	49	w	4250
first	2	w	4255
treated	1	w	4262
with	14	w	4266
disdain	1	w	4273
but	7	w	4277
later	2	w	4282
when	11	w	4287
what	2	w	4291
he	128	w	4293
had	1	w	4296
foretold	1	w	4304
came	2	w	4308
to	23	w	4310
pass	2	w	4314
they	6	w	4319
were	1	w	4323
amazed	1	w	4329
The	3	w	4333
most	2	w	4337
learned	1	w	4344
of	37	w	4346
the	89	w	4349
people	1	w	4355
of	38	w	4357
Delphi	1	w	4363
still	2	w	4368
preserve	1	w	4376
the	90	w	4379
tradition	1	w	4388
of	39	w	4390
his	9	w	4393
name	1	w	4397
which	14	w	4403
they	7	w	4407
say	3	w	4410
was	2	w	4413
Coretas	1	w	4420
But	5	w	4424
I	6	w	4425
incline	1	w	4432
most	3	w	4436
to	24	w	4438
the	92	w	4441
opinion	1	w	4448
that	15	w	4452
the	93	w	4455
soul	10	w	4459
acquires	1	w	4467
towards	1	w	4474
the	94	w	4477
prophetic	4	w	4486
spirit	3	w	4492
a	331	w	4493
close	2	w	4498
and	47	w	4501
intimate	1	w	4509
connexion	1	w	4518
of	40	w	4520
the	95	w	4523
sort	2	w	4527
that	16	w	4531
vision	1	w	4537
has	4	w	4540
towards	2	w	4547
light	1	w	4552
which	15	w	4558
possesses	2	w	4567
similar	2	w	4574
properties	1	w	4584
For	3	w	4588
although	3	w	4597
the	96	w	4600
eye	1	w	4603
has	5	w	4606
the	97	w	4609
power	3	w	4614
of	41	w	4616
vision	2	w	4622
there	6	w	4628
is	53	w	4630
no	18	w	4632
function	1	w	4640
for	13	w	4643
it	58	w	4645
to	27	w	4647
perform	1	w	4654
without	3	w	4661
light	2	w	4666
See	1	w	4669
436	1	w	4672
d	164	w	4673
infra	1	w	4679
and	48	w	4683
Plato	2	w	4688
Republic	1	w	4697
508	1	w	4701
a	343	w	4702
509	1	w	4706
b	57	w	4707
and	49	w	4712
so	28	w	4714
the	99	w	4717
prophetic	5	w	4726
power	4	w	4731
of	42	w	4733
the	100	w	4736
soul	11	w	4740
like	3	w	4745
an	79	w	4747
eye	2	w	4750
has	6	w	4754
need	1	w	4758
of	43	w	4760
something	1	w	4769
kindred	1	w	4776
to	29	w	4778
help	3	w	4782
to	30	w	4784
kindle	1	w	4790
it	60	w	4792
and	50	w	4795
stimulate	1	w	4804
it	61	w	4806
further	3	w	4813
Hence	1	w	4819
many	5	w	4823
among	1	w	4828
earlier	1	w	4835
generations	1	w	4846
regarded	1	w	4854
Apollo	2	w	4860
and	51	w	4863
the	102	w	4866
Sun	1	w	4869
as	33	w	4871
one	8	w	4874
and	52	w	4877
the	103	w	4880
same	3	w	4884
god	1	w	4887
but	8	w	4891
those	2	w	4896
who	3	w	4899
understood	1	w	4909
and	53	w	4912
respected	1	w	4921
fair	1	w	4925
and	54	w	4928
wise	2	w	4932
analogy	2	w	4939
conjectured	1	w	4950
that	17	w	4954
as	34	w	4956
body	5	w	4960
is	55	w	4962
to	32	w	4964
soul	12	w	4968
vision	3	w	4975
to	33	w	4977
intellect	1	w	4986
and	55	w	4990
light	3	w	4995
to	34	w	4997
truth	1	w	5002
so	32	w	5005
is	57	w	5007
the	104	w	5010
power	5	w	5015
of	44	w	5017
the	105	w	5020
sun	1	w	5023
to	35	w	5025
the	106	w	5028
nature	1	w	5034
of	45	w	5036
Apollo	3	w	5042
and	56	w	5046
they	8	w	5050
would	1	w	5055
make	4	w	5059
it	62	w	5061
appear	1	w	5067
that	18	w	5071
the	108	w	5074
sun	2	w	5077
is	58	w	5079
his	10	w	5082
offspring	1	w	5091
and	57	w	5094
progeny	1	w	5101
being	1	w	5107
for	15	w	5110
ever	2	w	5114
born	1	w	5118
of	47	w	5120
him	3	w	5123
that	19	w	5127
is	60	w	5129
for	16	w	5132
ever	3	w	5136
For	4	w	5140
the	109	w	5143
sun	3	w	5146
kindles	1	w	5153
and	58	w	5156
promotes	1	w	5164
and	59	w	5167
helps	1	w	5172
to	36	w	5174
keep	1	w	5178
in	86	w	5180
activity	1	w	5188
the	110	w	5191
power	6	w	5196
of	48	w	5198
vision	4	w	5204
in	87	w	5206
our	5	w	5209
perceptive	1	w	5219
senses	1	w	5225
just	4	w	5230
as	35	w	5232
the	111	w	5235
god	2	w	5238
does	1	w	5242
for	17	w	5245
the	112	w	5248
power	7	w	5253
of	49	w	5255
prophecy	3	w	5263
in	88	w	5265
the	113	w	5268
soul	13	w	5272
Those	1	w	5278
however	1	w	5286
who	4	w	5290
had	2	w	5293
reached	1	w	5300
the	114	w	5303
conclusion	1	w	5313
that	20	w	5317
the	115	w	5320
two	1	w	5323
are	2	w	5326
one	9	w	5329
and	60	w	5332
the	116	w	5335
same	4	w	5339
god	3	w	5342
very	2	w	5346
naturally	1	w	5355
dedicated	1	w	5364
the	117	w	5367
oracle	1	w	5373
to	37	w	5375
Apollo	4	w	5381
and	61	w	5384
Earth	1	w	5389
in	89	w	5391
common	1	w	5397
thinking	2	w	5406
that	21	w	5410
the	118	w	5413
sun	4	w	5416
creates	2	w	5423
the	119	w	5426
disposition	3	w	5437
and	62	w	5440
temperament	5	w	5451
in	92	w	5453
the	120	w	5456
earth	3	w	5461
from	6	w	5465
which	16	w	5470
the	121	w	5473
prophet-inspiring	1	w	5490
vapours	1	w	5497
are	3	w	5500
wafted	1	w	5506
forth	3	w	5511
As	1	w	5514
Hesiod	1	w	5520
Theogony	1	w	5529
117	1	w	5533
then	1	w	5538
with	16	w	5543
a	398	w	5544
better	1	w	5550
understanding	1	w	5563
than	1	w	5567
some	5	w	5571
philosophers	1	w	5583
spoke	1	w	5589
of	50	w	5591
the	123	w	5594
Earth	2	w	5599
itself	5	w	5605
as	36	w	5607
Of	2	w	5609
All	2	w	5612
the	124	w	5615
unshaken	1	w	5623
foundation	1	w	5633
so	36	w	5636
we	15	w	5638
believe	1	w	5645
it	67	w	5647
to	38	w	5649
be	17	w	5651
everlasting	1	w	5662
and	64	w	5665
imperishable	1	w	5677
But	6	w	5681
in	97	w	5683
the	125	w	5686
case	1	w	5690
of	51	w	5692
the	126	w	5695
powers	1	w	5701
associated	1	w	5711
with	17	w	5715
the	127	w	5718
earth	4	w	5723
it	69	w	5725
is	64	w	5727
reasonable	2	w	5737
that	22	w	5741
there	7	w	5746
should	1	w	5752
come	5	w	5756
to	39	w	5758
pass	3	w	5762
disappearances	1	w	5776
in	98	w	5778
one	10	w	5781
place	2	w	5786
and	65	w	5789
generation	2	w	5799
in	99	w	5801
another	3	w	5808
place	3	w	5813
and	66	w	5817
elsewrhere	1	w	5827
shifting	1	w	5835
of	52	w	5837
location	1	w	5845
and	67	w	5848
from	7	w	5853
some	6	w	5857
other	8	w	5862
source	1	w	5868
changes	1	w	5876
in	101	w	5878
current	2	w	5885
Cf	8	w	5888
432	1	w	5892
e	689	w	5893
supra	2	w	5899
and	68	w	5903
that	23	w	5907
such	2	w	5911
cycles	1	w	5917
should	2	w	5923
complete	1	w	5931
many	6	w	5935
revolutions	1	w	5946
within	1	w	5952
it	71	w	5954
in	103	w	5956
the	131	w	5959
whole	1	w	5964
course	1	w	5970
of	53	w	5972
time	5	w	5976
as	42	w	5979
we	17	w	5981
may	3	w	5984
judge	1	w	5989
from	8	w	5993
what	3	w	5997
happens	1	w	6004
before	1	w	6010
our	9	w	6013
eyes	1	w	6017
For	5	w	6021
in	104	w	6023
the	132	w	6026
case	2	w	6030
of	54	w	6032
lakes	1	w	6037
and	69	w	6040
rivers	2	w	6046
and	70	w	6050
even	3	w	6054
more	1	w	6058
frequently	1	w	6068
in	105	w	6070
hot	2	w	6073
springs	1	w	6080
there	8	w	6086
have	3	w	6090
occurred	1	w	6098
disappearances	2	w	6112
and	71	w	6115
complete	2	w	6123
extinction	1	w	6133
in	108	w	6135
some	7	w	6139
places	1	w	6145
and	72	w	6149
in	109	w	6151
others	2	w	6157
a	447	w	6158
stealing	1	w	6166
away	3	w	6170
as	44	w	6173
it	72	w	6175
were	2	w	6179
and	73	w	6183
sinking	1	w	6190
under	3	w	6195
ground	1	w	6201
A	16	w	6202
not	10	w	6205
uncommon	1	w	6213
phenomenon	2	w	6223
in	113	w	6225
Greece	1	w	6231
cf	2	w	6234
Moralia	4	w	6242
557	1	w	6246
e	735	w	6247
later	3	w	6254
they	9	w	6258
came	3	w	6262
back	1	w	6266
appearing	1	w	6276
after	1	w	6281
a	461	w	6282
time	6	w	6286
in	115	w	6288
the	136	w	6291
same	5	w	6295
places	2	w	6301
or	51	w	6303
flowing	1	w	6310
out	7	w	6313
from	9	w	6317
below	1	w	6322
somewhere	1	w	6331
near	1	w	6335
We	1	w	6338
know	1	w	6342
also	4	w	6346
of	55	w	6348
the	137	w	6351
exhaustion	1	w	6361
of	56	w	6363
mines	1	w	6368
some	9	w	6373
of	57	w	6375
which	17	w	6380
have	4	w	6384
given	1	w	6389
out	8	w	6392
recently	1	w	6400
as	45	w	6403
for	20	w	6406
example	1	w	6413
the	138	w	6416
silver	1	w	6422
mines	2	w	6427
of	58	w	6429
Attica	1	w	6435
and	74	w	6438
the	139	w	6441
copper	2	w	6447
ore	10	w	6450
in	119	w	6452
Euboea	1	w	6458
from	10	w	6462
which	18	w	6467
the	140	w	6470
cold-forged	1	w	6481
sword-blades	1	w	6493
used	2	w	6497
to	40	w	6499
be	20	w	6501
wrought	1	w	6508
as	46	w	6511
Aeschylus	1	w	6520
Cf	9	w	6522
Nauck	2	w	6528
Trag	2	w	6533
Graec	2	w	6539
Frag	4	w	6544
p	167	w	6546
107	1	w	6550
Aeschylus	2	w	6560
no	24	w	6563
356	1	w	6567
The	5	w	6571
hardness	1	w	6579
and	75	w	6582
temper	6	w	6588
of	59	w	6590
cold-forged	2	w	6601
copper	3	w	6607
is	67	w	6609
well	2	w	6613
attested	1	w	6621
has	7	w	6625
said	2	w	6629
Euboean	1	w	6637
sword	4	w	6642
self-sharpened	1	w	6657
in	120	w	6660
his	11	w	6663
hand	1	w	6667
And	3	w	6671
it	73	w	6673
is	69	w	6675
no	25	w	6677
long	1	w	6681
time	7	w	6685
since	1	w	6690
the	141	w	6693
rock	1	w	6697
in	122	w	6699
Euboea	3	w	6705
ceased	1	w	6711
to	41	w	6713
yield	1	w	6718
among	2	w	6724
its	8	w	6727
other	10	w	6732
products	1	w	6740
soft	1	w	6745
petrous	1	w	6752
filaments	1	w	6761
like	4	w	6765
yarn	1	w	6769
An	5	w	6772
interesting	1	w	6783
early	1	w	6788
notice	1	w	6794
of	61	w	6796
the	143	w	6799
use	3	w	6802
of	62	w	6804
asbestos	1	w	6812
I	7	w	6814
think	3	w	6819
some	10	w	6823
of	63	w	6825
you	2	w	6828
have	5	w	6832
seen	1	w	6836
towels	1	w	6842
nets	1	w	6847
and	77	w	6851
women	1	w	6856
s	474	w	6858
head-coverings	1	w	6872
from	11	w	6876
there	9	w	6881
which	19	w	6887
cannot	1	w	6893
be	22	w	6895
burned	1	w	6901
by	8	w	6903
fire	1	w	6907
but	9	w	6911
if	7	w	6913
any	9	w	6916
become	3	w	6922
soiled	1	w	6928
by	9	w	6930
use	4	w	6933
their	4	w	6939
owners	1	w	6945
throw	2	w	6950
them	5	w	6954
into	3	w	6958
a	499	w	6959
blazing	1	w	6966
fire	2	w	6970
and	78	w	6973
take	2	w	6977
them	6	w	6981
out	9	w	6984
bright	3	w	6990
and	79	w	6993
clear	1	w	6998
To-day	1	w	7005
all	8	w	7008
this	7	w	7012
has	8	w	7015
disappeared	1	w	7026
and	80	w	7030
there	10	w	7035
are	5	w	7038
scarcely	1	w	7046
any	10	w	7049
attenuated	1	w	7059
fibres	1	w	7065
or	58	w	7067
hairs	1	w	7072
as	51	w	7075
it	75	w	7077
were	3	w	7081
running	2	w	7089
through	5	w	7096
the	149	w	7099
mines	3	w	7104
And	4	w	7108
yet	1	w	7111
the	150	w	7114
school	1	w	7120
of	64	w	7122
Aristotle	2	w	7131
Cf	10	w	7133
Aristotle	3	w	7143
Meteorologica	1	w	7157
i	503	w	7159
3	13	w	7161
340	1	w	7165
b	85	w	7166
29	2	w	7168
Cicero	1	w	7176
De	4	w	7179
Divinatione	1	w	7190
i	508	w	7192
19	1	w	7195
38	2	w	7198
ii	4	w	7202
57	2	w	7205
117	2	w	7209
would	2	w	7216
make	5	w	7220
it	76	w	7222
appear	6	w	7228
that	24	w	7232
exhalation	1	w	7242
is	74	w	7244
the	151	w	7247
author	1	w	7253
of	65	w	7255
all	9	w	7258
these	2	w	7263
changes	2	w	7270
that	25	w	7274
have	6	w	7278
taken	1	w	7283
place	6	w	7288
in	132	w	7290
the	153	w	7293
earth	5	w	7298
and	81	w	7302
that	26	w	7306
things	1	w	7312
of	66	w	7314
this	8	w	7318
nature	2	w	7324
must	1	w	7328
of	67	w	7330
necessity	1	w	7339
follow	2	w	7345
with	19	w	7349
it	79	w	7351
in	134	w	7353
disappearing	1	w	7365
changing	1	w	7374
their	5	w	7379
locality	1	w	7387
and	82	w	7391
bursting	1	w	7399
forth	4	w	7404
once	1	w	7408
more	2	w	7412
in	138	w	7414
full	1	w	7418
vigour	1	w	7424
Plainly	1	w	7432
the	155	w	7435
same	6	w	7439
sober	1	w	7444
opinion	2	w	7451
is	77	w	7453
to	47	w	7455
be	25	w	7457
held	1	w	7461
regarding	2	w	7470
the	156	w	7473
spirits	1	w	7480
that	27	w	7484
inspire	2	w	7491
prophecy	4	w	7499
the	157	w	7503
power	9	w	7508
that	28	w	7512
they	10	w	7516
possess	4	w	7523
is	78	w	7525
not	13	w	7528
everlasting	2	w	7539
and	83	w	7542
ageless	1	w	7549
but	10	w	7553
is	79	w	7555
subject	2	w	7562
to	48	w	7564
changes	3	w	7571
For	6	w	7575
excessive	1	w	7584
rains	1	w	7589
most	4	w	7593
likely	2	w	7599
extinguish	2	w	7609
them	7	w	7613
and	84	w	7617
they	11	w	7621
probably	1	w	7629
are	6	w	7632
dispersed	1	w	7641
by	10	w	7643
thunderbolts	1	w	7655
and	85	w	7659
especially	1	w	7669
when	12	w	7674
the	161	w	7677
earth	6	w	7682
is	82	w	7684
shaken	2	w	7690
beneath	1	w	7697
by	11	w	7699
an	131	w	7701
earthquake	1	w	7711
and	86	w	7714
suffers	1	w	7721
subsidence	1	w	7731
and	87	w	7734
ruinous	1	w	7741
confusion	1	w	7750
in	147	w	7752
its	10	w	7755
depths	1	w	7761
the	162	w	7765
exhalations	1	w	7776
shift	2	w	7781
their	6	w	7786
site	2	w	7790
or	64	w	7792
find	1	w	7796
completely	1	w	7806
blind	1	w	7811
outlets	1	w	7818
as	53	w	7821
in	150	w	7823
this	9	w	7827
place	7	w	7832
they	12	w	7836
say	4	w	7839
that	29	w	7843
there	11	w	7848
are	7	w	7851
still	3	w	7856
traces	1	w	7862
of	68	w	7864
that	30	w	7868
great	1	w	7873
earthquake	2	w	7883
which	20	w	7888
overthrew	1	w	7897
the	166	w	7900
city	1	w	7904
And	5	w	7908
in	151	w	7910
Orchomenos	1	w	7920
they	13	w	7924
relate	1	w	7930
that	31	w	7934
a	579	w	7935
pestilence	1	w	7945
raged	1	w	7950
and	88	w	7953
many	7	w	7957
persons	2	w	7964
died	1	w	7968
of	69	w	7970
it	85	w	7972
and	89	w	7976
the	168	w	7979
oracle	2	w	7985
of	70	w	7987
Teiresias	1	w	7996
become	4	w	8002
altogether	1	w	8012
obsolescent	1	w	8023
and	90	w	8026
even	4	w	8030
to	50	w	8032
this	10	w	8036
day	2	w	8039
remains	1	w	8046
idle	1	w	8050
and	91	w	8053
mute	1	w	8057
And	6	w	8061
if	9	w	8063
a	591	w	8064
like	6	w	8068
fate	1	w	8072
has	9	w	8075
befallen	1	w	8083
those	3	w	8088
in	153	w	8090
Cilicia	1	w	8097
as	56	w	8100
we	23	w	8102
have	7	w	8106
been	1	w	8110
told	2	w	8114
there	12	w	8120
is	85	w	8122
nobody	1	w	8128
Demetrius	2	w	8138
who	6	w	8142
could	1	w	8147
give	2	w	8151
us	34	w	8153
more	3	w	8157
certain	3	w	8164
information	1	w	8175
than	2	w	8179
you	3	w	8182