Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Were the Athenians More Famous in War or in Wisdom?

Were the Athenians More Famous in War or in Wisdom? (6)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg088.perseus-eng3:6
Refs {'start': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Is it, then, your pleasure that we introduce the men themselves bearing the emblems and badges of their achievements, and assign to each their proper entrance? Then from this entrance let the poets approach, speaking and chanting to the accompaniment of flutes and lyres,

Now speak not a word of evil sound, and keep clear the way for our chorus,
Whoever in words like these is unskilled and whose mind is not free from uncleanness,
Who never has sung and never has danced in the rites of the noble Muses,
Nor has ever been trained in the Bacchic rites of the tongue of bull-eating Cratinus![*]
Let them bring with them their equipment, their masks and altars, their stage machinery, their revolving changes of scene, and the tripods that commemorate their victories. Let their tragic actors accompany them, men like Nicostratus and Callippides,
Mynniscus, Theodorus, and Polus, who robe Tragedy and bear her litter, as though she were some woman of wealth; or rather, let them follow on as though they were painters and gilders and dyers of statues.[*] Let there be provided also a bounteous outlay for stage furnishings, supernumeraries, sea-purple robes, stage machinery, as well as dancing-masters and bodyguards, an intractable crowd. It was in reference to all this that a Spartan[*] not ineptly remarked that the Athenians were making a great mistake in wasting their energies on amusements, that is to say, in lavishing on the theatre what would pay for great fleets and would support armies in the field. For, if we reckon up the cost of each tragedy, the Athenian people will be seen to have spent more on productions of Bacchae, Phoenissae, Oedipuses, and Antigones, and the woes of Medea and Electra, than they spent in fighting for their supremacy and for their liberty against the barbarians. For the generals often ordered their men to bring along uncooked rations when they led them forth to battle; and the commanders, I can swear, after providing barley-meal and a relish of onions and cheese for the rowers, would embark them on the triremes. But the men who paid for the choruses gave the choristers eels and tender lettuces, roastbeef and marrow, and pampered them for a long time while they were training their voices and living in luxury. The result for the defeated choregoi [*] was to
be held in contumely and ridicule; but to the victors belonged a tripod,[*] which was, as Demetrius says, not a votive offering to commemorate their victory, but a last oblation of their wasted livelihood, an empty memorial of their vanished estates. Such are the returns paid by the poetic art and nothing more splendid ever comes from it.

Tokens

Is 1 w 2
it 1 w 4
then 1 w 9
your 1 w 14
pleasure 1 w 22
that 1 w 26
we 1 w 28
introduce 1 w 37
the 2 w 40
men 1 w 43
themselves 1 w 53
bearing 1 w 60
the 4 w 63
emblems 1 w 70
and 1 w 73
badges 1 w 79
of 1 w 81
their 1 w 86
achievements 1 w 98
and 2 w 102
assign 1 w 108
to 1 w 110
each 1 w 114
their 2 w 119
proper 1 w 125
entrance 1 w 133
Then 1 w 138
from 1 w 142
this 1 w 146
entrance 2 w 154
let 1 w 157
the 7 w 160
poets 1 w 165
approach 1 w 173
speaking 1 w 182
and 3 w 185
chanting 1 w 193
to 2 w 195
the 8 w 198
accompaniment 1 w 211
of 2 w 213
flutes 1 w 219
and 4 w 222
lyres 1 w 227
Now 1 w 231
speak 2 w 236
not 1 w 239
a 21 w 240
word 1 w 244
of 3 w 246
evil 1 w 250
sound 1 w 255
and 5 w 259
keep 1 w 263
clear 1 w 268
the 9 w 271
way 1 w 274
for 1 w 277
our 2 w 280
chorus 1 w 286
Whoever 1 w 294
in 5 w 296
words 1 w 301
like 1 w 305
these 1 w 310
is 2 w 312
unskilled 1 w 321
and 6 w 324
whose 1 w 329
mind 1 w 333
is 3 w 335
not 2 w 338
free 1 w 342
from 2 w 346
uncleanness 1 w 357
Who 2 w 361
never 1 w 366
has 1 w 369
sung 1 w 373
and 7 w 376
never 2 w 381
has 2 w 384
danced 1 w 390
in 7 w 392
the 11 w 395
rites 1 w 400
of 4 w 402
the 12 w 405
noble 1 w 410
Muses 1 w 415
Nor 1 w 419
has 3 w 422
ever 4 w 426
been 1 w 430
trained 1 w 437
in 9 w 439
the 13 w 442
Bacchic 1 w 449
rites 2 w 454
of 5 w 456
the 14 w 459
tongue 1 w 465
of 6 w 467
bull-eating 1 w 478
Cratinus 1 w 486
Aristophanes 1 w 499
Frogs 1 w 505
353-356 1 w 513
cf 1 w 516
Aulus 1 w 522
Gellius 1 w 529
Praefatio 1 w 539
20 1 w 542
f 14 w 543
Let 1 w 547
them 2 w 551
bring 1 w 556
with 1 w 560
them 3 w 564
their 3 w 569
equipment 1 w 578
their 4 w 584
masks 1 w 589
and 8 w 592
altars 1 w 598
their 5 w 604
stage 1 w 609
machinery 1 w 618
their 6 w 624
revolving 1 w 633
changes 1 w 640
of 7 w 642
scene 1 w 647
and 9 w 651
the 21 w 654
tripods 1 w 661
that 2 w 665
commemorate 1 w 676
their 7 w 681
victories 1 w 690
Let 2 w 694
their 8 w 699
tragic 1 w 705
actors 1 w 711
accompany 1 w 720
them 4 w 724
men 5 w 728
like 2 w 732
Nicostratus 1 w 743
and 10 w 746
Callippides 1 w 757
Mynniscus 1 w 767
Theodorus 1 w 777
and 11 w 781
Polus 1 w 786
who 2 w 790
robe 1 w 794
Tragedy 1 w 801
and 12 w 804
bear 2 w 808
her 1 w 811
litter 1 w 817
as 7 w 820
though 1 w 826
she 1 w 829
were 1 w 833
some 1 w 837
woman 1 w 842
of 8 w 844
wealth 1 w 850
or 10 w 853
rather 1 w 859
let 2 w 863
them 5 w 867
follow 1 w 873
on 2 w 875
as 8 w 877
though 2 w 883
they 1 w 887
were 2 w 891
painters 1 w 899
and 13 w 902
gilders 1 w 909
and 14 w 912
dyers 1 w 917
of 9 w 919
statues 1 w 926
That 1 w 931
is 6 w 933
a 70 w 935
tragedy 1 w 942
is 7 w 944
an 25 w 946
unadorned 1 w 955
statue 2 w 961
The 3 w 965
actors 2 w 971
supply 1 w 977
the 28 w 980
decoration 1 w 990
encaustic 1 w 1000
paint 2 w 1005
gold-leaf 1 w 1015
and 15 w 1019
dye 2 w 1022
Let 3 w 1026
there 1 w 1031
be 5 w 1033
provided 1 w 1041
also 1 w 1045
a 82 w 1046
bounteous 1 w 1055
outlay 1 w 1061
for 2 w 1064
stage 2 w 1069
furnishings 1 w 1080
supernumeraries 1 w 1096
sea-purple 1 w 1107
robes 1 w 1112
stage 3 w 1118
machinery 2 w 1127
as 9 w 1130
well 1 w 1134
as 10 w 1136
dancing-masters 1 w 1151
and 16 w 1154
bodyguards 1 w 1164
an 29 w 1167
intractable 1 w 1178
crowd 1 w 1183
It 1 w 1186
was 1 w 1189
in 21 w 1191
reference 1 w 1200
to 8 w 1202
all 2 w 1205
this 2 w 1209
that 3 w 1213
a 101 w 1214
Spartan 1 w 1221
Cf 1 w 1223
Moralia 1 w 1231
230 1 w 1235
b 15 w 1236
and 17 w 1239
the 30 w 1242
note 1 w 1246
not 4 w 1250
ineptly 1 w 1257
remarked 1 w 1265
that 4 w 1269
the 31 w 1272
Athenians 1 w 1281
were 3 w 1285
making 1 w 1291
a 111 w 1292
great 1 w 1297
mistake 1 w 1304
in 24 w 1306
wasting 1 w 1313
their 9 w 1318
energies 1 w 1326
on 4 w 1328
amusements 1 w 1338
that 5 w 1343
is 11 w 1345
to 9 w 1347
say 1 w 1350
in 26 w 1353
lavishing 1 w 1362
on 5 w 1364
the 34 w 1367
theatre 1 w 1374
what 1 w 1378
would 1 w 1383
pay 1 w 1386
for 3 w 1389
great 2 w 1394
fleets 1 w 1400
and 18 w 1403
would 2 w 1408
support 1 w 1415
armies 1 w 1421
in 28 w 1423
the 36 w 1426
field 1 w 1431
For 1 w 1435
if 1 w 1438
we 7 w 1440
reckon 1 w 1446
up 4 w 1448
the 37 w 1451
cost 2 w 1455
of 10 w 1457
each 2 w 1461
tragedy 2 w 1468
the 38 w 1472
Athenian 2 w 1480
people 1 w 1486
will 1 w 1490
be 7 w 1492
seen 1 w 1496
to 10 w 1498
have 1 w 1502
spent 1 w 1507
more 1 w 1511
on 7 w 1513
productions 1 w 1524
of 11 w 1526
Bacchae 1 w 1533
Phoenissae 1 w 1544
Oedipuses 1 w 1554
and 19 w 1558
Antigones 1 w 1567
and 20 w 1571
the 40 w 1574
woes 1 w 1578
of 12 w 1580
Medea 1 w 1585
and 21 w 1588
Electra 1 w 1595
than 1 w 1600
they 2 w 1604
spent 2 w 1609
in 29 w 1611
fighting 1 w 1619
for 4 w 1622
their 10 w 1627
supremacy 1 w 1636
and 22 w 1639
for 5 w 1642
their 11 w 1647
liberty 1 w 1654
against 1 w 1661
the 44 w 1664
barbarians 1 w 1674
For 2 w 1678
the 45 w 1681
generals 1 w 1689
often 1 w 1694
ordered 1 w 1701
their 12 w 1706
men 7 w 1709
to 11 w 1711
bring 2 w 1716
along 1 w 1721
uncooked 1 w 1729
rations 1 w 1736
when 1 w 1740
they 3 w 1744
led 2 w 1747
them 6 w 1751
forth 1 w 1756
to 12 w 1758
battle 1 w 1764
and 23 w 1768
the 49 w 1771
commanders 1 w 1781
I 3 w 1783
can 1 w 1786
swear 1 w 1791
after 1 w 1797
providing 1 w 1806
barley-meal 1 w 1817
and 25 w 1820
a 157 w 1821
relish 1 w 1827
of 14 w 1829
onions 1 w 1835
and 26 w 1838
cheese 1 w 1844
for 7 w 1847
the 50 w 1850
rowers 1 w 1856
would 3 w 1862
embark 1 w 1868
them 7 w 1872
on 14 w 1874
the 52 w 1877
triremes 1 w 1885
But 1 w 1889
the 53 w 1892
men 8 w 1895
who 3 w 1898
paid 1 w 1902
for 8 w 1905
the 54 w 1908
choruses 1 w 1916
gave 1 w 1920
the 55 w 1923
choristers 1 w 1933
eels 1 w 1937
and 27 w 1940
tender 1 w 1946
lettuces 1 w 1954
roastbeef 1 w 1964
and 28 w 1967
marrow 1 w 1973
and 29 w 1977
pampered 1 w 1985
them 8 w 1989
for 9 w 1992
a 168 w 1993
long 2 w 1997
time 1 w 2001
while 1 w 2006
they 4 w 2010
were 4 w 2014
training 1 w 2022
their 13 w 2027
voices 1 w 2033
and 30 w 2036
living 1 w 2042
in 37 w 2044
luxury 1 w 2050
The 4 w 2054
result 1 w 2060
for 10 w 2063
the 59 w 2066
defeated 1 w 2074
choregoi 1 w 2082
The 5 w 2085
choregoi 2 w 2093
the 60 w 2097
men 9 w 2100
who 4 w 2103
trained 2 w 2110
the 61 w 2113
tragic 2 w 2119
choruses 2 w 2127
at 23 w 2129
Athens 1 w 2135
lavished 1 w 2144
their 14 w 2149
private 1 w 2156
resources 1 w 2165
on 16 w 2167
the 64 w 2170
festival 1 w 2178
competitions 1 w 2190
but 1 w 2194
the 65 w 2197
victor 2 w 2203
had 1 w 2206
merely 1 w 2212
a 179 w 2213
tripod 2 w 2219
awarded 1 w 2226
to 14 w 2228
him 1 w 2231
to 15 w 2233
show 1 w 2237
for 11 w 2240
all 3 w 2243
his 3 w 2246
vast 1 w 2250
expenditure 1 w 2261
the 66 w 2265
loser 1 w 2270
worse 1 w 2275
than 2 w 2279
nothing 1 w 2286
was 3 w 2290
to 16 w 2292
be 10 w 2294
held 1 w 2298
in 40 w 2300
contumely 1 w 2309
and 31 w 2312
ridicule 1 w 2320
but 2 w 2324
to 17 w 2326
the 67 w 2329
victors 1 w 2336
belonged 1 w 2344
a 187 w 2345
tripod 3 w 2351
Cf 2 w 2354
Life 1 w 2359
of 15 w 2361
Aristeides 1 w 2371
chap 1 w 2376
i 141 w 2378
318 1 w 2383
e 312 w 2384
Life 2 w 2390
of 16 w 2392
Nicias 1 w 2398
chap 2 w 2403
iii 1 w 2407
524 1 w 2412
e 314 w 2413
which 1 w 2420
was 4 w 2423
as 19 w 2426
Demetrius 1 w 2435
says 1 w 2439
not 6 w 2443
a 194 w 2444
votive 1 w 2450
offering 1 w 2458
to 19 w 2460
commemorate 2 w 2471
their 15 w 2476
victory 1 w 2483
but 3 w 2487
a 196 w 2488
last 1 w 2492
oblation 1 w 2500
of 18 w 2502
their 16 w 2507
wasted 1 w 2513
livelihood 1 w 2523
an 52 w 2526
empty 1 w 2531
memorial 1 w 2539
of 19 w 2541
their 17 w 2546
vanished 1 w 2554
estates 1 w 2561
Such 1 w 2566
are 1 w 2569
the 71 w 2572
returns 1 w 2579
paid 2 w 2583
by 1 w 2585
the 72 w 2588
poetic 1 w 2594
art 2 w 2597
and 32 w 2600
nothing 2 w 2607
more 2 w 2611
splendid 1 w 2619
ever 5 w 2623
comes 1 w 2628
from 3 w 2632
it 8 w 2634