Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (28-29)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:28-29
Refs {'start': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}, 'end': {'reference': '29', 'human_reference': 'Section 29'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do they tell children, whenever they would swear by Hercules, not to do so under a roof, and bid them go out into the open air?[*]

Is it, as some relate, because they believe that Hercules had no pleasure in staying in the house, but rejoiced in a life in the open air and a bed under the stars?

Or is it rather because Hercules is not one of the native gods, but a foreigner from afar? For neither do they swear under a roof by Bacchus, since he also is a foreign god if he is from Nysa.

Or is this but said in jest to the children, and what is done is really a check upon over-readiness and hastiness to swear, as Favorinus stated? For what is done following, as it were, upon preparation produces delay and allows deliberation. Yet one might urge against Favorinus the fact that this custom is not common, but peculiar to Hercules, as may be seen from the legend about him: for it is recorded that he was so circumspect regarding an oath that he swore but once and for Phyleus, the son of Augeas, alone. Wherefore they say that the prophetic priestess also brought up against the Spartans all the oaths they had sworn, saying that it would be better and much more to be desired if they would keep them![*]

Why do they not allow the bride to cross the threshold of her home herself, but those who are escorting her lift her over?[*]

Is it because they carried off by force also the first Roman brides and bore them in in this manner, and the women did not enter of their own accord?

Or do they wish it to appear that it is under constraint and not of their own desire that they enter a dwelling where they are about to lose their virginity?

Or is it a token that the woman may not go forth of her own accord and abandon her home if she be not constrained, just as it was under constraint that she entered it? So likewise among us in Boeotia they burn the axle of the bridal carriage before the door, signifying that the bride must remain, since her means of departure has been destroyed.

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
they 1 w 9
tell 1 w 13
children 1 w 21
whenever 1 w 30
they 2 w 34
would 1 w 39
swear 1 w 44
by 1 w 46
Hercules 1 w 54
not 1 w 58
to 1 w 60
do 2 w 62
so 1 w 64
under 1 w 69
a 2 w 70
roof 1 w 74
and 1 w 78
bid 1 w 81
them 1 w 85
go 1 w 87
out 1 w 90
into 1 w 94
the 4 w 97
open 1 w 101
air 1 w 104
Cf 1 w 107
Varro 1 w 113
De 1 w 116
Lingua 1 w 122
Latina 1 w 128
v 2 w 130
66 1 w 133
Is 1 w 136
it 1 w 138
as 1 w 141
some 1 w 145
relate 1 w 151
because 1 w 159
they 3 w 163
believe 1 w 170
that 1 w 174
Hercules 2 w 182
had 1 w 185
no 2 w 187
pleasure 1 w 195
in 4 w 197
staying 1 w 204
in 6 w 206
the 6 w 209
house 1 w 214
but 1 w 218
rejoiced 1 w 226
in 7 w 228
a 16 w 229
life 1 w 233
in 8 w 235
the 7 w 238
open 2 w 242
air 2 w 245
and 2 w 248
a 19 w 249
bed 1 w 252
under 2 w 257
the 8 w 260
stars 1 w 265
Or 1 w 268
is 1 w 270
it 2 w 272
rather 1 w 278
because 2 w 285
Hercules 3 w 293
is 2 w 295
not 2 w 298
one 1 w 301
of 2 w 303
the 10 w 306
native 1 w 312
gods 1 w 316
but 2 w 320
a 24 w 321
foreigner 1 w 330
from 1 w 334
afar 1 w 338
For 1 w 342
neither 1 w 349
do 3 w 351
they 4 w 355
swear 2 w 360
under 3 w 365
a 28 w 366
roof 2 w 370
by 2 w 372
Bacchus 1 w 379
since 1 w 385
he 14 w 387
also 1 w 391
is 3 w 393
a 31 w 394
foreign 2 w 401
god 2 w 404
if 2 w 406
he 15 w 408
is 4 w 410
from 2 w 414
Nysa 1 w 418
Or 2 w 421
is 5 w 423
this 1 w 427
but 3 w 430
said 1 w 434
in 10 w 436
jest 1 w 440
to 3 w 442
the 13 w 445
children 2 w 453
and 3 w 457
what 1 w 461
is 7 w 463
done 1 w 467
is 8 w 469
really 1 w 475
a 37 w 476
check 1 w 481
upon 1 w 485
over-readiness 1 w 499
and 4 w 502
hastiness 1 w 511
to 4 w 513
swear 3 w 518
as 4 w 521
Favorinus 1 w 530
stated 1 w 536
For 2 w 540
what 2 w 544
is 9 w 546
done 2 w 550
following 1 w 559
as 5 w 562
it 4 w 564
were 1 w 568
upon 2 w 573
preparation 1 w 584
produces 1 w 592
delay 1 w 597
and 5 w 600
allows 1 w 606
deliberation 1 w 618
Yet 1 w 622
one 4 w 625
might 1 w 630
urge 1 w 634
against 1 w 641
Favorinus 2 w 650
the 14 w 653
fact 1 w 657
that 2 w 661
this 2 w 665
custom 1 w 671
is 11 w 673
not 3 w 676
common 1 w 682
but 4 w 686
peculiar 1 w 694
to 6 w 696
Hercules 4 w 704
as 6 w 707
may 1 w 710
be 6 w 712
seen 1 w 716
from 3 w 720
the 15 w 723
legend 1 w 729
about 1 w 734
him 1 w 737
for 3 w 741
it 5 w 743
is 12 w 745
recorded 1 w 753
that 3 w 757
he 20 w 759
was 1 w 762
so 4 w 764
circumspect 1 w 775
regarding 1 w 784
an 6 w 786
oath 1 w 790
that 4 w 794
he 21 w 796
swore 1 w 801
but 5 w 804
once 1 w 808
and 6 w 811
for 4 w 814
Phyleus 1 w 821
the 16 w 825
son 1 w 828
of 4 w 830
Augeas 1 w 836
alone 1 w 842
Wherefore 1 w 852
they 5 w 856
say 1 w 859
that 5 w 863
the 18 w 866
prophetic 1 w 875
priestess 1 w 884
also 2 w 888
brought 1 w 895
up 3 w 897
against 2 w 904
the 19 w 907
Spartans 1 w 915
all 3 w 918
the 20 w 921
oaths 1 w 926
they 6 w 930
had 2 w 933
sworn 1 w 938
saying 1 w 945
that 6 w 949
it 6 w 951
would 2 w 956
be 7 w 958
better 1 w 964
and 7 w 967
much 1 w 971
more 1 w 975
to 7 w 977
be 9 w 979
desired 1 w 986
if 3 w 988
they 7 w 992
would 3 w 997
keep 1 w 1001
them 2 w 1005
Cf 2 w 1008
Moralia 1 w 1016
229 1 w 1020
b 20 w 1021
and 8 w 1024
the 24 w 1027
note 1 w 1031
Vol 1 w 1035
III 1 w 1039
p 17 w 1041
372 1 w 1045
Why 2 w 1050
do 6 w 1052
they 8 w 1056
not 5 w 1059
allow 2 w 1064
the 26 w 1067
bride 1 w 1072
to 8 w 1074
cross 1 w 1079
the 27 w 1082
threshold 1 w 1091
of 5 w 1093
her 4 w 1096
home 1 w 1100
herself 1 w 1107
but 6 w 1111
those 1 w 1116
who 1 w 1119
are 1 w 1122
escorting 1 w 1131
her 6 w 1134
lift 1 w 1138
her 7 w 1141
over 2 w 1145
Cf 3 w 1148
Life 1 w 1153
of 6 w 1155
Romulus 1 w 1162
xv 1 w 1165
26 1 w 1169
d-e 1 w 1172
Is 2 w 1176
it 7 w 1178
because 3 w 1185
they 9 w 1189
carried 1 w 1196
off 1 w 1199
by 3 w 1201
force 1 w 1206
also 3 w 1210
the 29 w 1213
first 1 w 1218
Roman 1 w 1223
brides 1 w 1229
and 9 w 1232
bore 1 w 1236
them 3 w 1240
in 21 w 1242
in 22 w 1244
this 3 w 1248
manner 1 w 1254
and 10 w 1258
the 31 w 1261
women 1 w 1266
did 1 w 1269
not 6 w 1272
enter 1 w 1277
of 8 w 1279
their 1 w 1284
own 1 w 1287
accord 1 w 1293
Or 3 w 1296
do 7 w 1298
they 10 w 1302
wish 1 w 1306
it 8 w 1308
to 9 w 1310
appear 1 w 1316
that 7 w 1320
it 9 w 1322
is 15 w 1324
under 4 w 1329
constraint 1 w 1339
and 11 w 1342
not 7 w 1345
of 9 w 1347
their 2 w 1352
own 2 w 1355
desire 2 w 1361
that 8 w 1365
they 11 w 1369
enter 2 w 1374
a 103 w 1375
dwelling 1 w 1383
where 1 w 1388
they 12 w 1392
are 2 w 1395
about 2 w 1400
to 10 w 1402
lose 1 w 1406
their 3 w 1411
virginity 1 w 1420
Or 4 w 1423
is 16 w 1425
it 11 w 1427
a 106 w 1428
token 1 w 1433
that 9 w 1437
the 38 w 1440
woman 1 w 1445
may 2 w 1448
not 8 w 1451
go 4 w 1453
forth 1 w 1458
of 10 w 1460
her 9 w 1463
own 3 w 1466
accord 2 w 1472
and 12 w 1475
abandon 1 w 1482
her 10 w 1485
home 2 w 1489
if 6 w 1491
she 1 w 1494
be 11 w 1496
not 9 w 1499
constrained 1 w 1510
just 1 w 1515
as 9 w 1517
it 12 w 1519
was 2 w 1522
under 5 w 1527
constraint 2 w 1537
that 10 w 1541
she 2 w 1544
entered 1 w 1551
it 13 w 1553
So 1 w 1556
likewise 1 w 1564
among 1 w 1569
us 12 w 1571
in 28 w 1573
Boeotia 1 w 1580
they 13 w 1584
burn 1 w 1588
the 40 w 1591
axle 1 w 1595
of 11 w 1597
the 41 w 1600
bridal 1 w 1606
carriage 1 w 1614
before 1 w 1620
the 42 w 1623
door 1 w 1627
signifying 1 w 1638
that 11 w 1642
the 43 w 1645
bride 3 w 1650
must 1 w 1654
remain 1 w 1660
since 2 w 1666
her 11 w 1669
means 1 w 1674
of 12 w 1676
departure 1 w 1685
has 2 w 1688
been 1 w 1692
destroyed 1 w 1701