Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (82-83)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:82-83
Refs {'start': {'reference': '82', 'human_reference': 'Section 82'}, 'end': {'reference': '83', 'human_reference': 'Section 83'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why are the rods of the praetors carried in bundles with axes attached?

Is it because this is a symbolic indication that the temper of the official should not be too quick or unrestrained? Or does the deliberate unfastening of the rods, which creates delay and postponement of his iit of temper, oftentimes cause him to change his mind about the punishment? Now since some badness is curable, but other badness is past remedy, the rods correct that which may be amended and the axes cut off the incorrigible.

When the Romans learned that the people called Bletonesii,[*] a barbarian tribe, had sacrificed a man to the gods, why did they send for the tribal rulers with intent to punish them, but, when it was made plain that they had done thus in accordance with a certain custom, why did the Romans set them at liberty, but forbid the practice for the future? Yet they themselves, not many years before, had buried alive two men and two women, two of them Greeks, two Gauls, in the place called the Forum Boarium. It certainly

seems strange that they themselves should do this, and yet rebuke barbarians on the ground that they were acting with impiety.

Did they think it impious to sacrifice men to the gods, but necessary to sacrifice them to the spirits? Or did they believe that men who did this by tradition and custom were sinning, whereas they themselves did it by command of the Sibylline books? For the tale is told that a certain maiden, Helvia, was struck by lightning while she was riding on horseback, and her horse was found lying stripped of its trappings: and she herself was naked, for her tunic had been pulled far up as if purposely: and her shoes, her rings, and her head-dress were scattered apart here and there, and her open mouth allowed the tongue to protrude. The soothsayers declared that it was a terrible disgrace for the Vestal Virgins, that it would be bruited far and wide, and that some wanton outrage would be found touching the knights also. Thereupon a barbarian slave of a certain knight gave information against three Vestal Virgins, Aemilia, Licinia, and Marcia, that they had all been corrupted at about the same time, and that they had long entertained lovers, one of whom was Vetutius Barrus,[*] the informers master. The Vestals, accordingly, were convicted and punished: but, since the deed was plainly atrocious, it was resolved that the priests should consult the Sibylline books. They say that oracles were found foretelling that these events would come to pass for the bane of the Romans, and enjoining on them that, to avert the impending disaster, they should offer as a sacrifice to certain

strange and alien spirits two Greeks and two Gauls, buried alive on the spot.[*]

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
are 1 w 6
the 1 w 9
rods 1 w 13
of 1 w 15
the 2 w 18
praetors 1 w 26
carried 1 w 33
in 1 w 35
bundles 1 w 42
with 1 w 46
axes 1 w 50
attached 1 w 58
Is 1 w 61
it 2 w 63
because 1 w 70
this 1 w 74
is 2 w 76
a 8 w 77
symbolic 1 w 85
indication 1 w 95
that 1 w 99
the 3 w 102
temper 1 w 108
of 2 w 110
the 4 w 113
official 1 w 121
should 1 w 127
not 1 w 130
be 2 w 132
too 1 w 135
quick 1 w 140
or 2 w 142
unrestrained 1 w 154
Or 1 w 157
does 1 w 161
the 5 w 164
deliberate 1 w 174
unfastening 1 w 185
of 4 w 187
the 6 w 190
rods 2 w 194
which 1 w 200
creates 1 w 207
delay 1 w 212
and 1 w 215
postponement 1 w 227
of 5 w 229
his 2 w 232
iit 1 w 235
of 6 w 237
temper 2 w 243
oftentimes 1 w 254
cause 2 w 259
him 1 w 262
to 3 w 264
change 1 w 270
his 3 w 273
mind 1 w 277
about 1 w 282
the 7 w 285
punishment 1 w 295
Now 1 w 299
since 1 w 304
some 1 w 308
badness 1 w 315
is 6 w 317
curable 1 w 324
but 1 w 328
other 1 w 333
badness 2 w 340
is 7 w 342
past 1 w 346
remedy 1 w 352
the 9 w 356
rods 3 w 360
correct 1 w 367
that 2 w 371
which 2 w 376
may 1 w 379
be 4 w 381
amended 1 w 388
and 2 w 391
the 10 w 394
axes 2 w 398
cut 1 w 401
off 2 w 404
the 11 w 407
incorrigible 1 w 419
When 1 w 424
the 12 w 427
Romans 1 w 433
learned 1 w 440
that 3 w 444
the 13 w 447
people 1 w 453
called 1 w 459
Bletonesii 1 w 469
Of 1 w 472
Bletisa 1 w 479
in 8 w 481
Spain 1 w 486
according 1 w 496
to 5 w 498
Cichorius 1 w 507
Römische 1 w 516
Studien 1 w 523
Berlin 1 w 530
1922 1 w 535
a 37 w 538
barbarian 1 w 547
tribe 1 w 552
had 1 w 556
sacrificed 1 w 566
a 43 w 567
man 2 w 570
to 6 w 572
the 14 w 575
gods 1 w 579
why 1 w 583
did 1 w 586
they 1 w 590
send 1 w 594
for 1 w 597
the 16 w 600
tribal 1 w 606
rulers 1 w 612
with 2 w 616
intent 1 w 622
to 7 w 624
punish 2 w 630
them 1 w 634
but 2 w 638
when 1 w 643
it 5 w 645
was 1 w 648
made 1 w 652
plain 1 w 657
that 4 w 661
they 2 w 665
had 2 w 668
done 1 w 672
thus 1 w 676
in 14 w 678
accordance 1 w 688
with 3 w 692
a 53 w 693
certain 1 w 700
custom 1 w 706
why 2 w 710
did 2 w 713
the 19 w 716
Romans 2 w 722
set 1 w 725
them 2 w 729
at 9 w 731
liberty 1 w 738
but 3 w 742
forbid 1 w 748
the 21 w 751
practice 1 w 759
for 3 w 762
the 22 w 765
future 1 w 771
Yet 1 w 775
they 3 w 779
themselves 1 w 789
not 2 w 793
many 1 w 797
years 1 w 802
before 1 w 808
had 3 w 812
buried 1 w 818
alive 1 w 823
two 1 w 826
men 4 w 829
and 3 w 832
two 2 w 835
women 1 w 840
two 3 w 844
of 9 w 846
them 4 w 850
Greeks 1 w 856
two 4 w 860
Gauls 1 w 865
in 16 w 868
the 26 w 871
place 1 w 876
called 2 w 882
the 27 w 885
Forum 1 w 890
Boarium 1 w 897
It 1 w 900
certainly 1 w 909
seems 1 w 914
strange 1 w 921
that 5 w 925
they 4 w 929
themselves 2 w 939
should 2 w 945
do 3 w 947
this 2 w 951
and 4 w 955
yet 1 w 958
rebuke 1 w 964
barbarians 1 w 974
on 5 w 976
the 30 w 979
ground 1 w 985
that 6 w 989
they 5 w 993
were 1 w 997
acting 1 w 1003
with 4 w 1007
impiety 1 w 1014
Did 1 w 1018
they 6 w 1022
think 1 w 1027
it 8 w 1029
impious 1 w 1036
to 9 w 1038
sacrifice 2 w 1047
men 6 w 1050
to 10 w 1052
the 33 w 1055
gods 2 w 1059
but 4 w 1063
necessary 1 w 1072
to 11 w 1074
sacrifice 3 w 1083
them 6 w 1087
to 12 w 1089
the 35 w 1092
spirits 1 w 1099
Or 2 w 1102
did 3 w 1105
they 7 w 1109
believe 1 w 1116
that 7 w 1120
men 7 w 1123
who 1 w 1126
did 4 w 1129
this 3 w 1133
by 1 w 1135
tradition 1 w 1144
and 5 w 1147
custom 2 w 1153
were 2 w 1157
sinning 1 w 1164
whereas 1 w 1172
they 8 w 1176
themselves 3 w 1186
did 5 w 1189
it 11 w 1191
by 2 w 1193
command 1 w 1200
of 10 w 1202
the 39 w 1205
Sibylline 1 w 1214
books 1 w 1219
For 2 w 1223
the 40 w 1226
tale 1 w 1230
is 13 w 1232
told 1 w 1236
that 8 w 1240
a 86 w 1241
certain 3 w 1248
maiden 1 w 1254
Helvia 1 w 1261
was 2 w 1265
struck 1 w 1271
by 4 w 1273
lightning 1 w 1282
while 1 w 1287
she 1 w 1290
was 3 w 1293
riding 1 w 1299
on 7 w 1301
horseback 1 w 1310
and 7 w 1314
her 3 w 1317
horse 2 w 1322
was 4 w 1325
found 1 w 1330
lying 1 w 1335
stripped 1 w 1343
of 11 w 1345
its 2 w 1348
trappings 1 w 1357
and 8 w 1361
she 2 w 1364
herself 1 w 1371
was 5 w 1374
naked 1 w 1379
for 5 w 1383
her 5 w 1386
tunic 1 w 1391
had 4 w 1394
been 1 w 1398
pulled 1 w 1404
far 1 w 1407
up 1 w 1409
as 9 w 1411
if 4 w 1413
purposely 1 w 1422
and 9 w 1426
her 6 w 1429
shoes 1 w 1434
her 7 w 1438
rings 1 w 1443
and 10 w 1447
her 8 w 1450
head-dress 1 w 1460
were 3 w 1464
scattered 1 w 1473
apart 1 w 1478
here 2 w 1482
and 11 w 1485
there 1 w 1490
and 12 w 1494
her 11 w 1497
open 1 w 1501
mouth 1 w 1506
allowed 1 w 1513
the 42 w 1516
tongue 1 w 1522
to 16 w 1524
protrude 1 w 1532
The 1 w 1536
soothsayers 1 w 1547
declared 1 w 1555
that 9 w 1559
it 13 w 1561
was 6 w 1564
a 115 w 1565
terrible 1 w 1573
disgrace 1 w 1581
for 6 w 1584
the 43 w 1587
Vestal 1 w 1593
Virgins 1 w 1600
that 10 w 1605
it 14 w 1607
would 1 w 1612
be 10 w 1614
bruited 1 w 1621
far 2 w 1624
and 13 w 1627
wide 1 w 1631
and 14 w 1635
that 11 w 1639
some 2 w 1643
wanton 1 w 1649
outrage 1 w 1656
would 2 w 1661
be 11 w 1663
found 2 w 1668
touching 1 w 1676
the 44 w 1679
knights 1 w 1686
also 1 w 1690
Thereupon 1 w 1700
a 126 w 1701
barbarian 3 w 1710
slave 1 w 1715
of 12 w 1717
a 131 w 1718
certain 4 w 1725
knight 2 w 1731
gave 1 w 1735
information 1 w 1746
against 1 w 1753
three 1 w 1758
Vestal 2 w 1764
Virgins 2 w 1771
Aemilia 1 w 1779
Licinia 1 w 1787
and 15 w 1791
Marcia 1 w 1797
that 12 w 1802
they 9 w 1806
had 5 w 1809
all 4 w 1812
been 2 w 1816
corrupted 1 w 1825
at 20 w 1827
about 2 w 1832
the 46 w 1835
same 1 w 1839
time 2 w 1843
and 16 w 1847
that 13 w 1851
they 10 w 1855
had 6 w 1858
long 1 w 1862
entertained 1 w 1873
lovers 1 w 1879
one 4 w 1883
of 13 w 1885
whom 1 w 1889
was 7 w 1892
Vetutius 1 w 1900
Barrus 1 w 1906
Cf 1 w 1909
Cicero 1 w 1916
Brutus 1 w 1923
46 1 w 1926
169 1 w 1930
Horace 1 w 1938
Satires 1 w 1946
i 141 w 1948
6 3 w 1950
30 1 w 1953
if 5 w 1956
the 48 w 1959
emendation 1 w 1969
is 15 w 1971
right 1 w 1976
the 49 w 1980
informer 1 w 1988
s 120 w 1990
master 1 w 1996
The 3 w 2000
Vestals 1 w 2007
accordingly 1 w 2019
were 4 w 2024
convicted 1 w 2033
and 17 w 2036
punished 1 w 2044
but 5 w 2048
since 2 w 2054
the 50 w 2057
deed 1 w 2061
was 8 w 2064
plainly 1 w 2071
atrocious 1 w 2080
it 16 w 2083
was 9 w 2086
resolved 1 w 2094
that 14 w 2098
the 51 w 2101
priests 1 w 2108
should 3 w 2114
consult 1 w 2121
the 52 w 2124
Sibylline 2 w 2133
books 2 w 2138
They 1 w 2143
say 2 w 2146
that 15 w 2150
oracles 1 w 2157
were 5 w 2161
found 3 w 2166
foretelling 1 w 2177
that 16 w 2181
these 1 w 2186
events 1 w 2192
would 3 w 2197
come 1 w 2201
to 19 w 2203
pass 1 w 2207
for 10 w 2210
the 54 w 2213
bane 1 w 2217
of 14 w 2219
the 55 w 2222
Romans 3 w 2228
and 18 w 2232
enjoining 1 w 2241
on 17 w 2243
them 8 w 2247
that 17 w 2251
to 20 w 2254
avert 1 w 2259
the 57 w 2262
impending 1 w 2271
disaster 1 w 2279
they 11 w 2284
should 4 w 2290
offer 1 w 2295
as 17 w 2297
a 179 w 2298
sacrifice 4 w 2307
to 21 w 2309
certain 5 w 2316
strange 2 w 2323
and 19 w 2326
alien 1 w 2331
spirits 2 w 2338
two 5 w 2341
Greeks 2 w 2347
and 20 w 2350
two 6 w 2353
Gauls 2 w 2358
buried 2 w 2365
alive 2 w 2370
on 18 w 2372
the 59 w 2375
spot 1 w 2379
Cf 2 w 2382
Life 1 w 2387
of 16 w 2389
Marcellus 1 w 2398
chap 1 w 2403
iii 1 w 2407
299 1 w 2412
d 110 w 2413
Livy 1 w 2419
xxii 1 w 2424
57 1 w 2427