Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (46-47)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:46-47
Refs {'start': {'reference': '46', 'human_reference': 'Section 46'}, 'end': {'reference': '47', 'human_reference': 'Section 47'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why did the men of old keep the temple of Horta continually open?

Is it, as Antistius Labeo has stated, that since to

urge on is expressed by hortari, Horta is the goddess who urges us on, as it were, and incites us to noble actions: and thus they thought that, since she was ever active, she should never be procrastinating nor shut off by herself nor unemployed?

Or rather do they call her, as at present, Hora, with the first syllable lengthened, an attentive and very considerate goddess, who, since she was protective and thoughtful, they felt was never indifferent nor neglectful of human affairs?

Or is this too, like many other Latin words, a Greek word, and does it signify the supervising and guardian goddess? Hence her temple was continually open since she neither slumbers nor sleeps.

If, however, Labeo be right in pointing out that Hora is derived from parorman [*] (to urge on), consider whether we must not declare that orator is thus to be derived, since an orator is a counsellor or popular leader who stimulates, as it were, and incites: and it is not to be derived from imprecating or praying (orare), as some assert.

Why did Romulus build the temple of Vulcan outside the city?

Was it in consequence of Vulcans fabled jealousy of Mars because of Venus[*] that Romulus, the reputed son of Mars, did not give Vulcan a share in his home or his city?

Or is this a foolish explanation, and was the temple originally built as a secret place of assembly and council-chamber for himself and his colleague Tatius,

that here they might convene with the senators and take counsel concerning public affairs in quiet without being disturbed?

Or was it that since Rome, from the very beginning, has been in great danger from conflagrations, they decided to show honour to this god, but to place his temple outside of the city?[*]

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
did 1 w 6
the 1 w 9
men 1 w 12
of 1 w 14
old 1 w 17
keep 1 w 21
the 2 w 24
temple 1 w 30
of 2 w 32
Horta 1 w 37
continually 1 w 48
open 1 w 52
Is 1 w 55
it 1 w 57
as 1 w 60
Antistius 1 w 69
Labeo 1 w 74
has 1 w 77
stated 1 w 83
that 1 w 88
since 1 w 93
to 1 w 95
urge 1 w 99
on 2 w 101
is 2 w 103
expressed 1 w 112
by 1 w 114
hortari 1 w 121
Horta 2 w 127
is 3 w 129
the 3 w 132
goddess 1 w 139
who 1 w 142
urges 1 w 147
us 2 w 149
on 3 w 151
as 3 w 154
it 2 w 156
were 1 w 160
and 1 w 164
incites 1 w 171
us 3 w 173
to 2 w 175
noble 1 w 180
actions 1 w 187
and 2 w 191
thus 1 w 195
they 1 w 199
thought 1 w 206
that 2 w 210
since 2 w 216
she 1 w 219
was 1 w 222
ever 1 w 226
active 1 w 232
she 2 w 236
should 1 w 242
never 1 w 247
be 2 w 249
procrastinating 1 w 264
nor 1 w 267
shut 1 w 271
off 1 w 274
by 2 w 276
herself 1 w 283
nor 2 w 286
unemployed 1 w 296
Or 1 w 299
rather 1 w 305
do 1 w 307
they 2 w 311
call 1 w 315
her 3 w 318
as 6 w 321
at 6 w 323
present 1 w 330
Hora 1 w 335
with 1 w 340
the 7 w 343
first 1 w 348
syllable 1 w 356
lengthened 1 w 366
an 3 w 369
attentive 1 w 378
and 3 w 381
very 1 w 385
considerate 1 w 396
goddess 2 w 403
who 2 w 407
since 3 w 413
she 3 w 416
was 2 w 419
protective 1 w 429
and 4 w 432
thoughtful 1 w 442
they 3 w 447
felt 1 w 451
was 3 w 454
never 2 w 459
indifferent 1 w 470
nor 3 w 473
neglectful 1 w 483
of 4 w 485
human 1 w 490
affairs 1 w 497
Or 2 w 500
is 4 w 502
this 1 w 506
too 1 w 509
like 1 w 514
many 1 w 518
other 1 w 523
Latin 1 w 528
words 1 w 533
a 37 w 535
Greek 1 w 540
word 2 w 544
and 5 w 548
does 1 w 552
it 5 w 554
signify 1 w 561
the 11 w 564
supervising 1 w 575
and 6 w 578
guardian 1 w 586
goddess 3 w 593
Hence 1 w 599
her 5 w 602
temple 2 w 608
was 4 w 611
continually 2 w 622
open 2 w 626
since 4 w 631
she 4 w 634
neither 1 w 641
slumbers 1 w 649
nor 4 w 652
sleeps 1 w 658
If 1 w 661
however 1 w 669
Labeo 2 w 675
be 5 w 677
right 1 w 682
in 13 w 684
pointing 1 w 692
out 1 w 695
that 3 w 699
Hora 2 w 703
is 7 w 705
derived 1 w 712
from 1 w 716
parorman 1 w 724
Plutarch 1 w 732
here 1 w 736
in 16 w 739
hora 1 w 743
horman 1 w 750
h 44 w 753
orator 1 w 760
as 10 w 764
often 1 w 769
makes 1 w 775
havoc 1 w 780
of 6 w 782
etymology 1 w 791
and 7 w 794
quantity 1 w 802
to 5 w 806
urge 3 w 810
on 7 w 812
consider 2 w 822
whether 1 w 829
we 3 w 831
must 1 w 835
not 1 w 838
declare 1 w 845
that 4 w 849
orator 2 w 855
is 8 w 857
thus 2 w 861
to 7 w 863
be 6 w 865
derived 2 w 872
since 5 w 878
an 15 w 880
orator 3 w 886
is 9 w 888
a 63 w 889
counsellor 1 w 899
or 22 w 901
popular 1 w 908
leader 1 w 914
who 3 w 917
stimulates 1 w 927
as 11 w 930
it 8 w 932
were 2 w 936
and 8 w 940
incites 2 w 947
and 9 w 951
it 10 w 953
is 10 w 955
not 2 w 958
to 9 w 960
be 7 w 962
derived 3 w 969
from 2 w 973
imprecating 1 w 984
or 23 w 986
praying 1 w 993
orare 1 w 999
as 12 w 1003
some 1 w 1007
assert 1 w 1013
Why 2 w 1017
did 2 w 1020
Romulus 1 w 1027
build 1 w 1032
the 14 w 1035
temple 3 w 1041
of 7 w 1043
Vulcan 1 w 1049
outside 1 w 1056
the 15 w 1059
city 1 w 1063
Was 1 w 1067
it 12 w 1069
in 21 w 1071
consequence 1 w 1082
of 8 w 1084
Vulcan 2 w 1090
s 80 w 1092
fabled 1 w 1098
jealousy 1 w 1106
of 9 w 1108
Mars 1 w 1112
because 1 w 1119
of 10 w 1121
Venus 1 w 1126
Cf 1 w 1128
Homer 1 w 1134
Od 1 w 1137
viii 1 w 1142
266-359 1 w 1150
that 5 w 1155
Romulus 2 w 1162
the 16 w 1166
reputed 1 w 1173
son 1 w 1176
of 11 w 1178
Mars 2 w 1182
did 3 w 1186
not 3 w 1189
give 1 w 1193
Vulcan 3 w 1199
a 85 w 1200
share 1 w 1205
in 22 w 1207
his 2 w 1210
home 1 w 1214
or 25 w 1216
his 3 w 1219
city 2 w 1223
Or 3 w 1226
is 13 w 1228
this 2 w 1232
a 87 w 1233
foolish 1 w 1240
explanation 1 w 1251
and 10 w 1255
was 5 w 1258
the 17 w 1261
temple 4 w 1267
originally 1 w 1277
built 1 w 1282
as 16 w 1284
a 94 w 1285
secret 1 w 1291
place 1 w 1296
of 12 w 1298
assembly 1 w 1306
and 11 w 1309
council-chamber 1 w 1324
for 1 w 1327
himself 1 w 1334
and 12 w 1337
his 5 w 1340
colleague 1 w 1349
Tatius 1 w 1355
that 6 w 1360
here 2 w 1364
they 4 w 1368
might 1 w 1373
convene 1 w 1380
with 2 w 1384
the 19 w 1387
senators 1 w 1395
and 13 w 1398
take 1 w 1402
counsel 2 w 1409
concerning 1 w 1419
public 1 w 1425
affairs 2 w 1432
in 25 w 1434
quiet 1 w 1439
without 1 w 1446
being 1 w 1451
disturbed 1 w 1460
Or 4 w 1463
was 6 w 1466
it 16 w 1468
that 7 w 1472
since 6 w 1477
Rome 1 w 1481
from 3 w 1486
the 20 w 1489
very 2 w 1493
beginning 1 w 1502
has 2 w 1506
been 1 w 1510
in 30 w 1512
great 1 w 1517
danger 1 w 1523
from 4 w 1527
conflagrations 1 w 1541
they 5 w 1546
decided 1 w 1553
to 11 w 1555
show 1 w 1559
honour 1 w 1565
to 12 w 1567
this 3 w 1571
god 4 w 1574
but 1 w 1578
to 13 w 1580
place 2 w 1585
his 7 w 1588
temple 5 w 1594
outside 2 w 1601
of 13 w 1603
the 22 w 1606
city 3 w 1610
Cf 2 w 1613
Vitruvius 1 w 1623
i 112 w 1625
7 1 w 1627
1 1 w 1629