Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Oracle at Delphi no Longer Given in Verse

The Oracle at Delphi no Longer Given in Verse (18)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg091.perseus-eng3:18
Refs {'start': {'reference': '18', 'human_reference': 'Section 18'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

That, Boëthus, said Sarapion, is more reasonable and harmonious. For we must not show hostility towards the god, nor do away with his providence and divine powers together with his prophetic gifts; but we must seek for explanations of such matters as seem to stand in the way, and not relinquish the reverent faith of our fathers.

What you say, my esteemed Sarapion, said I, is quite right. We have not been surrendering hope for philosophy either, as if it had been completely done away with and destroyed, just because formerly the philosophers used to publish their doctrines and discourses in the form of poems, as Orpheus, Hesiod, Parmenides, Xenophanes, Empedocles, and Thales. Later they ceased to do this, and now all have ceased using metrical form, all except you. At your hands the poetic art returns to philosophy from its banishment, and sounds a clear and noble challenge to the young.

Nor did Aristarchus, Timocharis, Aristyllus, and Hipparchus, and their followers make astronomy less
notable by writing in prose, although in earlier days Eudoxus, Hesiod, and Thales wrote in verse, if indeed Thales, in all truth, composed the Astronomy which is attributed to him. Pindar also confesses that he is puzzled by the neglect of a mode of music and is astonished that[*] The fact is that there is nothing dreadful nor abnormal in seeking the causes of such changes; but to do away with these arts and faculties themselves because something about them has been disturbed or changed is not right.

Tokens

That 1 w 4
Boëthus 1 w 12
said 1 w 17
Sarapion 1 w 25
is 1 w 28
more 1 w 32
reasonable 1 w 42
and 1 w 45
harmonious 1 w 55
For 1 w 59
we 1 w 61
must 1 w 65
not 1 w 68
show 1 w 72
hostility 1 w 81
towards 1 w 88
the 1 w 91
god 1 w 94
nor 1 w 98
do 1 w 100
away 1 w 104
with 1 w 108
his 1 w 111
providence 1 w 121
and 2 w 124
divine 1 w 130
powers 1 w 136
together 1 w 144
with 2 w 148
his 2 w 151
prophetic 1 w 160
gifts 1 w 165
but 1 w 169
we 3 w 171
must 2 w 175
seek 1 w 179
for 1 w 182
explanations 1 w 194
of 1 w 196
such 1 w 200
matters 1 w 207
as 2 w 209
seem 1 w 213
to 3 w 215
stand 1 w 220
in 2 w 222
the 3 w 225
way 2 w 228
and 4 w 232
not 2 w 235
relinquish 1 w 245
the 4 w 248
reverent 1 w 256
faith 1 w 261
of 2 w 263
our 1 w 266
fathers 1 w 273
What 1 w 278
you 1 w 281
say 1 w 284
my 1 w 287
esteemed 1 w 295
Sarapion 2 w 303
said 2 w 308
I 1 w 309
is 5 w 312
quite 1 w 317
right 1 w 322
We 1 w 325
have 1 w 329
not 3 w 332
been 1 w 336
surrendering 1 w 348
hope 1 w 352
for 2 w 355
philosophy 1 w 365
either 1 w 371
as 3 w 374
if 2 w 376
it 7 w 378
had 1 w 381
been 2 w 385
completely 1 w 395
done 1 w 399
away 2 w 403
with 3 w 407
and 5 w 410
destroyed 1 w 419
just 1 w 424
because 1 w 431
formerly 1 w 439
the 7 w 442
philosophers 1 w 454
used 1 w 458
to 4 w 460
publish 1 w 467
their 1 w 472
doctrines 1 w 481
and 6 w 484
discourses 1 w 494
in 6 w 496
the 9 w 499
form 2 w 503
of 3 w 505
poems 1 w 510
as 4 w 513
Orpheus 1 w 520
Hesiod 1 w 527
Parmenides 1 w 538
Xenophanes 1 w 549
Empedocles 1 w 560
and 7 w 564
Thales 1 w 570
Later 1 w 576
they 1 w 580
ceased 1 w 586
to 5 w 588
do 5 w 590
this 1 w 594
and 8 w 598
now 1 w 601
all 1 w 604
have 2 w 608
ceased 2 w 614
using 1 w 619
metrical 1 w 627
form 3 w 631
all 2 w 635
except 1 w 641
you 2 w 644
At 1 w 647
your 1 w 651
hands 1 w 656
the 11 w 659
poetic 1 w 665
art 1 w 668
returns 1 w 675
to 6 w 677
philosophy 2 w 687
from 1 w 691
its 1 w 694
banishment 1 w 704
and 10 w 708
sounds 1 w 714
a 52 w 715
clear 1 w 720
and 11 w 723
noble 1 w 728
challenge 1 w 737
to 7 w 739
the 12 w 742
young 1 w 747
Nor 1 w 751
did 1 w 754
Aristarchus 1 w 765
Timocharis 1 w 776
Aristyllus 1 w 787
and 12 w 791
Hipparchus 1 w 801
and 13 w 805
their 2 w 810
followers 1 w 819
make 1 w 823
astronomy 1 w 832
less 1 w 836
notable 1 w 843
by 1 w 845
writing 1 w 852
in 9 w 854
prose 1 w 859
although 1 w 868
in 10 w 870
earlier 1 w 877
days 1 w 881
Eudoxus 1 w 888
Hesiod 2 w 895
and 14 w 899
Thales 2 w 905
wrote 1 w 910
in 11 w 912
verse 1 w 917
if 3 w 920
indeed 1 w 926
Thales 3 w 932
in 13 w 935
all 4 w 938
truth 1 w 943
composed 1 w 952
the 14 w 955
Astronomy 1 w 964
which 1 w 969
is 13 w 971
attributed 1 w 981
to 8 w 983
him 1 w 986
Pindar 1 w 993
also 1 w 997
confesses 1 w 1006
that 1 w 1010
he 18 w 1012
is 14 w 1014
puzzled 1 w 1021
by 2 w 1023
the 15 w 1026
neglect 1 w 1033
of 4 w 1035
a 75 w 1036
mode 1 w 1040
of 5 w 1042
music 1 w 1047
and 15 w 1050
is 15 w 1052
astonished 1 w 1062
that 2 w 1066
Unfortunately 1 w 1079
the 16 w 1082
cause 2 w 1087
of 6 w 1089
Pindar 2 w 1095
s 91 w 1097
astonishment 1 w 1109
has 1 w 1112
been 3 w 1116
omitted 1 w 1123
by 3 w 1125
the 17 w 1128
copyist 1 w 1135
who 1 w 1139
left 1 w 1143
a 84 w 1144
blank 1 w 1149
here 1 w 1153
The 1 w 1157
fact 1 w 1161
is 19 w 1163
that 3 w 1167
there 1 w 1172
is 20 w 1174
nothing 1 w 1181
dreadful 1 w 1189
nor 2 w 1192
abnormal 1 w 1200
in 17 w 1202
seeking 1 w 1209
the 19 w 1212
causes 1 w 1218
of 7 w 1220
such 2 w 1224
changes 1 w 1231
but 3 w 1235
to 11 w 1237
do 7 w 1239
away 3 w 1243
with 4 w 1247
these 1 w 1252
arts 1 w 1256
and 16 w 1259
faculties 1 w 1268
themselves 1 w 1278
because 2 w 1285
something 1 w 1294
about 1 w 1299
them 2 w 1303
has 2 w 1306
been 4 w 1310
disturbed 1 w 1319
or 13 w 1321
changed 1 w 1328
is 22 w 1330
not 6 w 1333
right 2 w 1338