Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Concerning the fortune or virtue of Alexander the Great.

Concerning the fortune or virtue of Alexander the Great. (1.11-1.12)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg087.perseus-eng4:1.11-1.12
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.11', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 1 Section 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.12', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 1 Section 12'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Tell me now; can such generous acts of Alexander as these be thought to speak the spontaneous favors of Fortune, only an impetuous torrent of success and strength of hand? Do they not rather demonstrate much of fortitude and justice, much of mildness and temperance, in one who managed all things with decorum and consideration, with a sober and intelligent judgment? Not that I (believe me) go about to distinguish between the several acts of Alexander, and to ascribe this to fortitude, that to humanity, another to temperance; but I take every act to be an act of all the virtues mixed together. This is conformable to that Stoic sentence, What a wise man does he does by the impulse of all the virtues together; only one particular virtue seems to head every action, and calling the rest to her assistance drives on to the end proposed. Therefore we may behold in Alexander a warlike humanity, a meek fortitude, a liberality poised with good husbandry, anger easily appeased, chaste amours, a busy relaxation of mind, and labor not wanting recreation. Who ever like him mixed festivals with combats, revels and jollity with expeditions, nuptials and bacchanals with sieges and difficult attempts? To those that offended against the law who more severe To the unfortunate who more pitiful? To those that made resistance who more terrible? To suppliants who more

merciful? This gives me an occasion to insert here the saying of Porus. For he being brought a captive before Alexander, and by him being asked how he expected to be treated, Royally, said he, O Alexander. And beiig further asked whether he desired no more, he replied, Nothing; for all things are comprehended in that word royally. And for my part, I know not how to give a greater applause to the actions of Alexander, than by adding the word philosophically, for in that word all other things are included. Being ravished with the beauty of Roxana, the daughter of Oxyarthes, dancing among the captive ladies, he never assailed her with injurious lust, but married her philosophically. Beholding Darius stuck to the heart with several arrows, he did not presently sacrifice to the Gods or sing triumphal songs to celebrate the end of so long a war, but unclasping his own cloak from his shoulders he threw it over the dead corpse philosophically, as it were to cover the shame of royal calamity. Another time, as he was perusing a private letter sent him by his mother, he observed Hephaestion, who was sitting by him, to read it along with him, little understanding what he did. For which unwary act Alexander forbore to reprove him; only clapping his signet to his mouth, he thus kindly admonished him that his lips were then sealed up to silence by the friendly confidence which he reposed in him,—all this philosophically. And indeed if these were not acts done philosophically, where shall we find them?

Let us compare with his some few acts of those who are by all allowed to be philosophers. Socrates yielded to the lustful embraces of Alcibiades. Alexander, when Philoxenus, governor of the sea-coasts, wrote to him concerning an Ionian lad that had not his equal for youthful beauty, and desired to know whether he should e sent to him or not, returned him this nipping answer: Vilest of men, when wast thou ever privy to any desires of mine,

that thou shouldst think to flatter me with such abhorred allurements? We admire the abstinency of Xenocrates for refusing the gift of fifty talents which Alexander sent him; but do we take no notice of the munificence of the giver? Or is the bountiful person not to be thought as much a contemner of money as he that refuses it? Xenocrates needed not riches, by reason of his philosophy; but Alexander wanted wealth, by reason of the same philosophy, that he might be more liberal to such persons.... How often has Alexander borne witness to this in the midst of a thousand dangers? It is true, we believe that it is in the power of all men to judge rightly of things; for nature guides us of herself to virtue and bravery. But herein philosophers excel all others, that they have by education acquired a fixed and solid judgment to encounter whatever dangers they meet with. For most men have no such maxims to defend them as this in Homer,—
Without a sign his sword the brave man draws,
And needs no omen but his countrys cause.
[*]
And that other of Demosthenes,—
Death is the certain end of all mankind.
[*]
But sudden apparitions of imminent danger many times break our resolutions; and the fancy troubled with the imagination of approaching peril chases away true judgment from her seat. For fear not only astonishes the memory, according to the saying of Thucydides,[*] but it dissipates all manner of consideration, sense of honor, and resolution; while philosophy binds and keeps them together.. .. [*]

Tell 1 w 4
me 1 w 6
now 1 w 9
can 1 w 13
such 1 w 17
generous 1 w 25
acts 1 w 29
of 1 w 31
Alexander 1 w 40
as 1 w 42
these 1 w 47
be 1 w 49
thought 1 w 56
to 1 w 58
speak 1 w 63
the 2 w 66
spontaneous 1 w 77
favors 1 w 83
of 2 w 85
Fortune 1 w 92
only 1 w 97
an 4 w 99
impetuous 1 w 108
torrent 1 w 115
of 3 w 117
success 1 w 124
and 2 w 127
strength 1 w 135
of 4 w 137
hand 1 w 141
Do 1 w 144
they 1 w 148
not 1 w 151
rather 1 w 157
demonstrate 1 w 168
much 1 w 172
of 5 w 174
fortitude 1 w 183
and 4 w 186
justice 1 w 193
much 2 w 198
of 6 w 200
mildness 1 w 208
and 5 w 211
temperance 1 w 221
in 1 w 224
one 1 w 227
who 1 w 230
managed 1 w 237
all 1 w 240
things 1 w 246
with 1 w 250
decorum 1 w 257
and 6 w 260
consideration 1 w 273
with 2 w 278
a 21 w 279
sober 1 w 284
and 7 w 287
intelligent 1 w 298
judgment 1 w 306
Not 1 w 310
that 1 w 314
I 1 w 315
believe 1 w 323
me 3 w 325
go 1 w 328
about 1 w 333
to 3 w 335
distinguish 1 w 346
between 1 w 353
the 5 w 356
several 1 w 363
acts 2 w 367
of 7 w 369
Alexander 2 w 378
and 9 w 382
to 4 w 384
ascribe 1 w 391
this 1 w 395
to 5 w 397
fortitude 2 w 406
that 2 w 411
to 6 w 413
humanity 1 w 421
another 1 w 429
to 7 w 431
temperance 2 w 441
but 1 w 445
I 2 w 446
take 1 w 450
every 1 w 455
act 3 w 458
to 8 w 460
be 6 w 462
an 18 w 464
act 4 w 467
of 8 w 469
all 2 w 472
the 7 w 475
virtues 1 w 482
mixed 1 w 487
together 1 w 495
This 1 w 500
is 5 w 502
conformable 1 w 513
to 10 w 515
that 3 w 519
Stoic 1 w 524
sentence 1 w 532
What 1 w 537
a 42 w 538
wise 1 w 542
man 3 w 545
does 1 w 549
he 9 w 551
does 2 w 555
by 1 w 557
the 9 w 560
impulse 1 w 567
of 9 w 569
all 3 w 572
the 10 w 575
virtues 2 w 582
together 2 w 590
only 2 w 595
one 2 w 598
particular 1 w 608
virtue 3 w 614
seems 1 w 619
to 13 w 621
head 1 w 625
every 2 w 630
action 1 w 636
and 10 w 640
calling 1 w 647
the 12 w 650
rest 1 w 654
to 14 w 656
her 5 w 659
assistance 1 w 669
drives 1 w 675
on 11 w 677
to 15 w 679
the 13 w 682
end 1 w 685
proposed 1 w 693
Therefore 1 w 703
we 2 w 705
may 1 w 708
behold 1 w 714
in 6 w 716
Alexander 3 w 725
a 55 w 726
warlike 1 w 733
humanity 2 w 741
a 58 w 743
meek 1 w 747
fortitude 3 w 756
a 59 w 758
liberality 1 w 768
poised 1 w 774
with 3 w 778
good 1 w 782
husbandry 1 w 791
anger 1 w 797
easily 1 w 803
appeased 1 w 811
chaste 1 w 818
amours 1 w 824
a 68 w 826
busy 1 w 830
relaxation 1 w 840
of 10 w 842
mind 1 w 846
and 13 w 850
labor 1 w 855
not 3 w 858
wanting 1 w 865
recreation 1 w 875
Who 1 w 879
ever 4 w 883
like 2 w 887
him 1 w 890
mixed 2 w 895
festivals 1 w 904
with 4 w 908
combats 1 w 915
revels 1 w 922
and 14 w 925
jollity 1 w 932
with 5 w 936
expeditions 1 w 947
nuptials 1 w 956
and 15 w 959
bacchanals 1 w 969
with 6 w 973
sieges 1 w 979
and 16 w 982
difficult 1 w 991
attempts 1 w 999
To 1 w 1002
those 1 w 1007
that 4 w 1011
offended 1 w 1019
against 1 w 1026
the 14 w 1029
law 1 w 1032
who 2 w 1035
more 1 w 1039
severe 1 w 1045
To 2 w 1047
the 15 w 1050
unfortunate 1 w 1061
who 3 w 1064
more 2 w 1068
pitiful 1 w 1075
To 3 w 1078
those 2 w 1083
that 5 w 1087
made 1 w 1091
resistance 1 w 1101
who 4 w 1104
more 3 w 1108
terrible 1 w 1116
To 4 w 1119
suppliants 1 w 1129
who 5 w 1132
more 4 w 1136
merciful 1 w 1144
This 2 w 1149
gives 1 w 1154
me 6 w 1156
an 34 w 1158
occasion 1 w 1166
to 16 w 1168
insert 1 w 1174
here 2 w 1178
the 16 w 1181
saying 1 w 1187
of 12 w 1189
Porus 1 w 1194
For 2 w 1198
he 22 w 1200
being 1 w 1205
brought 1 w 1212
a 97 w 1213
captive 1 w 1220
before 1 w 1226
Alexander 4 w 1235
and 18 w 1239
by 2 w 1241
him 2 w 1244
being 2 w 1249
asked 1 w 1254
how 1 w 1257
he 23 w 1259
expected 1 w 1267
to 17 w 1269
be 12 w 1271
treated 1 w 1278
Royally 1 w 1286
said 1 w 1291
he 24 w 1293
O 1 w 1295
Alexander 5 w 1304
And 1 w 1308
beiig 1 w 1313
further 1 w 1320
asked 2 w 1325
whether 1 w 1332
he 28 w 1334
desired 1 w 1341
no 5 w 1343
more 5 w 1347
he 29 w 1350
replied 1 w 1357
Nothing 1 w 1365
for 8 w 1369
all 6 w 1372
things 2 w 1378
are 1 w 1381
comprehended 1 w 1393
in 16 w 1395
that 6 w 1399
word 1 w 1403
royally 1 w 1410
And 2 w 1414
for 9 w 1417
my 1 w 1419
part 2 w 1423
I 3 w 1425
know 1 w 1429
not 4 w 1432
how 2 w 1435
to 18 w 1437
give 2 w 1441
a 112 w 1442
greater 1 w 1449
applause 1 w 1457
to 19 w 1459
the 19 w 1462
actions 1 w 1469
of 13 w 1471
Alexander 6 w 1480
than 1 w 1485
by 3 w 1487
adding 1 w 1493
the 20 w 1496
word 2 w 1500
philosophically 1 w 1515
for 10 w 1519
in 18 w 1521
that 7 w 1525
word 3 w 1529
all 9 w 1532
other 2 w 1537
things 3 w 1543
are 2 w 1546
included 1 w 1554
Being 1 w 1560
ravished 1 w 1568
with 7 w 1572
the 22 w 1575
beauty 1 w 1581
of 14 w 1583
Roxana 1 w 1589
the 23 w 1593
daughter 1 w 1601
of 15 w 1603
Oxyarthes 1 w 1612
dancing 1 w 1620
among 1 w 1625
the 25 w 1628
captive 2 w 1635
ladies 1 w 1641
he 39 w 1644
never 1 w 1649
assailed 1 w 1657
her 11 w 1660
with 8 w 1664
injurious 1 w 1673
lust 1 w 1677
but 2 w 1681
married 1 w 1688
her 12 w 1691
philosophically 2 w 1706
Beholding 1 w 1716
Darius 1 w 1722
stuck 1 w 1727
to 20 w 1729
the 26 w 1732
heart 1 w 1737
with 9 w 1741
several 2 w 1748
arrows 1 w 1754
he 44 w 1757
did 1 w 1760
not 5 w 1763
presently 1 w 1772
sacrifice 1 w 1781
to 21 w 1783
the 27 w 1786
Gods 1 w 1790
or 26 w 1792
sing 1 w 1796
triumphal 1 w 1805
songs 1 w 1810
to 22 w 1812
celebrate 1 w 1821
the 28 w 1824
end 4 w 1827
of 16 w 1829
so 5 w 1831
long 1 w 1835
a 145 w 1836
war 2 w 1839
but 3 w 1843
unclasping 1 w 1853
his 4 w 1856
own 1 w 1859
cloak 1 w 1864
from 1 w 1868
his 5 w 1871
shoulders 1 w 1880
he 47 w 1882
threw 1 w 1887
it 19 w 1889
over 1 w 1893
the 29 w 1896
dead 1 w 1900
corpse 1 w 1906
philosophically 3 w 1921
as 12 w 1924
it 20 w 1926
were 1 w 1930
to 23 w 1932
cover 1 w 1937
the 30 w 1940
shame 1 w 1945
of 17 w 1947
royal 2 w 1952
calamity 1 w 1960
Another 1 w 1968
time 1 w 1972
as 13 w 1975
he 51 w 1977
was 1 w 1980
perusing 1 w 1988
a 158 w 1989
private 1 w 1996
letter 1 w 2002
sent 3 w 2006
him 3 w 2009
by 4 w 2011
his 6 w 2014
mother 1 w 2020
he 53 w 2023
observed 1 w 2031
Hephaestion 1 w 2042
who 6 w 2046
was 2 w 2049
sitting 1 w 2056
by 5 w 2058
him 4 w 2061
to 24 w 2064
read 1 w 2068
it 23 w 2070
along 1 w 2075
with 10 w 2079
him 5 w 2082
little 1 w 2089
understanding 1 w 2102
what 1 w 2106
he 54 w 2108
did 2 w 2111
For 3 w 2115
which 1 w 2120
unwary 1 w 2126
act 7 w 2129
Alexander 7 w 2138
forbore 1 w 2145
to 25 w 2147
reprove 1 w 2154
him 6 w 2157
only 3 w 2162
clapping 1 w 2170
his 7 w 2173
signet 1 w 2179
to 26 w 2181
his 8 w 2184
mouth 1 w 2189
he 55 w 2192
thus 1 w 2196
kindly 1 w 2202
admonished 1 w 2212
him 7 w 2215
that 8 w 2219
his 9 w 2222
lips 1 w 2226
were 2 w 2230
then 1 w 2234
sealed 1 w 2240
up 3 w 2242
to 27 w 2244
silence 1 w 2251
by 6 w 2253
the 34 w 2256
friendly 1 w 2264
confidence 1 w 2274
which 2 w 2279
he 59 w 2281
reposed 1 w 2288
in 32 w 2290
him 8 w 2293
all 12 w 2298
this 2 w 2302
philosophically 4 w 2317
And 3 w 2321
indeed 1 w 2327
if 5 w 2329
these 2 w 2334
were 3 w 2338
not 7 w 2341
acts 3 w 2345
done 1 w 2349
philosophically 5 w 2364
where 1 w 2370
shall 1 w 2375
we 6 w 2377
find 1 w 2381
them 1 w 2385
Let 1 w 2389
us 14 w 2391
compare 1 w 2398
with 11 w 2402
his 11 w 2405
some 1 w 2409
few 1 w 2412
acts 4 w 2416
of 18 w 2418
those 3 w 2423
who 7 w 2426
are 4 w 2429
by 7 w 2431
all 16 w 2434
allowed 1 w 2441
to 28 w 2443
be 15 w 2445
philosophers 1 w 2457
Socrates 1 w 2466
yielded 1 w 2473
to 29 w 2475
the 37 w 2478
lustful 1 w 2485
embraces 1 w 2493
of 19 w 2495
Alcibiades 1 w 2505
Alexander 8 w 2515
when 1 w 2520
Philoxenus 1 w 2530
governor 1 w 2539
of 20 w 2541
the 38 w 2544
sea-coasts 1 w 2554
wrote 1 w 2560
to 30 w 2562
him 9 w 2565
concerning 1 w 2575
an 45 w 2577
Ionian 1 w 2583
lad 2 w 2586
that 9 w 2590
had 1 w 2593
not 8 w 2596
his 12 w 2599
equal 1 w 2604
for 12 w 2607
youthful 1 w 2615
beauty 2 w 2621
and 24 w 2625
desired 2 w 2632
to 31 w 2634
know 2 w 2638
whether 2 w 2645
he 69 w 2647
should 2 w 2653
e 324 w 2654
sent 4 w 2658
to 32 w 2660
him 10 w 2663
or 33 w 2665
not 9 w 2668
returned 1 w 2677
him 11 w 2680
this 3 w 2684
nipping 1 w 2691
answer 1 w 2697
Vilest 1 w 2704
of 21 w 2706
men 2 w 2709
when 2 w 2714
wast 1 w 2718
thou 2 w 2722
ever 8 w 2726
privy 1 w 2731
to 33 w 2733
any 1 w 2736
desires 1 w 2743
of 22 w 2745
mine 1 w 2749
that 10 w 2754
thou 3 w 2758
shouldst 1 w 2766
think 1 w 2771
to 34 w 2773
flatter 1 w 2780
me 11 w 2782
with 12 w 2786
such 2 w 2790
abhorred 1 w 2798
allurements 1 w 2809
We 1 w 2812
admire 1 w 2818
the 40 w 2821
abstinency 1 w 2831
of 23 w 2833
Xenocrates 1 w 2843
for 13 w 2846
refusing 1 w 2854
the 41 w 2857
gift 1 w 2861
of 24 w 2863
fifty 1 w 2868
talents 1 w 2875
which 3 w 2880
Alexander 9 w 2889
sent 5 w 2893
him 12 w 2896
but 4 w 2900
do 4 w 2902
we 9 w 2904
take 2 w 2908
no 16 w 2910
notice 1 w 2916
of 25 w 2918
the 42 w 2921
munificence 1 w 2932
of 26 w 2934
the 43 w 2937
giver 1 w 2942
Or 1 w 2945
is 23 w 2947
the 44 w 2950
bountiful 1 w 2959
person 1 w 2965
not 11 w 2968
to 35 w 2970
be 17 w 2972
thought 2 w 2979
as 18 w 2981
much 3 w 2985
a 211 w 2986
contemner 1 w 2995
of 27 w 2997
money 1 w 3002
as 19 w 3004
he 76 w 3006
that 11 w 3010
refuses 1 w 3017
it 28 w 3019
Xenocrates 2 w 3030
needed 1 w 3036
not 12 w 3039
riches 1 w 3045
by 8 w 3048
reason 1 w 3054
of 28 w 3056
his 14 w 3059
philosophy 1 w 3069
but 5 w 3073
Alexander 10 w 3082
wanted 1 w 3088
wealth 1 w 3094
by 9 w 3097
reason 2 w 3103
of 29 w 3105
the 45 w 3108
same 1 w 3112
philosophy 2 w 3122
that 12 w 3127
he 79 w 3129
might 1 w 3134
be 18 w 3136
more 6 w 3140
liberal 2 w 3147
to 36 w 3149
such 3 w 3153
persons 1 w 3160
How 1 w 3167
often 1 w 3172
has 2 w 3175
Alexander 11 w 3184
borne 1 w 3189
witness 1 w 3196
to 37 w 3198
this 4 w 3202
in 41 w 3204
the 46 w 3207
midst 1 w 3212
of 31 w 3214
a 225 w 3215
thousand 1 w 3223
dangers 1 w 3230
It 1 w 3233
is 26 w 3235
true 1 w 3239
we 11 w 3242
believe 2 w 3249
that 13 w 3253
it 30 w 3255
is 27 w 3257
in 42 w 3259
the 47 w 3262
power 1 w 3267
of 32 w 3269
all 19 w 3272
men 4 w 3275
to 38 w 3277
judge 1 w 3282
rightly 1 w 3289
of 33 w 3291
things 4 w 3297
for 14 w 3301
nature 1 w 3307
guides 1 w 3313
us 20 w 3315
of 34 w 3317
herself 1 w 3324
to 39 w 3326
virtue 4 w 3332
and 29 w 3335
bravery 1 w 3342
But 1 w 3346
herein 1 w 3352
philosophers 2 w 3364
excel 1 w 3369
all 20 w 3372
others 1 w 3378
that 14 w 3383
they 2 w 3387
have 1 w 3391
by 10 w 3393
education 1 w 3402
acquired 1 w 3410
a 238 w 3411
fixed 1 w 3416
and 30 w 3419
solid 1 w 3424
judgment 2 w 3432
to 40 w 3434
encounter 1 w 3443
whatever 1 w 3451
dangers 2 w 3458
they 3 w 3462
meet 1 w 3466
with 13 w 3470
For 4 w 3474
most 1 w 3478
men 6 w 3481
have 2 w 3485
no 21 w 3487
such 4 w 3491
maxims 1 w 3497
to 41 w 3499
defend 1 w 3505
them 2 w 3509
as 23 w 3511
this 5 w 3515
in 45 w 3517
Homer 1 w 3522
Without 1 w 3531
a 245 w 3532
sign 2 w 3536
his 17 w 3539
sword 1 w 3544
the 52 w 3547
brave 2 w 3552
man 5 w 3555
draws 1 w 3560
And 4 w 3564
needs 1 w 3569
no 22 w 3571
omen 1 w 3575
but 6 w 3578
his 18 w 3581
country 1 w 3588
s 219 w 3590
cause 1 w 3595
Il 1 w 3598
XII 1 w 3602
243 1 w 3606
And 5 w 3610
that 15 w 3614
other 6 w 3619
of 35 w 3621
Demosthenes 1 w 3632
Death 1 w 3639
is 31 w 3641
the 55 w 3644
certain 1 w 3651
end 7 w 3654
of 36 w 3656
all 21 w 3659
mankind 1 w 3666
Demosthenes 2 w 3678
on 35 w 3680
the 57 w 3683
Crown 1 w 3688
p 65 w 3690
258 1 w 3694
20 1 w 3697
But 2 w 3701
sudden 1 w 3707
apparitions 1 w 3718
of 37 w 3720
imminent 1 w 3728
danger 3 w 3734
many 1 w 3738
times 1 w 3743
break 1 w 3748
our 2 w 3751
resolutions 1 w 3762
and 31 w 3766
the 58 w 3769
fancy 1 w 3774
troubled 1 w 3782
with 14 w 3786
the 59 w 3789
imagination 1 w 3800
of 38 w 3802
approaching 1 w 3813
peril 1 w 3818
chases 1 w 3824
away 1 w 3828
true 2 w 3832
judgment 3 w 3840
from 2 w 3844
her 23 w 3847
seat 1 w 3851
For 5 w 3855
fear 1 w 3859
not 13 w 3862
only 4 w 3866
astonishes 1 w 3876
the 60 w 3879
memory 1 w 3885
according 1 w 3895
to 43 w 3897
the 61 w 3900
saying 2 w 3906
of 39 w 3908
Thucydides 1 w 3918
Thucyd 2 w 3925
II 2 w 3928
87 1 w 3931
but 7 w 3935
it 35 w 3937
dissipates 1 w 3947
all 22 w 3950
manner 1 w 3956
of 40 w 3958
consideration 2 w 3971
sense 1 w 3977
of 41 w 3979
honor 1 w 3984
and 32 w 3988
resolution 2 w 3998
while 1 w 4004
philosophy 3 w 4014
binds 1 w 4019
and 33 w 4022
keeps 1 w 4027
them 3 w 4031
together 3 w 4039
Note 1 w 4047
The 2 w 4052
text 1 w 4056
is 34 w 4058
defective 1 w 4067
at 42 w 4069
the 64 w 4072
end 8 w 4075
and 34 w 4079
elsewhere 1 w 4088
in 54 w 4090
the 65 w 4093
last 1 w 4097
chapter 1 w 4104
The 3 w 4108
sense 2 w 4113
of 42 w 4115
the 66 w 4118
clause 1 w 4124
just 2 w 4128
preceding 1 w 4137
the 67 w 4140
quotation 1 w 4149
from 3 w 4153
Homer 2 w 4158
is 35 w 4160
chiefly 1 w 4167
conjectural 1 w 4178
A 19 w 4180
similar 1 w 4187
deficiency 1 w 4197
is 36 w 4199
found 1 w 4204
at 44 w 4206
the 68 w 4209
end 9 w 4212
of 43 w 4214
the 69 w 4217
Second 1 w 4223
Oration 1 w 4230
on 49 w 4232
Alexander 12 w 4241
which 4 w 4247
immediately 1 w 4258
follows 1 w 4265
G 2 w 4268