Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Roman Questions

Roman Questions (93-95)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng4:93-95
Refs {'start': {'reference': '93', 'human_reference': 'Section 93'}, 'end': {'reference': '95', 'human_reference': 'Section 95'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Question 93. Why do they for the most part use vultures for soothsaying?

Solution. Was this the reason, because twelve vultures appeared to Romulus upon the building of Rome? Or because of all birds this is least frequent and familiar? For it is not easy to meet with young vultures, but they fly to us unexpectedly from some remote parts; therefore the sight of them is portentous. Or haply they learned this from Hercules, if Herodotus speak true that Hercules rejoiced most in the beginning of an enterprise at the sight of a vulture, being of opinion that a vulture was the justest of all birds of prey. For first, he meddles not with any living creature, neither doth he destroy any thing that hath breath in it, as eagles, hawks, and other fowls do that prey by night, but lives only upon dead carcasses; and next, he passeth by all those of his kind, for none ever saw a vulture feeding on a bird, as eagles and hawks do, which for the most part pursue birds like themselves, and slay them, even as Aeschylus hath it,

A bird that preys on birds, how cant be clean?

And verily this bird is not pernicious to men, for it neither destroys fruits nor plants, nor is hurtful to any tame animal. Moreover if it be (as the Egyptians fabulously pretend) that the whole kind of them is of the female sex, and that they conceive by the reception of the east wind into their bodies, as the trees do by receiving the west wind, it is most probable that very certain and sound prognostics may be made from them; whereas in other birds (there being so many rapines, flights, and pursuits about copulation)

there are great disturbances and uncertainties attending them.

Question 94. For what reason is the temple of Aesculapius placed without the city?

Solution. Was it because they reckoned it a wholesomer kind of living without the city than within? For the Greeks have placed the edifices belonging to Aesculapius for the most part on high places, where the air is pure and clear. Or is it that they suppose this God was fetched from Epidaurus? For the temple of Aesculapius is not close by that city, but at a great distance from it. Or is it that, by a serpent that went on shore out of a trireme galley into the island and disappeared, they think the God himself intimated to them the place of building his temple?

Question 95. Why was it ordained that they that were to live chaste should abstain from pulse?

Solution. Did they, like the Pythagoreans, abominate beans for the causes which are alleged, and the lathyrus and erebinthus as being named from Lethe and Erebus? Or was it because they used pulse for the most part in their funeral feasts and invocations of the dead? Or rather was it because they should bring empty and slender bodies to their purifications and expiations? For pulse are windy, and cause a great deal of excrements that require purging off. Or is it because they irritate lechery, by reason of their flatulent and windy nature?

Tokens

Question 1 w 8
93 1 w 10
Why 1 w 14
do 1 w 16
they 1 w 20
for 1 w 23
the 2 w 26
most 1 w 30
part 1 w 34
use 1 w 37
vultures 1 w 45
for 2 w 48
soothsaying 1 w 59
Solution 1 w 68
Was 1 w 72
this 1 w 76
the 3 w 79
reason 1 w 85
because 1 w 93
twelve 1 w 99
vultures 2 w 107
appeared 1 w 115
to 1 w 117
Romulus 1 w 124
upon 1 w 128
the 4 w 131
building 1 w 139
of 1 w 141
Rome 1 w 145
Or 1 w 148
because 2 w 155
of 2 w 157
all 1 w 160
birds 1 w 165
this 2 w 169
is 3 w 171
least 1 w 176
frequent 1 w 184
and 1 w 187
familiar 1 w 195
For 1 w 199
it 1 w 201
is 4 w 203
not 1 w 206
easy 1 w 210
to 2 w 212
meet 1 w 216
with 1 w 220
young 1 w 225
vultures 3 w 233
but 1 w 237
they 2 w 241
fly 1 w 244
to 3 w 246
us 5 w 248
unexpectedly 1 w 260
from 1 w 264
some 1 w 268
remote 1 w 274
parts 1 w 279
therefore 1 w 289
the 7 w 292
sight 1 w 297
of 3 w 299
them 1 w 303
is 5 w 305
portentous 1 w 315
Or 2 w 318
haply 1 w 323
they 3 w 327
learned 1 w 334
this 3 w 338
from 2 w 342
Hercules 1 w 350
if 1 w 353
Herodotus 1 w 362
speak 1 w 367
true 1 w 371
that 1 w 375
Hercules 2 w 383
rejoiced 1 w 391
most 2 w 395
in 3 w 397
the 10 w 400
beginning 1 w 409
of 4 w 411
an 2 w 413
enterprise 1 w 423
at 2 w 425
the 11 w 428
sight 2 w 433
of 5 w 435
a 22 w 436
vulture 4 w 443
being 1 w 449
of 6 w 451
opinion 1 w 458
that 2 w 462
a 24 w 463
vulture 5 w 470
was 1 w 473
the 12 w 476
justest 1 w 483
of 7 w 485
all 2 w 488
birds 2 w 493
of 8 w 495
prey 1 w 499
For 2 w 503
first 1 w 508
he 13 w 511
meddles 1 w 518
not 2 w 521
with 2 w 525
any 1 w 528
living 1 w 534
creature 1 w 542
neither 1 w 550
doth 1 w 554
he 15 w 556
destroy 1 w 563
any 2 w 566
thing 1 w 571
that 3 w 575
hath 1 w 579
breath 1 w 585
in 10 w 587
it 5 w 589
as 6 w 592
eagles 1 w 598
hawks 1 w 604
and 2 w 608
other 1 w 613
fowls 1 w 618
do 4 w 620
that 4 w 624
prey 2 w 628
by 1 w 630
night 1 w 635
but 2 w 639
lives 1 w 644
only 1 w 648
upon 2 w 652
dead 1 w 656
carcasses 1 w 665
and 3 w 669
next 1 w 673
he 17 w 676
passeth 1 w 683
by 2 w 685
all 3 w 688
those 1 w 693
of 9 w 695
his 4 w 698
kind 1 w 702
for 4 w 706
none 1 w 710
ever 1 w 714
saw 1 w 717
a 45 w 718
vulture 6 w 725
feeding 1 w 732
on 9 w 734
a 46 w 735
bird 3 w 739
as 9 w 742
eagles 2 w 748
and 4 w 751
hawks 2 w 756
do 5 w 758
which 1 w 764
for 5 w 767
the 15 w 770
most 3 w 774
part 3 w 778
pursue 1 w 784
birds 3 w 789
like 1 w 793
themselves 1 w 803
and 5 w 807
slay 1 w 811
them 3 w 815
even 1 w 820
as 10 w 822
Aeschylus 1 w 831
hath 2 w 835
it 6 w 837
A 2 w 839
bird 5 w 843
that 5 w 847
preys 1 w 852
on 10 w 854
birds 4 w 859
how 1 w 863
can 1 w 866
t 86 w 868
be 5 w 870
clean 1 w 875
And 1 w 879
verily 1 w 885
this 4 w 889
bird 7 w 893
is 10 w 895
not 3 w 898
pernicious 1 w 908
to 5 w 910
men 1 w 913
for 6 w 917
it 7 w 919
neither 2 w 926
destroys 1 w 934
fruits 1 w 940
nor 1 w 943
plants 1 w 949
nor 2 w 953
is 11 w 955
hurtful 1 w 962
to 6 w 964
any 3 w 967
tame 1 w 971
animal 1 w 977
Moreover 1 w 986
if 2 w 988
it 10 w 990
be 6 w 992
as 11 w 995
the 19 w 998
Egyptians 1 w 1007
fabulously 1 w 1017
pretend 1 w 1024
that 6 w 1029
the 20 w 1032
whole 1 w 1037
kind 2 w 1041
of 10 w 1043
them 4 w 1047
is 12 w 1049
of 11 w 1051
the 22 w 1054
female 1 w 1060
sex 1 w 1063
and 6 w 1067
that 7 w 1071
they 4 w 1075
conceive 1 w 1083
by 3 w 1085
the 24 w 1088
reception 1 w 1097
of 12 w 1099
the 25 w 1102
east 2 w 1106
wind 1 w 1110
into 1 w 1114
their 1 w 1119
bodies 1 w 1125
as 13 w 1128
the 27 w 1131
trees 1 w 1136
do 6 w 1138
by 4 w 1140
receiving 1 w 1149
the 28 w 1152
west 1 w 1156
wind 2 w 1160
it 11 w 1163
is 13 w 1165
most 4 w 1169
probable 1 w 1177
that 8 w 1181
very 1 w 1185
certain 1 w 1192
and 7 w 1195
sound 1 w 1200
prognostics 1 w 1211
may 1 w 1214
be 7 w 1216
made 1 w 1220
from 3 w 1224
them 5 w 1228
whereas 1 w 1236
in 19 w 1238
other 2 w 1243
birds 5 w 1248
there 2 w 1254
being 2 w 1259
so 5 w 1261
many 1 w 1265
rapines 1 w 1272
flights 1 w 1280
and 8 w 1284
pursuits 1 w 1292
about 1 w 1297
copulation 1 w 1307
there 3 w 1313
are 2 w 1316
great 1 w 1321
disturbances 1 w 1333
and 9 w 1336
uncertainties 1 w 1349
attending 1 w 1358
them 6 w 1362
Question 2 w 1371
94 1 w 1373
For 3 w 1377
what 1 w 1381
reason 2 w 1387
is 15 w 1389
the 34 w 1392
temple 1 w 1398
of 13 w 1400
Aesculapius 1 w 1411
placed 1 w 1417
without 1 w 1424
the 35 w 1427
city 1 w 1431
Solution 2 w 1440
Was 2 w 1444
it 15 w 1446
because 3 w 1453
they 5 w 1457
reckoned 1 w 1465
it 16 w 1467
a 97 w 1468
wholesomer 1 w 1478
kind 3 w 1482
of 14 w 1484
living 2 w 1490
without 2 w 1497
the 37 w 1500
city 2 w 1504
than 1 w 1508
within 1 w 1514
For 4 w 1518
the 38 w 1521
Greeks 1 w 1527
have 1 w 1531
placed 2 w 1537
the 39 w 1540
edifices 1 w 1548
belonging 1 w 1557
to 8 w 1559
Aesculapius 2 w 1570
for 7 w 1573
the 40 w 1576
most 5 w 1580
part 4 w 1584
on 19 w 1586
high 1 w 1590
places 1 w 1596
where 2 w 1602
the 41 w 1605
air 1 w 1608
is 16 w 1610
pure 1 w 1614
and 10 w 1617
clear 1 w 1622
Or 3 w 1625
is 17 w 1627
it 20 w 1629
that 9 w 1633
they 6 w 1637
suppose 1 w 1644
this 5 w 1648
God 1 w 1651
was 2 w 1654
fetched 1 w 1661
from 4 w 1665
Epidaurus 1 w 1674
For 5 w 1678
the 43 w 1681
temple 2 w 1687
of 15 w 1689
Aesculapius 3 w 1700
is 19 w 1702
not 4 w 1705
close 1 w 1710
by 5 w 1712
that 10 w 1716
city 3 w 1720
but 3 w 1724
at 20 w 1726
a 113 w 1727
great 2 w 1732
distance 1 w 1740
from 5 w 1744
it 22 w 1746
Or 4 w 1749
is 21 w 1751
it 23 w 1753
that 11 w 1757
by 6 w 1760
a 117 w 1761
serpent 1 w 1768
that 12 w 1772
went 1 w 1776
on 20 w 1778
shore 1 w 1783
out 4 w 1786
of 16 w 1788
a 119 w 1789
trireme 1 w 1796
galley 1 w 1802
into 2 w 1806
the 44 w 1809
island 1 w 1815
and 12 w 1818
disappeared 1 w 1829
they 7 w 1834
think 1 w 1839
the 46 w 1842
God 2 w 1845
himself 1 w 1852
intimated 1 w 1861
to 10 w 1863
them 7 w 1867
the 48 w 1870
place 4 w 1875
of 17 w 1877
building 2 w 1885
his 7 w 1888
temple 3 w 1894
Question 3 w 1903
95 1 w 1905
Why 2 w 1909
was 3 w 1912
it 24 w 1914
ordained 1 w 1922
that 13 w 1926
they 8 w 1930
that 14 w 1934
were 1 w 1938
to 11 w 1940
live 2 w 1944
chaste 1 w 1950
should 1 w 1956
abstain 1 w 1963
from 6 w 1967
pulse 1 w 1972
Solution 3 w 1981
Did 1 w 1985
they 9 w 1989
like 2 w 1994
the 51 w 1997
Pythagoreans 1 w 2009
abominate 1 w 2019
beans 1 w 2024
for 8 w 2027
the 52 w 2030
causes 1 w 2036
which 2 w 2041
are 4 w 2044
alleged 1 w 2051
and 13 w 2055
the 53 w 2058
lathyrus 1 w 2066
and 14 w 2069
erebinthus 1 w 2079
as 20 w 2081
being 3 w 2086
named 1 w 2091
from 7 w 2095
Lethe 1 w 2100
and 15 w 2103
Erebus 1 w 2109
Or 5 w 2112
was 4 w 2115
it 25 w 2117
because 4 w 2124
they 10 w 2128
used 1 w 2132
pulse 2 w 2137
for 9 w 2140
the 56 w 2143
most 6 w 2147
part 5 w 2151
in 37 w 2153
their 2 w 2158
funeral 1 w 2165
feasts 1 w 2171
and 16 w 2174
invocations 1 w 2185
of 18 w 2187
the 58 w 2190
dead 2 w 2194
Or 6 w 2197
rather 1 w 2203
was 5 w 2206
it 26 w 2208
because 5 w 2215
they 11 w 2219
should 2 w 2225
bring 1 w 2230
empty 1 w 2235
and 17 w 2238
slender 1 w 2245
bodies 2 w 2251
to 12 w 2253
their 3 w 2258
purifications 1 w 2271
and 18 w 2274
expiations 1 w 2284
For 6 w 2288
pulse 3 w 2293
are 5 w 2296
windy 1 w 2301
and 19 w 2305
cause 7 w 2310
a 166 w 2311
great 3 w 2316
deal 1 w 2320
of 19 w 2322
excrements 1 w 2332
that 15 w 2336
require 1 w 2343
purging 1 w 2350
off 1 w 2353
Or 7 w 2356
is 25 w 2358
it 27 w 2360
because 6 w 2367
they 12 w 2371
irritate 1 w 2379
lechery 1 w 2386
by 7 w 2389
reason 3 w 2395
of 21 w 2397
their 4 w 2402
flatulent 1 w 2411
and 20 w 2414
windy 2 w 2419
nature 1 w 2425