Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Oracle at Delphi no Longer Given in Verse

The Oracle at Delphi no Longer Given in Verse (19)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg091.perseus-eng3:19
Refs {'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'Section 19'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Theon, taking up the subject, said, But these matters have actually undergone great changes and innovations, whereas you know that many of the oracles here have been given out in prose, and those that concerned no unimportant matters. For, as Thucydides[*] has recorded, when the Spartans consulted the god about their war against the Athenians, his answer was a promise of victory and power and that he himself would come to their aid, bidden or unbidden; and in another oracle that if they would not allow Pleistoanax to return from exile, they should plough with a silver ploughshare.[*]

When the Athenians sought advice about their campaign in Sicily, he directed them to get the priestess of Athena at Erythrae; the name which the woman bore was Quiet.[*]

When Deinomenes of Sicily asked advice about his sons, the answer was that all three should rule as despots; and when Deinomenes rejoined, To their sorrow, then, O Lord Apollo, the god said that he granted this also to Deinomenes, and added it to the response. You all know, of course, that Gelo, while he was despot, suffered from dropsy; and likewise Hiero from gall-stones; and the third, Thrasybulus, became involved in seditions and wars, and it was no long time before he was dethroned.

Then there was Procles, the despot of Epidaurus, who did away with many men in a cruel and lawless manner, and finally put to death Timarchus, who had come to him from Athens with money, after receiving him and entertaining him with much show of hospitality. The body he thrust into a basket and sank in the sea. All this he accomplished through Cleander of Aegina, and nobody else knew anything about it. But later, when his affairs were in sad confusion, he sent here his brother Cleotimus to ask advice in secret concerning his flight and withdrawal to another country. The god therefore made answer that he granted Procles flight and withdrawal to the place in which he had bidden his friend from Aegina deposit the basket, or where the stag sheds his horns. The despot at once understood that the god ordered him to sink himself in the sea or to bury himself in the earth (for stags, whenever their horns fall off, bury them out of sight underground[*]); but he waited for a short time, and then, when the state of his aflairs became altogether desperate, he had to leave the country. And the friends of Timarchus seized him, slew him, and cast forth his dead body into the sea.

Most important of all is the fact that the decrees through which Lycurgus gave form and order to the Spartan constitution were given to him in prose.

Now Herodotus and Philochorus and Ister, men who were most assiduous in collecting prophecies in verse, have quoted countless oracles not in verse; but Theopompus, who has given more diligent study to the oracle than any one man, has strongly rebuked those who do not believe that in his time the prophetic priestess used verse in her oracular responses. Afterwards, wishing to prove this, he has found to support his contention an altogether meagre number of such oracles, indicating that the others were given out in prose even as early as that time.

Tokens

Theon 1 w 5
taking 1 w 12
up 1 w 14
the 1 w 17
subject 1 w 24
said 1 w 29
But 1 w 33
these 1 w 38
matters 1 w 45
have 1 w 49
actually 1 w 57
undergone 1 w 66
great 1 w 71
changes 1 w 78
and 1 w 81
innovations 1 w 92
whereas 1 w 100
you 1 w 103
know 1 w 107
that 1 w 111
many 1 w 115
of 1 w 117
the 3 w 120
oracles 1 w 127
here 2 w 131
have 2 w 135
been 1 w 139
given 1 w 144
out 1 w 147
in 3 w 149
prose 1 w 154
and 2 w 158
those 1 w 163
that 2 w 167
concerned 1 w 176
no 3 w 178
unimportant 1 w 189
matters 2 w 196
For 1 w 200
as 2 w 203
Thucydides 1 w 213
Thucydides 2 w 223
i 10 w 225
118 1 w 229
has 1 w 233
recorded 1 w 241
when 1 w 246
the 4 w 249
Spartans 1 w 257
consulted 1 w 266
the 5 w 269
god 1 w 272
about 1 w 277
their 1 w 282
war 1 w 285
against 1 w 292
the 7 w 295
Athenians 1 w 304
his 1 w 308
answer 1 w 314
was 1 w 317
a 31 w 318
promise 1 w 325
of 2 w 327
victory 1 w 334
and 3 w 337
power 1 w 342
and 4 w 345
that 3 w 349
he 13 w 351
himself 1 w 358
would 1 w 363
come 1 w 367
to 2 w 369
their 2 w 374
aid 2 w 377
bidden 1 w 384
or 6 w 386
unbidden 1 w 394
and 5 w 398
in 5 w 400
another 1 w 407
oracle 2 w 413
that 4 w 417
if 1 w 419
they 1 w 423
would 2 w 428
not 2 w 431
allow 1 w 436
Pleistoanax 1 w 447
to 4 w 449
return 1 w 455
from 1 w 459
exile 1 w 464
they 2 w 469
should 1 w 475
plough 1 w 481
with 1 w 485
a 43 w 486
silver 1 w 492
ploughshare 1 w 503
Ibid 1 w 508
v 7 w 510
16 1 w 513
The 2 w 517
meaning 1 w 524
seems 1 w 529
to 5 w 531
be 2 w 533
that 5 w 537
they 3 w 541
would 3 w 546
have 3 w 550
to 6 w 552
buy 1 w 555
their 3 w 560
grain 1 w 565
When 1 w 570
the 15 w 573
Athenians 2 w 582
sought 1 w 588
advice 1 w 594
about 2 w 599
their 4 w 604
campaign 1 w 612
in 8 w 614
Sicily 1 w 620
he 25 w 623
directed 1 w 631
them 1 w 635
to 7 w 637
get 1 w 640
the 19 w 643
priestess 1 w 652
of 3 w 654
Athena 1 w 660
at 10 w 662
Erythrae 1 w 670
the 21 w 674
name 1 w 678
which 1 w 683
the 22 w 686
woman 1 w 691
bore 1 w 695
was 2 w 698
Quiet 1 w 703
Cf 1 w 706
Life 1 w 711
of 4 w 713
Nicias 1 w 719
chap 1 w 724
xiii 1 w 729
532 1 w 734
a 62 w 735
where 2 w 742
it 2 w 744
is 4 w 746
explained 1 w 755
that 6 w 759
the 23 w 762
god 2 w 765
advised 1 w 772
them 2 w 776
τὴν 1 w 779
ἡσυχίαν 1 w 786
ἄγειν 1 w 791
to 8 w 794
keep 1 w 798
Quiet 2 w 803
When 2 w 808
Deinomenes 1 w 818
of 5 w 820
Sicily 2 w 826
asked 1 w 831
advice 2 w 837
about 3 w 842
his 2 w 845
sons 1 w 849
the 25 w 853
answer 2 w 859
was 3 w 862
that 7 w 866
all 3 w 869
three 1 w 874
should 2 w 880
rule 1 w 884
as 9 w 886
despots 1 w 893
and 6 w 897
when 2 w 901
Deinomenes 2 w 911
rejoined 1 w 919
To 1 w 922
their 5 w 927
sorrow 1 w 933
then 4 w 938
O 1 w 940
Lord 1 w 944
Apollo 1 w 950
the 28 w 954
god 3 w 957
said 2 w 961
that 8 w 965
he 40 w 967
granted 1 w 974
this 1 w 978
also 1 w 982
to 9 w 984
Deinomenes 3 w 994
and 7 w 998
added 1 w 1003
it 3 w 1005
to 10 w 1007
the 29 w 1010
response 1 w 1018
You 1 w 1022
all 4 w 1025
know 2 w 1029
of 6 w 1032
course 1 w 1038
that 9 w 1043
Gelo 1 w 1047
while 1 w 1053
he 42 w 1055
was 4 w 1058
despot 2 w 1064
suffered 1 w 1073
from 2 w 1077
dropsy 1 w 1083
and 8 w 1087
likewise 1 w 1095
Hiero 1 w 1100
from 3 w 1104
gall-stones 1 w 1115
and 9 w 1119
the 30 w 1122
third 1 w 1127
Thrasybulus 1 w 1139
became 1 w 1146
involved 1 w 1154
in 15 w 1156
seditions 1 w 1165
and 10 w 1168
wars 1 w 1172
and 11 w 1176
it 5 w 1178
was 5 w 1181
no 10 w 1183
long 1 w 1187
time 1 w 1191
before 1 w 1197
he 44 w 1199
was 6 w 1202
dethroned 1 w 1211
Then 1 w 1216
there 1 w 1221
was 7 w 1224
Procles 1 w 1231
the 32 w 1235
despot 3 w 1241
of 7 w 1243
Epidaurus 1 w 1252
who 1 w 1256
did 3 w 1259
away 1 w 1263
with 2 w 1267
many 2 w 1271
men 4 w 1274
in 16 w 1276
a 99 w 1277
cruel 1 w 1282
and 12 w 1285
lawless 1 w 1292
manner 1 w 1298
and 13 w 1302
finally 1 w 1309
put 1 w 1312
to 12 w 1314
death 1 w 1319
Timarchus 1 w 1328
who 2 w 1332
had 1 w 1335
come 2 w 1339
to 13 w 1341
him 2 w 1344
from 4 w 1348
Athens 1 w 1354
with 3 w 1358
money 1 w 1363
after 1 w 1369
receiving 1 w 1378
him 3 w 1381
and 14 w 1384
entertaining 1 w 1396
him 4 w 1399
with 4 w 1403
much 1 w 1407
show 1 w 1411
of 8 w 1413
hospitality 1 w 1424
The 4 w 1428
body 1 w 1432
he 50 w 1434
thrust 1 w 1440
into 1 w 1444
a 112 w 1445
basket 1 w 1451
and 15 w 1454
sank 1 w 1458
in 22 w 1460
the 34 w 1463
sea 1 w 1466
All 1 w 1470
this 2 w 1474
he 52 w 1476
accomplished 1 w 1488
through 1 w 1495
Cleander 1 w 1503
of 9 w 1505
Aegina 1 w 1511
and 17 w 1515
nobody 1 w 1521
else 1 w 1525
knew 1 w 1529
anything 1 w 1537
about 4 w 1542
it 11 w 1544
But 2 w 1548
later 1 w 1553
when 3 w 1558
his 5 w 1561
affairs 1 w 1568
were 1 w 1572
in 25 w 1574
sad 1 w 1577
confusion 1 w 1586
he 55 w 1589
sent 1 w 1593
here 5 w 1597
his 6 w 1600
brother 1 w 1607
Cleotimus 1 w 1616
to 15 w 1618
ask 3 w 1621
advice 3 w 1627
in 26 w 1629
secret 1 w 1635
concerning 1 w 1645
his 7 w 1648
flight 1 w 1654
and 18 w 1657
withdrawal 1 w 1667
to 16 w 1669
another 2 w 1676
country 1 w 1683
The 5 w 1687
god 4 w 1690
therefore 1 w 1699
made 1 w 1703
answer 3 w 1709
that 10 w 1713
he 61 w 1715
granted 2 w 1722
Procles 2 w 1729
flight 2 w 1735
and 19 w 1738
withdrawal 2 w 1748
to 17 w 1750
the 38 w 1753
place 1 w 1758
in 28 w 1760
which 2 w 1765
he 63 w 1767
had 2 w 1770
bidden 3 w 1776
his 8 w 1779
friend 1 w 1785
from 5 w 1789
Aegina 2 w 1795
deposit 1 w 1802
the 39 w 1805
basket 2 w 1811
or 13 w 1814
where 3 w 1819
the 40 w 1822
stag 1 w 1826
sheds 1 w 1831
his 9 w 1834
horns 1 w 1839
The 6 w 1843
despot 4 w 1849
at 18 w 1851
once 3 w 1855
understood 1 w 1865
that 11 w 1869
the 41 w 1872
god 5 w 1875
ordered 1 w 1882
him 5 w 1885
to 19 w 1887
sink 1 w 1891
himself 2 w 1898
in 31 w 1900
the 42 w 1903
sea 2 w 1906
or 16 w 1908
to 20 w 1910
bury 1 w 1914
himself 3 w 1921
in 32 w 1923
the 43 w 1926
earth 1 w 1931
for 3 w 1935
stags 1 w 1940
whenever 1 w 1949
their 6 w 1954
horns 2 w 1959
fall 1 w 1963
off 1 w 1966
bury 2 w 1971
them 3 w 1975
out 6 w 1978
of 11 w 1980
sight 1 w 1985
underground 1 w 1996
Cf 2 w 1998
Moralia 1 w 2006
700 1 w 2010
d 98 w 2011
but 1 w 2017
he 75 w 2019
waited 1 w 2025
for 4 w 2028
a 154 w 2029
short 1 w 2034
time 2 w 2038
and 20 w 2042
then 6 w 2046
when 5 w 2051
the 47 w 2054
state 1 w 2059
of 12 w 2061
his 10 w 2064
aflairs 1 w 2071
became 2 w 2077
altogether 1 w 2087
desperate 1 w 2096
he 80 w 2099
had 3 w 2102
to 22 w 2104
leave 1 w 2109
the 49 w 2112
country 2 w 2119
And 1 w 2123
the 50 w 2126
friends 1 w 2133
of 13 w 2135
Timarchus 2 w 2144
seized 1 w 2150
him 8 w 2153
slew 1 w 2158
him 9 w 2161
and 21 w 2165
cast 1 w 2169
forth 1 w 2174
his 11 w 2177
dead 1 w 2181
body 3 w 2185
into 2 w 2189
the 51 w 2192
sea 3 w 2195
Most 1 w 2200
important 2 w 2209
of 14 w 2211
all 8 w 2214
is 18 w 2216
the 52 w 2219
fact 1 w 2223
that 12 w 2227
the 53 w 2230
decrees 1 w 2237
through 2 w 2244
which 3 w 2249
Lycurgus 1 w 2257
gave 1 w 2261
form 1 w 2265
and 22 w 2268
order 2 w 2273
to 24 w 2275
the 54 w 2278
Spartan 2 w 2285
constitution 1 w 2297
were 2 w 2301
given 2 w 2306
to 25 w 2308
him 10 w 2311
in 34 w 2313
prose 2 w 2318
Now 1 w 2322
Herodotus 1 w 2331
and 23 w 2334
Philochorus 1 w 2345
and 24 w 2348
Ister 1 w 2353
men 5 w 2357
who 3 w 2360
were 3 w 2364
most 1 w 2368
assiduous 1 w 2377
in 35 w 2379
collecting 1 w 2389
prophecies 1 w 2399
in 37 w 2401
verse 1 w 2406
have 4 w 2411
quoted 1 w 2417
countless 1 w 2426
oracles 2 w 2433
not 4 w 2436
in 38 w 2438
verse 2 w 2443
but 2 w 2447
Theopompus 1 w 2457
who 4 w 2461
has 2 w 2464
given 3 w 2469
more 1 w 2473
diligent 1 w 2481
study 1 w 2486
to 26 w 2488
the 55 w 2491
oracle 4 w 2497
than 1 w 2501
any 4 w 2504
one 5 w 2507
man 5 w 2510
has 3 w 2514
strongly 1 w 2522
rebuked 1 w 2529
those 2 w 2534
who 5 w 2537
do 2 w 2539
not 5 w 2542
believe 1 w 2549
that 13 w 2553
in 39 w 2555
his 12 w 2558
time 3 w 2562
the 56 w 2565
prophetic 1 w 2574
priestess 2 w 2583
used 1 w 2587
verse 3 w 2592
in 40 w 2594
her 12 w 2597
oracular 1 w 2605
responses 1 w 2614
Afterwards 1 w 2625
wishing 1 w 2633
to 27 w 2635
prove 1 w 2640
this 3 w 2644
he 93 w 2647
has 4 w 2650
found 1 w 2655
to 28 w 2657
support 1 w 2664
his 14 w 2667
contention 1 w 2677
an 50 w 2679
altogether 2 w 2689
meagre 1 w 2695
number 1 w 2701
of 15 w 2703
such 1 w 2707
oracles 3 w 2714
indicating 1 w 2725
that 14 w 2729
the 58 w 2732
others 1 w 2738
were 4 w 2742
given 4 w 2747
out 7 w 2750
in 44 w 2752
prose 3 w 2757
even 1 w 2761
as 23 w 2763
early 1 w 2768
as 24 w 2770
that 15 w 2774
time 4 w 2778