Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (84-85)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:84-85
Refs {'start': {'reference': '84', 'human_reference': 'Section 84'}, 'end': {'reference': '85', 'human_reference': 'Section 85'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do they reckon the beginning of the day from midnight?[*]

Is it because the Roman State was based originally on a military organization and most of the matters that are of use on campaigns are taken up beforehand at night? Or did they make sunrise the beginning of activity, and night the beginning of preparation? For men should be prepared when they act, and not be making their preparations during the action, as Myson,[*] who was fashioning a grain-fork in wintertime, is reported to have remarked to Chilon the Wise.

Or, just as noon is for most people the end of their transaction of public or serious business, even so did it seem good to make midnight the beginning? A weighty testimony to this is the fact that a Roman official does not make treaties or agreements after midday.

Or is it impossible to reckon the beginning and end of the day by sunset and sunrise? For if we follow the method by which most people formulate their definitions, by their perceptions, reckoning the first peep of the sun above the horizon as the beginning of day, and the cutting off of its last rays as the beginning of night, we shall have no equinox: but that night which we think is most nearly equal to the day will plainly be less than that day by the diameter of

the sun.[*] But then again the remedy which the mathematicians apply to this anomaly, decreeing that the instant when the centre of the sun touches the horizon is the boundary between day and night, is a negation of plain fact; for the result will be that when there is still much light over the earth and the sun is shining upon us, we cannot admit that it is day, but must say that it is already night. Since, therefore, the beginning of day and night is difficult to determine at the time of the risings and settings of the sun because of the irrationalities which I have mentioned, there is left the zenith or the nadir of the suii to reckon as the beginning. The second is better; for from noon on the suns course is away from us to its setting, but from midnight on its course is towards us to its rising.

Why in the early days did they not allow their wives to grind grain or to cook?[*]

Was it in memory of the treaty which they made with the Sabines? For when they had carried off the Sabines daughters, and later, after warring with the Sabines, had made peace, it was specified among the other articles of agreement that no Sabine woman should grind grain for a Roman or cook for him.

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
they 1 w 9
reckon 1 w 15
the 2 w 18
beginning 1 w 27
of 1 w 29
the 3 w 32
day 1 w 35
from 1 w 39
midnight 1 w 47
Cf 1 w 50
Pliny 1 w 56
Natural 1 w 64
History 1 w 71
ii 1 w 74
77 1 w 77
188 1 w 81
Aulus 1 w 88
Gellius 1 w 95
iii 1 w 99
2 1 w 101
Macrobius 1 w 111
Saturnalia 1 w 122
i 15 w 124
3 1 w 126
Is 1 w 129
it 1 w 131
because 1 w 138
the 4 w 141
Roman 1 w 146
State 1 w 151
was 1 w 154
based 1 w 159
originally 1 w 169
on 2 w 171
a 14 w 172
military 1 w 180
organization 1 w 192
and 1 w 195
most 1 w 199
of 2 w 201
the 5 w 204
matters 1 w 211
that 1 w 215
are 1 w 218
of 3 w 220
use 2 w 223
on 4 w 225
campaigns 1 w 234
are 2 w 237
taken 1 w 242
up 1 w 244
beforehand 1 w 254
at 7 w 256
night 2 w 261
Or 1 w 264
did 1 w 267
they 2 w 271
make 1 w 275
sunrise 1 w 282
the 7 w 285
beginning 2 w 294
of 4 w 296
activity 1 w 304
and 3 w 308
night 3 w 313
the 8 w 316
beginning 3 w 325
of 5 w 327
preparation 1 w 338
For 1 w 342
men 1 w 345
should 1 w 351
be 6 w 353
prepared 1 w 361
when 1 w 365
they 3 w 369
act 2 w 372
and 4 w 376
not 1 w 379
be 7 w 381
making 1 w 387
their 1 w 392
preparations 1 w 404
during 1 w 410
the 11 w 413
action 1 w 419
as 3 w 422
Myson 1 w 427
Similar 1 w 435
foresight 1 w 444
regarding 1 w 454
a 43 w 455
plough 1 w 461
instead 1 w 468
of 6 w 470
a 45 w 471
fork 1 w 475
is 3 w 477
reported 1 w 485
by 1 w 487
Diogenes 1 w 495
Laertius 1 w 503
i 48 w 505
106 1 w 509
who 1 w 513
was 2 w 516
fashioning 1 w 526
a 49 w 527
grain-fork 1 w 537
in 15 w 539
wintertime 1 w 549
is 4 w 552
reported 2 w 560
to 2 w 562
have 1 w 566
remarked 1 w 574
to 3 w 576
Chilon 1 w 582
the 12 w 585
Wise 1 w 589
Or 2 w 592
just 1 w 597
as 6 w 599
noon 1 w 603
is 6 w 605
for 5 w 608
most 2 w 612
people 1 w 618
the 13 w 621
end 1 w 624
of 7 w 626
their 2 w 631
transaction 1 w 642
of 8 w 644
public 1 w 650
or 12 w 652
serious 1 w 659
business 1 w 667
even 1 w 672
so 2 w 674
did 2 w 677
it 4 w 679
seem 1 w 683
good 1 w 687
to 4 w 689
make 2 w 693
midnight 2 w 701
the 15 w 704
beginning 4 w 713
A 2 w 715
weighty 1 w 722
testimony 1 w 731
to 5 w 733
this 1 w 737
is 8 w 739
the 16 w 742
fact 1 w 746
that 2 w 750
a 59 w 751
Roman 2 w 756
official 1 w 764
does 1 w 768
not 2 w 771
make 3 w 775
treaties 1 w 783
or 13 w 785
agreements 1 w 795
after 1 w 800
midday 1 w 806
Or 3 w 809
is 9 w 811
it 5 w 813
impossible 1 w 823
to 6 w 825
reckon 2 w 831
the 17 w 834
beginning 5 w 843
and 5 w 846
end 2 w 849
of 10 w 851
the 18 w 854
day 3 w 857
by 2 w 859
sunset 1 w 865
and 6 w 868
sunrise 2 w 875
For 2 w 879
if 1 w 881
we 2 w 883
follow 1 w 889
the 19 w 892
method 1 w 898
by 3 w 900
which 1 w 905
most 3 w 909
people 2 w 915
formulate 1 w 924
their 3 w 929
definitions 1 w 940
by 4 w 943
their 4 w 948
perceptions 1 w 959
reckoning 1 w 969
the 22 w 972
first 1 w 977
peep 1 w 981
of 11 w 983
the 23 w 986
sun 4 w 989
above 1 w 994
the 24 w 997
horizon 1 w 1004
as 7 w 1006
the 25 w 1009
beginning 6 w 1018
of 12 w 1020
day 4 w 1023
and 7 w 1027
the 26 w 1030
cutting 1 w 1037
off 2 w 1040
of 14 w 1042
its 1 w 1045
last 1 w 1049
rays 1 w 1053
as 9 w 1055
the 27 w 1058
beginning 7 w 1067
of 15 w 1069
night 5 w 1074
we 3 w 1077
shall 1 w 1082
have 2 w 1086
no 4 w 1088
equinox 1 w 1095
but 1 w 1099
that 3 w 1103
night 6 w 1108
which 2 w 1113
we 4 w 1115
think 1 w 1120
is 11 w 1122
most 4 w 1126
nearly 1 w 1132
equal 1 w 1137
to 7 w 1139
the 28 w 1142
day 5 w 1145
will 1 w 1149
plainly 1 w 1156
be 12 w 1158
less 1 w 1162
than 1 w 1166
that 4 w 1170
day 6 w 1173
by 5 w 1175
the 29 w 1178
diameter 1 w 1186
of 16 w 1188
the 30 w 1191
sun 5 w 1194
Long 1 w 1199
before 2 w 1205
Plutarch 1 w 1213
s 69 w 1215
day 7 w 1218
the 31 w 1221
Greeks 1 w 1227
had 1 w 1230
calculated 1 w 1240
the 32 w 1243
angle 1 w 1248
subtended 1 w 1257
by 6 w 1259
the 33 w 1262
sun 6 w 1265
with 1 w 1269
an 14 w 1271
accuracy 1 w 1279
that 5 w 1283
stood 1 w 1288
the 34 w 1291
test 2 w 1295
of 17 w 1297
centuries 1 w 1306
and 8 w 1310
was 3 w 1313
not 3 w 1316
modified 1 w 1324
until 1 w 1329
comparatively 1 w 1342
recent 1 w 1348
times 1 w 1353
Cf 2 w 1356
Archimedes 1 w 1367
Arenarius 1 w 1377
i 120 w 1379
10 2 w 1382
J 1 w 1384
L 3 w 1386
Heiberg 1 w 1394
s 80 w 1396
ed 10 w 1398
ii 4 w 1401
p 24 w 1403
248 1 w 1407
But 1 w 1412
then 1 w 1416
again 1 w 1421
the 36 w 1424
remedy 1 w 1430
which 3 w 1435
the 37 w 1438
mathematicians 1 w 1452
apply 1 w 1457
to 9 w 1459
this 2 w 1463
anomaly 1 w 1470
decreeing 1 w 1480
that 6 w 1484
the 39 w 1487
instant 1 w 1494
when 2 w 1498
the 40 w 1501
centre 1 w 1507
of 18 w 1509
the 41 w 1512
sun 7 w 1515
touches 1 w 1522
the 42 w 1525
horizon 2 w 1532
is 13 w 1534
the 43 w 1537
boundary 1 w 1545
between 1 w 1552
day 8 w 1555
and 9 w 1558
night 7 w 1563
is 14 w 1566
a 117 w 1567
negation 1 w 1575
of 19 w 1577
plain 2 w 1582
fact 2 w 1586
for 8 w 1590
the 44 w 1593
result 1 w 1599
will 2 w 1603
be 16 w 1605
that 7 w 1609
when 3 w 1613
there 1 w 1618
is 15 w 1620
still 1 w 1625
much 1 w 1629
light 1 w 1634
over 1 w 1638
the 46 w 1641
earth 1 w 1646
and 10 w 1649
the 47 w 1652
sun 8 w 1655
is 16 w 1657
shining 1 w 1664
upon 1 w 1668
us 11 w 1670
we 6 w 1673
cannot 1 w 1679
admit 1 w 1684
that 8 w 1688
it 10 w 1690
is 17 w 1692
day 9 w 1695
but 2 w 1699
must 1 w 1703
say 1 w 1706
that 9 w 1710
it 11 w 1712
is 18 w 1714
already 1 w 1721
night 8 w 1726
Since 1 w 1732
therefore 1 w 1742
the 49 w 1746
beginning 8 w 1755
of 20 w 1757
day 10 w 1760
and 11 w 1763
night 9 w 1768
is 19 w 1770
difficult 1 w 1779
to 11 w 1781
determine 1 w 1790
at 25 w 1792
the 50 w 1795
time 3 w 1799
of 21 w 1801
the 51 w 1804
risings 1 w 1811
and 12 w 1814
settings 1 w 1822
of 22 w 1824
the 52 w 1827
sun 9 w 1830
because 2 w 1837
of 23 w 1839
the 53 w 1842
irrationalities 1 w 1857
which 4 w 1862
I 2 w 1863
have 3 w 1867
mentioned 1 w 1876
there 3 w 1882
is 21 w 1884
left 1 w 1888
the 55 w 1891
zenith 1 w 1897
or 21 w 1899
the 56 w 1902
nadir 1 w 1907
of 24 w 1909
the 57 w 1912
suii 1 w 1916
to 12 w 1918
reckon 4 w 1924
as 11 w 1926
the 58 w 1929
beginning 9 w 1938
The 1 w 1942
second 1 w 1948
is 22 w 1950
better 1 w 1956
for 10 w 1960
from 2 w 1964
noon 2 w 1968
on 28 w 1970
the 59 w 1973
sun 10 w 1976
s 113 w 1978
course 1 w 1984
is 23 w 1986
away 1 w 1990
from 3 w 1994
us 14 w 1996
to 13 w 1998
its 2 w 2001
setting 2 w 2008
but 3 w 2012
from 4 w 2016
midnight 3 w 2024
on 29 w 2026
its 3 w 2029
course 2 w 2035
is 24 w 2037
towards 1 w 2044
us 15 w 2046
to 15 w 2048
its 4 w 2051
rising 2 w 2057
Why 2 w 2061
in 48 w 2063
the 60 w 2066
early 2 w 2071
days 1 w 2075
did 3 w 2078
they 4 w 2082
not 5 w 2085
allow 1 w 2090
their 5 w 2095
wives 1 w 2100
to 16 w 2102
grind 1 w 2107
grain 2 w 2112
or 23 w 2114
to 17 w 2116
cook 1 w 2120
Cf 3 w 2123
Life 1 w 2128
of 25 w 2130
Romulus 1 w 2137
chap 1 w 2142
xv 1 w 2145
26 1 w 2149
d 72 w 2150
xix 1 w 2155
30 1 w 2159
a 150 w 2160
Was 1 w 2165
it 17 w 2167
in 51 w 2169
memory 1 w 2175
of 26 w 2177
the 63 w 2180
treaty 1 w 2186
which 5 w 2191
they 5 w 2195
made 1 w 2199
with 2 w 2203
the 65 w 2206
Sabines 1 w 2213
For 3 w 2217
when 4 w 2221
they 6 w 2225
had 2 w 2228
carried 1 w 2235
off 3 w 2238
the 67 w 2241
Sabines 2 w 2248
daughters 1 w 2258
and 13 w 2262
later 1 w 2267
after 2 w 2273
warring 1 w 2280
with 3 w 2284
the 68 w 2287
Sabines 3 w 2294
had 3 w 2298
made 2 w 2302
peace 1 w 2307
it 20 w 2310
was 4 w 2313
specified 1 w 2322
among 1 w 2327
the 69 w 2330
other 1 w 2335
articles 1 w 2343
of 28 w 2345
agreement 2 w 2354
that 10 w 2358
no 11 w 2360
Sabine 4 w 2366
woman 1 w 2371
should 2 w 2377
grind 2 w 2382
grain 3 w 2387
for 11 w 2390
a 175 w 2391
Roman 3 w 2396
or 27 w 2398
cook 2 w 2402
for 12 w 2405
him 2 w 2408