Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (20-21)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:20-21
Refs {'start': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}, 'end': {'reference': '21', 'human_reference': 'Section 21'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why is it that the women, when they adorn in their houses a shrine to the womens goddess, whom they call Bona Dea,[*] bring in no myrtle, although they are very eager to make use of all manner of growing and blooming plants?

Was this goddess, as the mythologists relate, the wife of the seer Faunus; and was she secretly addicted to wine,[*] but did not escape detection and was beaten by her husband with myrtle rods, and is this the reason why they do not bring in myrtle and, when they make libations of wine to her, call it milk?

Or is it because they remain pure from many things, particularly from venery, when they perform this holy service? For they not only exclude their husbands, but they also drive everything male out of the house[*] whenever they conduct the customary ceremonies in honour of the goddess. So, because the myrtle is sacred to Venus, they religiously exclude it. For she whom they now call Venus Murcia, in ancient days, it seems, they styled Myrtia.

Why do the Latins revere the woodpecker and all strictly abstain[*] from it?

Is it because, as they tell the tale, Picus,[*] transformed by his wifes magic drugs, became a woodpecker and in that form gives oracles and prophecies to those who consult him?

Or is this wholly incredible and monstrous, and is that other tale[*] more credible which relates that when Romulus and Remus were exposed, not only did a she-wolf suckle them, but also a certain woodpecker carne continually to visit them and bring them scraps of food? For generally, even to this day, in foot-hills and thickly wooded places where the woodpecker is found, there also is found the wolf, as Nigidius records.

Or is it rather because they regard this bird as sacred to Mars, even as other birds to other gods? For it is a courageous and spirited bird and has a beak so strong that it can overturn oaks by pecking them until it has reached the inmost part of the tree.

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
is 1 w 5
it 1 w 7
that 1 w 11
the 1 w 14
women 1 w 19
when 1 w 24
they 1 w 28
adorn 1 w 33
in 1 w 35
their 1 w 40
houses 1 w 46
a 3 w 47
shrine 1 w 53
to 1 w 55
the 4 w 58
women 2 w 63
s 5 w 65
goddess 1 w 72
whom 1 w 77
they 2 w 81
call 1 w 85
Bona 1 w 89
Dea 1 w 92
Cf 1 w 95
Macrobius 1 w 105
Saturnalia 1 w 116
i 8 w 118
12 1 w 121
21-28 1 w 127
bring 1 w 133
in 4 w 135
no 1 w 137
myrtle 1 w 143
although 1 w 152
they 3 w 156
are 1 w 159
very 1 w 163
eager 1 w 168
to 2 w 170
make 1 w 174
use 2 w 177
of 1 w 179
all 2 w 182
manner 1 w 188
of 2 w 190
growing 1 w 197
and 1 w 200
blooming 1 w 208
plants 1 w 214
Was 1 w 218
this 1 w 222
goddess 2 w 229
as 2 w 232
the 7 w 235
mythologists 1 w 247
relate 1 w 253
the 8 w 257
wife 1 w 261
of 3 w 263
the 9 w 266
seer 1 w 270
Faunus 1 w 276
and 2 w 280
was 1 w 283
she 1 w 286
secretly 1 w 294
addicted 1 w 302
to 3 w 304
wine 1 w 308
Cf 2 w 311
265 1 w 315
b 4 w 316
supra 1 w 322
but 1 w 326
did 1 w 329
not 1 w 332
escape 1 w 338
detection 1 w 347
and 3 w 350
was 2 w 353
beaten 1 w 359
by 1 w 361
her 1 w 364
husband 1 w 371
with 1 w 375
myrtle 2 w 381
rods 1 w 385
and 5 w 389
is 4 w 391
this 2 w 395
the 10 w 398
reason 1 w 404
why 1 w 407
they 4 w 411
do 2 w 413
not 2 w 416
bring 2 w 421
in 9 w 423
myrtle 3 w 429
and 6 w 432
when 2 w 437
they 5 w 441
make 2 w 445
libations 1 w 454
of 4 w 456
wine 2 w 460
to 4 w 462
her 2 w 465
call 2 w 470
it 3 w 472
milk 1 w 476
Or 1 w 479
is 6 w 481
it 4 w 483
because 1 w 490
they 6 w 494
remain 1 w 500
pure 1 w 504
from 1 w 508
many 1 w 512
things 1 w 518
particularly 1 w 531
from 2 w 535
venery 1 w 541
when 3 w 546
they 7 w 550
perform 1 w 557
this 3 w 561
holy 1 w 565
service 1 w 572
For 1 w 576
they 8 w 580
not 3 w 583
only 1 w 587
exclude 1 w 594
their 2 w 599
husbands 1 w 607
but 2 w 611
they 9 w 615
also 1 w 619
drive 1 w 624
everything 1 w 634
male 1 w 638
out 1 w 641
of 5 w 643
the 18 w 646
house 2 w 651
Cf 3 w 653
Life 1 w 658
of 6 w 660
Caesar 1 w 666
ix 1 w 669
711 1 w 674
e 78 w 675
Life 2 w 681
of 7 w 683
Cicero 1 w 689
xix 1 w 693
870 1 w 698
b 14 w 699
Juvenal 1 w 708
vi 2 w 711
339 1 w 715
whenever 1 w 724
they 10 w 728
conduct 1 w 735
the 20 w 738
customary 1 w 747
ceremonies 1 w 757
in 14 w 759
honour 1 w 765
of 8 w 767
the 21 w 770
goddess 3 w 777
So 1 w 780
because 2 w 788
the 22 w 791
myrtle 4 w 797
is 8 w 799
sacred 1 w 805
to 6 w 807
Venus 1 w 812
they 11 w 817
religiously 1 w 828
exclude 2 w 835
it 5 w 837
For 2 w 841
she 2 w 844
whom 2 w 848
they 12 w 852
now 1 w 855
call 3 w 859
Venus 2 w 864
Murcia 1 w 870
in 15 w 873
ancient 1 w 880
days 1 w 884
it 6 w 887
seems 1 w 892
they 13 w 897
styled 1 w 903
Myrtia 1 w 909
Why 2 w 913
do 3 w 915
the 26 w 918
Latins 1 w 924
revere 1 w 930
the 27 w 933
woodpecker 1 w 943
and 8 w 946
all 5 w 949
strictly 1 w 957
abstain 1 w 964
No 1 w 966
doubt 1 w 971
this 4 w 975
means 1 w 980
from 3 w 984
eating 1 w 990
it 7 w 992
since 1 w 997
they 14 w 1001
used 1 w 1005
to 7 w 1007
eat 3 w 1010
all 6 w 1013
small 1 w 1018
birds 1 w 1023
from 4 w 1028
it 8 w 1030
Is 1 w 1033
it 9 w 1035
because 3 w 1042
as 6 w 1045
they 15 w 1049
tell 1 w 1053
the 30 w 1056
tale 1 w 1060
Picus 1 w 1066
Cf 4 w 1069
Ovid 1 w 1074
Metamorphoses 1 w 1088
xiv 1 w 1092
320 1 w 1096
ff 1 w 1098
transformed 1 w 1110
by 2 w 1112
his 5 w 1115
wife 2 w 1119
s 74 w 1121
magic 1 w 1126
drugs 1 w 1131
became 1 w 1138
a 74 w 1139
woodpecker 2 w 1149
and 9 w 1152
in 20 w 1154
that 2 w 1158
form 3 w 1162
gives 1 w 1167
oracles 1 w 1174
and 10 w 1177
prophecies 1 w 1187
to 8 w 1189
those 1 w 1194
who 3 w 1197
consult 1 w 1204
him 1 w 1207
Or 2 w 1210
is 11 w 1212
this 5 w 1216
wholly 1 w 1222
incredible 1 w 1232
and 11 w 1235
monstrous 1 w 1244
and 12 w 1248
is 13 w 1250
that 3 w 1254
other 1 w 1259
tale 2 w 1263
Cf 5 w 1265
278 1 w 1269
c 35 w 1270
320 2 w 1274
d 45 w 1275
infra 1 w 1281
Life 3 w 1286
of 9 w 1288
Romulus 1 w 1295
iv 4 w 1298
19 1 w 1302
e 147 w 1303
vii 1 w 1308
21 2 w 1312
c 36 w 1313
more 1 w 1319
credible 2 w 1327
which 1 w 1332
relates 1 w 1339
that 4 w 1343
when 5 w 1347
Romulus 2 w 1354
and 13 w 1357
Remus 1 w 1362
were 1 w 1366
exposed 1 w 1373
not 4 w 1377
only 2 w 1381
did 2 w 1384
a 87 w 1385
she-wolf 1 w 1393
suckle 1 w 1399
them 1 w 1403
but 3 w 1407
also 2 w 1411
a 89 w 1412
certain 1 w 1419
woodpecker 3 w 1429
carne 1 w 1434
continually 1 w 1445
to 9 w 1447
visit 1 w 1452
them 2 w 1456
and 14 w 1459
bring 3 w 1464
them 3 w 1468
scraps 1 w 1474
of 10 w 1476
food 1 w 1480
For 3 w 1484
generally 1 w 1493
even 1 w 1498
to 10 w 1500
this 6 w 1504
day 2 w 1507
in 26 w 1510
foot-hills 1 w 1520
and 15 w 1523
thickly 1 w 1530
wooded 1 w 1536
places 1 w 1542
where 1 w 1547
the 35 w 1550
woodpecker 4 w 1560
is 16 w 1562
found 1 w 1567
there 1 w 1573
also 3 w 1577
is 17 w 1579
found 2 w 1584
the 37 w 1587
wolf 2 w 1591
as 7 w 1594
Nigidius 1 w 1602
records 1 w 1609
Or 3 w 1612
is 18 w 1614
it 11 w 1616
rather 1 w 1622
because 4 w 1629
they 16 w 1633
regard 1 w 1639
this 7 w 1643
bird 2 w 1647
as 8 w 1649
sacred 2 w 1655
to 11 w 1657
Mars 1 w 1661
even 2 w 1666
as 9 w 1668
other 2 w 1673
birds 2 w 1678
to 12 w 1680
other 3 w 1685
gods 1 w 1689
For 4 w 1693
it 12 w 1695
is 20 w 1697
a 108 w 1698
courageous 1 w 1708
and 16 w 1711
spirited 1 w 1719
bird 4 w 1723
and 17 w 1726
has 1 w 1729
a 113 w 1730
beak 1 w 1734
so 5 w 1736
strong 1 w 1742
that 5 w 1746
it 14 w 1748
can 1 w 1751
overturn 1 w 1759
oaks 1 w 1763
by 3 w 1765
pecking 1 w 1772
them 4 w 1776
until 1 w 1781
it 15 w 1783
has 2 w 1786
reached 1 w 1793
the 43 w 1796
inmost 1 w 1802
part 2 w 1806
of 11 w 1808
the 44 w 1811
tree 1 w 1815