Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Obsolesence of Oracles

The Obsolesence of Oracles (30-31)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg092.perseus-eng3:30-31
Refs {'start': {'reference': '30', 'human_reference': 'Section 30'}, 'end': {'reference': '31', 'human_reference': 'Section 31'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

That other concept is, I think, more dignified and sublime, that the gods are not subject to outside control, but are their own masters, even as the twin sons of Tyndareüs[*] come to the aid of men who are labouring in the storm,

Soothing the oncoming raging sea,
Taming the swift-driving blasts of the winds,[*]
not, however, sailing on the ships and sharing in the danger, but appearing above and rescuing; so, in the same way, one or another of the gods visits now this world and now that, led thither by pleasure in the sight, and co-operates with Nature in the directing of each. The Zeus of Homer[*] turned his gaze not so very far away from the land of Troy towards the
Thracian regions and the wandering tribes about the Danube; but the real Zeus has a fair and fitting variety of spectacles in numerous worlds, not viewing the infinite void outside nor concentrating his mind upon himself and nothing else, as some have imagined,[*] but surveying from above the many works of gods and men and the movements and courses of the stars in their cycles. In fact, the Deity is not averse to changes, but has a very great joy therein, to judge, if need be, by the alternations and cycles in the heavens among the bodies that are visible there. Infinity is altogether senseless and unreasoning, and nowhere admits a god, but in all relations it brings into action the concept of chance and accident. But the Oversight and Providence in a limited group and number of worlds, when compared with that which has entered one body and become attached to one and reshapes and remodels it an infinite number of times, seems to me to contain nothing involving less dignity or greater labour.

Having spoken at this length, I stopped. Philip, after no long interval, said, That the truth about these matters is thus or otherwise is not for me to assert. But if we eliminate the god from one world, there is the question why we make him the creator of only five worlds and no more, and what is the relation of this number to the great mass of numbers; and I feel that I would rather gain a knowledge of this than of the meaning of the E[*] dedicated here. For the number five represents neither a triangle nor a square, nor is it a perfect number nor a cube, nor does it seem to present any

other subtlety for those who love and admire such speculations. Its derivation from the number of elements, at which the Master[*] hinted darkly, is in every way hard to grasp and gives no clear intimation of the plausibility which must have drawn him on to assert that it is likely that when five bodies with equal angles and equal sides and enclosed by equal areas are engendered in matter the same number of worlds should at once be perfected from them.

Tokens

That 1 w 4
other 1 w 9
concept 1 w 16
is 1 w 18
I 1 w 20
think 1 w 25
more 1 w 30
dignified 1 w 39
and 1 w 42
sublime 1 w 49
that 1 w 54
the 2 w 57
gods 1 w 61
are 1 w 64
not 1 w 67
subject 1 w 74
to 1 w 76
outside 1 w 83
control 1 w 90
but 1 w 94
are 2 w 97
their 1 w 102
own 1 w 105
masters 1 w 112
even 1 w 117
as 2 w 119
the 4 w 122
twin 1 w 126
sons 1 w 130
of 1 w 132
Tyndareüs 1 w 141
Castor 1 w 147
and 2 w 150
Pollux 1 w 156
the 5 w 160
protectors 1 w 170
of 2 w 172
sailors 1 w 179
come 1 w 184
to 4 w 186
the 6 w 189
aid 1 w 192
of 3 w 194
men 1 w 197
who 1 w 200
are 4 w 203
labouring 1 w 212
in 4 w 214
the 7 w 217
storm 1 w 222
Soothing 1 w 231
the 8 w 234
oncoming 1 w 242
raging 1 w 248
sea 1 w 251
Taming 1 w 258
the 9 w 261
swift-driving 1 w 274
blasts 1 w 280
of 4 w 282
the 10 w 285
winds 1 w 290
Repeated 1 w 299
with 1 w 303
some 1 w 307
variants 1 w 315
by 1 w 317
Plutarch 1 w 325
in 11 w 327
Moralia 1 w 334
1103 1 w 339
c-d 1 w 342
cf 1 w 345
Bergk 1 w 351
Poet 1 w 356
Lyr 1 w 360
Graec 1 w 366
iii 1 w 370
p 4 w 372
730 1 w 376
not 2 w 380
however 1 w 388
sailing 1 w 396
on 5 w 398
the 11 w 401
ships 1 w 406
and 3 w 409
sharing 1 w 416
in 14 w 418
the 12 w 421
danger 1 w 427
but 2 w 431
appearing 1 w 440
above 1 w 445
and 4 w 448
rescuing 1 w 456
so 3 w 459
in 17 w 462
the 13 w 465
same 1 w 469
way 1 w 472
one 1 w 476
or 7 w 478
another 1 w 485
of 5 w 487
the 15 w 490
gods 2 w 494
visits 1 w 500
now 1 w 503
this 1 w 507
world 1 w 512
and 5 w 515
now 2 w 518
that 2 w 522
led 1 w 526
thither 1 w 533
by 2 w 535
pleasure 1 w 543
in 18 w 545
the 17 w 548
sight 1 w 553
and 6 w 557
co-operates 1 w 568
with 2 w 572
Nature 1 w 578
in 19 w 580
the 18 w 583
directing 1 w 592
of 6 w 594
each 1 w 598
The 1 w 602
Zeus 1 w 606
of 7 w 608
Homer 1 w 613
Homer 2 w 618
Il 1 w 621
xiii 1 w 626
3 3 w 628
turned 1 w 635
his 2 w 638
gaze 1 w 642
not 4 w 645
so 4 w 647
very 1 w 651
far 1 w 654
away 1 w 658
from 1 w 662
the 19 w 665
land 1 w 669
of 8 w 671
Troy 1 w 675
towards 1 w 682
the 20 w 685
Thracian 1 w 693
regions 1 w 700
and 8 w 703
the 21 w 706
wandering 1 w 715
tribes 1 w 721
about 1 w 726
the 22 w 729
Danube 1 w 735
but 3 w 739
the 23 w 742
real 1 w 746
Zeus 2 w 750
has 1 w 753
a 58 w 754
fair 1 w 758
and 10 w 761
fitting 1 w 768
variety 1 w 775
of 9 w 777
spectacles 1 w 787
in 23 w 789
numerous 1 w 797
worlds 1 w 803
not 5 w 807
viewing 1 w 814
the 24 w 817
infinite 1 w 825
void 1 w 829
outside 2 w 836
nor 1 w 839
concentrating 1 w 852
his 3 w 855
mind 1 w 859
upon 1 w 863
himself 1 w 870
and 11 w 873
nothing 1 w 880
else 1 w 884
as 7 w 887
some 2 w 891
have 1 w 895
imagined 1 w 903
Cf 1 w 906
Aristotle 1 w 916
The 2 w 920
Eudemian 1 w 928
Ethics 1 w 934
vii 1 w 938
12 1 w 941
16 1 w 944
1245 1 w 949
b 14 w 950
14 1 w 952
but 4 w 957
surveying 1 w 966
from 2 w 970
above 2 w 975
the 25 w 978
many 1 w 982
works 1 w 987
of 10 w 989
gods 3 w 993
and 12 w 996
men 2 w 999
and 13 w 1002
the 26 w 1005
movements 1 w 1014
and 14 w 1017
courses 1 w 1024
of 11 w 1026
the 27 w 1029
stars 1 w 1034
in 32 w 1036
their 2 w 1041
cycles 1 w 1047
In 1 w 1050
fact 1 w 1054
the 29 w 1058
Deity 1 w 1063
is 7 w 1065
not 7 w 1068
averse 1 w 1074
to 8 w 1076
changes 1 w 1083
but 5 w 1087
has 2 w 1090
a 79 w 1091
very 2 w 1095
great 1 w 1100
joy 1 w 1103
therein 1 w 1110
to 9 w 1113
judge 1 w 1118
if 3 w 1121
need 1 w 1125
be 3 w 1127
by 3 w 1130
the 31 w 1133
alternations 1 w 1145
and 15 w 1148
cycles 2 w 1154
in 34 w 1156
the 32 w 1159
heavens 1 w 1166
among 1 w 1171
the 33 w 1174
bodies 1 w 1180
that 3 w 1184
are 5 w 1187
visible 1 w 1194
there 2 w 1199
Infinity 1 w 1208
is 9 w 1210
altogether 1 w 1220
senseless 1 w 1229
and 16 w 1232
unreasoning 1 w 1243
and 17 w 1247
nowhere 1 w 1254
admits 1 w 1260
a 93 w 1261
god 4 w 1264
but 6 w 1268
in 37 w 1270
all 1 w 1273
relations 1 w 1282
it 10 w 1284
brings 1 w 1290
into 1 w 1294
action 1 w 1300
the 36 w 1303
concept 2 w 1310
of 12 w 1312
chance 1 w 1318
and 18 w 1321
accident 1 w 1329
But 1 w 1333
the 37 w 1336
Oversight 1 w 1345
and 19 w 1348
Providence 1 w 1358
in 40 w 1360
a 101 w 1361
limited 1 w 1368
group 1 w 1373
and 20 w 1376
number 1 w 1382
of 13 w 1384
worlds 2 w 1390
when 1 w 1395
compared 1 w 1403
with 3 w 1407
that 4 w 1411
which 1 w 1416
has 3 w 1419
entered 1 w 1426
one 2 w 1429
body 1 w 1433
and 21 w 1436
become 1 w 1442
attached 1 w 1450
to 12 w 1452
one 3 w 1455
and 22 w 1458
reshapes 1 w 1466
and 23 w 1469
remodels 1 w 1477
it 13 w 1479
an 33 w 1481
infinite 2 w 1489
number 2 w 1495
of 14 w 1497
times 1 w 1502
seems 1 w 1508
to 13 w 1510
me 14 w 1512
to 14 w 1514
contain 1 w 1521
nothing 2 w 1528
involving 1 w 1537
less 2 w 1541
dignity 1 w 1548
or 13 w 1550
greater 1 w 1557
labour 2 w 1563
Having 1 w 1570
spoken 1 w 1576
at 15 w 1578
this 2 w 1582
length 1 w 1588
I 5 w 1590
stopped 1 w 1597
Philip 1 w 1604
after 1 w 1610
no 13 w 1612
long 1 w 1616
interval 1 w 1624
said 1 w 1629
That 2 w 1634
the 38 w 1637
truth 1 w 1642
about 2 w 1647
these 1 w 1652
matters 1 w 1659
is 11 w 1661
thus 1 w 1665
or 14 w 1667
otherwise 1 w 1676
is 13 w 1678
not 9 w 1681
for 1 w 1684
me 15 w 1686
to 16 w 1688
assert 1 w 1694
But 2 w 1698
if 4 w 1700
we 2 w 1702
eliminate 1 w 1711
the 41 w 1714
god 5 w 1717
from 3 w 1721
one 4 w 1724
world 4 w 1729
there 3 w 1735
is 14 w 1737
the 43 w 1740
question 1 w 1748
why 1 w 1751
we 3 w 1753
make 1 w 1757
him 2 w 1760
the 44 w 1763
creator 1 w 1770
of 15 w 1772
only 1 w 1776
five 1 w 1780
worlds 3 w 1786
and 24 w 1789
no 15 w 1791
more 2 w 1795
and 25 w 1799
what 1 w 1803
is 15 w 1805
the 45 w 1808
relation 2 w 1816
of 16 w 1818
this 3 w 1822
number 3 w 1828
to 18 w 1830
the 46 w 1833
great 3 w 1838
mass 1 w 1842
of 17 w 1844
numbers 1 w 1851
and 26 w 1855
I 6 w 1856
feel 1 w 1860
that 5 w 1864
I 7 w 1865
would 1 w 1870
rather 1 w 1876
gain 1 w 1880
a 138 w 1881
knowledge 1 w 1890
of 18 w 1892
this 4 w 1896
than 1 w 1900
of 19 w 1902
the 48 w 1905
meaning 1 w 1912
of 20 w 1914
the 49 w 1917
E 3 w 1918
The 3 w 1921
meaning 2 w 1928
is 18 w 1930
discussed 1 w 1939
in 53 w 1941
the 50 w 1944
second 1 w 1950
essay 1 w 1955
of 21 w 1957
this 5 w 1961
volume 1 w 1967
dedicated 1 w 1977
here 5 w 1981
For 1 w 1985
the 51 w 1988
number 5 w 1994
five 2 w 1998
represents 1 w 2008
neither 1 w 2015
a 144 w 2016
triangle 1 w 2024
nor 2 w 2027
a 146 w 2028
square 1 w 2034
nor 3 w 2038
is 21 w 2040
it 17 w 2042
a 148 w 2043
perfect 1 w 2050
number 6 w 2056
nor 4 w 2059
a 149 w 2060
cube 1 w 2064
nor 5 w 2068
does 1 w 2072
it 18 w 2074
seem 2 w 2078
to 19 w 2080
present 2 w 2087
any 2 w 2090
other 4 w 2095
subtlety 1 w 2103
for 2 w 2106
those 1 w 2111
who 2 w 2114
love 1 w 2118
and 27 w 2121
admire 1 w 2127
such 1 w 2131
speculations 1 w 2143
Its 1 w 2147
derivation 1 w 2157
from 4 w 2161
the 54 w 2164
number 7 w 2170
of 22 w 2172
elements 1 w 2180
at 28 w 2183
which 2 w 2188
the 55 w 2191
Master 1 w 2197
Presumably 1 w 2207
Pythagoras 1 w 2217
but 7 w 2221
possibly 1 w 2229
Plato 1 w 2234
hinted 1 w 2241
darkly 1 w 2247
is 22 w 2250
in 55 w 2252
every 1 w 2257
way 3 w 2260
hard 1 w 2264
to 21 w 2266
grasp 1 w 2271
and 28 w 2274
gives 1 w 2279
no 21 w 2281
clear 1 w 2286
intimation 1 w 2296
of 23 w 2298
the 56 w 2301
plausibility 1 w 2313
which 3 w 2318
must 1 w 2322
have 2 w 2326
drawn 1 w 2331
him 3 w 2334
on 28 w 2336
to 22 w 2338
assert 2 w 2344
that 6 w 2348
it 20 w 2350
is 23 w 2352
likely 1 w 2358
that 7 w 2362
when 2 w 2366
five 3 w 2370
bodies 2 w 2376
with 4 w 2380
equal 1 w 2385
angles 1 w 2391
and 29 w 2394
equal 2 w 2399
sides 1 w 2404
and 30 w 2407
enclosed 1 w 2415
by 4 w 2417
equal 3 w 2422
areas 1 w 2427
are 9 w 2430
engendered 1 w 2440
in 57 w 2442
matter 2 w 2448
the 57 w 2451
same 2 w 2455
number 8 w 2461
of 24 w 2463
worlds 4 w 2469
should 1 w 2475
at 34 w 2477
once 4 w 2481
be 14 w 2483
perfected 1 w 2492
from 5 w 2496
them 1 w 2500