Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (26-27)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:26-27
Refs {'start': {'reference': '26', 'human_reference': 'Section 26'}, 'end': {'reference': '27', 'human_reference': 'Section 27'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do women in mourning wear white robes and white head-dresses?

Do they do this, as men say the Magi do, arraying themselves against Hades and the powers of darkness, and making themselves like unto Light and Brightness?

Or is it that, just as they clothe the body of the dead in white, they think it proper that the relatives should also wear this colour? They adorn the body thus since they cannot so adorn the soul; and they wish to send forth the soul bright and pure, since it is now set free after having fought the good fight in all its manifold forms.

Or are plainness and simplicity most becoming on these occasions? Of the dyed garments, some reflect expense, others over-elaboration: for we may say no less with reference to black than to purple: These be cheating garments, these be cheating colours. [*] That which is naturally black is dyed not through art, but by nature: and when it is

combined with a dark colour, it is overpowered.[*] Only white,[*] therefore, is pure, unmixed, and uncontaminated by dye, nor can it be imitated: wherefore it is most appropriate for the dead at burial. For he who is dead has become something simple, unmixed, and pure, once he has been released from the body, which is indeed to be compared with a stain made by dyeing. In Argos, as Socrates[*] says, persons in mourning wear white garments washed in water.

Why do they regard all the city wall as inviolable and sacred, but not the gates?

Is it, as Varro has written, because the wall must be considered sacred that men may fight and die with enthusiasm in its defence? It was under such circumstances, it seems, that Romulus killed his brother because he was attempting to leap across a place that was inviolable and sacred, and to make it traversable and profane.

But it was impossible to consecrate the gates, for through them they carry out many other objectionable things and also dead bodies.[*] Wherefore the original founders of a city yoke a bull and a cow, and mark out with a plough all the land on which they intend to build[*]; and when they are engaged in tracing[*] the circuit of the walls, as they measure off the space intended for gates, they lift up the ploughshare and thus carry the plough across,

since they hold that all the land that is ploughed is to be kept sacred and inviolable.

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
women 1 w 10
in 1 w 12
mourning 1 w 20
wear 1 w 24
white 1 w 29
robes 1 w 34
and 1 w 37
white 2 w 42
head-dresses 1 w 54
Do 1 w 57
they 1 w 61
do 2 w 63
this 1 w 67
as 1 w 70
men 2 w 73
say 1 w 76
the 2 w 79
Magi 1 w 83
do 3 w 85
arraying 1 w 94
themselves 1 w 104
against 1 w 111
Hades 1 w 116
and 2 w 119
the 4 w 122
powers 1 w 128
of 1 w 130
darkness 1 w 138
and 3 w 142
making 1 w 148
themselves 2 w 158
like 1 w 162
unto 1 w 166
Light 1 w 171
and 4 w 174
Brightness 1 w 184
Or 1 w 187
is 2 w 189
it 3 w 191
that 1 w 195
just 1 w 200
as 2 w 202
they 2 w 206
clothe 1 w 212
the 8 w 215
body 1 w 219
of 2 w 221
the 9 w 224
dead 1 w 228
in 6 w 230
white 3 w 235
they 3 w 240
think 1 w 245
it 5 w 247
proper 1 w 253
that 2 w 257
the 11 w 260
relatives 1 w 269
should 1 w 275
also 1 w 279
wear 2 w 283
this 2 w 287
colour 1 w 293
They 1 w 298
adorn 1 w 303
the 12 w 306
body 2 w 310
thus 1 w 314
since 1 w 319
they 4 w 323
cannot 1 w 329
so 2 w 331
adorn 2 w 336
the 14 w 339
soul 1 w 343
and 5 w 347
they 5 w 351
wish 1 w 355
to 2 w 357
send 1 w 361
forth 1 w 366
the 16 w 369
soul 2 w 373
bright 1 w 379
and 6 w 382
pure 1 w 386
since 2 w 392
it 6 w 394
is 5 w 396
now 1 w 399
set 1 w 402
free 1 w 406
after 1 w 411
having 1 w 417
fought 1 w 423
the 17 w 426
good 1 w 430
fight 1 w 435
in 11 w 437
all 1 w 440
its 1 w 443
manifold 1 w 451
forms 1 w 456
Or 2 w 459
are 1 w 462
plainness 1 w 471
and 7 w 474
simplicity 1 w 484
most 1 w 488
becoming 1 w 496
on 1 w 498
these 1 w 503
occasions 1 w 512
Of 1 w 515
the 19 w 518
dyed 1 w 522
garments 1 w 530
some 1 w 535
reflect 1 w 542
expense 1 w 549
others 1 w 556
over-elaboration 1 w 572
for 3 w 576
we 4 w 578
may 1 w 581
say 2 w 584
no 3 w 586
less 1 w 590
with 1 w 594
reference 1 w 603
to 3 w 605
black 1 w 610
than 1 w 614
to 4 w 616
purple 1 w 622
These 1 w 628
be 3 w 630
cheating 1 w 638
garments 2 w 646
these 2 w 652
be 4 w 654
cheating 2 w 662
colours 1 w 669
Apparently 1 w 680
a 48 w 681
misquotation 1 w 693
of 3 w 695
Herodotus 1 w 704
iii 1 w 708
22 1 w 711
1 1 w 713
otherwise 1 w 723
misquoted 1 w 732
in 16 w 734
Moralia 1 w 741
646 1 w 745
b 10 w 746
and 8 w 749
863 1 w 752
e 89 w 753
Cf 1 w 756
also 2 w 761
Clement 1 w 768
of 4 w 770
Alexandria 1 w 780
Stromateis 1 w 791
i 53 w 793
x 3 w 795
48 1 w 798
6 4 w 800
p 12 w 802
344 1 w 806
Potter 1 w 812
That 1 w 818
which 1 w 823
is 10 w 825
naturally 1 w 834
black 2 w 839
is 11 w 841
dyed 2 w 845
not 2 w 848
through 1 w 855
art 1 w 858
but 1 w 862
by 1 w 864
nature 1 w 870
and 10 w 874
when 1 w 878
it 10 w 880
is 12 w 882
combined 1 w 890
with 2 w 894
a 64 w 895
dark 2 w 899
colour 3 w 905
it 12 w 908
is 13 w 910
overpowered 1 w 921
This 1 w 926
apparently 1 w 936
means 1 w 941
Naturally 1 w 951
black 3 w 956
wool 1 w 960
may 2 w 963
be 5 w 965
dyed 3 w 969
purple 2 w 975
or 8 w 977
any 1 w 980
other 3 w 985
strong 1 w 991
dark 3 w 995
colour 4 w 1001
It 1 w 1004
is 15 w 1006
possible 1 w 1014
however 1 w 1022
that 3 w 1027
Plutarch 1 w 1035
wrote 1 w 1040
κέκραται 1 w 1048
and 11 w 1052
so 7 w 1054
several 1 w 1061
mss 1 w 1064
it 13 w 1069
is 16 w 1071
modified 1 w 1079
when 2 w 1083
combined 2 w 1091
with 3 w 1095
a 79 w 1096
dark 4 w 1100
colour 5 w 1106
Only 1 w 1111
white 4 w 1116
Cf 2 w 1119
Plato 1 w 1125
Republic 1 w 1134
729 1 w 1138
d-e 1 w 1141
therefore 1 w 1151
is 17 w 1154
pure 2 w 1158
unmixed 1 w 1166
and 12 w 1170
uncontaminated 1 w 1184
by 2 w 1186
dye 4 w 1189
nor 1 w 1193
can 2 w 1196
it 16 w 1198
be 6 w 1200
imitated 1 w 1208
wherefore 1 w 1218
it 18 w 1220
is 18 w 1222
most 2 w 1226
appropriate 1 w 1237
for 6 w 1240
the 25 w 1243
dead 2 w 1247
at 18 w 1249
burial 1 w 1255
For 1 w 1259
he 34 w 1261
who 1 w 1264
is 19 w 1266
dead 3 w 1270
has 1 w 1273
become 1 w 1279
something 1 w 1288
simple 1 w 1294
unmixed 2 w 1302
and 13 w 1306
pure 3 w 1310
once 1 w 1315
he 35 w 1317
has 2 w 1320
been 1 w 1324
released 1 w 1332
from 1 w 1336
the 26 w 1339
body 3 w 1343
which 2 w 1349
is 20 w 1351
indeed 1 w 1357
to 6 w 1359
be 9 w 1361
compared 1 w 1369
with 4 w 1373
a 98 w 1374
stain 1 w 1379
made 1 w 1383
by 3 w 1385
dyeing 1 w 1391
In 1 w 1394
Argos 1 w 1399
as 7 w 1402
Socrates 1 w 1410
Müller 1 w 1416
Frag 1 w 1421
Hist 1 w 1426
Graec 1 w 1432
iv 2 w 1435
498 1 w 1439
says 1 w 1444
persons 1 w 1452
in 24 w 1454
mourning 2 w 1462
wear 3 w 1466
white 5 w 1471
garments 3 w 1479
washed 1 w 1485
in 26 w 1487
water 1 w 1492
Why 2 w 1496
do 7 w 1498
they 6 w 1502
regard 1 w 1508
all 4 w 1511
the 28 w 1514
city 2 w 1518
wall 1 w 1522
as 9 w 1524
inviolable 1 w 1534
and 14 w 1537
sacred 1 w 1543
but 2 w 1547
not 3 w 1550
the 29 w 1553
gates 1 w 1558
Is 1 w 1561
it 22 w 1563
as 10 w 1566
Varro 1 w 1571
has 3 w 1574
written 1 w 1581
because 1 w 1589
the 30 w 1592
wall 2 w 1596
must 1 w 1600
be 11 w 1602
considered 1 w 1612
sacred 2 w 1618
that 4 w 1622
men 7 w 1625
may 3 w 1628
fight 2 w 1633
and 15 w 1636
die 1 w 1639
with 5 w 1643
enthusiasm 1 w 1653
in 28 w 1655
its 2 w 1658
defence 1 w 1665
It 2 w 1668
was 2 w 1671
under 1 w 1676
such 1 w 1680
circumstances 1 w 1693
it 26 w 1696
seems 1 w 1701
that 5 w 1706
Romulus 1 w 1713
killed 1 w 1719
his 4 w 1722
brother 1 w 1729
because 2 w 1736
he 43 w 1738
was 3 w 1741
attempting 1 w 1751
to 7 w 1753
leap 1 w 1757
across 1 w 1763
a 136 w 1764
place 1 w 1769
that 6 w 1773
was 4 w 1776
inviolable 2 w 1786
and 16 w 1789
sacred 3 w 1795
and 17 w 1799
to 8 w 1801
make 1 w 1805
it 27 w 1807
traversable 1 w 1818
and 18 w 1821
profane 1 w 1828
But 1 w 1832
it 28 w 1834
was 5 w 1837
impossible 1 w 1847
to 9 w 1849
consecrate 1 w 1859
the 32 w 1862
gates 2 w 1867
for 7 w 1871
through 2 w 1878
them 3 w 1882
they 7 w 1886
carry 1 w 1891
out 1 w 1894
many 1 w 1898
other 5 w 1903
objectionable 1 w 1916
things 1 w 1922
and 19 w 1925
also 3 w 1929
dead 4 w 1933
bodies 1 w 1939
Cf 3 w 1942
Moralia 2 w 1950
518 1 w 1954
b 40 w 1955
Wherefore 1 w 1965
the 36 w 1968
original 1 w 1976
founders 1 w 1984
of 6 w 1986
a 161 w 1987
city 3 w 1991
yoke 1 w 1995
a 162 w 1996
bull 1 w 2000
and 20 w 2003
a 164 w 2004
cow 1 w 2007
and 21 w 2011
mark 1 w 2015
out 2 w 2018
with 6 w 2022
a 167 w 2023
plough 1 w 2029
all 7 w 2032
the 37 w 2035
land 1 w 2039
on 12 w 2041
which 3 w 2046
they 8 w 2050
intend 1 w 2056
to 10 w 2058
build 1 w 2063
Cf 4 w 2065
Varro 2 w 2071
De 1 w 2074
Lingua 1 w 2080
Latina 1 w 2086
v 13 w 2088
143 1 w 2092
Res 1 w 2096
Rusticae 1 w 2104
ii 3 w 2107
1 4 w 2109
9 3 w 2111
Dionysius 1 w 2121
of 7 w 2123
Halicarnassus 1 w 2136
Roman 1 w 2142
Antiquities 1 w 2153
i 145 w 2155
88 1 w 2158
Ovid 1 w 2163
Fasti 1 w 2169
iv 3 w 2172
819 1 w 2176
ff 1 w 2178
and 23 w 2183
when 3 w 2187
they 9 w 2191
are 5 w 2194
engaged 1 w 2201
in 36 w 2203
tracing 1 w 2210
Cf 5 w 2212
Life 1 w 2217
of 8 w 2219
Romulus 2 w 2226
xi 1 w 2229
23 1 w 2233
d 94 w 2234
the 40 w 2239
circuit 1 w 2246
of 9 w 2248
the 41 w 2251
walls 1 w 2256
as 19 w 2259
they 10 w 2263
measure 1 w 2270
off 1 w 2273
the 43 w 2276
space 1 w 2281
intended 1 w 2289
for 9 w 2292
gates 3 w 2297
they 11 w 2302
lift 1 w 2306
up 1 w 2308
the 45 w 2311
ploughshare 1 w 2322
and 24 w 2325
thus 3 w 2329
carry 2 w 2334
the 46 w 2337
plough 3 w 2343
across 2 w 2349
since 3 w 2355
they 12 w 2359
hold 1 w 2363
that 7 w 2367
all 9 w 2370
the 48 w 2373
land 2 w 2377
that 8 w 2381
is 23 w 2383
ploughed 1 w 2391
is 24 w 2393
to 11 w 2395
be 13 w 2397
kept 1 w 2401
sacred 4 w 2407
and 26 w 2410
inviolable 3 w 2420