Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Roman Questions

Roman Questions (27-28)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng4:27-28
Refs {'start': {'reference': '27', 'human_reference': 'Section 27'}, 'end': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Question 27. Why do they repute every wall immaculate and sacred, but the gates not so?

Solution. Is it (as Varro hath wrote) that the wall is to be accounted sacred, that they might defend it cheerfully and even lay down their lives for it? Upon this very account it appears that Romulus slew his brother, because

he attempted to leap over a sacred and inaccessible place, and to render it transcendible and profane; but it could not possibly be that the gates should be kept sacred, through which they carried many things that necessity required, even dead corpses. When they built a city from the foundation, they marked out with a plough the place on which they intended to build it, yoking a bull and a cow together; but when they did set out the bounds of the walls, measuring the space of the gates, they lifted up the ploughshare and carried the plough over it, believing that all the ploughed part should be sacred and inviolable.

Question 28. Why do they prohibit the children to swear by Hercules within doors, but command them to go out of doors to do it?

Solution. Is the reason (as some say) that they are of opinion that Hercules was not delighted in a domestic life, but chose rather to live abroad in the fields? Or rather because he was none of their native country Gods, but a foreigner? For neither do they swear by Bacchus within doors, he being a foreigner, if it be he whom the Greeks call Dionysus. Or what if these things are uttered in sport to amuse children; and is this, on the contrary, for a restraint of a frivolous and rash oath, as Favorinus saith? For that which is done, as it were, with preparation causes delay and deliberation. If a man judges as Favorinus doth of the things recorded about Hercules, it would seem that this was not common to other Gods, but peculiar to him; for history tells us that he had such a religious veneration for an oath, that he swore but once only to Phyleus, son of Augeas. Wherefore the Pythia upbraids the Lacedaemonians with such swearing, as though it would be more laudable and better to pay their vows than to swear.

Tokens

Question 1 w 8
27 1 w 10
Why 1 w 14
do 1 w 16
they 1 w 20
repute 1 w 26
every 1 w 31
wall 1 w 35
immaculate 1 w 45
and 1 w 48
sacred 1 w 54
but 1 w 58
the 2 w 61
gates 1 w 66
not 1 w 69
so 1 w 71
Solution 1 w 80
Is 1 w 83
it 1 w 85
as 1 w 88
Varro 1 w 93
hath 1 w 97
wrote 1 w 102
that 1 w 107
the 3 w 110
wall 2 w 114
is 1 w 116
to 1 w 118
be 1 w 120
accounted 1 w 129
sacred 2 w 135
that 2 w 140
they 2 w 144
might 1 w 149
defend 1 w 155
it 2 w 157
cheerfully 1 w 167
and 2 w 170
even 1 w 174
lay 1 w 177
down 1 w 181
their 1 w 186
lives 1 w 191
for 1 w 194
it 3 w 196
Upon 1 w 201
this 1 w 205
very 2 w 209
account 2 w 216
it 4 w 218
appears 1 w 225
that 3 w 229
Romulus 1 w 236
slew 1 w 240
his 2 w 243
brother 1 w 250
because 1 w 258
he 8 w 260
attempted 1 w 269
to 2 w 271
leap 1 w 275
over 1 w 279
a 24 w 280
sacred 3 w 286
and 3 w 289
inaccessible 1 w 301
place 1 w 306
and 4 w 310
to 3 w 312
render 1 w 318
it 5 w 320
transcendible 1 w 333
and 5 w 336
profane 1 w 343
but 2 w 347
it 6 w 349
could 1 w 354
not 2 w 357
possibly 1 w 365
be 3 w 367
that 4 w 371
the 7 w 374
gates 2 w 379
should 1 w 385
be 4 w 387
kept 1 w 391
sacred 4 w 397
through 1 w 405
which 1 w 410
they 3 w 414
carried 1 w 421
many 1 w 425
things 1 w 431
that 5 w 435
necessity 1 w 444
required 1 w 452
even 2 w 457
dead 1 w 461
corpses 1 w 468
When 1 w 473
they 4 w 477
built 1 w 482
a 40 w 483
city 1 w 487
from 1 w 491
the 10 w 494
foundation 1 w 504
they 5 w 509
marked 1 w 515
out 1 w 518
with 1 w 522
a 43 w 523
plough 1 w 529
the 12 w 532
place 2 w 537
on 5 w 539
which 2 w 544
they 6 w 548
intended 1 w 556
to 4 w 558
build 1 w 563
it 10 w 565
yoking 1 w 572
a 45 w 573
bull 1 w 577
and 6 w 580
a 47 w 581
cow 1 w 584
together 1 w 592
but 3 w 596
when 1 w 600
they 7 w 604
did 1 w 607
set 1 w 610
out 2 w 613
the 16 w 616
bounds 1 w 622
of 2 w 624
the 17 w 627
walls 1 w 632
measuring 1 w 642
the 18 w 645
space 1 w 650
of 3 w 652
the 19 w 655
gates 3 w 660
they 8 w 665
lifted 1 w 671
up 1 w 673
the 21 w 676
ploughshare 1 w 687
and 7 w 690
carried 2 w 697
the 22 w 700
plough 3 w 706
over 2 w 710
it 11 w 712
believing 1 w 722
that 6 w 726
all 4 w 729
the 23 w 732
ploughed 1 w 740
part 1 w 744
should 2 w 750
be 6 w 752
sacred 5 w 758
and 8 w 761
inviolable 1 w 771
Question 2 w 780
28 1 w 782
Why 2 w 786
do 3 w 788
they 9 w 792
prohibit 1 w 800
the 25 w 803
children 1 w 811
to 6 w 813
swear 1 w 818
by 1 w 820
Hercules 1 w 828
within 1 w 834
doors 1 w 839
but 4 w 843
command 1 w 850
them 1 w 854
to 7 w 856
go 1 w 858
out 3 w 861
of 4 w 863
doors 2 w 868
to 8 w 870
do 6 w 872
it 14 w 874
Solution 2 w 883
Is 2 w 886
the 27 w 889
reason 1 w 895
as 4 w 898
some 1 w 902
say 1 w 905
that 7 w 910
they 10 w 914
are 2 w 917
of 5 w 919
opinion 1 w 926
that 8 w 930
Hercules 2 w 938
was 1 w 941
not 3 w 944
delighted 1 w 953
in 10 w 955
a 70 w 956
domestic 1 w 964
life 1 w 968
but 5 w 972
chose 1 w 977
rather 1 w 983
to 9 w 985
live 2 w 989
abroad 1 w 995
in 11 w 997
the 30 w 1000
fields 1 w 1006
Or 1 w 1009
rather 2 w 1015
because 2 w 1022
he 37 w 1024
was 2 w 1027
none 1 w 1031
of 6 w 1033
their 2 w 1038
native 1 w 1044
country 1 w 1051
Gods 1 w 1055
but 6 w 1059
a 78 w 1060
foreigner 1 w 1069
For 1 w 1073
neither 1 w 1080
do 8 w 1082
they 11 w 1086
swear 2 w 1091
by 2 w 1093
Bacchus 1 w 1100
within 2 w 1106
doors 3 w 1111
he 41 w 1114
being 1 w 1119
a 81 w 1120
foreigner 2 w 1129
if 3 w 1132
it 17 w 1134
be 9 w 1136
he 42 w 1138
whom 1 w 1142
the 35 w 1145
Greeks 1 w 1151
call 1 w 1155
Dionysus 1 w 1163
Or 2 w 1166
what 1 w 1170
if 4 w 1172
these 1 w 1177
things 2 w 1183
are 3 w 1186
uttered 1 w 1193
in 15 w 1195
sport 1 w 1200
to 10 w 1202
amuse 1 w 1207
children 2 w 1215
and 10 w 1219
is 4 w 1221
this 2 w 1225
on 12 w 1228
the 37 w 1231
contrary 1 w 1239
for 4 w 1243
a 88 w 1244
restraint 1 w 1253
of 7 w 1255
a 90 w 1256
frivolous 1 w 1265
and 11 w 1268
rash 1 w 1272
oath 1 w 1276
as 8 w 1279
Favorinus 1 w 1288
saith 1 w 1293
For 2 w 1297
that 9 w 1301
which 3 w 1306
is 6 w 1308
done 1 w 1312
as 9 w 1315
it 19 w 1317
were 1 w 1321
with 4 w 1326
preparation 1 w 1337
causes 1 w 1343
delay 1 w 1348
and 12 w 1351
deliberation 1 w 1363
If 1 w 1366
a 105 w 1367
man 3 w 1370
judges 1 w 1376
as 10 w 1378
Favorinus 2 w 1387
doth 1 w 1391
of 8 w 1393
the 38 w 1396
things 3 w 1402
recorded 1 w 1410
about 1 w 1415
Hercules 3 w 1423
it 21 w 1426
would 1 w 1431
seem 1 w 1435
that 10 w 1439
this 3 w 1443
was 3 w 1446
not 4 w 1449
common 1 w 1455
to 11 w 1457
other 2 w 1462
Gods 2 w 1466
but 7 w 1470
peculiar 1 w 1478
to 12 w 1480
him 1 w 1483
for 5 w 1487
history 1 w 1494
tells 1 w 1499
us 11 w 1501
that 11 w 1505
he 48 w 1507
had 1 w 1510
such 1 w 1514
a 115 w 1515
religious 1 w 1524
veneration 1 w 1534
for 6 w 1537
an 17 w 1539
oath 2 w 1543
that 12 w 1548
he 49 w 1550
swore 1 w 1555
but 8 w 1558
once 1 w 1562
only 1 w 1566
to 14 w 1568
Phyleus 1 w 1575
son 2 w 1579
of 9 w 1581
Augeas 1 w 1587
Wherefore 1 w 1597
the 40 w 1600
Pythia 1 w 1606
upbraids 1 w 1614
the 41 w 1617
Lacedaemonians 1 w 1631
with 5 w 1635
such 2 w 1639
swearing 1 w 1647
as 13 w 1650
though 1 w 1656
it 23 w 1658
would 2 w 1663
be 11 w 1665
more 1 w 1669
laudable 1 w 1677
and 13 w 1680
better 1 w 1686
to 15 w 1688
pay 1 w 1691
their 3 w 1696
vows 1 w 1700
than 1 w 1704
to 16 w 1706
swear 4 w 1711