Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (14-17)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:14-17
Refs {'start': {'reference': '14', 'human_reference': 'Section 14'}, 'end': {'reference': '17', 'human_reference': 'Section 17'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do sons cover their heads when they escort their parents to the grave, while daughters go with uncovered heads and hair unbound?

Is it because fathers should be honoured as gods

by their male offspring, but mourned as dead by their daughters, that custom has assigned to each sex its proper part and has produced a fitting result from both?

Or is it that the unusual is proper in mourning, and it is more usual for women to go forth in public with their heads covered and men with their heads uncovered? So in Greece, whenever any misfortune comes, the women cut off their hair and the men let it grow, for it is usual for men to have their hair cut and for women to let it grow.

Or is it that it has become customary for sons to cover their heads for the reason already given?[*] For they turn about at the graves, as Varro relates, thus honouring the tombs of their fathers even as they do the shrines of the gods: and when they have cremated their parents, they declare that the dead person has become a god at the moment when first they find a bone.[*]

But formerly women were not allowed to cover the head at all. At least it is recorded that Spurius Carvilius[*] was the first man to divorce his wife and the reason was her barrenness: the second was Sulpicius Gallus, because he saw his wife pull her cloak over her head: and the third was Publius Sempronius, because his wife had been present as a spectator at funeral games.[*]

Why is it that they were wont to sacrifice no living creature to Terminus,[*] in whose honour they held the Terminalia, although they regard him as a god?

Is it that Romulus placed no boundary-stones for his country, so that Romans might go forth, seize land, and regard all as theirs, as the Spartan said,[*] which their spears could reach; whereas Numa Pompilius,[*] a just man and a statesman, who had become versed in philosophy, marked out the boundaries between Rome and her neighbours, and, when on the boundary-stones he had formally installed Terminus as overseer and guardian of friendship and peace, he thought that Terminus should be kept pure and undefiled from blood and gore?

Why is it that it is forbidden to slave-women to set foot in the shrine of Matuta, and why do the women bring in one slave-woman only and slap her on the head and beat her?[*]

Is the beating of this slave but a symbol of the prohibition, and do they prevent the others from entering because of the legend? For Ino[*] is said to have become madly jealous of a slave-woman on her husbands account, and to have vented her madness on her son. The Greeks relate that the slave was an Aetolian by birth and that her name was Antiphera. Wherefore also in my native town, Chaeroneia, the temple-guardian stands before the precinct of Leucothea and, taking a whip in his hand, makes proclamation: Let no slave enter, nor any Aetolian, man or woman!

Why is it that in the shrine of this goddess they do not pray for blessings on their own children, but only on their sisters children?[*]

Is it because Ino was fond of her sister and suckled her sisters son also, but was herself unfortunate in her own children? Or is it that, quite apart from this reason, the custom is morally excellent and produces much goodwill among kindred?

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
sons 1 w 9
cover 1 w 14
their 1 w 19
heads 1 w 24
when 1 w 28
they 1 w 32
escort 1 w 38
their 2 w 43
parents 1 w 50
to 1 w 52
the 4 w 55
grave 1 w 60
while 1 w 66
daughters 1 w 75
go 1 w 77
with 1 w 81
uncovered 1 w 90
heads 2 w 95
and 1 w 98
hair 1 w 102
unbound 1 w 109
Is 1 w 112
it 2 w 114
because 1 w 121
fathers 1 w 128
should 1 w 134
be 2 w 136
honoured 1 w 144
as 1 w 146
gods 1 w 150
by 1 w 152
their 3 w 157
male 1 w 161
offspring 1 w 170
but 1 w 174
mourned 1 w 181
as 2 w 183
dead 1 w 187
by 2 w 189
their 4 w 194
daughters 2 w 203
that 1 w 208
custom 1 w 214
has 1 w 217
assigned 1 w 225
to 3 w 227
each 1 w 231
sex 1 w 234
its 1 w 237
proper 1 w 243
part 1 w 247
and 2 w 250
has 2 w 253
produced 1 w 261
a 22 w 262
fitting 1 w 269
result 1 w 275
from 1 w 279
both 1 w 283
Or 1 w 286
is 1 w 288
it 5 w 290
that 2 w 294
the 8 w 297
unusual 1 w 304
is 2 w 306
proper 2 w 312
in 3 w 314
mourning 1 w 322
and 3 w 326
it 6 w 328
is 3 w 330
more 1 w 334
usual 2 w 339
for 1 w 342
women 1 w 347
to 4 w 349
go 3 w 351
forth 1 w 356
in 5 w 358
public 1 w 364
with 2 w 368
their 5 w 373
heads 3 w 378
covered 2 w 385
and 4 w 388
men 2 w 391
with 3 w 395
their 6 w 400
heads 4 w 405
uncovered 2 w 414
So 1 w 417
in 6 w 419
Greece 1 w 425
whenever 1 w 434
any 1 w 437
misfortune 1 w 447
comes 1 w 452
the 11 w 456
women 2 w 461
cut 1 w 464
off 2 w 467
their 7 w 472
hair 2 w 476
and 5 w 479
the 13 w 482
men 4 w 485
let 1 w 488
it 9 w 490
grow 1 w 494
for 4 w 498
it 10 w 500
is 5 w 502
usual 3 w 507
for 5 w 510
men 5 w 513
to 5 w 515
have 1 w 519
their 8 w 524
hair 3 w 528
cut 2 w 531
and 6 w 534
for 6 w 537
women 3 w 542
to 6 w 544
let 2 w 547
it 11 w 549
grow 2 w 553
Or 2 w 556
is 6 w 558
it 12 w 560
that 3 w 564
it 13 w 566
has 3 w 569
become 1 w 575
customary 1 w 584
for 7 w 587
sons 2 w 591
to 8 w 593
cover 5 w 598
their 9 w 603
heads 5 w 608
for 8 w 611
the 16 w 614
reason 1 w 620
already 1 w 627
given 1 w 632
The 1 w 636
first 1 w 641
reason 2 w 647
above 1 w 652
The 2 w 656
father 2 w 662
should 2 w 668
be 4 w 670
honoured 2 w 678
as 9 w 680
a 48 w 681
god 2 w 684
For 1 w 688
they 2 w 692
turn 1 w 696
about 1 w 701
at 6 w 703
the 19 w 706
graves 1 w 712
as 10 w 715
Varro 1 w 720
relates 1 w 727
thus 1 w 732
honouring 1 w 741
the 20 w 744
tombs 1 w 749
of 3 w 751
their 10 w 756
fathers 2 w 763
even 1 w 767
as 11 w 769
they 3 w 773
do 2 w 775
the 24 w 778
shrines 1 w 785
of 4 w 787
the 25 w 790
gods 2 w 794
and 7 w 798
when 3 w 802
they 4 w 806
have 2 w 810
cremated 1 w 818
their 11 w 823
parents 2 w 830
they 5 w 835
declare 1 w 842
that 4 w 846
the 29 w 849
dead 2 w 853
person 1 w 859
has 4 w 862
become 2 w 868
a 65 w 869
god 4 w 872
at 11 w 874
the 30 w 877
moment 1 w 883
when 4 w 887
first 2 w 892
they 6 w 896
find 1 w 900
a 67 w 901
bone 1 w 905
Cf 1 w 908
Cicero 1 w 915
De 1 w 918
Legibus 1 w 925
ii 1 w 928
22 1 w 931
57 1 w 934
But 1 w 939
formerly 1 w 947
women 4 w 952
were 1 w 956
not 1 w 959
allowed 1 w 966
to 10 w 968
cover 6 w 973
the 32 w 976
head 6 w 980
at 12 w 982
all 2 w 985
At 1 w 988
least 1 w 993
it 14 w 995
is 7 w 997
recorded 1 w 1005
that 5 w 1009
Spurius 1 w 1016
Carvilius 1 w 1025
Cf 2 w 1027
278 1 w 1031
e 129 w 1032
infra 1 w 1038
Comparison 1 w 1049
of 5 w 1051
Lycurgus 1 w 1059
and 8 w 1062
Numa 1 w 1066
iii 1 w 1070
77 1 w 1074
c 25 w 1075
Comparison 2 w 1087
of 6 w 1089
Theseus 1 w 1096
and 9 w 1099
Romulus 1 w 1106
vi 2 w 1109
39 1 w 1113
b 17 w 1114
Dionysius 1 w 1125
of 7 w 1127
Halicarnassus 1 w 1140
Roman 1 w 1146
Antiquities 1 w 1157
ii 4 w 1160
25 1 w 1163
7 5 w 1165
Valerius 1 w 1174
Maximus 1 w 1181
ii 5 w 1184
1 1 w 1186
4 1 w 1188
Aulus 1 w 1194
Gellius 1 w 1201
iv 2 w 1204
3 2 w 1206
2 5 w 1208
xvii 1 w 1213
21 1 w 1216
44 1 w 1219
Tertullian 1 w 1230
Apol 1 w 1235
vi 4 w 1238
De 2 w 1242
Monogamia 1 w 1251
ix 1 w 1254
was 1 w 1258
the 33 w 1261
first 3 w 1266
man 2 w 1269
to 11 w 1271
divorce 1 w 1278
his 1 w 1281
wife 1 w 1285
and 10 w 1288
the 34 w 1291
reason 3 w 1297
was 2 w 1300
her 4 w 1303
barrenness 1 w 1313
the 35 w 1317
second 1 w 1323
was 3 w 1326
Sulpicius 1 w 1335
Gallus 1 w 1341
because 2 w 1349
he 50 w 1351
saw 1 w 1354
his 2 w 1357
wife 2 w 1361
pull 1 w 1365
her 5 w 1368
cloak 1 w 1373
over 7 w 1377
her 6 w 1380
head 7 w 1384
and 11 w 1388
the 36 w 1391
third 1 w 1396
was 4 w 1399
Publius 1 w 1406
Sempronius 1 w 1416
because 3 w 1424
his 3 w 1427
wife 3 w 1431
had 1 w 1434
been 1 w 1438
present 1 w 1445
as 20 w 1447
a 107 w 1448
spectator 1 w 1457
at 15 w 1459
funeral 1 w 1466
games 1 w 1471
Cf 3 w 1474
Valerius 2 w 1483
Maximus 2 w 1490
vi 5 w 1493
3 3 w 1495
10 1 w 1498
Why 2 w 1502
is 13 w 1504
it 16 w 1506
that 6 w 1510
they 7 w 1514
were 2 w 1518
wont 1 w 1522
to 13 w 1524
sacrifice 1 w 1533
no 6 w 1535
living 1 w 1541
creature 1 w 1549
to 14 w 1551
Terminus 1 w 1559
This 1 w 1564
is 15 w 1566
certainly 1 w 1575
not 2 w 1578
true 1 w 1582
of 8 w 1584
later 1 w 1589
times 1 w 1594
Cf 4 w 1597
for 10 w 1601
example 1 w 1608
Horace 1 w 1615
Epodes 1 w 1622
2 7 w 1624
59 1 w 1627
in 14 w 1630
whose 1 w 1635
honour 4 w 1641
they 8 w 1645
held 1 w 1649
the 39 w 1652
Terminalia 1 w 1662
although 1 w 1671
they 9 w 1675
regard 1 w 1681
him 1 w 1684
as 21 w 1686
a 126 w 1687
god 5 w 1690
Is 2 w 1693
it 17 w 1695
that 7 w 1699
Romulus 2 w 1706
placed 1 w 1712
no 9 w 1714
boundary-stones 1 w 1729
for 11 w 1732
his 5 w 1735
country 1 w 1742
so 9 w 1745
that 8 w 1749
Romans 1 w 1755
might 1 w 1760
go 8 w 1762
forth 2 w 1767
seize 1 w 1773
land 1 w 1777
and 13 w 1781
regard 2 w 1787
all 4 w 1790
as 22 w 1792
theirs 1 w 1798
as 23 w 1801
the 42 w 1804
Spartan 1 w 1811
said 1 w 1815
Cf 5 w 1818
Moralia 1 w 1826
210 1 w 1830
e 197 w 1831
with 4 w 1835
the 43 w 1838
note 1 w 1842
Vol 1 w 1846
III 1 w 1850
p 25 w 1852
257 1 w 1856
which 1 w 1863
their 13 w 1868
spears 1 w 1874
could 1 w 1879
reach 1 w 1884
whereas 1 w 1892
Numa 2 w 1896
Pompilius 1 w 1905
Cf 6 w 1908
Life 1 w 1913
of 9 w 1915
Numa 3 w 1919
xvi 2 w 1923
70 1 w 1927
f 46 w 1928
Dionysius 2 w 1939
of 10 w 1941
Halicarnassus 2 w 1954
Roman 3 w 1960
Antiquities 2 w 1971
ii 7 w 1974
74 1 w 1977
2 10 w 1979
ff 3 w 1981
a 152 w 1983
just 1 w 1987
man 5 w 1990
and 14 w 1993
a 155 w 1994
statesman 1 w 2003
who 2 w 2007
had 2 w 2010
become 3 w 2016
versed 1 w 2022
in 16 w 2024
philosophy 1 w 2034
marked 1 w 2041
out 2 w 2044
the 45 w 2047
boundaries 1 w 2057
between 1 w 2064
Rome 1 w 2068
and 15 w 2071
her 8 w 2074
neighbours 1 w 2084
and 16 w 2088
when 5 w 2093
on 21 w 2095
the 46 w 2098
boundary-stones 2 w 2113
he 69 w 2115
had 3 w 2118
formally 1 w 2126
installed 1 w 2135
Terminus 2 w 2143
as 26 w 2145
overseer 1 w 2153
and 17 w 2156
guardian 1 w 2164
of 11 w 2166
friendship 1 w 2176
and 18 w 2179
peace 1 w 2184
he 70 w 2187
thought 1 w 2194
that 9 w 2198
Terminus 3 w 2206
should 3 w 2212
be 11 w 2214
kept 1 w 2218
pure 1 w 2222
and 19 w 2225
undefiled 1 w 2234
from 2 w 2238
blood 1 w 2243
and 20 w 2246
gore 1 w 2250
Why 3 w 2254
is 17 w 2256
it 20 w 2258
that 10 w 2262
it 21 w 2264
is 18 w 2266
forbidden 1 w 2275
to 17 w 2277
slave-women 1 w 2288
to 18 w 2290
set 1 w 2293
foot 1 w 2297
in 20 w 2299
the 47 w 2302
shrine 2 w 2308
of 12 w 2310
Matuta 1 w 2316
and 21 w 2320
why 1 w 2323
do 3 w 2325
the 48 w 2328
women 6 w 2333
bring 1 w 2338
in 23 w 2340
one 4 w 2343
slave-woman 1 w 2354
only 1 w 2358
and 22 w 2361
slap 1 w 2365
her 9 w 2368
on 25 w 2370
the 49 w 2373
head 8 w 2377
and 23 w 2380
beat 1 w 2384
her 10 w 2387
Cf 7 w 2390
Life 2 w 2395
of 13 w 2397
Camillus 1 w 2405
v 29 w 2407
131 1 w 2412
b-c 1 w 2415
Ovid 1 w 2421
Fasti 1 w 2427
vi 9 w 2430
551 1 w 2434
ff 4 w 2436
with 5 w 2441
Frazer 1 w 2447
s 163 w 2449
note 2 w 2453
Is 3 w 2456
the 50 w 2459
beating 1 w 2466
of 14 w 2468
this 1 w 2472
slave 3 w 2477
but 2 w 2480
a 193 w 2481
symbol 1 w 2487
of 15 w 2489
the 51 w 2492
prohibition 1 w 2503
and 24 w 2507
do 4 w 2509
they 10 w 2513
prevent 1 w 2520
the 53 w 2523
others 1 w 2529
from 3 w 2533
entering 1 w 2541
because 4 w 2548
of 16 w 2550
the 55 w 2553
legend 1 w 2559
For 2 w 2563
Ino 1 w 2566
Ino 2 w 2569
is 20 w 2571
the 56 w 2574
Greek 1 w 2579
name 1 w 2583
for 15 w 2586
the 57 w 2589
Greek 2 w 2594
goddess 1 w 2601
Leucothea 1 w 2610
before 1 w 2616
her 12 w 2619
violent 1 w 2626
death 1 w 2631
and 25 w 2634
deification 1 w 2645
Matuta 2 w 2652
is 21 w 2654
the 59 w 2657
supposed 1 w 2665
Roman 4 w 2670
equivalent 1 w 2680
of 17 w 2682
both 2 w 2686
Greek 3 w 2691
names 1 w 2696
is 22 w 2699
said 2 w 2703
to 19 w 2705
have 3 w 2709
become 4 w 2715
madly 1 w 2720
jealous 1 w 2727
of 18 w 2729
a 210 w 2730
slave-woman 2 w 2741
on 28 w 2743
her 13 w 2746
husband 1 w 2753
s 182 w 2755
account 1 w 2762
and 27 w 2766
to 20 w 2768
have 4 w 2772
vented 1 w 2778
her 14 w 2781
madness 1 w 2788
on 29 w 2790
her 15 w 2793
son 9 w 2796
The 4 w 2800
Greeks 1 w 2806
relate 2 w 2812
that 11 w 2816
the 60 w 2819
slave 5 w 2824
was 5 w 2827
an 41 w 2829
Aetolian 1 w 2837
by 3 w 2839
birth 1 w 2844
and 28 w 2847
that 12 w 2851
her 16 w 2854
name 3 w 2858
was 6 w 2861
Antiphera 1 w 2870
Wherefore 1 w 2880
also 1 w 2884
in 26 w 2886
my 1 w 2888
native 1 w 2894
town 1 w 2898
Chaeroneia 1 w 2909
the 61 w 2913
temple-guardian 1 w 2928
stands 1 w 2934
before 2 w 2940
the 62 w 2943
precinct 1 w 2951
of 19 w 2953
Leucothea 2 w 2962
and 30 w 2965
taking 1 w 2972
a 239 w 2973
whip 1 w 2977
in 29 w 2979
his 7 w 2982
hand 1 w 2986
makes 1 w 2992
proclamation 1 w 3004
Let 1 w 3008
no 14 w 3010
slave 6 w 3015
enter 2 w 3020
nor 1 w 3024
any 2 w 3027
Aetolian 2 w 3035
man 10 w 3039
or 30 w 3041
woman 3 w 3046
Why 4 w 3050
is 24 w 3052
it 24 w 3054
that 13 w 3058
in 30 w 3060
the 64 w 3063
shrine 3 w 3069
of 20 w 3071
this 2 w 3075
goddess 2 w 3082
they 11 w 3086
do 5 w 3088
not 5 w 3091
pray 1 w 3095
for 19 w 3098
blessings 1 w 3107
on 33 w 3109
their 14 w 3114
own 2 w 3117
children 1 w 3125
but 3 w 3129
only 2 w 3133
on 35 w 3135
their 15 w 3140
sisters 1 w 3147
children 2 w 3156
Cf 8 w 3159
Moralia 2 w 3167
492 1 w 3171
d 118 w 3172
Is 4 w 3175
it 25 w 3177
because 5 w 3184
Ino 3 w 3187
was 7 w 3190
fond 1 w 3194
of 21 w 3196
her 19 w 3199
sister 2 w 3205
and 32 w 3208
suckled 1 w 3215
her 20 w 3218
sister 3 w 3224
s 215 w 3226
son 10 w 3229
also 2 w 3233
but 4 w 3237
was 8 w 3240
herself 1 w 3247
unfortunate 1 w 3258
in 33 w 3260
her 22 w 3263
own 3 w 3266
children 3 w 3274
Or 3 w 3277
is 29 w 3279
it 26 w 3281
that 14 w 3285
quite 1 w 3291
apart 1 w 3296
from 4 w 3300
this 3 w 3304
reason 4 w 3310
the 68 w 3314
custom 3 w 3320
is 31 w 3322
morally 1 w 3329
excellent 1 w 3338
and 33 w 3341
produces 1 w 3349
much 1 w 3353
goodwill 1 w 3361
among 1 w 3366
kindred 1 w 3373